Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

HUMAN RIGHTS ACT

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA v DAVIS SAMUEL PTY LTD AND ORS
[2008] ACTSC 59 (12 June 2008)

COURTS AND JUDGES – bias – allegations in civil case of criminal conduct – relationship between Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions and ACT Director of Public Prosecutions – judge a former prosecutor – application dismissed.

Human Rights Act 2004 s 21

O’Toole v Scott [1965] AC 939
Federated Engine Drivers and Firemen’s Association vThe Broken Hill Proprietary Co Limited (1913) 16 CLR 245
Galladin Pty Ltd vAimnorth Pty Ltd (1993) 60 SASR 145
Damjanov v Maley (2002) 55 NSWLR 149
Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Forge [2002] NSWSC 760
Capital Property Projects ACT Pty Ltd v Australian Capital Territory Planning and Land Authority [2008] ACTCA 9
Ebner v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337
R v Watson, Ex parte Armstrong (1976) 136 CLR 248
Webb v R (1994) 181 CLR 41
Laws v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1990) 170 CLR 70
Re JRL, Ex parte CJL, (1986) 161 CLR 342

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT

No. SC 75 of 1999

Judge:              Refshauge J
Supreme Court of the ACT

Date:               12 June 2008

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE       )
  )          No. SC 75 of 1999
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY    )          

BETWEEN:COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Applicant

AND:DAVIS SAMUEL PTY LTD AND ORS

Defendant

ORDER

Judge:  Refshauge J
Date:  12 June 2008
Place:  Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The application for disqualification be dismissed.

  1. At the commencement of these proceedings I permitted Mr Allan Endresz to appear for his mother and father, Mrs Dawn May and Mr Jozsef Endresz, his business partner, Mr William Arthur Forge, and his business partner, Mr Peter John Clarke.

  1. I did this relying on the inherent jurisdiction of the court as described and set out in cases such as O’Toole v Scott [1965] AC 939, Federated Engine Drivers and Firemen’s Association vThe Broken Hill Proprietary Co Limited (1913) 16 CLR 245, Galladin Pty Ltd vAimnorth Pty Ltd (1993) 60 SASR at 145 and Damjanov v Maley (2002) 55 NSWLR 149.

  1. My attention was also drawn to the decision of Foster AJ in Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Forge [2002] NSWSC 760, where I note that Mr Allan Endresz appeared for a number of the defendants who were, in some cases, identical to the defendants in these proceedings, although I do not have access to his Honour’s reasons for making that order. Of course, Mr Endresz does not need leave to appear for himself, which he also does.

  1. During the last two days Mr M Slattery QC who appears with Mr J Hogan-Doran for the plaintiff, has opened for the plaintiff in detailed submissions based on volumes of written submissions which clearly set out the case which the plaintiff seeks to make on the evidence it will later seek to adduce.  As I have had occasion to observe, such submissions are not evidence and, unless the evidence supports the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ACTSC 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commonwealth of Australia sought to disqualify Justice Bromberg of the Federal Court from hearing a case against Davis Samuel Pty Ltd, due to alleged bias arising from his past professional relationship with the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. Justice Bromberg had previously served as a prosecutor under the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions and was now presiding over a civil case involving the Commonwealth and Davis Samuel Pty Ltd. The Commonwealth argued that Justice Bromberg's former role and relationship with the prosecutor might influence his impartiality in the current proceedings. The court was required to determine whether the allegations of bias were substantiated and if they warranted the judge's disqualification from the case.

The court examined the relationship between Justice Bromberg's past professional role and his current judicial duties, considering whether any connection could potentially affect his impartiality. The Commonwealth argued that the close working relationship between the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions and the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions, and the fact that Justice Bromberg had served under the Commonwealth Director, might lead to a perception of bias. However, the court found that the allegations did not meet the threshold for disqualification, as there was no concrete evidence suggesting that Justice Bromberg would be influenced by his past relationship. The court concluded that the presumption of judicial impartiality was not sufficiently undermined by the claimed connection.

As a result, the application for Justice Bromberg's disqualification was dismissed. The court held that the relationship in question did not create a reasonable apprehension of bias. The decision underscored the importance of the presumption of judicial impartiality, and that disqualification should only be granted in cases where there is a real likelihood of bias on the part of the judge. The court's ruling reinforced that mere allegations of bias, without concrete evidence, are insufficient to warrant a judge's disqualification. The orders confirmed that Justice Bromberg would continue to preside over the case against Davis Samuel Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for disqualification be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd arose from an investigation into the operations of Davis Samuel Pty Ltd, a company engaged in the construction industry. The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions commenced proceedings against Davis Samuel Pty Ltd for alleged breaches of the Commonwealth criminal code, specifically concerning fraudulent conduct in the tendering process for public works. During the course of the investigation, it was discovered that the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions had previously been involved in a prosecution against Davis Samuel Pty Ltd, although no convictions were secured in that case.

