Soliman v University of Technology, Sydney

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Soliman v University of Technology, Sydney [2008] FCA 1512

INDUSTRIAL LAW – certified agreement – contract of employment – whether contract of employment incorporates certified agreement – whether certified agreement constitutes a contract – construction of contract of employment – construction of certified agreement – alleged breaches of certified agreement with respect to disciplinary action - remedies
Held: Application dismissed

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
The University of Technology, Sydney, Act 1987 (NSW)
University of Technology, Sydney, Act 1989 (NSW)
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth)

ACTEW Corporation Ltd v Pangallo (2002) 127 FCR 1; [2002] FCAFC 325
Ambulance Service Victoria (South Western Region) v Australian Liquor, Hospitality & Miscellaneous Workers Union (1998) 80 IR 275
Bowen-James v Delegate of the Director-General of the Department of Health (1992) 27 NSWLR 457
Bruce v Cole (1998) 45 NSWLR 163
Byrne & Frew v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410
Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1982) 149 CLR 337
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2000) 203 CLR 645; [2001] HCA 16
Goldman Sachs JBWere Services Pty Ltd v Nikolich (2007) 163 FCR 62; [2007] FCAFC 120
Grindley v Barker (1798) 1 B&P 229; 126 ER 875
Kucks v CSR Limited (1996) 66 IR 18
McAleer v University of Western Australia (2007) 159 IR 96; [2007] FCA 52
McAleer v The University of Western Australia (No 3) [2008] FCA 1490
McCormick v Riverwood International (Australia) Pty Ltd (1999) 167 ALR 689; [1999] FCA 1640
NTEIU (National Tertiary Education Industry Union) v University of Wollongong [2002] FCA 31
Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Limited v Maritime Union of Australia (1998) 195 CLR 1; [1998] HCA 30
Printing & Kindred Industries Union v Davies Bros Ltd (1986) 18 IR 444
Riverwood International Australia Pty Ltd v McCormick (2000) 177 ALR 193; [2000] FCA 889
Schenker & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd v Maplas Equipment and Services Pty Ltd [1990] VR 834
Seamen’s Union of Australia v Adelaide Steamship Co Ltd (1976) 46 FLR 444
Short v F W Hercus Pty Limited (1993) 40 FCR 511
Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165; [2004] HCA 52
Transport Workers Union v Lee (1998) 84 FCR 60

DR FAWZY IBRAHIM SOLIMAN v UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY, SYDNEY and AUSTRALIAN HIGHER EDUCATION INDUSTRIAL ASSOCIATION

NSD 452 OF 2008

JAGOT J
10 OCTOBER 2008
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 452 OF 2008

BETWEEN:

DR FAWZY IBRAHIM SOLIMAN
Applicant

AND:

UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY, SYDNEY
First Respondent

AUSTRALIAN HIGHER EDUCATION INDUSTRIAL ASSOCIATION
Intervener

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 OCTOBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.The exhibits may be returned.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soliman v University of Technology, Sydney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1512
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Soliman v University of Technology, Sydney involved the applicant, a senior lecturer employed by the University, who was accused of academic misconduct. The University's handling of the complaint and the subsequent investigation and disciplinary process were the subject of dispute. The applicant challenged the University's actions, including the nomination of the committee chair and the timing of the committee's proceedings. The court was required to determine whether the University's actions were in accordance with the terms of the employment agreement and whether any procedural errors invalidated the investigation or the subsequent disciplinary action.

The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation and application of specific clauses within the employment agreement. The applicant argued that the University's failure to adhere to the agreement in nominating the committee chair and the timing of the committee's proceedings were breaches that invalidated the investigation and the subsequent disciplinary action. The court had to consider the enforceability of the agreement's provisions and whether any deviations from the agreement rendered the investigation and disciplinary action unlawful.

The court found that the University's actions in nominating the committee chair were in accordance with the agreement, as the Vice-Chancellor had the authority to resolve any deadlock in the nomination process. Additionally, the court clarified that the term "proceedings" in the agreement referred to the investigative process rather than the report of factual findings. Consequently, the committee's actions were deemed to comply with the agreement, and the investigation and disciplinary process were not invalidated by procedural errors. The court dismissed the applicant's application and allowed the exhibits to be returned.

