[2011] WADC 4
| JURISDICTION | : | DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA IN CRIMINAL |
| LOCATION | : PERTH | ||
| CITATION |
| ||
| CORAM | : SLEIGHT DCJ | ||
| HEARD |
| ||
| DELIVERED |
| ||
| FILE NO/S |
| ||
| BETWEEN |
|
AND
CJF
Catchwords:
Application by the State to lead propensity and relationship evidence - Evidence of prior sexual penetration outside the jurisdiction of the court - Evidence of overtly sexual behaviour towards the complainant - Evidence of non-overtly sexual behaviour towards the complainant - Rulings turn on the nature of the evidence to be presented
Legislation:
Evidence Act 1906, s 31A
Result:
Various rulings
[2011] WADC 4
Representation:
Counsel:
| State of Western Australia | : | Mr B Hollingsworth |
| Accused | : | Mr I D Hope |
Solicitors:
| State of Western Australia | : | State Director of Public Prosecutions |
| Accused | : | Ian Hope |
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Buiks v State of Western Australia [2008] WASCA 194
Buttsworth v The Queen (2004) 29 WAR 1
Dair v State of Western Australia [2008] WASCA 72; (2008) 36 WAR 413
Di Lena v The State of Western Australia [2006] WASCA 162; (2006) 165 A
Crim R 482
Donaldson v The State of Western Australia [2005] WASCA 196; (2005) 31
WAR 122
DTS v The Queen [2008] NSWCCA 329
HML v The Queen [2008] HCA 16; (2008) 235 CLR 334
Horsman v The State of Western Australia [2008] WASCA 190
Mansell v State of Western Australia [2009] WASCA 140
Noto v The State of Western Australia [2006] WASCA 278; (2006) 168 A Crim
R 457
Pfennig v R [1995] HCA 7; (1995) 182 CLR 461
PIM v The State of Western Australia [2009] WASCA 131; (2009)
196 A Crim R 516
R v ATR [2008] QCA 385
R v McKenzie-McHarg [2008] VSCA 206
R v S, PC [2008] SASC 285; (2008) 102 SASR 199
R v UC [2008] QCA 194
The State of Western Australia v Atherton [2009] WASCA 148
Upton v The State of Western Australia [2008] WASCA 54
Zaknic Pty Ltd v Svelte Corporation Pty Ltd (1995) 61 FCR 171
[2011] WADC 4
SLEIGHT DCJ: The accused is charged with the following:
1. Two counts of indecently dealing with a child who he then knew to be his de facto child and who was a child under the age 16 years. 2. Four counts of sexually penetrating a child who he then knew to be his de facto child, and who was a child under the age of 16 years.
The State's application before me is pursuant to s 98 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2004 whereby the State seeks a direction as to the admissibility of certain items of evidence. Most of the evidence is propensity or relationship evidence as defined in s 31A of the Evidence Act 1906.
The accused's trial is to be held at a later…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND CJF and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] WADC 4
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the definition of significant probative value, which lies between mere relevance and substantial relevance. The court referenced previous cases, including Zaknic Pty Ltd v Svelte Corporation Pty Ltd, Dair's case, Buiks v State of Western Australia, Mansell v State of Western Australia, and The State of Western Australia v Atherton. The court acknowledged that determining whether evidence has significant probative value can be challenging and relied on the principle that the evidence must point strongly to the existence of the relevant fact in issue. The court also considered whether relationship evidence had significant probative value, which depended on the nature of the relationship and the circumstances of the case.
The Court of Appeal found that the evidence of prior sexual penetration outside the jurisdiction had significant probative value because it was relevant to the charged offences and demonstrated a pattern of behaviour. The overtly sexual behaviour towards the complainant also had significant probative value as it pointed strongly to the existence of the relevant fact in issue. However, the court found that the non-overtly sexual behaviour towards the complainant did not have significant probative value. The court emphasised that relationship evidence was not automatically significantly probative and that evidence of the details of the relationship must have significant probative value.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the trial court for a fresh trial. The court ordered that the evidence of prior sexual penetration outside the jurisdiction and overtly sexual behaviour towards the complainant be admitted, while the evidence of non-overtly sexual behaviour towards the complainant be excluded. The court also directed that the trial judge consider the weight to be given to the evidence of prior sexual penetration outside the jurisdiction and overtly sexual behaviour towards the complainant in light of the court's findings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
After referring to a decision of Haydon J in Zaknic Pty Ltd v Svelte Corporation Pty Ltd (1995) 61 FCR 171, 175 - 176 Steytler P went on to state as follows: Haydon J suggested that significant probative value is something more than mere relevance but something less than a substantial degree of relevance and that it is a probative value which is important or of consequence. He makes the point that the significance of the probative value of tendency evidence must depend upon the nature of the facts in issue to which it is relevant and the significance or importance at which that evidence may have in establishing the facts. The decision of Steytler P in Dair's case has been cited with approval in subsequent Court of Appeal decisions such as Horsman v The State of Western Australia [2008] WASCA 190; Buiks v State of Western Australia [2008] WASCA 194; Mansell v State of Western Australia [2009] WASCA 140 and The State of Western Australia v Atherton [2009] WASCA 148. It is not always easy to apply the definition to an evidentiary circumstance. I believe assistance is provided by other dicta. In Dair's case Heenan AJA stated as follows [267]: For the propensity evidence to be admissible, it must 'have significant probative value' thereby emphasising that a merely tenuous, oblique or remote probative potential of the evidence would be insufficient to justify admission. In Buik's case Murray AJA stated as follows [139]: The first test of the admission of the evidence is that, in the context of the case, having regard to the whole of the evidence adduced or to be adduced, it has significant probative value. The evidence must be more than merely relevant to the proof of a fact in issue. It must be of such substance and weight that it points strongly to the existence of the relevant fact in issue. Propensity evidence is potentially significantly probative if it tends to show the accused is likely to commit the crime he or she is charged. The probative force of propensity evidence, assessed by reference to objective probabilities, derives, directly or indirectly, from propensity reasoning: see Noto's case at [24]. Whether propensity evidence is significantly probative will depend upon the circumstances. Often this will involve a consideration of the similarities between the circumstances of the propensity evidence and the charged offences to see if there is any similarity or underlying pattern. It is clear that relationship evidence is not automatically significantly probative. It is not enough to simply say the jury should be made aware of the full details of the relationship between the accused and a complainant. Evidence of the details of the relationship must have significant probative value. This may arise in many ways but alleged inappropriate conduct to be significantly probative is generally held relevant for one of the following reasons (see Buttsworth v The Queen (2004) 29 WAR 1 [15] – [23] (Murray, Templeman, Wheeler, Miller and McKechnie JJ)):