Tarangau Game Fishing Charters Pty Ltd v Eagle Yachts Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Tarangau Game Fishing Charters Pty Ltd v Eagle Yachts Pty Ltd & Anor [2017] QSC 306

PARTIES:

TARANGAU GAME FISHING CHARTERS PTY LTD

ACN 120 602 440

(plaintiff)

v

EAGLE YACHTS PTY LTD ACN 108 311 404

(first defendant)

and

BY WINDDOWN, INC

(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

No 9201 of 2010

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

14 December 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 May 2017 to 26 May 2017

JUDGE:

Atkinson J

ORDERS:

1.   The court orders that the first defendant pay the plaintiff:

$1,933,900 together with interest pursuant to s 47 of the Supreme Court Act 1995 from 22 July 2006 until the date of judgment.

2.   The court orders that the second defendant pay the plaintiff:

$1,239,919 together with interest pursuant to s 47 of the Supreme Court Act 1995 from 7 March 2016 until the date of judgment.

CATCHWORDS:

SALE OF GOODS – SALE OF GOODS LEGISLATION – ACTIONS FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT – REMEDIES OF BUYER – where the plaintiff purchased a yacht from the first defendant which was manufactured by the second defendant – where the yacht began to delaminate and then developed other structural defects well within its expected lifetime – where the yacht was purchased for use in deep sea fishing – whether the yacht was fit for its intended purpose – whether the yacht was of merchantable quality

TRADE AND COMMERCE – COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION – TERMINOLOGY – CONSUMER – where the plaintiff purchased a yacht from the first defendant which was manufactured by the second defendant – where the yacht began to delaminate and then developed other structural defects well within its expected lifetime – where the yacht was purchased for use in deep sea fishing – where the plaintiff intended to use the boat for personal use and for commercial charter – whether the plaintiff falls within the meaning of “consumer” under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – whether the vessel was acquired for the purpose of resupply

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – where the plaintiff purchased a yacht from the first defendant which was manufactured by the second defendant – where the yacht began to delaminate and then developed other structural defects well within its expected lifetime – where the plaintiff signed a warranty card provided by the second defendant upon purchasing the yacht – where the second defendant offered to repair the yacht in accordance with the warranty upon the discovery of the defects – where four experts gave evidence about the extent of the delamination and other defects – where the plaintiff’s experts considered that the repair offer was inadequate to repair the defects – where the opinion of the plaintiff’s three experts differed significantly from the expert of the second defendant - whether the second defendant breached the terms of the warranty

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tarangau Game Fishing Charters Pty Ltd v Eagle Yachts Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QSC 306
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tarangau Game Fishing Charters Pty Ltd brought an action against Eagle Yachts Pty Ltd and Bertram Yachts LLC, alleging breaches of contract and tortious liability in relation to the sale and manufacture of a yacht. The yacht, a Bertram 570, was purchased by Tarangau from Eagle Yachts, which had acquired it from Bertram for resale. Tarangau alleged that the yacht was defective, having developed structural defects well within its expected lifetime, and that it was not fit for its intended purpose of deep sea fishing. The central legal issues revolved around whether the yacht met the required standards of fitness for purpose and merchantable quality under the sale of goods legislation, whether Tarangau qualified as a "consumer" under the Trade Practices Act, and if Bertram owed a duty of care to Tarangau in the manufacture of the yacht.

The court concluded that the yacht did not meet the required standards of fitness for purpose and merchantable quality, entitling Tarangau to damages from Eagle Yachts. The court rejected the argument that the claim against Eagle Yachts arose from a failure to take reasonable care, as there was no evidence suggesting the vessel was defective prior to the sale. The court found that Bertram breached the express warranty by failing to adequately repair the yacht's defects. Furthermore, the court held that the governing law was presumed to be that of Queensland, and Bertram could not be sued in tort for defects in the vessel under Florida law. The court awarded Tarangau damages against both defendants, with specific amounts including interest, and ordered the defendants to pay Tarangau for the breaches of contract and warranty.

