Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sanrus Pty Ltd & Ors v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd & Ors [2018] QSC 53

PARTIES:

SANRUS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE QC TRUST
ACN 097 049 315

(first plaintiff)
EDGE DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE KOWHAI TRUST
ABN 26 010 309 529
(second plaintiff)
H&J ENTERPRISES (QLD) PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE H&J TRUST
ACN 077 333 736
(third plaintiff)

v
MONTO COAL 2 PTY LTD
ACN 098 919 414

(first defendant)
MONTO COAL PTY LTD
ACN 098 393 072
(second defendant)
MACARTHUR COAL LIMITED

ACN 096 001 955
(third defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 8609 of 2007

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

15 March 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 February 2018

JUDGE:

Crow J

ORDERS:

1.   The application is dismissed.

2.   As to costs:

a.   If the parties are agreed as to the appropriate costs order the defendants are directed to file consent order with the Registrar by 4 pm on 20 March 2018.

b.   If the parties cannot agree on the appropriate order, the plaintiffs are directed to file and serve written submissions on this issue on or before 4 pm on 23 March 2018, the defendants are directed to file and serve written submissions on this issue on or before 27 March 2018, and the plaintiffs are to file any reply within two business days of receipt of the defendants’ submissions.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – SECURITY FOR COSTS – FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION – PLAINTIFF’S OR APPLICANT’S IMPECUNIOSITY – GENERALLY – where the defendant applied for a security of costs order for the defendants’ future costs of and incidental to the proceedings – where there was a previous consent order for security of the defendants’ costs – where the plaintiff corporations had paid up capital equal to or less than $100 – where the plaintiff corporations’ had a cumulative 49 per cent interest in the joint venture project in dispute – where the value of that interest in the joint venture project was disputed – where the joint venture agreement granted rights of pre-emption to the defendants – where the plaintiffs submitted they could apply for the appointment of a statutory trustee for the sale of joint venture assets under s 38(1) Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) – whether the plaintiffs would be unable to pay an order for costs

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), s 38(1), s 39(1)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 671, r 672

Aqua Blue (Noosa) Pty Ltd v Soil Surveys Engineering Pty Ltd [2010] QSC 176, considered
Bryan E Fencott and Assocs Pty Ltd v Eretta Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 497; [1987] FCA 102, applied
Hall v Busst (1960) 104 CLR 206; [1960] HCA 84, distinguished
Harpur v Ariadne Australia Ltd (No 2) (1984) 2 Qd R 523, cited
Lanai Unit Holdings Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd, the defendants sought an order for the plaintiffs to provide security for costs in the amount of $4 million. The dispute arose from a long-standing legal battle between the parties concerning the Monto Coal deposit, with the plaintiffs' claim for damages exceeding $1 billion. The defendants applied for the security of costs order under rule 670 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld). The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiffs would be unable to pay an order for costs, and if the application should be granted given the plaintiffs' financial status and their cumulative 49 per cent interest in the joint venture project in dispute.

The court examined the financial circumstances of the plaintiffs and their ability to pay the costs. The plaintiffs had paid-up capital equal to or less than $100, and the value of their interest in the joint venture project was disputed. The court considered the plaintiffs' submissions that they could apply for the appointment of a statutory trustee for the sale of joint venture assets under section 38(1) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld). The court found that the defendants' application for security of costs should be dismissed as the plaintiffs' financial situation did not warrant such an order. The court directed the parties to confer and agree on a costs order, with deadlines set for the filing of written submissions in the event of disagreement.

The court's decision was based on the plaintiffs' financial status, the disputed value of their interest in the joint venture project, and the potential for the appointment of a statutory trustee for the sale of joint venture assets. The court did not find it necessary to grant the defendants' application for security of costs, and directed the parties to attempt to agree on a costs order. If the parties could not agree, they were directed to file written submissions on the issue of costs within specific deadlines.

The court dismissed the defendants' application for security of costs and directed the parties to confer and agree on a costs order. If the parties could not agree, they were directed to file written submissions on the issue of costs within specified deadlines. This decision highlights the importance of considering the financial circumstances of parties and the potential for alternative dispute resolution methods when determining whether to grant an application for security of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. As to costs:

a. If the parties are agreed as to the appropriate costs order the defendants are directed to file consent order with the Registrar by 4 pm on 20 March 2018.

b. If the parties cannot agree on the appropriate order, the plaintiffs are directed to file and serve written submissions on this issue on or before 4 pm on 23 March 2018, the defendants are directed to file and serve written submissions on this issue on or before 27 March 2018, and the plaintiffs are to file any reply within two business days of receipt of the defendants’ submissions.

