Holmes v The State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   HOLMES -v- THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2023] WASCA 26

CORAM:   BUSS P

BEECH JA

VAUGHAN JA

HEARD:   16 JANUARY 2023

DELIVERED          :   10 FEBRUARY 2023

FILE NO/S:   CACR 39 of 2022

BETWEEN:   DEBRA JANE ALICIA HOLMES

Appellant

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   QUINLAN CJ

File Number            :   INS 11 of 2019


Catchwords:

Criminal law - Appeal against murder conviction - Where appellant made unrecorded admissions to police officers - Where appellant was intoxicated and emotional - Where there were some inconsistencies between unrecorded admissions and video record of interview made the following day -  Whether judge erred by finding that police had reasonable excuse for not recording admissions - Whether judge erred by finding that appellant's admissions were voluntary - Whether judge erred by not excluding admissions under unfairness discretion

Legislation:

Criminal Investigation Act 2006 (WA), s 118

Result:

Application for extension of time granted
Leave to appeal granted
Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : J Jackson
Respondent : B M Murray

Solicitors:

Appellant : James Jackson Criminal Defence
Respondent : Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Blum v The State of Western Australia [No 2] [2012] WASCA 40

Cleland v The Queen (1982) 151 CLR 1

EYO v The State of Western Australia [2019] WASCA 129

House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499

JMY v The State of Western Australia [2022] WASCA 60

Kelly v The State of Western Australia [2017] WASCA 221

Luo v The Queen [2020] WASCA 184

McDermott v The King (1948) 76 CLR 501

R v Arnott [2009] VSCA 299; (2009) 26 VR 490

R v Buchanan [1966] VR 9

R v Lee (1950) 82 CLR 133

R v Pfitzner (1996) 66 SASR 161

R v Swaffield [1998] HCA 1; (1998) 192 CLR 159

R v Williams (1992) 8 WAR 265

Sinclair v The King (1946) 73 CLR 316

The State of Western Australia v Holmes [2019] WASC 413

The State of Western Australia v Silich [2011] WASCA 135; (2011) 43 WAR 285

Tofilau v The Queen [2007] HCA 39; (2007) 231 CLR 396

Wendo v The Queen (1963) 109 CLR 559

WP v The State of Western Australia [2011] WASCA 198

Wright v The State of Western Australia [2010] WASCA 199; (2010) 43 WAR 1

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:

Introduction

  1. The appellant appeals her conviction for murder.  Her sole ground of appeal challenges a pre-trial ruling admitting evidence of certain unrecorded admissions made by the appellant to police officers. 

  2. There was no dispute at the appellant's trial that while she and the deceased, her partner, were in the shed at their property, the deceased died as a result of a shot fired from a rifle held by the appellant.  In issue were whether the appellant's act was unwilled, whether she…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holmes v The State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASCA 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Holmes v The State of Western Australia, the central issue revolves around the admissibility of unrecorded admissions made by the appellant, Holmes, to law enforcement officers. These admissions were pivotal in the prosecution's case against Holmes. The legal dispute focused on whether these unrecorded admissions could be admitted into evidence under the Criminal Investigation Act (CI Act). The appellant argued that the admissions were involuntary due to her level of intoxication at the time, while the prosecution maintained that the admissions were voluntary and should be admitted under the provisions of the CI Act, which allows for the admission of such evidence if certain criteria are met. The court was required to determine whether the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighed its undesirability, as per section 155 of the CI Act, and whether the admissions were voluntary under common law.

The court examined the provisions of the CI Act, particularly section 118(3)(b) and section 155, which provide that unrecorded admissions are not admissible unless a reasonable excuse for the absence of a recording is proven or the court decides, under section 155, to admit the evidence despite its undesirability. The court had to consider various factors, including the seriousness of the offence, the seriousness of any contravention of the Act in obtaining the evidence, and the probative value of the evidence. Additionally, the court assessed the voluntariness of the admissions, taking into account the appellant's level of intoxication. The court also had to determine whether the exercise of the common law discretion to exclude otherwise admissible confessional evidence on the basis of unfairness was warranted.

The court found that while the appellant's intoxication was a factor to consider in assessing the voluntariness of the admissions, it did not render the admissions involuntary. The court concluded that the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighed its undesirability under section 155 of the CI Act, and the admissions were voluntary. Consequently, the court ruled that the admissions could be admitted as evidence. The appellant's appeal against the admissibility of the unrecorded admissions was therefore dismissed. The court's decision was based on a thorough analysis of the statutory provisions and common law principles, ensuring that all relevant factors were considered in reaching its conclusion.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 155 of the CI Act provides:Inadmissible evidence, court may allow admission(1) This section applies if under another section a court may make a decision under this section in relation to evidence that is not admissible in proceedings in the court.(2) The court may nevertheless decide to admit the evidence if it is satisfied that the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighs the undesirability of admitting the evidence.(3) In making a decision under subsection (2) the court must take into account -(a) any objection to the evidence being admitted by the person against whom the evidence may be given;(b) the seriousness of the offence in respect of which the evidence is relevant;(c) the seriousness of any contravention of this Act in obtaining the evidence;(d) whether any contravention of this Act in obtaining the evidence -(i) was intentional or reckless; or(ii) arose from an honest and reasonable mistake of fact;(e) the probative value of the evidence;(f) any other matter the court thinks fit.(4) The probative value of the evidence does not by itself justify its admission. As can be seen, under s 118(3)(b) of the CI Act, unrecorded admissions are not admissible unless (i) the prosecution proves, on the balance of probabilities, that there is a reasonable excuse for the absence of an audio-visual recording or (ii) the court decides otherwise under s 155 of the CI Act. Before the directions hearing judge, it was accepted by both parties that the admissions made to the first responders and the other admissions the subject of the prosecution application were not audio-visually recorded and were therefore prima facie inadmissible. Section 155(2) of the CI Act, read with s 118(3)(b)(ii), provides that the court may, notwithstanding the absence of an audio-visual recording and the absence of a reasonable excuse, admit the evidence if it is satisfied that the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighs the undesirability of admitting the evidence, taking into account the factors listed in s 155(3). The prosecution contended that, to the extent that there was not a reasonable excuse for the absence of an audio-visual recording, the evidence should be admitted pursuant to s 155(2). Under the common law, admissions are inadmissible if they were made involuntarily. As explained later in these reasons, intoxication is relevant to the issue of voluntariness. Before the directions hearing judge, the appellant contended, and the prosecution denied, that her admissions were involuntary. Even if there was a reasonable excuse, or if s 155 was satisfied, and the admissions were voluntary, the circumstances may mean that the admissions should be ruled inadmissible in the exercise of the common law discretion to exclude otherwise admissible confessional evidence on the ground of unfairness. Again, we will say more as to these principles later in these reasons. The appellant invoked this discretion in opposing the prosecution's application. So, in summary, at the directions hearing, it was accepted that the admissions would only be admissible if: (1)(a) there was a reasonable excuse for them being unrecorded, or (b) the desirability of admitting them outweighed the undesirability of admitting them for the purposes of s 155(2);(2)they were made voluntarily; and (3)the judge's discretion to exclude them on the basis of unfairness should not be exercised. Each of these steps was in issue before the directions hearing judge and each is in issue on appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established