In summary, the court found in favour of Tarangau, holding both Eagle Yachts and Bertram liable for breaches of the sale of goods legislation and the express warranty, respectively. The court awarded Tarangau significant damages against both defendants, along with interest, and directed the defendants to pay the specified amounts. The court further directed the parties to provide further information regarding the form of orders and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The court orders that the first defendant pay the plaintiff:

$1,933,900 together with interest pursuant to s 47 of the Supreme Court Act 1995 from 22 July 2006 until the date of judgment.

2. The court orders that the second defendant pay the plaintiff:

$1,239,919 together with interest pursuant to s 47 of the Supreme Court Act 1995 from 7 March 2016 until the date of judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is first useful to narrate the facts and matters not in dispute. Some of the matters which were hotly contested during the evidence were no longer in issue by the end of the trial.Facts not in dispute The Bertram 570 purchased by Tarangau was manufactured in about July 2004 by Bertram.[2] Bertram was a corporation incorporated in the United States of America and thus a foreign corporation within the meaning of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (“TPA”).[3] Bertram designed and built a variety of yachts some of which were designed and built for use in the open water at sea, specifically sporting fishing yachts.[4] Bertram manufactured Bertram yachts in the United States of America which were sold worldwide through a network of dealers.[5] The Bertram 570, the subject of this litigation, is described as a 57.12 foot Bertram 570 Flybridge Cruiser having motor numbers (P) CLX00571(S) CLX 00570 and bearing the manufacturer’s Hull Identification Number US-BERX7019G405.[6][2] Statement of claim paragraph 5; first defendant’s defence paragraph 4; second defendant’s defence paragraph 1; list of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 4.[3] List of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 3.[4] Statement of claim paragraph 3; first defendant’s defence paragraph 2, second defendant’s defence paragraph 1, list of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 5. [5] Statement of claim paragraph 3; first defendant’s defence paragraph 2; second defendant’s defence paragraph 1; list of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 3.[6] Statement of claim paragraph 5; first defendant’s defence paragraph 4; second defendant’s defence paragraph 1; list of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 4. By a contract dated 9 March 2004 Bertram sold the Bertram 570 (pre-manufacture) to Azure Yachts Pty Ltd (“Azure Yachts”).[7] Then in November 2004 the benefit of that contract of sale was assigned from Azure Yachts to Eagle Yachts. Eagle Yachts paid the balance of the purchase price under the contract and the Bertram 570 was delivered into its possession.[8] Prior to May 2005, Azure Yachts was Bertram’s dealer for selling, servicing and promoting Bertram Yachts in Australia. On 9 May 2005, Bertram and Eagle Yachts entered into a dealer agreement under which Bertram appointed Eagle Yachts as its exclusive dealer in Australia to sell, service and promote Bertram Yachts in Australia.[9] Pursuant to that dealer agreement, Bertram from time to time sold yachts manufactured by Bertram to Eagle Yachts in order for Eagle Yachts to resell to members of the public in Australia. As Eagle Yachts was engaged in the business of selling yachts, it was a trading corporation within the meaning of the TPA.[10] Eagle Yachts acquired the Bertram 570 from Bertram for the purpose of re-selling it to the public in Australia and Bertram supplied the Bertram 570 to Eagle Yachts in trade and commerce.[11][7] Statement of claim paragraph 6; first defendant’s defence paragraph 5; second defendant’s defence paragraph 1; list of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 6.[8] Statement of claim paragraph 7; first defendant’s defence paragraph 6; second defendant’s defence paragraph 5; list of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 7.[9] Statement of claim paragraph 4; first defendant’s defence paragraph 3; second defendant’s defence paragraph 1; list of facts and matters not in issue paragraphs 8, 9. [10] Statement of claim paragraph 2; first defendant’s defence paragraph 1; second defendant’s defence paragraph 1; list of facts and matters not in issue paragraph 1.[11] Statement of claim paragraph 7; first defendant’s defence paragraph 6; second defendant’s defence paragraph 5.