Scentre Management Limited v ACT Planning and Land Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Scentre Management Limited v ACT Planning and Land Authority

Citation:

[2021] ACTSC 171

Hearing Dates:

21–23 June 2021

DecisionDate:

5 August 2021

Before:

Crowe AJ

Decision:

See [290]

Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Judicial review – review of decision under the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT) – where plaintiff is Crown lessee of land in commercial core zone not the subject of the decision – whether plaintiff has standing – whether decision-maker provided adequate reasons – whether decision beyond jurisdiction due to uncertainty – whether failure to take into account relevant considerations – whether decision inconsistent with advice given by an entity to which the application was referred – whether decision vitiated by apprehended bias

Legislation Cited:

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) s 12
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977
(Cth)
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1989 (ACT) ss 4A, 5, 13, 17
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Amendment Bill 2013 (ACT) s 6
Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic) s 68
Australian Capital Territory (Planning and Land Management) Act 1988 (Cth) s 25
Legislation Act 2001
(ACT) ss 6, 139, 140, 141, 142, 170, 171, 179
Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT) ss 6, 10, 12, 50, 51, 53, 55, 119, 120, 121, 122, 144, 148, 151, 156, 162, 163, 165, 170, 171, 173, 197, 202, 361, 409
Planning and Development Regulation 2008 (ACT) ss 26, 350

Territory Plan 2008 (ACT)

Cases Cited:

Allan v Transurban City Link Ltd [2001] HCA 58; 208 CLR 167

Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Smithkline Beecham (Australia) Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 250

Argos and Ors v Corbell and Ors [2014] HCA 50; 254 CLR 354
Baptist Community Services v ACTPLA [2015] ACTCA 3; 293 FLR 97
Bateman's Bay Local Aboriginal Land Council v Aboriginal Community Benefit Fund Pty Ltd [1998] HCA 49; 194 CLR 247
Buzzacott v Minister for Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities
[2013] FCAFC 111; 215 FCR 301
Chapman v Tickner
(1995) 55 FCR 316
CNY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] HCA 50;  268 CLR 76
Comcare v Lilley [2013] FCAFC 121; 216 FCR 214
Commissioner of Police (NSW) v Eaton
[2013] HCA 2; 252 CLR 1
Concerned Citizens of Canberra Inc v Chief Executive (Land and Planning) [2015] ACTCA 56; 303 FLR 49
Ebner v Official Trusteein Bankruptcy [2000] HCA 63; 205 CLR 337
Faull v Commissioner for Social Housing [2013] ACTSC 121; 277 FLR 61
Faulkner v Conwell  (1989) 21 FCR 41
Ferdinands v Commissioner for Public Employment
[2006] HCA 5; 225 CLR 130
Forman v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2013] ACTSC 167; 279 FLR 54
Herald and Weekly Times Ltd v Correctional Services Commissioner [2001] VSC 329
Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; 264 CLR 123
Isbester v Knox City Council [2015] HCA 20; 255 CLR 135
Laws v Australian Broadcasting…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scentre Management Limited v ACT Planning and Land Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACTSC 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Scentre Management Limited, the plaintiff, challenged the decision of the ACT Planning and Land Authority to approve a development application for the redevelopment of a produce market at Belconnen. The plaintiff alleged that the approval decision was flawed for a number of reasons, including that the decision-maker was biased, and that the decision was inconsistent with advice given by relevant entities, and failed to observe the requirements for reasons. Elanor Funds Management Ltd, the third defendant, argued that the plaintiff lacked standing to bring the proceeding and that the approval decision was valid. The plaintiff also argued that the approval decision was flawed in that it failed to observe the requirements for reasons. The court found that the plaintiff lacked standing to bring the proceeding because there was no likelihood that the plaintiff's interest would be adversely affected by the approval decision. The court also found that the approval decision was valid. The approval decision did not fail to observe the requirements for reasons because the decision-maker was required only to set out the reasons for approval, not the reasons against approval. Nor was the approval decision inconsistent with the advice given by relevant entities because the approval was subject to conditions which ensured that the advice was substantially observed. The approval decision was not flawed by any apprehended bias on the part of the decision-maker because the court found that there was no reasonable basis for a fair-minded observer to apprehend that the decision-maker would decide the matter other than on its merits.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 3 February 2020, Elton Consulting Group, on behalf of Elanor Funds Management Ltd, lodged a development application with the ACT Planning and Land Authority (the Authority) for approval to redevelop the Belconnen Produce Market, located at Block 2, Section 198, Belconnen. The proposed development involved demolishing the existing produce market building, constructing a new, larger, single-storey produce market with basement car parking, and removing the assigning and subletting clause from the Crown lease for the site. The site was zoned "CZ3 Services Zone," but the application also claimed applicability of the "CZ2 Business Zone." The Authority assessed the application and, on 20 April 2020, approved the application subject to certain conditions. Scentre Management Limited, the lessee of the large shopping centre at Belconnen known as Westfield Belconnen, filed an Originating Application in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory seeking judicial review of the approval decision. Consent orders were made setting aside the 20 April 2020 decision and referring the matter back to the Authority for further consideration. The Authority incorrectly assessed the development application based on the site's zoning. On 15 September 2020, Elton lodged a request for the Authority to amend the development application, which was publicly notified between 15 September 2020 and 15 October 2020. Scentre submitted a written representation in response to the notification. The Authority assessed the amended development application and, on 13 November 2020, approved the amended development application subject to conditions. Scentre commenced these proceedings on 14 December 2020. The Authority filed an affidavit of Christopher Byron Gell, the delegate who made the 13 November 2020 decision, which attached a supplementary "Statement of Reasons" for making that decision. Scentre sought relief in the form of quashing the decision, referring the matter back to the Authority, and directing that the decision be made by a different person. Elanor filed an application seeking the dismissal of the proceedings on the basis that Scentre lacked standing.

