The State of Western Australia v Holmes

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CRIMINAL

CITATION:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- HOLMES [2019] WASC 413

CORAM:   MCGRATH J

HEARD:   27-28 AUGUST & 26 SEPTEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   13 NOVEMBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   INS 11 of 2019

BETWEEN:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Prosecution

AND

DEBRA JANE ALICIA HOLMES

Accused


Catchwords:

Criminal law - Evidence - Admissibility of unrecorded admissions - Whether reasonable excuse for absence of recording - Discretion to exclude evidence on grounds of voluntariness, reliability and unfairness - Effect of intoxication - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Criminal Code (WA), s 279
Criminal Investigation Act 2006 (WA), s 115, s 118, s 154, s 155

Result:

Part of admissions not audiovisually recorded admissible

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Prosecution : Mr B E F Tooker
Accused : Ms H E Prince

Solicitors:

Prosecution : Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)
Accused : Curt Hoffman & Co

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Blum v The State of Western Australia [No 2] [2012] WASCA 40

Collins v The Queen (1980) 31 ALR 257

R v Lee (1950) 82 CLR 133

R v Swaffield [1998] HCA 1; (1998) 192 CLR 159

Sinclair v The King (1946) 73 CLR 316

The State of Western Australia v Silich [2011] WASCA 135; (2011) 43 WAR 285

Van Der Meer v The Queen [1988] HCA 56; (1988) 62 ALJR 656

Wendo v The Queen [1963] HCA 19; (1963) 109 CLR 559

Wright v The State of Western Australia [2010] WASCA 199; (2010) 43 WAR 1

MCGRATH J:

  1. The accused, Ms Holmes, has been charged on indictment which pleads that on 15 July 2018 at Muja she murdered Wayne Kenneth Chappell.  Ms Holmes has pleaded not guilty to that count and is proceeding to trial in December 2019.

  2. By application dated 16 May 2019 the State seeks leave to adduce evidence of the admissions allegedly made by the accused to police officers who attended the scene which were not audiovisually recorded, pursuant to s 118(3)(b) and, in the alternative, s 155 of the Criminal Investigation Act2006 (WA) (CIA).

  3. The State's application is opposed by the accused.  The accused, in opposition, raises issues of voluntariness and reliability due to her level of intoxication and emotional state at the time she made the alleged admissions.

  4. For the following reasons, I have determined that only part of the contended admissions made by the accused to the attending police officers are admissible. 

  5. In these reasons for decision, I will consider the following:

    (a)The factual background.

    (b)The admissions which the State seeks to adduce.

    (c) The relevant legal principles.

    (d)An assessment of the merits of the application.

Factual background - State's case

  1. The State's case is that the accused deliberately shot her partner, Mr Chappell, with a rifle at close range.  The State contends that the accused did so with the intention to kill Mr Chappell or, in the alternative, with the intention to inflict a bodily injury of such a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v Holmes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASC 413
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of The State of Western Australia v Holmes, the defendant was charged with the murder of her husband. The primary issue before the court was whether unrecorded admissions made by the defendant could be admitted as evidence. The case hinged on the application of sections 118(1) and 118(3) of the Criminal Investigation Act 2006 (WA), which governs the admissibility of unrecorded admissions by suspects. The court needed to determine whether there was a reasonable excuse under section 118(1)(a) for not recording the admissions, given the circumstances at the time they were made.

The court examined whether the circumstances justified not making an audiovisual recording of the defendant's admissions, considering the definition of 'practicable' and the availability of resources. It was acknowledged that the determination of whether it was practicable to record the admissions involved assessing the resources available, including personnel and equipment, the time available to organise these resources, and the expectation of an admission. The court also considered the effect of intoxication on the voluntariness, reliability, and fairness of the admissions. The defendant's intoxication at the time of making the admissions was deemed relevant to the assessment of the evidence's admissibility. Ultimately, the court concluded that the circumstances did not provide a reasonable excuse for not recording the admissions, but it found that the admissions could still be admitted under section 155 of the CIA as their probative value outweighed their undesirability.

The court found that part of the defendant's admissions were admissible despite not being audiovisually recorded. The decision highlighted the importance of considering all relevant circumstances when determining the admissibility of unrecorded admissions, including the practicality of making a recording and the voluntariness, reliability, and fairness of the admissions. The court's ruling underscores the nuanced approach required in assessing whether to admit unrecorded admissions in criminal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Part of admissions not audiovisually recorded admissible

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Further, s 155 of the CIA provides:155.Inadmissible evidence, court may allow admission (1)This section applies if under another section a court may make a decision under this section in relation to evidence that is not admissible in proceedings in the court. (2)The court may nevertheless decide to admit the evidence if it is satisfied that the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighs the undesirability of admitting the evidence. (3)In making a decision under subsection (2) the court must take into account - (a)any objection to the evidence being admitted by the person against whom the evidence may be given; (b)the seriousness of the offence in respect of which the evidence is relevant; (c)the seriousness of any contravention of this Act in obtaining the evidence; (d)whether any contravention of this Act in obtaining the evidence - (i)was intentional or reckless; or (ii)arose from an honest and reasonable mistake of fact; (e)the probative value of the evidence; (f)any other matter the court thinks fit. (4)The probative value of the evidence does not by itself justify its admission. Section 118(3) of the CIA provides that unrecorded admissions are prima facie inadmissible. There are limitations concerning the categories of admissions that fall within s 118(3) of the CIA. First, the subsection only applies to admissions made by a 'suspect' as defined in s 115 of the CIA, that is, a person suspected of having committed an offence whether or not he or she has been charged with the offence. Second, pursuant to s 118(4) there must be reasonable grounds for that suspicion. The third limitation is that s 118(3) only applies to admissions made to a police officer or a Corruption and Crime Commission officer. At the directions hearing there was no dispute between the parties that the three limitations of s 118(3) of the CIA had been satisfied in this case. It is clear that the police officers attended the scene having been informed that the accused told the 000 call operator she had shot her husband. Accordingly, each officer had a reasonable ground for suspecting that the accused had committed an offence by discharging a firearm. Further, the accused's statements were made to serving police officers. The definition of the term 'reasonable excuse' in s 118(1) of the CIA is not, in its terms or effect, exclusive. There may be a reasonable excuse which does not fall within those matters referred to in the subsection.[27] Whether there is a reasonable excuse requires an examination of all the circumstances relevant to the making of the alleged admission.[28] [27] Wright v The State of Western Australia [2010] WASCA 199; (2010) 43 WAR 1 [55].[28] Blum v The State of Western Australia [No 2] [2012] WASCA 40 [63]. An issue in this case is whether there was a reasonable excuse to not record the admissions for the reason that they were made when it was not practicable to make an audiovisual recording under s 118(1)(a). In Wright v The State of Western Australia, Blaxell JA stated that, consistent with the meaning of 'practicable', the issue whether a given task is practicable involves an enquiry as to the means and resources available to accomplish it.[29] Accordingly, Blaxell JA observed that the question of whether or not it was 'practicable' to record an admission will always involve a consideration of what resources (in terms of personnel and equipment) were available.[30] Other factors include the time that was available to organise those resources, the degree of expectation that an admission might be made and whether or not this justified the effort and cost involved in utilising the resources.[31] [29] Wright v The State of Western Australia [148].[30] Wright v The State of Western Australia [150].[31] Wright v The State of Western Australia [151].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established