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The submission that there is an apportionable claim under the Civil Liability Act must be rejected, because in order for there to be an apportionable claim, the court would in the first place need to make a finding that the claim against Eagle Yachts is one arising from a failure on its part to take reasonable care: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 34(1). There is no basis for a finding that Eagle Yachts failed to take reasonable care. None of the information before it prior to the sale to Tarangau suggested that the vessel was defective. Indeed, such evidence as to the condition of the vessel as was before Eagle Yachts provided confidence that the vessel was sound.Conclusion Tarangau is entitled to succeed against Eagle Yachts for its breach of terms implied into the contract of sale that the Bertram 570 would be fit for its purpose and of merchantable quality. The measure of its loss is $1,933,900 together with interest pursuant to s 47 of the Supreme Court Act 1995 from 22 July 2006 until the date of judgment. Tarangau is entitled to succeed against Bertram for its breach of the terms of the express warranty. The measure of damages is $1,239,919 together with interest pursuant to s 47 of the Supreme Court Act 1995 from 7 March 2016 until the date of judgment. I shall hear the parties as to the precise form of orders and any consequential orders to be made and as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Tarangau submitted that Bertram bears the onus[232] and was in a position to lead evidence on this issue but chose not to do so. It failed to establish that the negligent acts or omissions occurred in Florida. This disposed, it was submitted, of Bertram’s contention that the claim is governed by Florida law, and it is not necessary to canvass conflict of law principles. The governing law is presumed to be that of Queensland.[233][232] Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang (2002) 210 CLR 491, 518-519.[233] Neilson v Overseas Projects Corp of Victoria (2005) 223 CLR 331, 372.Consideration In Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang,[234] the High Court held that the law governing a claim in relation to a tort committed in another country is the lex loci delicti, the law of the place of the alleged wrong. The High Court held:[235]“The submission by the Renault companies is that the reasoning and conclusion in Pfeiffer that the substantive law for the determination of rights and liabilities in respect of intra-Australian torts is the lex loci delicti should be extended to foreign torts, despite the absence of the significant factor of federal considerations, and that this should be without the addition of any ‘flexible exception’. That submission should be accepted.”[234] Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang (2002) 210 CLR 491.[235] Zhang at 515 and 520 at [75] per Gleeson CJ, Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ. In Dow Jones & Co Inc v Gutnick,[236] Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ held:“locating the place of commission of a tort is not always easy … In the end the question is ‘where in substance did this cause of action arise’? In cases, like trespass or negligence, where some quality of the defendant’s conduct is critical, it will usually be very important to look to where the defendant acted, not to where the consequences of the conduct were felt.”[236] Dow Jones & Co Inc v Gutnick (2002) 210 CLR 575 at 606, [43] per Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ. It is uncontroversial in this case that Bertram issued the warranty for the vessel.[237] Further, it is clear on the evidence that Tarangau, by Mr Wong, completed the Bertram warranty card, returned it to Bertram and thereby became the beneficiary of a five year warranty in respect of the vessel’s hull and structural components. The only damage claimed in this matter is to the vessel itself. In those circumstances, Mr von Spiegelfeld’s summary above makes it plain that, pursuant to the economic loss rule, the law of Florida is that Bertram cannot be sued in tort for defects in the vessel that do not damage anything other than itself. This is so even in the event that the defects to the vessel caused a risk of injury.[237] Exhibit 73. Tarangau’s argument that Bertram failed to prove that the vessel was constructed in Florida can be relatively easily disposed of. The reference to a finding made in Vautin v BY Winddown, Inc (No 2) on the evidence led in that case is irrelevant to the determination of the facts on the evidence led in this case.