Straits Exploration (Australia) Pty Ltd v Kokatha Uwankara Native Title Claimants

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

STRAITS EXPLORATION (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD & ANOR v KOKATHA UWANKARA NATIVE TITLE CLAIMANTS & ORS

[2012] SASCFC 121

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Stanley)

5 November 2012

ABORIGINALS - NATIVE TITLE - CLAIMS AND DETERMINATIONS

ABORIGINALS - NATIVE TITLE - PROCEDURE

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GENERALLY

Appeal against decision of the Environment, Resources and Development Court – appeal by way of judicial review heard at the same time – appellants submitted that the District Court Judge sitting on the Environment, Resources and Development Court misconceived the role that he was to perform – the Judge dealt with the issues at trial as if they required resolution by way of judicial determination – it was submitted that the Judge was only engaged in the process of making an administrative decision and that the appellants were denied procedural fairness.

It was further submitted that the Judge failed to adequately address provisions as required by the Mining Act 1971 (SA) and that the Judge failed to address the question of mining being on approved terms.

Held (Gray and Sulan JJ): Appeal allowed – Judge misconceived his role in that he was only engaged to make an administrative decision – the appellants were denied procedural fairness – decision of the Environment, Resources and Development Court set aside – Order remitting the matter to another Judge of that Court for determination.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT - DISTINCTION BETWEEN ADMINISTRATIVE AND JUDICIAL FUNCTIONS

Appellants submitted that the approach taken by the Judge in the Environment, Resources and Development Court was judicial and not administrative – the approach belayed the statutory purpose underlying Part 9B of the Mining Act 1971 (SA) – the Judge was required to make an administrative decision for the purposes of section 63S(2) – the Judge’s role is not to make a judicial determination of a factual dispute.

Held (Gray and Stanley JJ): It was agreed that the Judge misunderstood his role under the legislation causing him to embark on a judicial determination of fact – the appropriate question of whether mining should be allowed on terms was not considered – the Judge made various adverse findings that reflected seriously upon the appellants and the appellants’ officers and employees – in making a determination under section 63S, the Court must take into account matters specified in section 63T.

Held (Kourakis CJ):  The Judge failed to consider whether mining should be allowed subject to conditions minimising its impact of mining on native title rights and interests.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT - REVIEWABLE CONDUCT

Appellants submitted that the Judge misconstrued the substantive content of the criteria specified by the Mining Act 1971 (SA) in failing to recognise that there were no exclusive native title rights and interests that were capable of being exercised on the relevant land – also that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Straits Exploration (Australia) Pty Ltd v Kokatha Uwankara N... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASCFC 121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Straits Exploration (Australia) Pty Ltd and Kelaray Pty Ltd (the appellants) sought authorisation for mining exploration operations on Lake Torrens, South Australia, under Part 9B of the *Mining Act 1971* (SA). Having failed to reach an agreement with the Kokatha Uwankara Native Title Claimants (the respondents), the appellants applied to the Environment, Resources and Development Court of South Australia for a determination authorising their proposed drilling activities. The respondents were the native title claimants in the proceedings below. The matter came before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia by way of appeal and judicial review proceedings, heard concurrently.

The central legal issues before the Full Court were whether the District Court Judge, sitting as a Judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court, had fundamentally misunderstood his role, acting as if he were determining a trial requiring judicial resolution rather than making an administrative decision. The appellants contended that this misconception led to a denial of procedural fairness and an unfair hearing. Furthermore, it was argued that the Judge failed to properly address a statutory requirement under the *Mining Act 1971* (SA) concerning the approval of mining on terms.

The Full Court reasoned that the Judge had indeed laboured under a misconception of his statutory role. The Court held that the Judge's approach, which involved making findings as if resolving a trial and criticising the appellants' past conduct, was inappropriate for the administrative decision-making process required by Part 9B of the *Mining Act 1971* (SA). The Court found that the Judge had failed to give the appellants adequate notice of his contemplated findings and an opportunity to address them, thereby denying procedural fairness. Moreover, the Judge had erred by not adequately considering the possibility of imposing conditions to allow mining operations to proceed, instead reasoning that the respondents' unwillingness to agree to any terms rendered further consideration of conditional approval futile. The Court emphasised that the statutory purpose involved a balancing exercise, not the penalisation of an applicant for past conduct.

