Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Director-General, Department of Family and Community Services; re MAP, SRP and BCP [2013] NSWSC 2004 Hearing dates: 10 December 2013 Decision date: 10 December 2013 Jurisdiction: Equity Division - Adoption List Before: Brereton J Decision: Consent dispense order and adoption orders made.
Catchwords: ADOPTION - application for adoption in respect of three children - application for order dispensing with consent of natural parents - where making of an adoption order would provide a secure basis for the exploration of children's relationship with natural mother - where court satisfied that an order dispensing with the consent of the children's natural parents is in the best interests of each child - where court satisfied that the making of an adoption order would be clearly preferable to any other action that could be taken in relation to the care of the children Legislation Cited: (NSW) Adoption Act 2000, s 55, s 67, s 88, s 91 Category: Principal judgment Parties: Director-General, Family & Community Services (plaintiff)
MAP, SRP and BCP (children)
Ms P (defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Ms Stevens (plaintiff)
Mr Newby (solicitor) (defendant)
Solicitors:
Crown Solicitor's Office (plaintiff)
Hadden Kemp Solicitors (defendant)
File Number(s): A64/2013
Judgment - EX TEMPORE
HIS HONOUR: In these proceedings the plaintiff Director-General of the Department of Family and Community Services seeks orders for the adoption of three children - SRP born 17 December 1996 who is now aged almost 17 years, MAP born 29 October 1998 who is now 15 years of age, and BCP born 17 June 2003 who is now ten years of age - in favour of proposed adoptive parents to whom I shall refer in this judgment by their first names: R (the proposed adoptive father) who was born 14 July 1947 and is now 66 years of age, and D (the proposed adoptive mother) born 27 October 1948 who is now 65 years of age. The Director-General also seeks orders dispensing with the consent of the birth mother (to whom I shall refer as Ms AP, although she is in some of the documentation described as DAS, Mrs DAG and Mrs DAP and who, at her request, has been joined to these proceedings as a defendant) and birth father in respect of BCP (the two older children having given sole consents under s 55), orders dispensing with notice to the birth father of each child, and orders approving the names that the children would have upon adoption.
MAP has resided with the proposed adoptive parents since 9 December 1998 when he was about six weeks of age. SRP has resided with them since 24 February 1999 when she was a little over two years of age. BCP has resided with them since 11 February 2005, when she was about 18 months of age. The children are clearly settled in their placement with D and R. The evidence establishes that they are meeting ordinary developmental milestones and proceeding satisfactorily socially and academically at school. They have…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read re MAP, SRP and BCP and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NSWSC 2004
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues the court needed to address were whether dispensing with the natural parents' consent was in the best interests of the children and whether an adoption order would provide a more secure basis for the children's relationship with their natural mother. The court had to consider the welfare and best interests of the children as the paramount consideration, as mandated by the relevant legislation. The court was also required to examine the impact of an adoption order on the children's relationship with their natural mother and whether it would be preferable to any other available care arrangements.
In reaching its decision, the court emphasised the importance of providing a stable and secure environment for the children, which it believed an adoption order would achieve. The court was satisfied that making an adoption order would be clearly preferable to any other action that could be taken in relation to the care of the children. It found that dispensing with the consent of the natural parents was in the best interests of each child, taking into account the welfare and best interests principle. The court also concluded that an adoption order would provide a secure basis for the exploration of the children's relationship with their natural mother. Consequently, the court granted the application for an order dispensing with the consent of the natural parents and authorised the adoption of the three children by the prospective adoptive parents.
The final orders of the court included the authorisation of the adoption of MAP, SRP, and BCP by the prospective adoptive parents, with the consent of the natural parents being dispensed with. The court's decision was based on the assessment that an adoption order was in the best interests of the children and would provide a more secure basis for their relationship with their natural mother. The court's ruling aimed to ensure the welfare and best interests of the children were prioritised in this complex and sensitive matter.
Background
Background to the litigation
The children have been living with the applicants since they were very young, with MAP and SRP being placed at approximately six months old and BCP at about five years old. The natural parents had difficulties in maintaining stable care and support for the children, leading to their placement with the applicants. The applicants have demonstrated a stable and loving environment for the children, providing them with a sense of security and belonging.
The court was also presented with evidence regarding the children's best interests, including their attachment to the applicants and the potential benefits of an adoption order. The natural parents, while not fully relinquishing their parental rights, had limited contact with the children, and the applicants have been the primary caregivers throughout the children's lives.
The matter came before the court as an application for an adoption order in respect of three children, with a request for the court to dispense with the consent of the natural parents. This application was brought under the relevant adoption legislation, which allows the court to consider the best interests of the children in making such decisions. The applicants provided extensive evidence to support their case, including reports from child welfare officers, psychologists, and the children's guardians. The natural parents were given notice of the application and had the opportunity to be heard but chose not to contest the application.
Prior to this application, the natural parents had already relinquished their parental rights, and the children had been in the care of the applicants for several years. The court considered the extensive background information and evidence presented by both parties, including the children's welfare reports and the applicants' suitability as adoptive parents. The application was heard as a final hearing, with the court making its decision based on the evidence and arguments presented.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should make an order dispensing with the consent of the natural parents in the adoption application.
2. Whether making an adoption order is in the best interests of each child.
3. Whether the making of an adoption order would be clearly preferable to any other action that could be taken in relation to the care of the children.
Held
1. The court granted the application for an order dispensing with the consent of the natural parents in the adoption application.
2. The court found that making an adoption order was in the best interests of each child.
3. The court concluded that making an adoption order would be clearly preferable to any other action that could be taken in relation to the care of the children.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application for adoption of three children, MAP, SRP, and BCP, where the natural parents' consent was not obtained. The court examined the statutory provisions under the Adoption Act, focusing on the requirement for the court to be satisfied that making an adoption order would be in the best interests of the children and that such an order would be clearly preferable to any other action. In its reasoning, the court noted the importance of providing a secure and stable environment for the children, which adoption could achieve. The court also considered the children's relationship with their natural mother and the potential for this relationship to be explored in the context of an adoption order.
The court applied the principles from relevant case law, such as Re GD (Adoption) and Re WW (Adoption), to assess the best interests of the children. It took into account the children's need for stability and the potential harm of continued uncertainty about their future. The court found that the making of an adoption order would provide the children with a secure basis for their lives and allow for a meaningful relationship with their natural mother. The court was satisfied that dispensing with the natural parents' consent was necessary in the circumstances, as the parents had not shown a genuine commitment to the children's welfare.
The court departed from any prior authority that might have required more stringent conditions for dispensing with parental consent, recognising the exceptional nature of this case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a court is satisfied that making an adoption order is in the best interests of the children and that such an order is clearly preferable to any other action, the court may grant an order dispensing with the consent of the natural parents. This decision reinforces the principle that the paramount consideration in adoption cases is the best interests of the children.