Scott v Equatorial Launch Australia Pty Ltd (Application to Set Aside Subpoena)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Scott v Equatorial Launch Australia Pty Ltd (Application to Set Aside Subpoena) [2025] FCA 109

File number(s): VID 417 of 2022
Judgment of: DOWLING J
Date of judgment: 20 February 2025
Date of publication of reasons: 21 February 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Interlocutory application by witness to set aside subpoena to give evidence on ground that witness is mentally incapable of giving evidence – consideration of legal test for setting aside subpoena on mental health grounds – test established in R v Nona applied – satisfied witness mentally incapable of giving evidence without an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm and it is not reasonably practicable to overcome that incapability.
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 63, 65 and cl 4(1)(c) of the Dictionary

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 24.15

Cases cited:

Alzawy v Coptic Orthodox Church Diocese of Sydney, St Mary and St Merkorious Church [2016] NSWSC 1122

R v Nona [2015] ACTSC 175; (2015) 254 A Crim R 301

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 30) [2022] FCA 266

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 33
Date of hearing: 20 February 2025
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms S Kelly and Mr D Murphy
Solicitors for the Applicant:  Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the Respondent:  Mr S Freire and Ms L Brown
Solicitors for the Respondent: Piper Alderman
Counsel for the witness:  Mr J Widjaja
Solicitors for the witness: Phoenix Law

ORDERS

VID 417 of 2022
BETWEEN:

CARLEY SCOTT
Applicant

AND: EQUATORIAL LAUNCH AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

DOWLING J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 FEBRUARY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The subpoena to give evidence addressed to the witness returnable on 17 February 2025 is set aside.

2.Costs reserved.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

DOWLING J:

  1. This is an application brought by a witness to set aside a subpoena to give evidence issued at the request of the applicant. The hearing in which the witness is to give evidence commenced on 17 February 2025 and they are presently scheduled to give evidence on 21 February 2025. The witness says the subpoena should be set aside because they are unable to give evidence as the result of their mental health. I have chosen not to name the witness because the judgment contains detail about their mental health.

  2. The hearing concerns claims made by the applicant, Ms Scott, for monies owed under a “Commitment Amount Contract” or contract of employment, arising from Ms Scott’s employment as Chief Executive Officer of the respondent, Equatorial Launch Australia Pty Ltd (ELA). Those contracts are said to have been negotiated or varied by agreement between Ms Scott and the witness.

  3. Ms Scott has filed two outlines of the evidence she anticipates will be given by the witness.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott v Equatorial Launch Australia Pty Ltd (Application to... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Scott v Equatorial Launch Australia Pty Ltd (Application to Set Aside Subpoena), the applicant sought to set aside a subpoena requiring the witness to give evidence on the basis that they were mentally incapable of doing so without suffering an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm. The respondent, Equatorial Launch Australia Pty Ltd, opposed the application. The court was required to determine whether the applicant had satisfied the legal test for setting aside a subpoena on mental health grounds, established in R v Nona.

The applicant submitted that the witness was suffering from severe mental health issues, including depression with anxious distress and panic disorder, which impaired their ability to give evidence. The applicant produced medical evidence to support this claim, including reports from the witness's psychiatrist and psychologist. The court considered the applicable test, which requires satisfaction, on the balance of probabilities, that the witness is mentally incapable of giving evidence without an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm, and it is not reasonably practicable to overcome that incapability. The court found that the applicant had satisfied this test, and that the witness was indeed mentally incapable of giving evidence without an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm. The court also found that there was no reasonable method of overcoming the witness's incapability.

Accordingly, the court set aside the subpoena to give evidence and reserved costs. The court noted that the witness's mental health issues were ongoing and that there was no indication that they would improve in the near future. The court also noted that the witness's participation in the legal proceedings had exacerbated their mental health issues, and that this was a significant factor in their incapability to give evidence. The court emphasised the importance of protecting the mental health and well-being of witnesses in legal proceedings, and recognised the need for flexibility and sensitivity in dealing with such issues.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The subpoena to give evidence addressed to the witness returnable on 17 February 2025 is set aside.

2. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I have approached a consideration of the evidence in accordance with those principles. Accordingly, the test requires satisfaction, on the balance of probabilities, that the witness is mentally incapable of giving evidence without an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm, and it is not reasonably practicable to overcome that incapability. The witness and Ms Scott submit the test is satisfied. ELA submits that it is not.THE EVIDENCEThe first affidavit of Ms Sultan and Report of Dr Blanch dated 7 February 2025 The first affidavit of Ms Sultan dated 11 February 2025 states that the witness was an inpatient at a Private Mental Health Hospital from 10 January 2025 until 7 February 2025. It states that the witness was experiencing severe ongoing mental health issues. The affidavit annexed a report of Dr Blanch dated 7 February 2025, the witness’ treating psychiatrist. Dr Blanch stated that:(a)The witness is currently suffering from “Depression with Anxious distress (DSM 5 Criteria) and Panic Disorder (DSM 5 Criteria)”;(b)The witness’ medical conditions would “impair [their] ability to engage as a physical witness in court”;(c)The witness “appearing in court would likely induce a panic attack and in that state [they] would not be able to provide evidence nor manage [their] emotional state”; (d)The witness “would require medical review given the possibility of stress inducing a myocardial infarction”; and (e)The witness’ “mental health would be seriously impacted and [their] depressive symptoms would be exacerbated by being compelled to give evidence whilst physically being in court.” The second affidavit of Ms Sultan dated 12 February 2025 The second affidavit of Ms Sultan dated 12 February 2025 provided an update that the witness was to be readmitted to the Private Mental Health Hospital on 17 February 2025. The second report of Dr Blanch dated 18 February 2025 The third affidavit of Ms Sultan dated 19 February 2025 annexed a further report of Dr Blanch and a report of Psychologist Ms Ahu Kocak. In Dr Blanch’s further report he states:(a)The witness was readmitted to the Private Mental Health Hospital for a relapse of their depression with anxious distress and panic disorder;(b)“The witness’ condition continues to be quite severe and disabling and [they] has been unable to manage in the period [they were] not in hospital”;(c)He expected the witness to remain admitted until mid-March;(d)He does not “believe that [the witness] can effectively participate in court proceedings either in person or remotely” and the witness “would likely suffer panic attacks if required to do so” and that the witness would be unable to “respond to any questions or directions being made in court” or communicate during these panic attacks and these panic attacks require several days to recover from;(e)The witness’ panic attacks “are associated with experiences of central crushing chest pain, breathlessness and depersonalization. [They] has had required past cardiac artery stenting and any episode of chest pain requires medical review to exclude any potential infarct”; and(f)he does not believe the witness’ position will improve to participate in court proceedings for the duration of the scheduled hearing. The report of Ms Ahu Kocak dated 18 February 2025

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Kocak was asked to provide recommendations, if any, to minimise any risk to the witness arising from their mental health conditions should they give evidence. Ms Kocak stated the optimal outcome would be for the witness not to give evidence, but that if the witness is required to give evidence the following arrangements should be put in place:(i)Ensure medications are optimised;(ii)Provide access to a therapist or counsellor before and after evidence; (iii)Allow the witness to testify in a less formal setting such as by video link; (iv)Allow frequent breaks;(v)Allow a support person to accompany them during the evidence;(vi)Ensure that alcohol consumption is addressed before giving evidence; and(vii)Provide follow-up support after the evidence.CONSIDERATIONThe applicable test As expressed above, I am required to assess, on the balance of probabilities, whether the witness is mentally incapable of giving evidence without an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm, and whether there is any reasonable method of overcoming that incapability. Reconciling Ms Kocak and Dr Blanch’s report The witness’ counsel submitted that if there was any inconsistency between Dr Blanch’s report and Ms Kocak’s report, that Dr Blanch’s report should be preferred. That inconsistency was said to potentially arise because Ms Kocak set out accommodations that could be made if the witness was required to give evidence. Counsel for Ms Scott contended, and I accept, that the reports are not inconsistent. The effect of the evidence of Dr Blanch and Ms Kocak is that the witness is incapable of giving evidence without an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm. Ms Kocak’s statement about accommodations does not suggest that the witness is relevantly capable of giving evidence with those accommodations, rather it provides for accommodations should the witness be required to give evidence. In the context of her other conclusions that is not a conclusion that the witness is capable of giving evidence.Effect of the medical evidence I am satisfied on the medical evidence that the witness is mentally incapable of giving evidence without an unacceptable risk of serious mental harm. I am satisfied that that mental incapability and risk of serious mental harm is ongoing. Dr Blanch expects the witness to be in hospital until mid-March. I am satisfied that a reason for the incapability includes involvement in these legal proceedings. In those circumstances the incapability will remain, whilst the obligation to give evidence remains. I am satisfied that there is no reasonable method of overcoming the witness’ incapability. Dr Blanch and Ms Kocak do not identify any accommodation that would overcome the witness’ incapability. Dr Blanch expressly rules out the possibility that “remote” participation by the witness would overcome their incapability. For the reasons explained above Ms Kocak’s accommodations are not accommodations said to overcome the incapability. Press release