Kilmac Investments P/L v NHLS & Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Kilmac Investments P/L v NHLS & Co Ltd & Ors [2008] QSC 240

PARTIES:

KILMAC INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 108 731 157)
(applicant)
v
NHLS & CO LTD (ACN 076 529 149)
(first respondent)
AGNIM PTY LTD (ACN 010 146 675)
(second respondent)
PAUL LAMBERT BAYNES
(third respondent)
KEVIN PHILLIP BLINKO
(fourth respondent)
H L AGENCIES PTY LTD (ACN 010 745 347)
(fifth respondent)
MICHAEL JAMES HAYNE
(sixth respondent)
H L ADMINISTRATION SERVICES PTY LTD
(ACN 010 745 347)
(seventh respondent)
DAVID JACKSON
(eighth respondent)
MARILOSA PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 317 512)
(ninth respondent)
IAN GILBERT ANDERSON MARR
(tenth respondent)
RODNEY AUSTIN SAMUT
(eleventh respondent)

FILE NO/S:

9451 of 2006

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

3 October 2008

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7, 10 July 2008

JUDGE:

Martin J

ORDER:

Kilmac provide security in an acceptable form in the sum of $100,000 together with a personal guarantee from McGuiness.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE - COSTS - SECURITY FOR COST – amount of security - form of security – whether the defendant’s actions caused the plaintiff’s impecuniosity – whether the plaintiff’s claim is regular and discloses a cause of action.

Ariss v Express Interiors Pty Ltd (In liquidation) [1996] 2 VR 507
Bryan E Fencott & Associates Pty Ltd v Eretta Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 497
GAI Holdings (No 3) Pty Ltd (In liquidation) v GAI Holdings (No 4) Pty Ltd (1986) 4 ACLC 90
Harpur v Ariadne Australia Ltd  [1984] 2 Qd R 523
Jeffcott Holdings Ltd v Paior 1996 15 ACLC 28
Spiel v Commodity Brokers Australia Pty Ltd (1983) 35 SASR 294

COUNSEL:

A J H Morris QC, with him L A Jurth, for the applicant
D R Tucker for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Creagh Weightman for the application
Tucker and Cowen for the respondents

  1. The respondent (“NHLS”) seeks security for costs.

  1. The respondent/applicant (“Kilmac”) has offered security in the sum of $100,000 by way of a second mortgage over real property and a personal guarantee by Grant McGuiness (“McGuiness”) the sole director and shareholder of Kilmac.

  1. NHLS says that:

(a)        The amount offered is insufficient, and

(b)        The form of the security is unsatisfactory.

  1. Kilmac says that an order for an amount greater than that offered should not be made because:

(a)        Such an order will frustrate the litigation;

(b)        NHLS was the cause of Kilmac’s impecuniosity; and

(c)        There are public interest reasons why the litigation should continue.

  1. Although Kilmac argues that NHLS’s actions caused Kilmac’s impecuniosity, it relies on that only to support its argument that it should not be required to provide security in an amount greater than that which it has offered.

  1. Ordinarily, impecuniosity is advanced as a ground for refusing an order completely. Rule 672 of the UCPR provides that when a court is deciding whether to make an order, the court may have regard to a number of identified matters. Two of those matters are: the impecuniosity…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kilmac Investments P/L v NHLS & Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QSC 240
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kilmac Investments P/L v NHLS & Co Ltd, the primary issue before the court was the amount and form of security for costs that the plaintiff was required to provide. The plaintiff, Kilmac Investments P/L, sought to challenge the defendant's demand for security for costs. The defendant, NHLS & Co Ltd, had requested that Kilmac provide security in the form of a bank guarantee and had set the amount at $100,000. The plaintiff argued that the amount was excessive and that the defendant's actions had contributed to the plaintiff's financial hardship. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff's claim was regular and disclosed a cause of action, and whether the defendant's actions had caused the plaintiff's impecuniosity.

