Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES SUPREME COURT

CITATION:     Idoport Pty Limited & Anor v National Australia Bank Limited and 8 Ors; Idoport Pty Limited & Market Holdings Pty Limited v Donald Robert Argus;  Idoport Pty Limited "JMG" v National Australia Bank Limited & Ors [51] [2001]  NSWSC 1081

CURRENT JURISDICTION:   

FILE NUMBER(S):     50113/98
50026/99
3991/00

HEARING DATE{S): 26/11/01

JUDGMENT DATE:     26/11/2001

PARTIES:
Idoport Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
National Australia Bank Limited (Defendant)
Donald Robert Argus (Defendant)

JUDGMENT OF:       Einstein J     

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:      Not Applicable

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):   Not Applicable

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:         Not Applicable

COUNSEL:
Mr JJ Garnsey QC, Mr M Dicker, Mr R Titterton, Mr R Alkadamani (Plaintiff)
Mr T Bathurst QC, Mr J Sackar QC, Dr A S Bell, Mr J Halley (Defendants)

SOLICITORS:
Withnell Hetherington (Plaintiff)
Freehills (Defendants)

CATCHWORDS:
Practice and procedure
Discretion to adjourn proceedings
Principles
Adjournment of final hearing for a period leading to substantial case management difficulties
Final hearing already having continued for 18 months
Failure to comply with orders to provide security for costs
Application for dismissal of proceedings following automatic stay of proceedings operative when security for costs not provided
Case management
Circumstances in which a party may be shut out from litigating an arguable case
Administration of justice requiring that a much less affluent litigant seeking to enforce alleged rights against a much wealthier party should be afforded a reasonable opportunity to secure funds to enable the continued enforcement of those claimed rights
Application to vary or stay or vacate interlocutory orders of a substantive nature made after a contested hearing requires applicant to show a material change of circumstances

ACTS CITED:
Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW)

DECISION:
Short moments of order to be brought in to provide for the giving of directions as contemplated by the reasons for judgment, namely being

  1. that insofar as orders and directions currently in place require the defendants to carry out procedural steps of and related to the final hearing, the order and directions be stayed until midnight on 1 December 2001

  2. that the main proceedings be re-listed for directions on the first day of the new term at noon

  3. that the defendants' application for orders dismissing the MLC proceedings be stood over for hearing on the first day of the new term at noon or on such later occasion as the circumstances which obtain on that day may dictate

  4. that each party be given general leave to make returnable on the first day of the new term at noon, such further or other motions as they seek to have heard in determining the fate of the proceedings

  5. the defendants have leave to make returnable on the first day of the new term at noon, any notice of motion seeking to dismiss the main proceedings for failure to prosecute and/or for any failure to provide security for costs

  6. the plaintiff has leave to make returnable on the same day at the same time, any notice of motion seeking to have the stay orders listed

  7. such…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 1081
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd, the court considered a complex commercial dispute involving an exceptional number of claims and issues, spanning over several years. The plaintiff sought damages exceeding $50 billion, and the defendants were one of Australia's largest banks. The case management difficulties were unprecedented, with numerous interlocutory motions, over 50 judgments, and a final hearing that had already continued for 18 months. The defendants had also applied for security for costs, which the plaintiff failed to provide, leading to an automatic stay of proceedings.

The legal issues before the court included the exercise of discretion to adjourn the final hearing, the administration of justice, and the principles governing case management. The court needed to balance the case management considerations with the administration of justice, ensuring that a less affluent litigant had a reasonable opportunity to secure funds to continue enforcing their claimed rights against a wealthier party. The court also had to consider whether there had been a material change of circumstances to justify varying or staying interlocutory orders.

The court exercised its discretion to adjourn the final hearing, taking into account the substantial case management difficulties and the failure of the plaintiff to comply with orders to provide security for costs. The court emphasised that while case management was important, the ultimate aim of the court was the attainment of justice. The court found that the plaintiff's failure to comply with the security for costs orders had prejudiced the defendants and that the administration of justice required the plaintiff to secure funds to continue the litigation. The court concluded that the plaintiff's failure to provide security for costs and the resulting automatic stay of proceedings constituted a material change of circumstances, warranting the adjournment of the final hearing.

