Selecta Homes and Building Co Pty Ltd v Advertiser-Weekend Publishing Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

SELECTA HOMES AND BUILDING COMPANY PTY LTD v ADVERTISER-NEWS WEEKEND PUBLISHING COMPANY PTY LTD
[2001] SASC 140

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Lander and Gray JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ          In my opinion the appeal should be allowed.  I agree with the reasons given by Lander J and by Gray J for concluding that the award of damages made by the trial Judge is inadequate.  I agree with them that damages should be assessed at $80,000.  On the question of interest, I consider that the approach taken by each of them is acceptable, but in this case I favour the approach taken by Gray J.  Having regard to the periods of time involved, I consider it unnecessary to attempt to allow for changes in the value of the dollar between 1998 and 2000.

  2. Accordingly, I would allow the appeal, set aside the judgment and orders of the District Court of 13 October and 27 October 2000, order that judgment be entered in the District Court for the plaintiff against the second defendant in the sum of $88,500 inclusive of interest, and order that the second defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of action.

  3. LANDER J.     This is an appeal from a decision of a District Court Judge in proceedings for defamation brought by the appellant against the respondent in which the appellant recovered damages of $25,000.  The appellant complains about the assessment of damages.

  4. The appellant (the plaintiff in the Court below) is a company which carries on the business of building transportable houses. 

  5. On 21 February 1998, the respondent published in its newspaper, the Sunday Mail, a letter from the first defendant, a former customer of the appellant in the following terms:

    “Lack of pride in product

    I AGREE wholeheartedly with “Going out of business” (Sunday Mail, 8/2/98):    We have recently had the misfortune to purchase a new transportable home from a company, whose total lack of pride in workmanship and presentation has been unbelievable.

    And, how dare we, the client, who has handed over a large sum of hard-earned money, complain.  Our complaints were treated with absolute contempt and arrogance.  If it is too late for us, but if anyone is buying a transportable home, make sure you go over it with a fine-tooth comb on delivery, because anything not noticed on the day of hand over ultimately will be blamed on the purchaser.

    The standard set by some of these unscrupulous builders is supposedly within the incredibly broad guidelines of the building industry.  It makes you wonder who sets the “guidelines”.

    Winning the Design of the Year Award for transportable homes from the Housing Industry Association does not guarantee the quality of workmanship one would expect.

    K FERRIER, Berri”

  6. The letter refers to an earlier letter of 8 February 1998 which the plaintiff relied upon to plead a true innuendo.  Because the words are defamatory, in my opinion, in their natural and ordinary meaning it is not necessary to refer to that letter.

  7. Indeed on this appeal Mr Whitington QC, counsel…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Selecta Homes and Building Co Pty Ltd v Advertiser-Weekend P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Selecta Homes and Building Co Pty Ltd v Advertiser-Weekend Publishing Co Pty Ltd involved Selecta Homes, the plaintiff, suing Advertiser-Weekend Publishing Co Pty Ltd, the defendant, for defamation. The dispute arose from an article published by the defendant that Selecta claimed was defamatory and caused loss of business. The matter was heard and determined by the court. The central legal issues revolved around the extent to which the defamatory imputations in the article caused the claimed losses, and the proper approach to assessing damages. The court had to determine whether the trial judge correctly applied the principles of causation and damage assessment in defamation cases.

In its reasoning, the court highlighted that when some defamatory imputations are actionable, the judge must focus solely on the actionable defamation to assess damages. The court referred to previous case law, including March v Stramare, Chappel v Hart, and Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd, which emphasised that irrelevant considerations, such as justified parts of the defamatory material or unproved whispers, should be disregarded. The court found that the trial judge had erred in his approach by considering the impact of justified parts of the article on the plaintiff’s loss. Instead, the court determined that Selecta was entitled to full recovery for the actionable wrongs without any subtractions or reductions.

