Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: The Adoption of Tiana (a pseudonym) [2024] NSWSC 1561 Hearing dates: In chambers Date of orders: 9 December 2024 Decision date: 09 December 2024 Jurisdiction: Equity - Adoptions List Before: Meek J Decision: Dispensation with notice of the application for a consent dispense order in respect of the birth parents. Consent dispense order made in respect of the birth parents. Dispensation with notice of the application for the adoption order to the birth parents. Adoption order made. Order approving change of child’s name made.
Catchwords: FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE — Adoption of 9 year old child where the birth parents have not provided consent — Whether the birth parents had been provided with the required notice pursuant to ss 72(1) and 88(1)(a) Adoption Act 2000 (NSW) (“Adoption Act”) through email communications
FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE — Notice — Requirements for giving of “notice” discussed — Review of the legislative history and subsequent amendments to s 197(1) Adoption Act, which specifies the manner of giving notice under the Act — Held that notice via email will only fulfil the requirements of s 197(1)(b) if, prior to the notice giver attempting to give notice to the intended recipient by email to a particular email address, the intended recipient confirmed that such email address may be used for the service of documents of that kind — Held that the required notice was not effected
FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE — Dispensing with consent — Whether consent of the birth parents should be dispensed with pursuant to s 67(1)(d) Adoption Act — In circumstances where the child had been placed with the proposed adoptive parents for close to 90% of her life (including the last eight years), there had been little engagement from the birth parents and there was no realistic prospect of the child being able to return to both or either of her birth parents, held that a consent dispense order in respect of the birth parents should be made
FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE — Considerations bearing upon orders dispensing with the requirement for birth parents’ consent identified and discussed — Whether notice of the application for a consent dispense order in respect of the birth parents should be dispensed with pursuant to s 72(2)(c) Adoption Act — While formal notice had not been effected, the birth parents had been made aware of the fact that an adoption order was being sought and progressed in this Court by email correspondence with the applicant — Consideration of the best interests of the child — In the circumstances, held that it was desirable to make the consent dispense order without notice of the application having been given to the birth parents
FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE — Requirements for notice of the application for adoption on the birth parents — Apparent overlap of notification provisions and dispensation powers as between ss 54(3) and 88(1) and (4) Adoption Act discussed and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Adoption of Tiana (a pseudonym) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWSC 1561
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the notice requirements were met through email communications. It concluded that notice via email would only be valid if the birth parents had previously confirmed that they accepted service of such documents via email. As no such confirmation was obtained, the court held that the required notice was not properly given. In terms of dispensing with the birth parents' consent, the court found that there was little engagement from the birth parents and no realistic prospect of the child returning to either parent. Therefore, the court made a consent dispense order in respect of the birth parents.
The court also deliberated on whether notice of the application for a consent dispense order should be dispensed with, and despite the failure to formally notify the birth parents, they were aware of the proceedings via email. The court deemed it desirable to proceed with the consent dispense order without formal notice to the birth parents. Additionally, the court considered whether notice of the application for an adoption order should be dispensed with and concluded that it would not be in the child's best interests to delay the adoption due to difficulties in formal notice. The court thus dispensed with the requirement for formal notice of the application to the birth parents.
Finally, the court addressed the change of the child's surname to align with her proposed adoptive parents. After considering the child's wishes, the views of the proposed adoptive parents and birth parents, and the opinion of the assessor, the court approved the proposed change of surname. The adoption order was ultimately made in the child's best interests.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case came before the court on an application for an adoption order in respect of Tiana. The application included a request to dispense with the consent of the birth parents pursuant to section 67(1)(d) of the Adoption Act, as well as a request to dispense with the notice of the application for a consent dispense order pursuant to section 72(2)(c) of the Act. The court also had to consider whether to dispense with the requirement for notice of the application for an adoption order pursuant to section 88(4) of the Act. The matter had been previously considered by the Family Court, which made several orders related to the child's welfare and the adoption process.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the required notice to the birth parents provided in compliance with sections 72(1) and 88(1)(a) of the Adoption Act?
2. Should the consent of the birth parents be dispensed with pursuant to section 67(1)(d) of the Adoption Act?
3. Should notice of the application for a consent dispense order be dispensed with pursuant to section 72(2)(c) of the Adoption Act?
4. Should the notice of the application for an adoption order be dispensed with pursuant to section 88(4) of the Adoption Act?
5. Should the adoption order be made in the best interests of the child?
6. Should the Court approve the proposed change to the child's surname to align with that of her proposed adoptive parents?
Held
1. The court concluded that the required notice to the birth parents was not provided in compliance with sections 72(1) and 88(1)(a) of the Adoption Act.
2. The court decided that the consent of the birth parents should be dispensed with pursuant to section 67(1)(d) of the Adoption Act.
3. The court held that notice of the application for a consent dispense order should be dispensed with pursuant to section 72(2)(c) of the Adoption Act.
4. The court concluded that notice of the application for an adoption order should be dispensed with pursuant to section 88(4) of the Adoption Act.
5. The court decided that the adoption order should be made in the best interests of the child.
6. The court approved the proposed change to the child's surname to align with that of her proposed adoptive parents.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether the required notice to the birth parents had been provided in compliance with sections 72(1) and 88(1)(a) of the Adoption Act. The court found that the notice provided via email did not meet the requirements as set out in section 197(1)(b) of the Adoption Act, which stipulated that notice by email would only be valid if the intended recipient had previously confirmed that such email address could be used for the service of documents of that kind. Given that there was no such confirmation, the court held that the required notice was not effected.
The court then turned to the issue of whether the consent of the birth parents should be dispensed with pursuant to section 67(1)(d) of the Adoption Act. The court noted that the child had been placed with the proposed adoptive parents for close to 90% of her life, and there had been little engagement from the birth parents. The court also noted that there was no realistic prospect of the child being able to return to either of her birth parents. In light of these circumstances, the court held that a consent dispense order in respect of the birth parents should be made.
Next, the court addressed whether notice of the application for a consent dispense order should be dispensed with pursuant to section 72(2)(c) of the Adoption Act. The court found that although formal notice had not been effected, the birth parents had been made aware of the fact that an adoption order was being sought and progressed in the Court through email correspondence with the applicant. The court also considered the best interests of the child, and concluded that it was desirable to make the consent dispense order without notice of the application having been given to the birth parents.
The court then considered whether notice of the application for an adoption order should be dispensed with pursuant to section 88(4) of the Adoption Act. The court found that despite several unsuccessful attempts to give formal notice of the application to each of the birth parents, both had been made aware that an adoption order was being sought by email correspondence with the applicant. The court considered that it would not be in the child's best interests for any adoption order to be stymied by difficulties with the applicant being able to formally give notice of the application to her birth parents, and held that the giving of notice of the application to the birth parents be dispensed with.
Finally, the court considered whether the adoption order should be made. The court concluded that in all the circumstances, the adoption order should be made. The court also approved the proposed change to the child's surname to align with that of her proposed adoptive parents, considering the wishes of the child, the proposed adoptive parents and the birth parents, as well as the assessor's opinion.