Consequently, the Full Court remitted the matter to another Judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court for determination in accordance with the reasons provided.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

It was the submission of Straits and Kelaray that the District Court Judge in making his determination had proceeded under a serious misconception of the role that he was to perform. It was contended that he proceeded as though he was dealing with issues arising in a trial requiring resolution by way of judicial determination, whereas in fact he was engaged in the process of making an administrative decision. It was submitted that in the course of the hearing the Judge denied Straits and Kelaray procedural fairness, leading to an unfair hearing. It was also argued that the Judge failed to attend to a matter that he was required to address under the provisions of the Mining Act 1971 (SA) and, in particular, failed to address, either properly or at all, the question of mining being approved on terms.Background Straits and Kelaray wish to conduct mining exploration on and near Lake Torrens, South Australia. There are early indications that substantial mineral deposits lie beneath the lake’s surface. Lake Torrens occupies an area of about 5,700 square kilometres and, at most times, is a dry salt flat. The southern tip of Lake Torrens is about 60 kilometres north of Port Augusta and extends north for a further 240 kilometres. Lake Torrens is of significance to indigenous Australians and in particular, to the Kokatha people. Straits and Kelaray, within the Mining Act regime, sought to negotiate a native title mining agreement with native title parties but were unsuccessful in that endeavour. On 2 August 2010, following the giving of appropriate notices, Straits and Kelaray made application to the Environment, Resources and Development Court of South Australia for a determination authorising mining operations and in particular, authorising exploration by drilling on Lake Torrens at a discrete site in the vicinity of Andamooka Island. The application was brought under Part 9B of the Mining Act. Jurisdiction under Part 9B is vested in the Environment, Resources and Development Court. This jurisdiction is, inter alia, addressed by the terms of section 63S which relevantly provides:Application for determination(1)If agreement between the proponent and the native title parties is not reached within the relevant period, any party to the negotiations or the Minister may apply to the ERD Court for a determination.…Once made, a determination becomes enforceable in the manner provided for in section 63V:Effect of determination(1) A determination under this Division—(a) must be lodged with a mining registrar; and(b) must be registered two months after it was lodged for registration unless it has in the meantime been overruled by the Minister;1 and(c) takes effect on registration.(2)A determination registered under this Division has effect as if it were a contract between the proponent and the native title parties.(3)A registered determination is (subject to its terms) binding on, and enforceable by or against the original parties to the proceedings in which the determination was made and—(a) the holders from time to time of native title in the land to which the determination relates; and(b) the holders from time to time of any exploration authority or production tenement under which mining operations to which the determination relates are carried out.(4)If a native title declaration establishes that the native title parties to whom the determination relates are not the holders of native title in the land or are not the only holders of native title in the land, the determination continues in operation (subject to its terms) until a fresh determination is made, or for 2 years after the date of the declaration (whichever is the lesser).(5)A determination under this Part that authorises mining operations to be conducted under a future mining tenement is contingent on the tenement being granted or registered.Note—1 See section 63W.Under section 63V(1)(b), the determination of the Court is subject to Ministerial intervention:[44]Ministerial power to overrule determinations(1)If the Minister considers it to be in the interests of the State to overrule a determination of the ERD Court under this Part, the Minister may, by notice in writing given to the ERD Court and the parties to the proceedings before the Court, overrule the determination and substitute another determination that might have been made by the Court.[44] Mining Act 1971 (SA) section 63W.There is an equivalent power in section 42(2) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), exercisable in “the National interest”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Judge erred in failing to consider the question of conditions any further. The strategic position adopted by the respondents could not relieve the Judge of his statutory responsibility to address the question of conditional permission. The Judge was bound to consider whether other conditions, in addition to those proposed by the appellants, might have sufficiently protected the social, cultural and economic structures of the respondent to allow some mining operations to proceed.Conclusion For the above reasons and the additional reasons given by Gray and Stanley JJ in paragraphs [143] to [167], I would remit the matter to another Judge of the ERD Court for determination in accordance with these reasons.GRAY and The proceedings in this Court arise from a determination made on 14 January 2011 by a District Court Judge sitting as a Judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court of South Australia. Straits Exploration (Australia) Pty Ltd and its joint venturer,[42] Kelaray Pty Ltd, the applicants and appellants, initially proceeded by way of appeal from the decision of the District Court Judge. The defendants in the proceedings before the Environment, Resources and Development Court and the respondents are the Kokatha Uwankara Native Title Claimants.[43] The Adnyamathanha people were interveners in the Court below and were named as respondents. However, there was no appearance on behalf of the Adnyamathanha people. The Attorney-General for the State of South Australia intervened on the hearing. [42] The evidence established that Straits and Kelaray are parties to a joint venture agreement in respect of Exploration Licence 4296. The terms of the agreement, while confidential, provide for Straits to assume a share in the ownership of Exploration Licence 4296 upon undertaking exploratory activities pursuant to Exploration Licence 4296 and bearing the costs of doing so. [43] In these reasons, where convenient, the Kokatha Uwankara Native Title Claimants are referred to as the “Kokatha people” or “Kokatha”. Following the lodging of the appeal, a question arose as to whether the matter should proceed as an appeal by way of judicial review. As a consequence, Straits and Kelaray issued judicial review proceedings. By agreement between the parties, both proceedings were heard at the same time and it was further agreed that the materials and submissions the subject of the proceedings could be used by this Court in its consideration of either set of proceedings. It is to be observed that comparable issues arise for consideration under both proceedings. It was the submission of Straits and Kelaray that the District Court Judge in making his determination had proceeded under a serious misconception of the role that he was to perform. It was contended that he proceeded as though he was dealing with issues arising in a trial requiring resolution by way of judicial determination, whereas in fact he was engaged in the process of making an administrative decision. It was submitted that in the course of the hearing the Judge denied Straits and Kelaray procedural fairness, leading to an unfair hearing. It was also argued that the Judge failed to attend to a matter that he was required to address under the provisions of the Mining Act 1971 (SA) and, in particular, failed to address, either properly or at all, the question of mining being approved on terms.Background