The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to the terms of employment agreements in disciplinary processes and highlighted the distinction between the investigative process and the reporting of findings within the context of the agreement. The University's handling of the academic misconduct complaint was found to be procedurally sound, and the subsequent disciplinary action was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The exhibits may be returned.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant’s probationary period expired on 4 February 1993. He was offered and accepted indefinite appointment in August 1993, being promoted to senior lecturer in July 1999.FACTS The University is a body corporate established by the University of Technology, Sydney, Act 1989 (NSW). At all relevant times before 3 January 2008 the University employed the applicant as a Level C (Senior Lecturer) Step 6. His employment was covered by the agreement. On 11 June 2007 a student lodged a complaint about alleged academic misconduct against the applicant with respect to an examination in one of his courses. The Dean of the relevant faculty informed the applicant about the complaint by letter dated 14 June 2007. The Dean wrote to the applicant again on 20 June 2007 requesting an explanation. The applicant responded on 26 and 29 June 2007, in part to the effect that he was obtaining legal advice. On 3 July 2007 the Dean advised the applicant that he had referred the matter to the Vice-Chancellor in accordance with cl 46 of the agreement. In the interim, on 6 July 2007, the applicant’s solicitors wrote to the Dean requesting further details of the allegations. The applicant’s solicitors wrote again on 16 July 2007 seeking a response to their earlier correspondence. Mr Peter Fox, the University’s Workplace Relations and Policy Manager, responded on 17 July 2007. The Dean referred the matter to the Vice-Chancellor on 17 July 2007. Further correspondence ensued from the applicant’s solicitors seeking a substantive response to their correspondence. On 3 August 2007 the Vice-Chancellor (Professor Milbourne) sent a letter to the applicant advising that he had determined that further investigation was warranted under cl 46.6 of the agreement. The letter provided details of the allegations. The letter required the applicant’s written response within 10 working days as referred to in cl 46.6(b) of the agreement (that is, by 17 August 2007). On 17 August 2007 the applicant wrote to the Vice-Chancellor advising that due to printer problems his response would be provided on 20 August 2007. On 20 August 2007 the applicant wrote to the Vice-Chancellor setting out his reply to the allegations. The Vice-Chancellor received this letter on 23 August 2007. The Vice-Chancellor wrote to the applicant on 24 August 2007 advising that he had “determined that these matters be referred to a Committee for investigation as provided for under sub-clause 46.7(a) of the Agreement”. The letter said that, in accordance with cl 47.1(a) of the agreement, the committee was to be chaired by a person independent of the University who has relevant knowledge and experience and agreed by the Vice-Chancellor and staff member, and the Vice-Chancellor would contact the applicant with his nomination shortly. The letter also enclosed a list of elected staff representatives for the applicant to select his representative. The applicant wrote to the Vice-Chancellor on 3 September 2007 (with the Vice-Chancellor receiving the letter on 5 September 2007). The applicant asked for some information (including the agreement) and said he was contacting Mr Patrick Healy to see if he would accept nomination to the committee and would confirm his nomination. On the same day Mr Frank Young, from the University’s Human Resources Unit, sent the applicant an email with a link to the agreement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JAGOT J
The applicant’s submissions about the University not being entitled to require the applicant to respond to its nomination within 24 hours or to assume agreement from silence overlook the fact that, if agreement cannot be reached, cl 47.1(a) enables the Vice-Chancellor to break the deadlock by requesting a nomination from a member of the panel. The Vice-Chancellor did so in this case. The fact that the panel member’s nomination was the same as the Vice-Chancellor’s does not undermine the conclusion that the appointment of Commissioner Lawson as the chair accorded with the requirements of cl 47.1(a). In any event, and for the reasons already given about the nature and enforceability of the agreement, the consequence of breach of cl 47.1(a) would not be invalidity of the committee’s investigation or the Vice-Chancellor’s decision to take disciplinary action. The conclusion of the committee’s proceedings issue The committee membership was settled on 4 October 2007 (with the nomination of Ms Oliffe as Dr Zowghi’s replacement). The committee met on 10 and 11 October 2007. Mr Healy, committee member, went overseas for four or five weeks. The committee delivered its report on 6 December 2007. The applicant submitted that this involved a contravention of cl 47.2(i) which provides that the committee will conclude proceedings within 10 working days of the appointment of the committee unless otherwise agreed between the committee chair, the Vice-Chancellor and the staff member. The applicant said that the clause required the whole “proceedings”, including the report, to be completed within 10 working days. Further, that failure to comply invalidated the committee’s actions and meant that the Vice-Chancellor had no power to take disciplinary action against the applicant. I do not accept these submissions. Clause 45.14 (although relating to unsatisfactory performance rather than misconduct) indicates that the agreement treats a committee’s process of investigation separately from its factual findings. This is reinforced by the structure of cll 46 and 47. The committee’s sole function is to investigate and report on the facts relating to the alleged misconduct (cll 46.9.2 and 46.9.3). It is clear from cl 46.9.5 that the committee’s factual findings are to be in the form of a report. The membership and processes of the committee are separately regulated by cl 47.1 and 47.2 respectively. The word “proceedings” is used in cl 47.2(a) and (h) as well as cl 47.2(i). In cl 47.2)(a) and (h) the word is being used to refer to the committee’s investigative process and not the committee’s report on its factual findings. For example, a report on factual findings is not “conducted” within the meaning of cl 47.2(a). Similarly, it is not possible to “keep a record” of the report on factual findings within the meaning of cl 47.2(h). The structure and content of cll 46 and 47 and of cl 47.2 thus indicates that the “proceedings” contemplated by cl 47.2(i) is the process by which the committee carries out its investigation rather than the report of the committee’s factual findings. On this basis, the committee complied with cl 47.2(i) because it was appointed on 4 October 2007 and concluded its proceedings on 11 October 2007.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JAGOT J

The court's reasoning focused on the interpretation of the terms of the employment agreement between the University and the applicant. Regarding the nomination process, the court found that cl 47.1(a) allowed the Vice-Chancellor to break any deadlock by requesting a nomination from a member of the panel if agreement could not be reached. In this case, the Vice-Chancellor had exercised this right, and the subsequent nomination of Commissioner Lawson as the chair was in accordance with the agreement. Therefore, the court concluded that the University was entitled to require the applicant to respond to its nomination within 24 hours or to assume agreement from silence.

Regarding the committee's conclusion of proceedings, the court examined the structure and content of the agreement, particularly cl 47.2(i), and found that the term "proceedings" referred to the process by which the committee carried out its investigation rather than the report of the committee's factual findings. The court further noted that cl 45.14, although relating to unsatisfactory performance, reinforced the idea that the agreement treated a committee's process of investigation separately from its factual findings. Consequently, the committee's compliance with cl 47.2(i) was upheld as it concluded its proceedings within 10 working days of the appointment of the committee. The court's interpretation of the agreement and its application of the legal principles to the facts established the ratio decidendi of this decision.