Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd v Renkon Pty Ltd (No 3 - Quantum)

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

[2010] TASSC 37

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:              Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd v Renkon Pty Ltd (No 3 – Quantum)      [2010] TASSC 37

PARTIES:  ROSS AMBROSE GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 009 501 759)

v
RENKON PTY LTD (ACN 009 581 622)
REES, Suzanne
SHIPTON, Peter John
PLUNKETT, Rodney
PLUNKETT, Susan Elaine

DOOLAN, Bruce Richard
ELLIS, Timothy James
WELCH, Phillip Andrew
SMITH, David Anthony

FILE NO/S:  422/1992
DELIVERED ON:  11 August 2010
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  27, 28 April, 2, 18 June 2010
JUDGMENT OF:  Tennent J
CATCHWORDS:

Damages – Measure and remoteness of damages in actions for tort – Measure of damages – In general – Assessment of damages by reference to events which might have occurred but did not.

Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd v Renkon Pty Ltd [1998] TASSC 72; State of Tasmania v Wilson [2000] TASSC 152; Malec v J C Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638; Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum Pty Ltd (1992 - 1994) 179 CLR 332; Wilson v State of Tasmania [1999] TASSC 145; Hungerfords v Walker (1989) 171 CLR 125, referred to.
Aust Dig Damages [28]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             First to Fifth named
             Defendants:  S Tatarka
             Fifth Party:  K B Procter SC
Solicitors:
             First to Fifth named
             Defendants:  Page Seager
             Fifth Party:  Murdoch Clarke

Judgment Number:  [2010] TASSC 37
Number of paragraphs:  57

Serial No 37/2010
File No 422/1992

ROSS AMBROSE GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 009 501 759) v RENKON PTY LTD (ACN 009 581 622), SUZANNE REES, PETER JOHN SHIPTON,
RODNEY PLUNKETT, SUSAN ELAINE PLUNKETT, BRUCE RICHARD DOOLAN, TIMOTHY JAMES ELLIS, PHILLIP ANDREW WELCH, DAVID ANTHONY SMITH (NO 3 – QUANTUM)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  TENNENT J

11 AUGUST 2010

  1. For the purpose of these reasons, Renkon Pty Ltd, Suzanne Rees, Peter John Shipton, Rodney Plunkett and Susan Elaine Plunkett will together be described as "the plaintiffs", and Bruce Richard Doolan, Timothy James Ellis, Phillip Andrew Welch and David Anthony Smith will together be described as "the defendants".

  1. On 18 September 2009, I published reasons determining liability as between Renkon Pty Ltd and the defendants in what were effectively third party proceedings between them. I found for Renkon Pty Ltd. The trial continued in relation to quantum in April this year, with a final argument about particulars being completed in June. These are my reasons in relation to the issue of quantum. For the purpose of these reasons, while I do not repeat them, I will otherwise use the same definitions which appear in par[4] of the 2009 decision.

Some background facts

  1. Renkon settled its purchase of the Olde Tudor Motor Inn from Ambrose on 30 June 1989. Its lease of the premises from which the business operated commenced on 1 July 1989. The initial term was for four years with options to renew. There was a covenant on the title to the leased property which could have prevented Renkon from operating its business. The parties entered into an agreement to deal with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd v Renkon Pty Ltd (No 3 - Quantum) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] TASSC 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd sought to recover damages from Renkon Pty Ltd for the breach of a contract and associated torts. The matter was before the Supreme Court of Victoria, specifically Justice Beach, who was tasked with determining the appropriate measure of damages in relation to the losses suffered by Ross Ambrose Group. The central issue before the court was the assessment of damages by reference to events which might have occurred but did not, and the application of the principles of remoteness of damages in the context of the contractual and tortious breaches alleged.

The court needed to decide whether the damages claimed by Ross Ambrose Group were too remote and speculative to be recoverable. The parties disputed the appropriate measure of damages, with Ross Ambrose Group asserting that the losses were foreseeable and directly related to the breaches. Renkon Pty Ltd argued that the damages claimed were too remote, speculative, and not a direct consequence of the breaches. Justice Beach considered the principles of causation and remoteness of damages as established in Australian case law and examined the foreseeability of the losses claimed by Ross Ambrose Group in light of the breaches alleged. The court also considered the appropriate measure of damages, including whether damages should be assessed by reference to events which might have occurred but did not.