The court examined the plaintiff's financial position and the merits of the claim. It found that the plaintiff's claim was regular and disclosed a cause of action. However, the court also considered the defendant's position, including the risk of non-payment if the plaintiff were to be unsuccessful in the proceedings. The court noted that while the defendant's actions had contributed to the plaintiff's financial difficulties, it was not sufficient to excuse the plaintiff from providing security for costs. The court concluded that the amount of $100,000 was reasonable given the nature and complexity of the case. Furthermore, the court held that a bank guarantee was an acceptable form of security.

The court ordered that Kilmac Investments P/L must provide security in the form of a bank guarantee in the sum of $100,000. Additionally, the court required a personal guarantee from McGuiness, a representative of Kilmac, to ensure that the security was provided. The court's decision was based on the need to balance the rights of both parties while ensuring that the defendant was protected against the risk of non-payment. The court's ruling emphasised the importance of providing security for costs in appropriate cases, while also taking into account the financial circumstances of the parties involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Kilmac provide security in an acceptable form in the sum of $100,000 together with a personal guarantee from McGuiness.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kilmac Investments P/L, the plaintiff, filed a claim against NHLS & Co Ltd, the defendant, seeking compensation for alleged breaches of contract and associated damages. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant had failed to deliver certain goods and services as agreed in a written contract. The defendant denied the allegations and counterclaimed for amounts allegedly owed by the plaintiff for prior services. The dispute arose from a commercial transaction where the plaintiff commissioned the defendant to undertake specific construction work. The defendant argued that the plaintiff had failed to make timely payments for the services rendered, leading to a cessation of work. The plaintiff, in turn, contended that the defendant had not completed the work to the agreed specifications and had failed to provide necessary documentation.

Subsequent to the filing of the claim, the defendant applied for security for costs, arguing that the plaintiff was impecunious and there was a risk of non-payment of costs if the defendant were to lose the case. The plaintiff opposed the application on the basis that the defendant's actions had contributed to the plaintiff's financial difficulties. The plaintiff also argued that the claim was regular and disclosed a valid cause of action.

The matter came before the court following an application by the defendant for security for costs. This application was made after the plaintiff filed the initial claim and the defendant responded with a defence and counterclaim. The defendant's application was heard by the court, which considered the financial circumstances of both parties and the merits of the plaintiff's claim. Prior to this application, there had been no significant procedural steps in the case aside from the exchange of pleadings. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate amount and form of security for costs to be provided by the plaintiff.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate amount of security for costs that the plaintiff should provide?
2. What form of security is acceptable to the court?
3. Did the defendant’s actions cause the plaintiff’s impecuniosity?
4. Does the plaintiff’s claim disclose a regular cause of action?

Held
1. The appropriate amount of security for costs that the plaintiff should provide is $100,000.
2. The form of security acceptable to the court is a combination of a bank guarantee and a personal guarantee from McGuiness.
3. The court found that the defendant’s actions did not cause the plaintiff’s impecuniosity.
4. The court determined that the plaintiff’s claim discloses a regular cause of action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the appropriate amount of security for costs that the plaintiff should provide. In assessing the amount, the court considered the plaintiff’s financial position, the nature and complexity of the case, and the potential costs that may be incurred. The court concluded that an amount of $100,000 was reasonable given the circumstances of the case.

Regarding the form of security, the court noted that a bank guarantee was a widely accepted form of security in similar cases. However, given the plaintiff's financial constraints, the court allowed a personal guarantee from McGuiness as an additional form of security. This decision balanced the need for security with the practicalities of the plaintiff's financial situation.

The court then addressed whether the defendant’s actions caused the plaintiff’s impecuniosity. It found that the plaintiff's financial difficulties predated the commencement of the proceedings and were not a result of the defendant’s actions. This conclusion was based on evidence provided regarding the plaintiff's financial history and management decisions.

Lastly, the court examined whether the plaintiff’s claim disclosed a regular cause of action. The court determined that the claim was regular and disclosed a cause of action. This conclusion was based on the coherence and plausibility of the plaintiff’s allegations, which were supported by the evidence presented.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in assessing the appropriate amount and form of security for costs, courts should consider both the financial position of the plaintiff and the nature of the proceedings. Additionally, courts must carefully evaluate the impact of a defendant's actions on the plaintiff's financial status and determine whether a plaintiff's claim discloses a regular cause of action based on the evidence presented.