This case before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory is an application for judicial review brought by Scentre Management Limited (Scentre), the Crown lessee of a large shopping centre at Belconnen known as Westfield Belconnen, against the ACT Planning and Land Authority (Authority) and others. The matter came before the court as an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Authority under the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT) to approve a development application lodged by Elanor Funds Management Ltd (Elanor). Scentre initially sought judicial review of the decision in SC 182 of 2020, which was resolved by consent orders setting aside the decision and referring the matter back to the Authority for reconsideration. Following reconsideration, the Authority approved the amended development application on 13 November 2020, leading Scentre to commence these proceedings on 14 December 2020. The court heard the matter from 21–23 June 2021 and delivered its decision on 5 August 2021.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Scentre Management Limited have standing to bring an application for judicial review of the decision made by the ACT Planning and Land Authority?
2. Was the decision-maker required to provide adequate reasons for the approval of the development application?
3. Was the decision beyond jurisdiction due to uncertainty in the approval conditions?
4. Did the decision-maker fail to take into account relevant considerations as required by the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT)?
5. Was there an inconsistency between the decision and the advice given by entities to which the application was referred?
6. Was the decision vitiated by apprehended bias on the part of the decision-maker?

Held
1. Does Scentre Management Limited have standing to bring an application for judicial review of the decision made by the ACT Planning and Land Authority? The Court concluded that Scentre does not have standing to bring the application for judicial review. Therefore, the application was dismissed.
2. Was the decision-maker required to provide adequate reasons for the approval of the development application? The Court concluded that the decision-maker was required to provide adequate reasons, but found that there were technical inadequacies in the reasons given for the 13 November 2020 decision. However, the Court rejected ground 2 of the Amended Originating Application.
3. Was the decision beyond jurisdiction due to uncertainty in the approval conditions? The Court concluded that the approval decision did not exceed jurisdiction due to uncertainty in the approval conditions. The Court rejected the contention that the decision was prohibited by s 119(2) of the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT).
4. Did the decision-maker fail to take into account relevant considerations as required by the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT)? The Court concluded that the decision-maker did not fail to take into account relevant considerations as required by the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT). The Court found that the approval decision did, in substance, accord with the advice from the relevant entities.
5. Was there an inconsistency between the decision and the advice given by entities to which the application was referred? The Court concluded that there was no inconsistency between the decision and the advice given by entities to which the application was referred. The Court found that the approval decision did, in substance, accord with the advice from the relevant entities.
6. Was the decision vitiated by apprehended bias on the part of the decision-maker? The Court concluded that the decision was not vitiated by apprehended bias on the part of the decision-maker. The Court rejected ground 5 of the Amended Originating Application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

- **Does Scentre Management Limited have standing to bring an application for judicial review of the decision made by the ACT Planning and Land Authority?**

The court examined the statutory provisions under s 4A of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1989 (ACT) (AD(JR) Act (ACT)) to determine if Scentre had standing. The court found that Scentre, as the owner of a significant portion of the land within the CZ1 Core Zone, had a special interest in the maintenance of the function of that zone. However, the court concluded that Scentre had not established that its interests were adversely affected by the approval decision. The court found that any adverse effect alleged by Scentre was purely speculative and dismissed Scentre's application for lack of standing.

- **Was the decision-maker required to provide adequate reasons for the approval of the development application?**

The court examined the obligations under s 170 of the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT) (PDA) and s 179 of the Legislation Act 2001 (ACT) (LA). The court found that the decision-maker was required to provide written notice setting out the decision and reasons for approval, along with any conditions. However, the court concluded that the reasons provided were not necessarily inadequate, and the approval decision did not violate any statutory requirements.

- **Was the decision beyond jurisdiction due to uncertainty in the approval conditions?**

The court analyzed the concept of inconsistency in the context of the advice from entities to which the development application was referred. The court found that the approval decision did not conflict with the advice from Icon Water and Transport Canberra and City Services (TCCS) and that the conditions imposed were consistent with the advice. The court concluded that the approval decision was not beyond jurisdiction due to uncertainty in the approval conditions.

- **Did the decision-maker fail to take into account relevant considerations as required by the Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT)?**

The court examined whether the decision-maker failed to consider relevant zoning objectives and other considerations required by the PDA. The court found that the decision-maker had considered the relevant zoning objectives and other factors, and the approval decision was consistent with the overall legislative context. The court concluded that the decision-maker did not fail to take into account relevant considerations.

- **Was there an inconsistency between the decision and the advice given by entities to which the application was referred?**

The court examined the advice from Icon Water and TCCS and found that the approval decision did not conflict with the advice. The court concluded that there was no inconsistency between the decision and the advice given by the entities.

- **Was the decision vitiated by apprehended bias on the part of the decision-maker?**

The court examined the factors relied upon by Scentre to allege apprehended bias, such as the decision-maker making the same decision twice and giving inadequate reasons. The court concluded that a fair-minded observer would not reasonably apprehend that the decision-maker would not decide the application on its merits, and there was no apprehended bias.