Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 30)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 30) [2022] FCA 266

File numbers: NSD 1485 of 2018
NSD 1486 of 2018
NSD 1487 of 2018
Judgment of: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 23 March 2022
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — Interlocutory application by respondents for leave to issue Subpoena to give evidence to person known as Person 56 (respondents’ application) — where time within which respondents were to file and serve outlines of evidence fixed for 31 May 2019 — where no outline of evidence of Person 56 served at that time — where previous application issued by respondents and dated 15 March 2021, for leave to issue Subpoena to Person 56, refused including on basis that respondents unable to obtain outline of evidence of Person 56 — where trial adjourned in August 2021 due to COVID-19 pandemic — where respondents’ solicitor swore affidavit on respondents’ application deposing as a result of developments in trial up to that point, respondents decided to make further attempt to speak with Person 56 — email dated 1 September 2021 from respondents’ solicitors to counsel for Person 56 recording proffering of undertaking that if Person 56 agreed to speak with respondents with respect to mission to Darwan in September 2012, respondents would not make any submission at trial that Person 56 be required to give evidence with respect to mission to Fasil in November 2012 should Person 56 take objection to giving evidence under s 128 of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) — where Particulars of Truth contained in respondents’ Second Further Amended Defence include allegation that applicant executed Afghan adolescent during mission to Fasil — where evidence tendered on respondents’ application included internal memorandum of respondents’ solicitors recording understanding that Person 56 involved in alleged execution — where respondents received signed statement of Person 56 in October 2021, containing matters relating to mission to Darwan — whether provision of statement constitutes material change in circumstances to those pertaining at time 15 March 2021 application refused — whether arrangement between respondents and Person 56 and circumstances of disclosure of arrangement reason to refuse application — consideration of asserted prejudice to applicant of Subpoena being issued — whether applicant prejudiced by inability to cross-examine Afghan witnesses on matters contained in statement of Person 56 — leave to issue Subpoena granted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — Interlocutory application by Person 56 under r 24.15 of Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) to set aside Subpoena to give evidence on ground that Subpoena oppressive or abuse of process — where Person 56’s solicitor affirmed affidavit exhibiting report of treating psychologist outlining negative impact on Person 56’s mental health of giving evidence at trial — consideration of legal test for setting aside Subpoena on mental health grounds — whether Person 56 mentally incapable of giving evidence at trial without unacceptable risk of serious mental harm, having regard to psychological evidence — application dismissed

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 128

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 3... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 30) involved an interlocutory application by the respondents seeking leave to issue a subpoena to a person known as Person 56. The respondents sought to adduce evidence from Person 56 regarding an alleged unlawful killing of an Afghan male named Ali Jan during a mission to Darwan in September 2012. The application raised legal issues concerning the provision of a material change in circumstances since a previous application was refused, the enforceability of an undertaking given to Person 56, and the mental health impact on Person 56 of giving evidence.

The court found that the provision of a signed statement by Person 56, containing matters relating to the mission to Darwan, constituted a material change in circumstances. The court noted that the respondents had made efforts to contact Person 56 and had provided an undertaking that they would not require Person 56 to give evidence concerning a separate mission if Person 56 agreed to speak with them regarding the mission to Darwan. The court also considered the impact on the applicant if the subpoena was issued but found that the applicant would not be prejudiced by the inability to cross-examine Afghan witnesses on matters contained in Person 56's statement.

The court granted leave to issue the subpoena to Person 56 and refused Person 56's application to set aside the subpoena on the ground that it was oppressive or an abuse of process. The court concluded that while giving evidence may adversely affect Person 56's mental health and potentially undermine his therapeutic intervention program, these factors did not constitute a sufficient basis to set aside the subpoena under the relevant test.

ORDERS:
1. The respondents be granted leave to issue a Subpoena to give evidence to Person 56.
2. Person 56’s application to set aside the Subpoena to give evidence be refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondents be granted leave to issue a Subpoena to give evidence to Person 56.

2. Person 56’s application to set aside the Subpoena to give evidence be refused.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Person 56 applied for a non-disclosure order with respect to certain matters in the report relating to his mental health. I made an order at the hearing pursuant to s 37AH of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) as follows:5.… there be no disclosure until further order of the three primary health conditions of Person 56, the date of onset of Person 56’s primary health conditions and the nature of the treatment of Person 56 at the direction of Ms Mitchell. This order is made having regard to the necessity to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice.The information which is relevant to Person 56’s application and which is the subject of the non-disclosure order is set out in a Confidential Annexure to these reasons.Evidence of Person 56 as set out in the Statement of Person 56 The starting point is the evidence the respondents propose to adduce from Person 56 as set out in his statement which is signed by him and dated 26 October 2021. The statement deals with a mission to an Afghan village named Darwan on 11 September 2012. Before going to the statement, it is necessary to explain the context of the matters in the statement by reference to the respondents’ pleaded allegations. The following is a summary of the key allegations. In the Second Further Amended Defence filed on 24 June 2021, the respondents’ Particulars of Truth in relation to the mission to Darwan are set out in paragraphs 93 to 117. The basic allegation is that the applicant and a number of soldiers, including members of the applicant’s patrol, were clearing compounds at the south-eastern end of the village. In one compound, they located and detained three fighting aged males. The detention of these males rendered each of them hors de combat. One of the males was an Afghan male named Ali Jan. The other two were Mohammed Hanifa Fatih and Mangul Rahmi. The three Afghan men, including Ali Jan, were handcuffed and questioned. The applicant questioned Ali Jan and Mohammed Hanifa. Towards the end of the interrogation, the applicant moved Ali Jan, who was still handcuffed, to outside the compound. He caused Ali Jan to be placed at the edge of a rocky cliff which was greater than 10 metres high and forced him into a kneeling position. The applicant then took a number of steps back before he moved towards Ali Jan and kicked him hard in the midriff/abdomen causing him to fall back over the cliff and land in the dry creek bed below. Ali Jan fell the full height of the cliff down to the creek bed. He was moved by two soldiers to the other side of the creek bed where there was vegetation. After he had been moved to that location, Ali Jan was shot multiple times in the presence of the applicant and Person 11. The respondents allege that the shots were fired by either the applicant or Person 11 (a soldier under the applicant’s command) or alternatively, by both the applicant and Person 11. The respondents allege that the shooting of Ali Jan was the result of an understanding or arrangement, amounting to an agreement between the applicant and Person 11 to ensure that Ali Jan was dead following the cliff kick. The respondents allege that the shooting of Ali Jan was carried out pursuant to a joint criminal enterprise, being the understanding or arrangement amounting to an agreement between the applicant and Person 11 to kill Ali Jan. In paragraph 110(a) of the Particulars of Truth, the respondents allege that the applicant and Person 4, Person 11 and Person 56 covered up the unlawful killing of Ali Jan by falsely alleging that Ali Jan was a “spotter”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Person 56 appears able to give relevant evidence in this case. As I have said, I accept that giving evidence gives rise to a risk that Person 56’s mental health may be adversely affected and a risk that his therapeutic intervention program or treatment may be undermined. However, those matters, having regard to the relevant test, do not constitute a sufficient basis to set aside the Subpoena to give evidence.Conclusions I grant leave to issue a Subpoena to give evidence to Person 56. I refuse Person 56’s application to set aside the Subpoena.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established