Telstra Corporation Ltd v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Telstra Corporation Ltd v State of Queensland [2016] FCA 1213

File number: QUD 202 of 2012
Judge: RANGIAH J
Date of judgment: 14 October 2016
Catchwords: COMMUNICATIONS LAW– whether Land Regulation 2009 (Qld) impermissibly discriminates against carriers by imposing higher rents on carriers than on other businesses for State leases – whether Land Regulation 2009 (Qld) discriminates by denying carriers a right to appeal against rents – construction of cl 44 of Sch 3 to the Telecommunications Act1997 (Cth) to determine whether market rent is a relevant, appropriate or permissible distinction
Legislation:

Australian and Overseas Telecommunications Act 1991 (Cth)

Competitionand Consumer Act2010 (Cth) Pts XIB and XIC

Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) ss 3, 7, 26, 30, 42, 56, 484, cll 27, 36, 37, 38, 39, 44 of Sch 3 and Divs 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8 of Sch 3

Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (Cth) s 12A

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) s 96

Land Act 1994 (Qld) ss 15, 153, 183 (repealed), 199A, 332, 448, Sch 1B and Pt 1, Chapter 5 (repealed)

Land Regulation 1995 (Qld) ss 12, 15, 19 (repealed)

Land Regulation 2009 (Qld) ss 26A, 27, 30, 33, 37A and Sch 12

Land and Other Legislation Amendment Act2014 (Qld)

Land Act and Other Legislation Amendment Regulation (No 1) 2014 (Qld)

Land Valuation Act 2010 (Qld) ss 5, 6, 7, 19, 26, 72, 105, 147, 155 and 172

Lands Legislation Amendment Act 1991 (Qld)

Local Government Act 1989 (Vic) ss 154 and 155 of Pt 8

Local Government Act 1993 (NSW) s 611

Explanatory Notes for the Land Bill 1994 (Qld)

Cases cited:

Bayside City Council v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2004) 216 CLR 595

Castlemaine Tooheys Ltd v South Australia (1990) 169 CLR 436

Development Assessment Commission v 3GIS Pty Ltd (2007) 212 FLR 123

Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Rockdale City Council (2005) 144 FCR 158

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hurstville City Council (2000) 103 FCR 322

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hurstville City Council (2002) 118 FCR 198

Telstra Corporation Ltd v State of Queensland [2013] FCA 1296

Date of hearing: 26, 27 and 28 April 2016
Date of last submissions: 28 April 2016
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 214
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr JD McKenna QC with Mr DS Piggott
Solicitor for the Applicant: King & Wood Mallesons
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Horton QC with Ms A Stoker
Solicitor for the Respondent: Crown Law

ORDERS

QUD 202 of 2012
BETWEEN:

TELSTRA CORPORATION LTD

Applicant

AND:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND

Respondent

JUDGE:

RANGIAH J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 OCTOBER 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant provide a draft of the orders it seeks to the respondent by 4 pm on 19 October 2016. 

2.The respondent provide to the applicant its response to the draft orders by 4 pm on 26 October 2016.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corporation Ltd v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1213
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Telstra Corporation Ltd, the largest telecommunications carrier in Australia, brought proceedings against the State of Queensland, challenging the legality of certain provisions within the Land Regulation 2009 (Qld). Telstra contended that these provisions, which govern the rents payable on State leases, impermissibly discriminate against carriers by imposing higher rents on them compared to other businesses. Furthermore, Telstra argued that the provisions unjustifiably deny carriers the right to appeal against the prescribed rents. The central legal question was whether the Land Regulation 2009 (Qld) violated clause 44 of Schedule 3 to the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) by discriminating against carriers in a manner not permissible under federal law.

The Court examined the statutory language of clause 44, which nullifies state laws that discriminate against carriers. The Court determined that the State had not demonstrated that the rents for categories 15.4 and 15.5 leases reasonably approximated market rents for leases over private land for communication purposes. Consequently, the Court found that the State's provisions did indeed discriminate against carriers in a manner prohibited by clause 44. Given this finding, the Court concluded that Telstra's application must succeed, and the State's cross-claim must be dismissed. The Court ordered Telstra to provide draft orders for repayment of overpaid rent, giving the parties an opportunity to agree on the precise form of relief. Should they fail to reach an agreement, the Court would then make the necessary orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant provide a draft of the orders it seeks to the respondent by 4 pm on 19 October 2016.

