Shire of Toodyay v Merrick

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   SHIRE OF TOODYAY -v- MERRICK [2016] WASC 29

CORAM:   ACTING MASTER GETHING

HEARD:   29 OCTOBER & 5 NOVEMBER 2015

DELIVERED          :   8 FEBRUARY 2016

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1396 of 2014

BETWEEN:   SHIRE OF TOODYAY

Plaintiff

AND

GRAHAM LESLIE MERRICK
First Defendant

CHARLES WROTH
Second Defendant

Catchwords:

Summary judgment - Whether claims are barred by a settlement deed - Whether action which can be commenced under Local Government Act 1995 (WA) pt 8 div 4, must be commenced under this part

Local government - Whether action which can be commenced under Local Government Act 1995 (WA) pt 8 div 4, must be commenced under this part

Legislation:

Limitation Act 2005 (WA), s 38
Local Government Act 1995 (WA), pt 8 div 4

Result:

Leave given to amend the writ
Applications for summary judgment dismissed
Application to extend the limitation period dismissed
Paragraphs struck out of the statement of clam

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr R J Price

First Defendant             :     Mr G D Cobby

Second Defendant         :     Mr S J Lemonis

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Civic Legal

First Defendant             :     Tottle Partners

Second Defendant         :     Lemonis & Tantiprasut Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

2 Elizabeth Bay Road Pty Ltd v The Owners Strata Plan No 73943 [2014] NSWCA 409

ABB Service Pty Ltd (formerly known as ABB Engineering Construction Pty Ltd) v Hetherington [2001] WASCA 235

ABB Service Pty Ltd v Hetherington [2001] WASCA 417

Agar v Hyde [2000] HCA 41; (2000) 201 CLR 552

Alcoa of Australia Ltd v Apache Energy Ltd [2012] WASC 209

AME Hospitals Pty Ltd v Dixon [2015] WASCA 63; (2015) 48 WAR 139

Anderson v Effexseven (1998) 10 ANZ Ins Cas 61‑424

Bank of Western Australia v Stein [2005] WASC 43

Barnes v Forty Two International Pty Ltd (2014) 316 ALR 408

Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales [2006] HCA 27; (2006) 226 CLR 256

Beaman v ARTS Ltd [1949] 1 KB 550

Belgravia Nominees Pty Ltd v Lowe Pty Ltd [No 3] [2015] WASC 442

Bell v Lever Brothers Ltd [1932] AC 161

Black v Black [2013] NSWSC 954

BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hasting Shire Council [1977] UKPCHCA 2; (1977) 180 CLR 266

Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336.

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor [1996] HCA 25; (1996) 186 CLR 541

Butler v St John of God Health Care Inc [2008] WASCA 174

Byrne & Frew v Australian Airlines Ltd [1995] HCA 24; (1995) 185 CLR 410

Carr & Purves v Thomas [2009] NSWCA 208

Collett v Repatriation Commission (2009) 178 FCR 39

Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police v Courtenay Investments Ltd [No 4] [2015] WASC 101

Commonwealth Development Bank of Australia Ltd v Kok [2003] FCA 90

Commonwealth of Australia v Cornwell [2007] HCA 16; (2007) 229 CLR 519

Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd (No 7) (2013) 282…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shire of Toodyay v Merrick and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] WASC 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Shire of Toodyay sought summary judgment against Mr Merrick regarding claims that he had improperly received payments from the Shire. The dispute centred on whether Mr Merrick's claims were barred by a Settlement Deed, and whether actions against a local government authority must be commenced under the Local Government Act 1995 (WA). The court had to determine if the Settlement Deed's terms precluded Mr Merrick's claims and if such claims fell under the Local Government Act's provisions.

The central legal issues were whether the Settlement Deed barred Mr Merrick's claims and whether the Local Government Act 1995 (WA) applied to these claims. The court needed to interpret the Settlement Deed's language, particularly the terms 'arising out of' and 'in connection with', to ascertain the scope of the release and bar clauses. It also had to determine if the claims against Mr Merrick fell within the ambit of the Local Government Act.

The court found that the Settlement Deed's terms, specifically the release and bar clauses, were broad enough to cover Mr Merrick's claims. The phrases 'arising out of' and 'in connection with' were interpreted to mean that any claim related to the employment or cessation of employment was covered by the Settlement Deed. The court held that the Settlement Deed was a comprehensive release that barred Mr Merrick's claims. Additionally, the court ruled that actions against a local government authority must be commenced under the Local Government Act 1995 (WA), and since the Settlement Deed effectively barred Mr Merrick's claims, they could not proceed.

