The State of Western Australia v Atherton

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- ATHERTON [2009] WASCA 148

CORAM:   PULLIN JA

BUSS JA
MILLER JA

HEARD:   21 MAY 2009

DELIVERED          :   25 AUGUST 2009

FILE NO/S:   CACR 118 of 2008

BETWEEN:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Appellant

AND

STEVEN JOHN ATHERTON
Respondent

FILE NO/S              :CACR 122 of 2008

BETWEEN             :STEVEN JOHN ATHERTON

Appellant

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :MACKNAY DCJ

File No  :IND 984 of 2005

Catchwords:

Criminal law - Propensity evidence - Section 31A Evidence Act 1906 (WA) - Admissibility of evidence of appellant's conviction for possession of methylamphetamine with intent to supply - Conviction in 2005 - Charges relating to offences of possession with intent to sell or supply of various drugs in 2004 and in 2006 - Whether circumstances in which pleas made at time of conviction for 2005 offence adequately put before jury - Whether miscarriage of justice

Criminal and procedure - Severance - Offences of possession with intent to sell or supply of methylamphetamine, MDMA and cannabis - Offences in 2004 - Offences of possession with intent to sell or supply of methylamphetamine and MDMA - Offences in 2006 - Whether indictment should have been severed - Whether evidence cross­admissible - Whether prejudice could be adequately guarded against by direction - Section 133(5) Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA)

Criminal law - Sentence - Prosecution appeal - Proper construction and effect of s 41(4) of the Criminal Appeals Act 2004 (WA) as amended by the Criminal Law and Evidence Amendment Act 2008 (WA) - Whether common law principles applicable to State appeals against sentence have been abrogated

Criminal law - Sentence - Prosecution appeal - Conviction on nine counts of possession with intent to sell or supply of drugs including methylamphetamine, MDMA and cannabis - Substantial quantities of methylamphetamine and MDMA - Aggregate sentence of 8 years' imprisonment - Whether manifestly inadequate

Legislation:

Criminal Appeals Act 2004 (WA), s 31(3), s 31(4), s 41(4)
Criminal Law and Evidence Amendment Act 2008 (WA)
Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA), s 40, s 98, s 133, s 135(5)
Evidence Act 1906 (WA), s 31A
Misuse of Drugs Act 1981 (WA), s 6(1)(a)

Result:

CACR 118 of 2008

Appeal allowed
Sentences imposed by the primary judge set aside
Respondent re-sentenced

CACR 122 of 2008

Leave to appeal on proposed ground 3 refused
Appeal dismissed

Category:    A

Representation:

CACR 118 of 2008

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr P D Yovich & Ms K I Goddard-Borger

Respondent:     Mr A E Eyers

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)

Respondent:     D G Price & Co

CACR 122 of 2008

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr A E Eyers

Respondent:     Mr P D Yovich & Ms K I Goddard-Borger

Solicitors:

Appellant:     D G Price & Co

Respondent:     Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Atholwood v The Queen [2000] WASCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v Atherton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASCA 148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The State of Western Australia appealed against the convictions and sentences of the appellant, Atherton, who was found guilty of nine counts of possession with intent to sell or supply of drugs, including methylamphetamine, MDMA, and cannabis. The appeal centred on the admissibility of the appellant's 2005 conviction for possession of methylamphetamine with intent to supply, the severance of the indictment, and the proportionality of the sentence. The appellant was acquitted of a charge relating to possession of cannabis with intent to sell or supply. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The key legal issues were whether the 2005 conviction was admissible under s 31A of the Evidence Act, whether the indictment should have been severed, whether the evidence was cross-admissible, and whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate. The court needed to determine whether the appellant's 2005 conviction was properly before the jury and if its admission led to a miscarriage of justice. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the offences were properly joined and whether the prejudice from the evidence could be guarded against by direction under s 133(5) of the Criminal Procedure Act. Lastly, the court assessed whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate under s 41(4) of the Criminal Appeals Act.

The court found that the appellant's 2005 conviction was admissible under s 31A of the Evidence Act. The court concluded that the evidence had significant probative value and that fair-minded people would think the public interest in adducing all relevant evidence of guilt must have priority over the risk of an unfair trial. The court further found that the indictment should not have been severed as the offences were properly joined, and the prejudice from the evidence could be guarded against by direction. Finally, the court held that the sentence was not manifestly inadequate and dismissed the appeal.

The appeal was dismissed, and the convictions and sentences of the appellant were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 31A of the Evidence Act provides: (1)In this section ‑ 'propensity evidence' means ‑ (a)similar fact evidence or other evidence of the conduct of the accused person; or(b)evidence of the character or reputation of the accused person or of a tendency that the accused person has or had;'relationship evidence' means evidence of the attitude or conduct of the accused person towards another person, or a class of persons, over a period of time. (2)Propensity evidence or relationship evidence is admissible in proceedings for an offence if the court considers ‑ (a)that the evidence would, either by itself or having regard to other evidence adduced or to be adduced, have significant probative value; and(b)that the probative value of the evidence compared to the degree of risk of an unfair trial, is such that fair-minded people would think that the public interest in adducing all relevant evidence of guilt must have priority over the risk of an unfair trial. (3)In considering the probative value of evidence for the purposes of subsection (2) it is not open to the court to have regard to the possibility that the evidence may be the result of collusion, concoction or suggestion. Section 31A was introduced into the Evidence Act by s 13 of the Criminal Law Amendment (Sexual Assault and Other Matters) Act 2004 (WA). It was introduced in conjunction with amendments to the law of joinder to override the decision of the High Court in Hoch v The Queen [1988] HCA 50; (1988) 165 CLR 292. The Parliament's purpose in enacting s 31A was to confer on the courts greater power to admit propensity and relationship evidence. See the second reading speech of the Hon Attorney General: Western Australia, Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 30 June 2004, 4068. It appears that the policy underlying s 31A reflected these observations of McHugh J, in his dissenting judgment in Pfennig v The Queen [1995] HCA 7; (1995) 182 CLR 461:The judge must compare the probative strength of the evidence with the degree of risk of an unfair trial if the evidence is admitted. Admitting the evidence will serve the interests of justice only if the judge concludes that the probative force of the evidence compared to the degree of risk of an unfair trial is such that fair minded people would think that the public interest in adducing all relevant evidence of guilt must have priority over the risk of an unfair trial (529). See Western Australia, Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Council, 24 September 2004, 6547 and the terms of s 31A itself. Section 31A substantially amended the common law. It abolished the test that propensity evidence is inadmissible if there is a rational view of it, when considered with other relevant evidence, that is inconsistent with the accused's guilt. See Donaldson v The State of Western Australia [2005] WASCA 196; (2005) 31 WAR 122 [102] ‑ [130]; Di Lena v The State of Western Australia [2006] WASCA 162; (2006) 165 A Crim R 482 [44] ‑ [73]; Noto v The State of Western Australia [2006] WASCA 278; (2006) 168 A Crim R 457 [26]. By s 31A, 'propensity evidence' and 'relationship evidence', as defined in s 31A(1), are admissible if the court considers that the requirements of each of pars (a) and (b) of s 31A(2) have been satisfied.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established