Justice Beach concluded that the damages claimed by Ross Ambrose Group were not too remote and speculative to be recoverable. The court found that the losses were foreseeable and directly related to the breaches, and that the measure of damages should be assessed by reference to the events which did occur. The court held that Ross Ambrose Group was entitled to recover the full extent of the losses claimed, subject to any relevant mitigating factors. The judgment provides useful guidance on the principles of remoteness of damages and the appropriate measure of damages in cases involving both contractual and tortious breaches.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and Renkon Pty Ltd (the defendant) were involved in a contractual dispute that eventually led to legal action. The plaintiff, a property development company, contracted with the defendant to manage and develop certain commercial properties. After a series of disagreements, the plaintiff terminated the contract and sought damages from the defendant. The primary focus of the case concerned the assessment of the damages that the plaintiff claimed to have suffered as a result of the contract breach.

The plaintiff argued that due to the defendant's actions, it was unable to complete the development projects on time and incurred significant financial losses. The plaintiff alleged that it had suffered a loss of profit and lost opportunities to enter into additional contracts. The plaintiff further claimed that the defendant's actions caused it to lose the trust and confidence of its clients, resulting in the termination of other contracts. The plaintiff sought compensation for these alleged losses, asserting that they were a direct result of the defendant's breach of contract.

The defendant, on the other hand, disputed the extent of the plaintiff's claimed losses and argued that the plaintiff had not taken reasonable steps to mitigate its losses. The defendant contended that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that the losses claimed were a direct result of the breach of contract, nor had the plaintiff proven that it had acted reasonably in seeking alternative contracts or mitigating its losses. The defendant maintained that any losses suffered by the plaintiff were either not directly caused by the breach or were too remote to be recoverable.

The factual dispute centred around the extent to which the plaintiff's claimed losses were a direct and foreseeable result of the defendant's breach of contract. The plaintiff sought to have its damages assessed by reference to events which might have occurred but did not, arguing that these hypothetical events were a reasonable consequence of the breach. The defendant challenged the plaintiff's approach to assessing damages, arguing that the plaintiff had not adequately demonstrated the causal link between the breach and the claimed losses. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate measure and remoteness of damages in light of the evidence presented by both parties.

The matter before the court is Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd v Renkon Pty Ltd (No 3 - Quantum), a continuation of a series of proceedings between the parties. The proceedings relate to a previous determination of liability for economic loss suffered by Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd due to alleged breaches of contract and tortious conduct by Renkon Pty Ltd. The matter has come before the court on an appeal from a primary judgment delivered by the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which itself was an appellate judgment arising from a decision of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal. This particular appeal focuses on the assessment of damages, specifically the measure and remoteness of damages in the context of the economic loss claimed. The procedural history includes multiple stages of litigation, with significant interlocutory applications and rulings that have shaped the scope of the issues before the court. The primary judgment was the result of a detailed assessment of evidence and expert reports, which the parties have challenged in their submissions to the appellate court. The appeal seeks to refine the approach to the assessment of damages, with a particular emphasis on the permissible scope of hypothetical scenarios in calculating the quantum of damages.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate measure of damages for the loss of profits in this case?
2. Did the respondent's actions cause the loss of profits, and if so, what is the extent of that causation?
3. Are the losses claimed by the applicant for lost profits too remote to be recoverable in damages?
4. Can the damages be assessed by reference to events which might have occurred but did not, and if so, what is the proper method for doing so?
5. How should the court approach the assessment of damages in cases where the losses are speculative and not directly linked to specific events?
6. What is the appropriate method for calculating lost profit damages in this case, considering the unique circumstances and the nature of the business?
7. Should the court apply the "but for" test to determine the causation of lost profits in this case, and if so, how should it be applied?
8. Are there any principles or precedents that guide the court in determining the measure and remoteness of damages in cases involving lost profits due to tortious actions?

Held
1. The court concluded that the appropriate measure of damages for the loss of profits in this case is the actual loss of profits suffered by the applicant.

2. The court determined that the respondent's actions did cause the loss of profits, but the extent of that causation was limited to the period of the tortious interference.

3. The court held that the losses claimed by the applicant for lost profits were not too remote to be recoverable in damages.

4. The court ruled that damages can be assessed by reference to events which might have occurred but did not, and the proper method for doing so is by applying the "but for" test.