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In our view, the requirements of procedural fairness necessitated that the District Court Judge should have given Straits and Kelaray fair notice that it had contemplated making findings in the impugned terms, and afforded Straits and Kelaray a reasonable opportunity to address them before the matter was decided. This did not occur. Inadequate Consideration of Statutory Criteria It was submitted that the District Court Judge misconstrued the substantive content of the criteria specified in sections 63T(1)(a)(i) and 63T(1)(a)(iv) in failing to recognise that there were no exclusive native title rights and interests that were capable of being exercised on the relevant land. It was said that the Judge also misconstrued the substantive content of the criteria specified in section 63T(1)(e) by assuming a status quo established by a statutory presumption against mining. It was further contended that the Judge misconstrued the substantive content of the criteria specified in section 63T(1)(f) by taking into account and according significant weight to “past conduct” without recognising the effect of such an approach on successors and without making findings about the likelihood of future conduct. The primary task of the District Court Judge was to assess and determine whether and in what circumstances mining could take place on Lake Torrens. In reaching a determination of the issues, the Judge was not entitled to assume a status quo. The Judge was to have regard to the nature of the claimed native title rights and to examine the nature of the proposed mining and in particular, to look to balance the two. If the Judge reached the view that mining per se could exist along side the proper protection of native title rights, he would then embark on a consideration of the terms on which the mining could take place. The Judge did not embark on such an inquiry adequately or at all. It appears that he reasoned that as the claimants to native title were not prepared to agree to mining on any terms, there was no point in considering mining on terms. The District Court Judge was highly critical of the bona fides of Straits and Kelaray. He, as noted above, expressed those criticisms in emotive terms. The Judge reasoned that Straits and Kelaray could not be trusted to comply with any conditions that might be imposed in respect of mining. Even if the Judge was correct to conclude that the conduct of Straits and Kelaray was “unforgiveable”,[118] terms could be imposed with respect to future mining with appropriately strict conditions to ensure compliance. [118] Straits Exploration (Australia) Pty Ltd & Anor v The Kokatha Uwankara Native Title Claimants & Ors [2011] SAERDC 2, [257]. As discussed above, in making the above findings, the District Court Judge misunderstood the statutory purpose underlying the balancing exercise to be undertaken under section 63T(1). That purpose does not extend to the making of findings which, in effect, penalise an applicant under Part 9B of the Mining Act for past conduct.