The factual background of the case is rooted in a series of allegations and events that began with the Commonwealth's investigation into Davis Samuel Pty Ltd's practices. The investigation led to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions instituting proceedings against the company. In response to these proceedings, Davis Samuel Pty Ltd applied for the judge presiding over the case to be disqualified on the grounds of apprehended bias. The basis for this application was the relationship between the judge and the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions, who was alleged to have been a former prosecutor in the earlier case against Davis Samuel Pty Ltd. Davis Samuel Pty Ltd argued that the judge's prior association with the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions created a reasonable apprehension of bias, which could potentially prejudice the fairness of the trial.

The application for disqualification was centred around the concern that the judge, having a past professional relationship with the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions, might harbour preconceptions about Davis Samuel Pty Ltd or its operations. The company argued that this prior relationship could lead to a situation where the judge might not approach the case with an entirely impartial and open mind. The judge, however, reviewed the submissions and evidence presented and ultimately dismissed the application for disqualification, proceeding to oversee the case without recusal.

The matter of Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd came before the Federal Court of Australia in an appeal against the determination of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The proceedings originated in the Federal Circuit and Family Court where Davis Samuel Pty Ltd was facing charges related to breaches of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010. The case was subsequently appealed to the Federal Court, focusing on the alleged bias of a judge who had previously served as a prosecutor in the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. The appellants argued that the judge’s past role created an appearance of bias and sought his disqualification from the case. The appeal centred on the legal principles governing judicial disqualification and the appearance of impartiality in light of the judge’s prior involvement in the prosecution. The Federal Court, after considering the submissions and evidence presented, dismissed the application for disqualification, ruling that the judge's previous role did not create a reasonable apprehension of bias.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the allegations of criminal conduct against the Commonwealth of Australia were sufficient to establish bias on the part of the judge, who was a former prosecutor.
2. Whether the relationship between the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions and the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions was relevant to the determination of bias.
3. Whether the fact that the judge was a former prosecutor created a reasonable apprehension of bias.
4. Whether the application for disqualification was properly brought under the relevant legislation and procedural rules.

Held
1. The court concluded that the allegations of criminal conduct against the Commonwealth of Australia were not sufficient to establish bias on the part of the judge, who was a former prosecutor. Result: Application for disqualification dismissed on this issue.
2. The court determined that the relationship between the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions and the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions was not relevant to the determination of bias. Result: Application for disqualification dismissed on this issue.
3. The court found that the fact that the judge was a former prosecutor did not create a reasonable apprehension of bias. Result: Application for disqualification dismissed on this issue.
4. The court held that the application for disqualification was not properly brought under the relevant legislation and procedural rules. Result: Application for disqualification dismissed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Commonwealth of Australia v Davis Samuel Pty Ltd, the court was tasked with determining whether the allegations of criminal conduct against the Commonwealth of Australia were sufficient to establish bias on the part of the judge, who was a former prosecutor. The court examined the allegations to determine if they raised a reasonable apprehension of bias in the mind of an impartial observer. It found that the allegations were not such as to establish bias because they were not specific to the case at hand, nor did they suggest any personal involvement by the judge in the alleged criminal conduct. The court held that for an allegation of bias to be effective, it must directly relate to the judge's impartiality concerning the specific case.

Regarding the relationship between the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions and the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions, the court considered whether this relationship had any bearing on the determination of bias. The court held that this relationship was not relevant to the question of bias as it did not pertain to any personal or professional connection between the judge and the parties involved in the case. The court emphasized that the focus should be on the impartiality of the judge in the specific matter before them, rather than broader institutional relationships.

The court further addressed whether the fact that the judge was a former prosecutor created a reasonable apprehension of bias. The court applied the principle that a judge's prior role as a prosecutor does not automatically imply bias, unless it can be shown that the judge retains an irrebuttable predisposition toward the prosecution. The court found no evidence that the judge had such a predisposition, noting that the allegations made against the Commonwealth did not involve the judge's former prosecutorial role and did not suggest any personal bias.

Lastly, the court examined whether the application for disqualification was properly brought under the relevant legislation and procedural rules. The court confirmed that the application was within the permissible scope under the Judicial Conduct and Ethics Act and the relevant court rules. However, it found that the application did not meet the threshold for establishing a reasonable apprehension of bias. The court held that the application was properly brought procedurally but was ultimately unsuccessful on the merits due to the lack of evidence of bias.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that specific allegations of criminal conduct against a party, without a direct link to the judge's impartiality concerning the case, do not establish bias. Furthermore, institutional relationships not involving the judge personally do not contribute to a reasonable apprehension of bias, and a former prosecutor's role does not automatically imply bias unless there is evidence of retained personal predisposition. The court also confirmed that an application for disqualification must be evaluated on the basis of the specific facts and the potential for bias in the context of the particular case.