2. The respondent provide to the applicant its response to the draft orders by 4 pm on 26 October 2016.

3. The parties are to either provide the Court with agreed draft orders or notify the Court that no agreement has been reached by 4 pm on 1 November 2016.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The resolution of these issues requires detailed consideration of the relevant statutory provisions, as well as valuation evidence called by each party. FACTS Telstra owns and operates the largest and most comprehensive fixed line and mobile telecommunications network in Australia. It is necessary for Telstra to place infrastructure on land throughout Australia, including on State land, in order to operate its network and provide carriage services. The infrastructure or facilities comprising Telstra’s fixed line network includes: exchanges; optic fibre cabling (underground and overhead); copper cabling (underground and overhead); optical fibre regenerators; radio towers; and, in remote areas, digital radio communications systems, high capacity radio concentrators and multiple drop out units. Additional facilities called “base stations” are needed to operate a mobile telephone network. Base stations receive and send radio transmissions to and from mobile telephones. Telstra’s base stations comprise Cellular Mobile Telephone Services Base Stations (“CMTS”) and microcells. When a call is made on Telstra’s fixed line telephone network, a signal is transmitted from the caller’s telephone through a network of cables, optical fibre, radio towers and exchanges to the recipient’s telephone. When a call is made on a mobile telephone, a signal is transmitted from the telephone to antennae which are linked by cabling or radio-link technology into and through the fixed line telephone network. Until 1991, Telecom was the only provider of telecommunication services in Australia. By the Australian and Overseas Telecommunications Act 1991 (Cth), the property and operations of Telecom were vested in the company now known as Telstra Corporation Ltd. A suite of legislation, including the Telecommunications Act, was also introduced allowing other telecommunications service providers to compete. Telstra is the only carrier with a fixed line telephone network in Queensland. It was unnecessary for competitors to replicate Telstra’s fixed line network as Telstra is required to give other carriers reasonable access to its fixed line network. Three carriers, Telstra, Vodafone and Optus, operate retail mobile telephone networks in Queensland. All three have set up mobile telephone infrastructure in populated areas and along some major highways. However the vast majority of the land area of Queensland is not covered by any mobile telephone service. Telstra’s infrastructure is situated in a wide variety of urban and rural locations. When Telstra selects sites for the installation of the infrastructure required to provide fixed line or mobile telephone networks, the factors it considers include its universal service obligation, technical constraints, construction and maintenance costs and co-location of services. Pursuant to s 12A of the Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (Cth), Telstra is subject to a universal service obligation. That obligation requires Telstra to ensure that all Australians, no matter where they live or conduct business, have reasonable access on an equitable basis to a standard telephone service and payphone service. This means that Telstra must install infrastructure to provide standard telephone services and payphone services in rural and remote areas of Australia, as well as urban areas. The universal service obligation does not apply to mobile telephone services.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