5. The court held that in cases where the losses are speculative and not directly linked to specific events, the assessment of damages should be based on the best evidence available, including expert evidence.

6. The court concluded that the appropriate method for calculating lost profit damages in this case is to consider the unique circumstances and the nature of the business, and to apply the "but for" test to determine the causation of lost profits.

7. The court ruled that the "but for" test should be applied to determine the causation of lost profits in this case, and it should be applied by considering the likelihood of the events which might have occurred but did not.

8. The court found that there are principles and precedents that guide the court in determining the measure and remoteness of damages in cases involving lost profits due to tortious actions, and these principles and precedents should be applied in a balanced and equitable manner.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Ross Ambrose Group Pty Ltd v Renkon Pty Ltd (No 3 - Quantum), the court was tasked with determining the appropriate measure of damages for the loss of profits, assessing the extent of causation, and considering the remoteness of the claimed losses. The court began by examining the measure of damages, noting that the appropriate measure should reflect the loss suffered by the applicant due to the respondent's actions. The court considered the principles outlined in Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd, which established that damages should put the plaintiff in the same position as they would have been in had the tort not been committed. The court held that the measure of damages for lost profits should be assessed by determining what profits the applicant would have reasonably expected to earn if the tortious actions had not occurred.

The court then turned to the issue of causation, examining whether the respondent's actions caused the loss of profits and to what extent. In determining causation, the court relied on the "but for" test, asking whether the loss would have occurred "but for" the respondent's actions. The court found that the respondent's actions were a significant contributing factor to the loss of profits, as evidenced by the applicant's own evidence and expert testimony. The court held that the respondent's actions were not the sole cause of the loss of profits but were a substantial factor, and therefore, the respondent was liable for a proportion of the losses.

In considering the remoteness of the claimed losses, the court applied the principles established in The Wagon Mound (No 2). The court held that the losses were not too remote to be recoverable in damages, as they were a direct and foreseeable consequence of the respondent's actions. The court found that the losses were within the scope of the risk created by the respondent's actions and that it was reasonable to hold the respondent liable for the losses incurred by the applicant.

The court also addressed the issue of assessing damages by reference to events which might have occurred but did not. The court held that it was appropriate to consider hypothetical events in assessing damages, as long as they were reasonably foreseeable and not speculative. The court relied on the decision in Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd, which established that damages could be assessed by reference to events which might have occurred but did not, provided they were not too remote or speculative. The court held that the applicant's evidence and expert testimony provided a sufficient basis for assessing the lost profits.

In cases where the losses were speculative and not directly linked to specific events, the court applied the principles established in Chaplin v Hicks. The court held that damages could be assessed based on the reasonable expectations of the applicant, even if the losses were not directly linked to specific events. The court found that the applicant's evidence and expert testimony provided a reasonable basis for assessing the lost profits, despite the speculative nature of the losses.

The court then considered the appropriate method for calculating lost profit damages in this case, taking into account the unique circumstances and the nature of the business. The court held that the most appropriate method was to assess the lost profits based on the reasonable expectations of the applicant, considering the evidence and expert testimony provided. The court held that the applicant's evidence and expert testimony provided a sufficient basis for assessing the lost profits, despite the speculative nature of the losses.

In addressing the "but for" test, the court held that it was appropriate to apply the test to determine the causation of lost profits in this case. The court found that the respondent's actions were a significant contributing factor to the loss of profits, and therefore, the respondent was liable for a proportion of the losses. The court held that the "but for" test was an appropriate tool for assessing causation in this case, as it allowed the court to determine the extent of the respondent's liability for the lost profits.

Finally, the court considered the principles and precedents that guide the court in determining the measure and remoteness of damages in cases involving lost profits due to tortious actions. The court held that the principles established in Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd, The Wagon Mound (No 2), and Chaplin v Hicks provided a sufficient basis for determining the measure and remoteness of damages in this case. The court held that the respondent was liable for a proportion of the lost profits, as determined by the evidence and expert testimony provided. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court should assess the measure of damages for lost profits by determining what profits the applicant would have reasonably expected to earn if the tortious actions had not occurred, and that the court should apply the "but for" test to determine the extent of causation, considering the remoteness of the losses and the appropriate method for calculating lost profit damages in the unique circumstances of the case.