The court ordered the final hearing to be adjourned, allowing the plaintiff an opportunity to secure funds to continue the litigation. The court emphasised that the adjournment was not intended to shut the plaintiff out from litigating their arguable case but to ensure the efficient administration of justice. The court also ordered that the plaintiff provide a detailed budget and funding plan within a specified timeframe to enable the final hearing to proceed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At the end of the day the salient consideration as in the case of many other instances of the exercise of a discretion, comes down to the requirements of justice in the particular circumstances of the particular case. As will appear from the reasons which follow, there are a large number of reasons why the current litigation clearly occupies a position at an extreme end of the continuum of conventional litigation. That having been said it is necessary to return to the detail.Background facts The defendants have helpfully provided a chronology in the following form: The judgment in relation to the security for costs motions ([2001] NSWSC 744) sets out a number of further background facts and funding details. The reasons extend to an examination of certain parameters of the proceedings. For obvious reasons it is unnecessary to presently repeat the reasoning to be found in that judgment. The plaintiff has usefully collated excerpts from a number of interlocutory judgments where the size and scope of the proceedings was referred to and where certain parameters of significance were outlined. Notwithstanding that these excerpts overlap from time to time it seems convenient to set them out in order to deal with the motions presently before the court, if only, to emphasise:(1)that the size and scope of the proceedings has been exceptional and that the extent of them is quite possibly unparalleled in a commercial case in this country; and(2)that a number of aspects of the proceedings, as well as matters outside of the proceedings, could not have reasonably been anticipated and on my findings were not anticipated, by the plaintiff or by the defendants. I proceed to set out these excerpts from previous Judgments:(a) Judgment [2001] NSWSC 868 (5 October 2001):“3.The plaintiffs claim damages from the defendants in excess of $50 billion. The general nature of the proceedings was outlined in an interlocutory judgment [(1999) NSWSC 828] delivered on 19 August 1999. Since that date there have been numerous contested motions and contested directions hearings. The pleadings have also moved on in terms of a number of further issues being raised and further particulars being furnished. More than 50 judgments have been delivered in relation to the proceedings; many of them delivered following the commencement of the final hearing. The general state of the matter as at mid-April 2000 was set out in a judgment dealing with a contested application relating to use of the Technology Court ([2000) 49 NSWLR 51). The most recent judgment on the defendants’ applications for security for costs ([2001] NSWSC 744) delivered on 13 September 2001 gives further substantial detail updating the state of the matter as at that date. . . .9In the course of previous published judgments I have had occasion to make the point that this litigation is in my view particularly difficult for the curial process. The essential difficulty which is encountered is readily revealed when one bears in mind that the proceedings concern claims by the plaintiffs which: (a) if successful, were (during the opening) said to exceed the capitalisation of the National Australia Bank; and (b)encapsulate a number of proceedings covering a plethora of factual and legal issues - and as to the damages claims, embrace a global investigation of e-commerce markets and technology. Moreover the number of witnesses and witness statements filed by both parties in the proceedings can only be regarded as extraordinary…63.There is no doubt that there are significant case management difficulties in relation to the present stage of the proceedings. It is now a matter of documented history that there have been significant case management difficulties at every stage of the period starting from the interlocutory receivership injunctive proceedings heard and determined in mid 1999 up until the commencement of the final hearing in late July 2000 and ever since. Further, there is no doubt that the proceedings are of a “one off” nature; and this has been the subject of observations in past interlocutory judgments (most recently the [2001] NSWSC 744 judgment dealing with the security for costs applications). It cannot be gainsaid that the capacity of the curial process to deal with the scale of these proceedings is stretched to the limit. Moreover, further factors to be considered in relation to the case management of the proceedings concern the respective positions of each of the parties to the proceedings. The position of the plaintiffs and the pressing significance and urgency attaching to the proceedings, was generally outlined in the interlocutory judgment [1999] NSWSC 828, where reference was made in paragraph 355 to "JMG's" claims of an ongoing and radical undermining of its contractual rights". The position of the defendants is that a very substantial verdict against the National Australia Bank which is probably the largest bank and one of the largest corporations in this country, would potentially have a marked effect upon the value of shares held by numerous shareholders and a potential flow on effect upon the economy of this country.”(b) Judgment [2001] NSWSC 744 (13 September 2001):“83.The nature of the proceedings and the approach taken by each of the parties to the proceedings from their commencement has always made it crystal clear that the duration of the final hearing would be very extended indeed. Whilst the precise ambit of the plaintiffs’ claims to damages may be said to have moved over time arguably from $20 billion to in excess of $50 billion, there was never any shadow of a doubt but that the defendants would defend the claim to the hilt and would do so in a careful and considered way using every resource available in that regard. It is not surprising that the defendants have retained one of Australia's largest law firms and built up a considerable legal team made up of many counsel and solicitors, no doubt backed by the National Australia Bank in every way possible. Previous judgments have described the defendants as mobilising massive legal resources in relation to the litigation. It is not surprising that the defendants would have carefully investigated any possible cross-claims and in due course determined to pursue the first cross-claim. It is not surprising that the defendants would have gone about investigation of the factual issues in the most meticulous fashion and would then have filed statements from their many witnesses. Mr Lovell’s evidence was that in round terms the defendants had paid between $20 million and $30 million to legal advisers between September 1998 and 3 October 2000 and a further $10 million to $15 million since 3 October 2000. Costs were running at between $1 million and $11/2 million per month possibly excluding GST. ...92The statistics with respect to the statements were nothing short of staggering. On the defendants’ side of the record, there are currently 177 statements [see the table Appendix “B” to this judgment]. . . .95In relation to the plaintiffs’ statements, the evidence was that the plaintiffs have filed and/or served 104 statements from 39 witnesses namely:

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Whilst the discretion is an unfettered one, a number of considerations have commonly been considered to be relevant including:(a) case management considerations;(b) prejudice to the parties; and(c)whether any prejudice caused by an adjournment is able to be compensated by costs.(a) Case management considerations Tamberlin J in Searle v Keayes 21/11/1994, Fed Ct (NSW) NG309/94 emphasised that one “important” consideration was that litigation must be resolved and must not be the subject of continuous re-opening and prolongation. Brennan, Deane and Mc Hugh JJ in Sali v SPC (1993) 116 ALR 625 put the matter as follows:“The contemporary approach to court administration has introduced another element into the equation or, more accurately, has put another consideration onto the scales. The view that the conduct of litigation is not merely a matter for the parties but is also one for the court and the need to avoid disruptions in the court’s lists with consequent inconvenience to the court and prejudice to the interests of other litigants waiting to be heard are pressing concerns to which a court may have regard….Unless we are to mouth the repeated cautions about discretionary judgments, case management, efficiency, practice and procedure, and the advantages of the managing judge, only to ignore them when it comes to the crunch, this appeal must be dismissed.”See also Squire v Rogers (1979) 39 FLR 106. However, in allowing an appeal against the trial judge’s refusal to allow a series of amendments to the defence, the majority of the High Court in Queensland v JL Holdings 189 CLR 146 at 154 referred to these passages in Sali and stated:“…nothing in that case suggests that those principles might be employed, except perhaps in extreme circumstances, to shut a party out from litigating an issue which is fairly arguable. Case management is not an end it itself. It is an important and useful aid for ensuring the prompt and efficient disposal of litigation. But it ought always to be borne in mind, even in changing times, that the ultimate aim of a court is the attainment of justice and no principle of case management can be allowed to supplant that aim.” [emphasis added] Kirby P in Sydney City Council v Ke-Su Investments Pty Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 246 in his dissenting judgment at 252 made the following observations:“True it is, the court maintains control of its own list. True also, the court will not permit its process to be misused by the parties. That is one reason why the court’s practice is not to make orders standing appeals over generally or indefinitely. Courts are frequently held responsible in the public eye, for delays in litigation when the fault of delay is the decision of the parties. That is a reason for courts, including this Court to maintain a close superintendence of their docket.” King CJ in Dawson v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [1984] 71 FLR 364 at 366 put the matter as follows:“The District Court, like the other courts of the State, is subject to great pressure from the volume of cases to be tried. The judges of that Court, like the judges and magistrates of the other courts, have a responsibility to ensure, as far as possible and subject to the overriding considerations of justice, that the limited resources which the State commits to the administration of justice are not wasted by failure of parties to adhere to trial dates of which they have had proper notice. Moreover, the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, like other plaintiffs, is entitled to have his claim adjudicated upon and enforced without unnecessary delay.”