Background

Background to the litigation

By an application filed 4 December 2017 the defendants apply for an order pursuant tor 670 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (“UCPR”), that the plaintiffs give security in the sum of $4 million for the defendants’ further costs of and incidental to the proceedings.Background Almost ten and a half years ago, on 1 October 2007, the plaintiffs commenced proceedings against the defendants in respect of a dispute over the Monto Coal deposit. There are 215 documents filed in the current proceedings and many other documents filed in the Court in associated proceedings. The plaintiffs’ claim for damages exceeds $1 billion. The amended consolidated statement of claim filed 3 April 2014 is 60 pages in length, the current defence (being the third further amended defence filed 21 April 2017) is 177 pages in length, the current reply (being the further amended reply of 20 June 2017) is 367 pages in length and the current rejoinder (being the rejoinder filed 9 October 2017) is 59 pages in length. The plaintiffs presently intend to call nine witnesses and, according to the parties’ joint report to the Court of 2 February 2018, the defendants intend to call 50 witnesses. More than 30,000 documents have been discovered. The case is being managed with the intent of setting a 16 week trial early next year. The proceeding concerns the Monto Coal Joint Venture (“MCJV”) which was established for the purpose of carrying out the Monto Coal Project. The MCJV is constituted under a Joint Venture Agreement dated 16 May 2002 (the Joint Venture Agreement). Under the Joint Venture Agreement:(a)the plaintiffs hold a 49 per cent interest in the MCJV (with 39.2 per cent held by the first plaintiff, 4.9 per cent held by the second plaintiff and 4.9 per cent held by the third plaintiff);(b)the first defendant (Monto Coal 2) holds the remaining 51 per cent interest in the MCJV. Monto Coal 2 was until 1 April 2008 a wholly owned subsidiary of the third defendant (Macarthur) and since that date Macarthur has been the majority shareholder of Monto Coal 2. The second defendant (Monto Coal) is the manager of the Monto Coal Project pursuant to a Management Agreement dated 16 May 2002 (the Management Agreement). Monto Coal is a wholly owned subsidiary of Macarthur. The Joint Venture Agreement envisages the development of the Monto Coal Project in two stages:(a)Stage 1 is defined (in cl 1) to mean Mining Operations producing between 1 million and 1.5 million tonnes of saleable coal per annum;(b)Stage 2 is defined (in cl 1) to mean the Mine Development and Mining Operations beyond Stage 1 with the expectation of production being 10 million tonnes or more of saleable coal per annum. Clause 4.1(f) of the Joint Venture Agreement requires the Participants to act in good faith towards the other Participants. Clause 5.1 of the Joint Venture Agreement provides:“The Participants must use all reasonable efforts to obtain the grant of the Mining Lease and to, having regard to all relevant factors relating to the Monto Coal Project and the economic viability of the Monto Coal Project, develop Stage 1 within three years of the Commencement Date [i.e. by 16 May 2005]. For the avoidance of doubt, Monto Coal 2 agrees not to have any regard to the profitability of any other ventures entered or to be entered into by its holding company, Macarthur Coal, or any of its Related Corporations.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As reflected by Daubney J in Aqua Blue (Noosa) Pty Ltd v Soil Surveys Engineering Pty Ltd,[42] the assessment can only occur with the broadest of brushes. It seems to me that absent an ability to test the fine detail of the Defendants’ estimation the justice of the case requires a mid-view of the two disparate assessments, that is by accepting the costs at $3.25 million. It is accepted that this is the simplistic average of the two estimates, however, there is no other basis of choosing between the experts accepting, as I do, the equal competing considerations of Mr Robinson’s unquestioned independence and expertise and Mr Ilott’s far better knowledge of the conduct of the case.[42] [2010] QSC 176.Conclusion For the reasons which I have set out above I refuse the defendants’ application. I direct that the parties confer with respect to agreement on the issue of costs and should a costs order be agreed, the parties are directed to provide the consent order in respect of costs to my Associate within three days. If the parties cannot agree as to the appropriate costs order within three days, the plaintiff is directed to file written submissions on the issue of costs within seven days. The defendant is to file and serve written submissions on costs within 10 days and the plaintiff is to file any necessary reply on the law within two days of receipt of the defendants’ submissions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.