Starkey v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

STARKEY & ORS v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2011] SASCFC 164

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice David and The Honourable Justice Stanley)

22 December 2011

ABORIGINALS - HERITAGE PROTECTION

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT - REVIEW OF PARTICULAR DECISIONS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS - CONSEQUENCE OF FAILURE TO ACCORD PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS

Appeal against a decision of a Judge of Supreme Court on an application for judicial review - Minister granted the third respondent’s application for an authorisation to damage, disturb or interfere with Aboriginal site - request for delegation of Minister’s powers made by Aboriginal people at consultation meeting - the Judge found the Minister was not required to delegate her powers - the Judge found Minister did not accord procedural fairness to those the requesting delegation, but that failure did not invalidate the Minister’s authorisation.

Plaintiffs appeal against that decision - whether the Minister is precluded from giving authorisation without first determining whether or not to delegate those powers in accordance with procedural fairness - whether the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) requires the Minister to make a determination under s 12 prior to determining whether or not to grant an authorisation - whether the terms of the authorisation were too wide and uncertain - whether the authorisation was invalid due to the Minister failing to satisfy herself of matters which condition the exercise of the power - whether the authorisation was invalid due to the Minister’s failure to consult with the first plaintiff.

Held (the Court): Appeal allowed - dismissal by the Judge of the application for judicial review set aside - declaration made that the authorisation purportedly given by the Minister pursuant to s 23 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) on 7 July 2010 was contrary to law - order made in the nature of certiorari to quash the authorisation - order of the Judge in the nature of mandamus confirmed.

(Stanley J with David J agreeing): The exercise of the Minister’s power to grant an authorisation was conditioned on the observation of the principles of procedural fairness - the condition has been breached, invalidating the authorisation - the Minister was not required to make a determination under s 12 prior to exercising her power - the terms of the authorisation were not too wide or uncertain - the Minister did not have to satisfy herself of those matters claimed to condition the exercise of her power - the Minister did not fail to consult with the first plaintiff.

(Gray J): The terms of the authorisation are too broad - further, it appears that the Minister proceeded on the misunderstanding of fact that, in some undefined way, the third defendant had rights under exploration licence 4296 - the authorisation was granted under a misunderstanding of fact.

Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) s 3, s 5, s 6, s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Starkey v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASCFC 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Robert John Starkey and Vince Coulthard, appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia against a decision of a single judge who had dismissed their application for judicial review. The original application sought to challenge an authorisation granted by the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Reconciliation to Straits Exploration (Australia) Ltd. This authorisation permitted Straits to damage, disturb, or interfere with Aboriginal sites, objects, or remains within a specified exploration licence area for the purpose of mineral exploration. The plaintiffs, representing Aboriginal people with interests in the area, had requested the Minister to delegate her powers under the Act, a request they argued was not properly considered.

The central legal issues before the Full Court were whether the Minister was legally required to determine the request for delegation before granting the authorisation, whether the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) mandated a specific procedural step under section 12 prior to authorisations, if the terms of the granted authorisation were excessively broad and uncertain, and if the authorisation was invalid due to the Minister failing to satisfy herself of certain pre-conditions or for failing to consult with the first plaintiff. The plaintiffs contended that the Minister's failure to accord procedural fairness in relation to their delegation request invalidated the authorisation.

The Court, comprising Stanley, David, and Gray JJ, allowed the appeal. Stanley J, with whom David J agreed, held that while the Minister was not required to make a determination under section 12 before granting an authorisation, the exercise of the power to grant an authorisation was nonetheless conditioned on the observance of procedural fairness. As this condition had been breached by the failure to properly consider the delegation request, the authorisation was invalidated. David J further clarified that the terms of the authorisation itself were not impermissibly broad. Gray J, while agreeing with the outcome, also found the authorisation to be invalid on the separate ground that its terms were too broad.

Consequently, the Full Court set aside the dismissal of the judicial review application, made a declaration that the authorisation granted by the Minister on 7 July 2010 was contrary to law, and ordered that the authorisation be quashed by certiorari. The Court also confirmed the single judge's order in the nature of mandamus.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is to be noted that in the above respect I disagree with the conclusion of Stanley J that the section 23 authorisation was not too wide or uncertain. I would declare that the section 23 authorisation was invalid on this ground. Otherwise I agree with the reasons of Stanley J and his conclusion that the authorisation was invalid. Conclusion I agree with the orders proposed by Stanley J. DAVID J: I would allow the appeal and agree with the orders proposed by Stanley J. I agree with his reasons in that the Minister’s failure to afford procedural fairness to the appellants in relation to their purported request for delegation invalidates the Minister’s authorisation under s 23 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA). I would add that in my view, the terms of the s 23 authorisation itself were not impermissibly broad. The authorisation clearly set out the area to which the authorisation applied, and those classes of people permitted by the authorisation to damage, disturb or interfere with the relevant Aboriginal sites or objects. There was no uncertainty as to the scope of the authorisation, nor was it in my view too wide in the circumstances.STANLEY J:Introduction This is an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Court on an application for judicial review. The third respondent, Straits Exploration (Australia) Ltd (“Straits”) is in a joint venture with Kelaray Pty Ltd (“Kelaray”), the holder of an exploration licence incorporating an area of approximately 320 square kilometres of Lake Torrens and approximately 25 square kilometres of the south-western corner of Andamooka Island (“the Lake Torrens site”). Straits plans to undertake mineral exploration activities within the Lake Torrens site, including drilling on Andamooka Island and on the bed of the main salt lake of Lake Torrens. For this purpose, on 27 November 2009, it applied to the second respondent, the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Reconciliation (“the Minister”) for an authorisation pursuant to s 23 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) (“the Act”). The purpose of the authorisation is to permit Straits to damage, disturb or interfere with any Aboriginal sites, objects or remains that may exist on the Lake Torrens site. The Minister granted the authorisation on 7 July 2010 in the following terms:[9][9] At the relevant time the Minister was the Honourable Grace Portolesi MP.I authorise the applicant together with its partners, staff, contractors and subcontractors and any company (including its partners, staff, contractors and subcontractors) to whom Straits may transfer its rights under EL#4296 to:(a)damage, disturb or interfere with any Aboriginal site; or(b)damage any Aboriginal object; or(c)where any Aboriginal object or remains are found –(i)disturb or interfere with the object or remains; or(ii)remove the object or remains,in accordance with the application lodged on 27 November 2009. The first appellant, Robert John Starkey, is a member of the Kokatha Wati people. The second appellant, Vince Coulthard, is a member of the Adnyamathantha people, and a chairperson of the Adnyamathantha Traditional Lands Association.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established