In conclusion, the court granted the Shire of Toodyay's application for summary judgment, dismissing Mr Merrick's claims. The court held that the Settlement Deed barred all claims arising out of or in connection with Mr Merrick's employment and its cessation, and that these claims could not proceed under the Local Government Act 1995 (WA). The court ordered that Mr Merrick's claims were permanently stayed and that the Shire of Toodyay recover its costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The starting point in the analysis is to construe the relevant clauses of the Settlement Deed. The 'Background' section of the Settlement Deed provides as follows:BackgroundAThe Employee was employed by the Shire and on Cessation held the full‑time position of Chief Executive Officer.BOn 16 February 2010 the Shire approached the Employee and sought to bring the Employee's contract of employment with the Shire to an end by mutual agreement.CThe parties have agreed that the Employee's employment with the Shire should cease on close of business 30 March 2010.DThe parties have agreed to settle all matters relating to the Employment and Cessation on the terms set out in this deed. The two key operative provisions are cl 2 and cl 3:2.Settlement2.1Settlement SumThe Shire by executing this deed agrees to pay to the Employee the gross sum of $217,579.60 (Settlement Sum) as an eligible termination payment in accordance with clause 2.2 of this deed.2.2Accrued entitlementsThe Settlement Sum does not include the Employee's accrued entitlements to unused annual, long service leave, and accrued rostered days off and retained bonuses, which will be paid to the Employee upon Cessation.2.3Payment termsThe Shire must pay the Settlement Sum to the Employee by way of electronic funds transfer into the Employee's bank account on or before close of business 30 March 2010.2.4TaxThe Employee will be liable to pay any tax on the Settlement Sum and the Employee acknowledges that the Shire will deduct from that sum such amounts as required under the Income Tax Assessment Act or other applicable taxation legislation, provided that the Employer shall be liable to pay any fringe benefits tax and any other tax, other than income tax, imposed on the components of the Settlement Sum.3.Release and discharge3.1ReleaseIn consideration of this deed, each party:(a)releases absolutely and forever discharges the other party and the other party's employees, agents and servants from all Claims which the other party may have or but for this deed might have had against those persons arising out of, from, in, or in connection with the Employment or Cessation; and(b)agrees not to bring, commence, seek, enforce or continue any Claim against the other party, its employees, agents, or servants arising out of, from, in, or in connection with the Employment or Cessation.3.2BarThis deed may be pleaded as a bar to any Claim now or in the future commenced or continued by or on behalf of either party, or any person claiming through either party arising out of, from, in, or in connection with the Employment or the Cessation, as set out in clause 3 1. The terms 'Cessation', 'Claim' and 'Employment' are defined in cl 1.1:Cessation means the cessation of the Employment which will take effect on the date referred to in Background clause C.Claim includes any complaint, action, suit, cause of action, application, arbitration, award, debt due, cost, claim, demand, liability, right, verdict, judgment or order either at law or in equity or arising out of the provisions of any statute, award, order or determination (with the exception of the provisions of any statute, award, order or determination relating to workers' compensation).Employment means the employment referred to in Background clause A.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The core principle that governs the way in which a contract is interpreted is that 'the meaning of the terms of a contractual document is to be determined by what a reasonable person would have understood them to mean'.[49] 'What the parties mean is to be determined by the language in which the parties express their agreement'.[50][49] Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640 [35] (French CJ, Hayne, Crennan & Kiefel JJ); Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 52; (2004) 219 CLR 165 [40] (Judgment of the Court); Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas [2004] HCA 35; (2004) 218 CLR 451 [22] (Judgment of the Court); Mackinlay v Derry Dew Pty Ltd [2014] WASCA 24; (2014) 46 WAR 247 [54] (Pullin JA, Buss & Newnes JJA agreeing on this point); Butler v St John of God Health Care Inc [2008] WASCA 174 [34] ‑ [35] (Newnes AJA, McLure & Buss JJA agreeing).[50] Electricity Generation [35]; Toll [40]; Pacific Carriers [22]; Mackinlay [54]; Butler [34]. The release in cl 3.1(a) is limited to 'Claims … arising out of, from, in, or in connection with the Employment or Cessation'. The agreement not to sue in cl 3.1(b) and the bar in cl 3.2 have the same limitation as the release. The expressions 'arising out of' and 'in connection with' used in the release, agreement not to sue and the bar are in their ordinary usage of wide connotation.[51] In Butler v St John of God Health Care Inc Newnes AJA stated of these phrases, in the context of a settlement agreement:[52][W]hile the words 'in connection with' connote a relationship between one thing and another, they do not necessarily connote any causal relationship between the two things: see North Eastern Railway Co v Furness Shipbuilding Co Ltd (1934) 50 TLR 257; Commissioner for Superannuation v Miller (1985) 8 FCR 153, 154, 160, 163; Our Town FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1987) 16 FCR 465, 479, 480 … While there is no easy test for the nature or extent of the causal or consequential relationship involved in the words 'arising out of', the relationship is less than that required by words such as 'caused by' or 'as a result of': beyond that it is a question of judgment on the particular facts: Dickinson v Motor Vehicle Insurance Trust (1987) 163 CLR 500, 505; Erect Safe Scaffolding (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sutton [2008] NSWCA 114 [11].[51] Butler [37].[52] Butler [38] ‑ [39]. The claims made against Mr Merrick relate to six different types of payments which Mr Merrick is said to have received that he was not entitled to:(a)instructing payroll offices of the Shire to pay additional superannuation to his superannuation fund on various dates during the period 15 November 2005 to 30 March 2010;(b)instructing payroll officers of the Shire to grant him additional rostered days off on various dates between July 2006 and August 2009;(c)instructing payroll officers of the Shire to grant him executive time off, and time off for attending quarterly Community Information Sessions, on various dates between December 2007 and March 2009;(d)instructing payroll officers of the Shire to pay out his unused sick leave in October 2009;(e)preparing and or submitting a salary package reconciliation for backpay for the 2004/05, 2005/06, 2006/07 and 2009/10 financial years, and instructing officers of the Shire to pay the deficit;(f)preparing and or submitting a salary package reconciliation for superannuation for the 2004/05, 2005/06, 2006/07and 2009/10 financial years, and instructing officers of the Shire to pay the deficit;(Employment Claims).