His Honour also rejected a submission that the differential treatment of Optus was permissible because there was differential treatment by the Council as between the two electricity entities. ACCOUNTING EVIDENCE Telstra called an accountant, Natalie McKay, to give evidence. Ms McKay has calculated that the total amount of rent payable under the Land Regulation by Telstra to the State in the period from 1 July 2010 to 30 June 2016 for Telstra’s category 15.4 and 15.5 leases was $32,913,145. In contrast, the rent payable if Telstra’s leases instead fell within category 13 would be $3,176,007. That is a difference of $29,737,138. Telstra has stopped paying rent at the rates prescribed for category 15.5 and 15.5 leases and has instead been paying rent at the rate for category 13 leases. Telstra’s conduct was the subject of an unsuccessful application for interlocutory relief: Telstra Corporation Ltd v State of Queensland [2013] FCA 1296. Ms McKay has calculated that if Telstra has only been required to pay category 13 rent since 1 July 2010, Telstra has overpaid rent to the State in the amount of $7,827,967 in the period to 30 June 2016. Ms McKay was cross-examined as to matters she had and had not taken into account, but not as to the figures she had arrived at. I accept Ms McKay’s evidence.THE SUBMISSIONS Telstra submits that the provisions of the Land Regulation which determine the rent payable for State leases are laws that discriminate, or which have the effect (directly or indirectly) of discriminating against carriers. Telstra argues that carriers are treated adversely in comparison to other businesses which hold State leases because, firstly, carriers pay higher rents and, secondly, carriers have no statutory right to appeal against the rents that are prescribed. Telstra notes that the annual rents for category 13 leases are set at 6% of the land valuation, but the rents for categories 15.4 and 15.5 are fixed amounts, currently $12,302 and $18,453 respectively. Telstra argues that if carriers’ rents were calculated in the same way as the rents for other businesses, they would pay much less rent. In aggregate, it is presently required to pay 10 times more than it would be required to pay under category 13. Telstra has not attempted a lease-by-lease comparison of the rent it pays compared to the rent that would be payable under category 13. It also argues that other businesses are treated more favourably than carriers because other businesses effectively have a right to object to and appeal against rents, whereas carriers do not. In its written submissions, the State concedes that the Land Regulation does treat carriers detrimentally by charging them more than other leaseholders, and that it does so based on the fact that carriers use the leased areas for communications purposes or their purposes as carriers. However, the State submits that, other than in the conceded areas, such detrimental treatment does not contravene cl44 of Sch 3.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I find that the State has not proved that the rents prescribed for categories 15.4 and 15.5 reasonably approximate the market rents for leases over private land for communication purposes in the disputed areas.CONCLUSION The findings I have made mean that Telstra’s application must succeed and the State’s cross-claim must be dismissed. The relief sought by Telstra includes various declarations and orders for the repayment of rent overpaid by Telstra. I indicated in the course of the trial that I would provide my reasons and then hear from the parties as to the precise form of relief that should be granted. I will make orders requiring Telstra to provide draft orders to the State so that the parties can attempt to agree upon a form of orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 38 provides:38 Concurrent operation of State and Territory lawsIt is the intention of the Parliament that, if clause 37 entitles a carrier to engage in activities despite particular laws of a State or Territory, nothing in this Division is to affect the operation of any other law of a State or Territory, so far as that other law is capable of operating concurrently with this Act. Clause 39 provides:39 Liability to taxation not affectedThis Division does not affect the liability of a carrier to taxation under a law of a State or Territory. Although Telstra has the power under Div 3 to compulsorily install facilities on both privately owned and State land (subject to obtaining a facility installation permit where the facility is not a low-impact facility), its policy is to avoid exercising such power, and to instead negotiate leases which allow it to install and maintain such facilities. Clause 44 appears in Div 8, which has the heading “Miscellaneous”. Clause 44 provides, relevantly:44State and Territory laws that discriminate against carriers and users of carriage services(1) The following provisions have effect:(a)a law of a State or Territory has no effect to the extent to which the law discriminates, or would have the effect (whether direct or indirect) of discriminating, against a particular carrier, against a particular class of carriers, or against carriers generally;(b)without limiting paragraph (a), a person is not entitled to a right, privilege, immunity or benefit, and must not exercise a power, under a law of a State or Territory to the extent to which the law discriminates, or would have the effect (whether direct or indirect) of discriminating, against a particular carrier, against a particular class of carriers, or against carriers generally;(c)without limiting paragraph (a), a person is not required to comply with a law of a State or Territory to the extent to which the law discriminates, or would have the effect (whether direct or indirect) of discriminating, against a particular carrier, against a particular class of carriers, or against carriers generally. Clause 44 is the critical provision in this proceeding. The resolution of the proceeding requires consideration of its meaning and effect.The Land Act 1994 (Qld) In 1990, the Wolfe Committee conducted a review of land regulation in Queensland. The Wolfe Committee considered the way rents for State leases should be fixed, concluding that the preferred mechanism was to apply a percentage to the unimproved capital value of land. The Committee said:The use of unimproved value as a factor in determining rents for Crown leaseholds is soundly based as it measures the value of Crown land, and disregards the improvements and development works either owned by the lease holder or for which he may claim compensation. A rental percentage applied to the unimproved value is a fair way of determining a rent for the use of Crown land. Once a percentage rental is established the rent is then directly related to the unimproved value of and will change as the unimproved value changes.