Consequently, the court allowed the appeal, varied the judgment and orders of the District Court to reflect an award of damages of $88,500 inclusive of interest, set aside the subsequent orders of the District Court, and ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the trial and the appeal. This decision underscored the importance of correctly applying causation principles in defamation cases to ensure just compensation for the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ LANDER J GRAY J
I would order that:1 The appeal be allowed.2The judgment and orders of the District Court of 13 October 2000 be varied to provide for an award of damages of $88,500 inclusive of interest.3The orders of the District Court of 27 October 2000 be set aside.4The Sunday Mail pay the Selecta’s costs of the trial and of this appeal.LIST OF CASES CITED AS THEY APPEAR IN THE JUDGMENT1Mrs Ferrier was joined as a defendant. The claim against Mrs Ferrier was resolved by agreement during Trial.2References in transcript as 21 and 22 February. Nothing turns on the precise date.3 This imputation was not challenged on appeal4 D & L Caterers Limited v D'Ajou [1945] 1 KB 4655March v Stramare (E & MH) Pty Ltd (1990-91) 171 CLR 506 at 509, 524, 530; Chappel v Hart (1998-99) 195 CLR 232; Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd (1998) 193 CLR 519 per Kirby J at [177]6 (most often where some are justified)7 [1964] AC 3718(1998) 193 CLR 519 per Gaudron and Gummow JJ at [93] , Kirby J at [181-183]9The authority for the practice is found in Polly Peck Holdings PLC v Trelford [1986] QB 1000 per O’Connor LJ at (1032-1033)10Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Limited (1998) 193 CLR 519 at para [9]11 unreported SC (SA) FC 15 October 1997 Judgment No. S 637012 (1998) 147 FLR 410 13 (1999) 1 VR 87514 [1998)] VSC 96, [2000] VSCA 2415[1945] 1 KB 364; See also Feo v Pioneer Concrete (Vic) Pty Ltd [1999] 3 VR 417 at [52-57]16 [1993] AC 53417 [1964] AC 23418 (1990) 2 NZLR 48819 [1999] 3 VR 55, see also Andrews v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd; 1980 2 NSWLR 225 at 235-7, 251-2; Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Comalco Ltd (1986) 12 F.C.R. 510 (586), (599-600)20 1840 6 Bing (NC) 212; 133 ER 8421 [1999] 3 VR 417 22 (1890-91) 60 LJ QB 231 (C.A.)23 [1991] 1 QB 28324 [1991] A Def R 42 087 (20 Nov 1991)25 Qd C of A 25.3.97 BC 970102626 1995-96) 15 WAR 7527 March v Stramare Pty Limited (1990-91) 171 CLR 506 at 509, 524, 53028 1991] 1 QB 283 at 296, 297, 30229 1984] 1 NSWLR 317 at 32030 1967-68) 117 CLR 11831 (1998-99) 196 CLR 132 “Aggravated, Exemplary and Restitutionary Damages”, United Kingdom Law Commission No. 247 (1997)33 at [23]34 (1983-1984) CLR 44835 (1980) 2 NSW LR 225 at (243-44), (248-50).36 (1993) 178 CLR 4437 [1977] VR 516 at 52938 MBP (SA) Proprietary Limited v Gogic (1990-1991) 171 CLR 65739Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd (1998-1999) 72 SASR 361 at (378-380)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ, LANDER J, GRAY J

Selecta submitted that the trial judge erred in his approach to causation. It was said that Selecta only needed to establish that the defamatory imputations were a cause of the loss. I agree. This proposition is well established.[5][5] March v Stramare (E & MH) Pty Ltd (1990-91) 171 CLR 506 at 509, 524, 530; Chappel v Hart (1998-99) 195 CLR 232; Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd (1998) 193 CLR 519 per Kirby J at [177]Irrelevant Considerations When some of the defamatory imputations in a publication are actionable[6], the judge must eliminate from his mind those which are not. The judge must ascertain the actual defamation and assess damages in relation to the injury caused by that defamation.[6] (most often where some are justified) In Associated Newspapers Ltd v Dingle[7] Lord Radcliffe said at (394):"The judge's task in arriving at a figure of damages for the defamation contained in the article ... was not a simple one. He had first to eliminate from his mind that small part of the imputation that he found to have been justified ... Next the judge had to eliminate that part of the article that consisted of extracts from the select committee's report, since under the Act of 1840 such extracts could not in law be treated as a libel. Having done all this, he had to ascertain and measure what was the actionable defamation and assess a figure of damages in relation to the injury it had caused."[7] [1964] AC 371 This passage was approved in Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd[8]. Kirby J said at [183]:"Nevertheless, thinking in terms of 'subtraction' or 'reduction' may lead to errors of calculation of general damages which would inappropriately diminish the plaintiff's just entitlements. The decision maker should never lose sight of the objective of the award of damages, once entitlement is established. It is to vindicate the reputation of the party wronged, to compensate that person for the hurt caused by the wrong proved and, at least in some cases, to resolve such matters before the public which may have its own interest to know the outcome. The damages must be such as to sustain the law's assumption that, once they are awarded, there will be no future loss. Irrelevant considerations such as the existence of other discreditable matter which might have been published of the plaintiff, but was not, or the existence of some accurate allegations in the midst of unsustainable ones must simply be put out of mind. The plaintiff is only entitled to recover damages for the actionable wrongs proved. But for them, the plaintiff is entitled to full recovery without subtractions and without reductions."[8] (1998) 193 CLR 519 per Gaudron and Gummow JJ at [93] , Kirby J at [181-183] In the light of this authority it is necessary to consider the trial judge's reasons. He said:"Much of the letter was justified. It went too far in suggesting dishonesty and in generalising from the specific problems with Mr. Ling. So much of the letter as was justified may well have affected sales of the plaintiff. I accept the proposition that 'bad news' can spread rapidly, though the whispers may be impossible to prove in detail. The plaintiff is to be compensated only for such additional loss as was caused by the unjustified parts of the letter."