Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 40)

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 40) [2022] FCA 1614

File numbers: NSD 1485 of 2018
NSD 1486 of 2018
NSD 1487 of 2018
Judgment of: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 30 March 2022
Date of publication of reasons: 1 June 2023
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — claim for damages in three proceedings for defamation — imputation that the applicant murdered or was involved in the murders of Afghan males under control or containment during the war in Afghanistan — respondents (newspaper companies and journalists) rely on defences of justification (s 25 Defamation Act 2005 (NSW)) and contextual truth (s 26 Defamation Act 2005 (NSW)) — respondents subpoena soldiers said to be involved in the murders — soldiers claim privilege against self-incrimination under s 128 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) — whether reasonable grounds for objection — soldiers unwilling to give evidence even with the benefit of a certificate

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — consideration of whether the soldier witnesses should be required to give evidence under s 128(4) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) — consideration of whether Court satisfied that evidence does not tend to prove that a witness has committed an offence against or arising under a law of a foreign country — meaning of a “law of a foreign country” in s 128(4)(a) — relevance of risk of action being taken by International Criminal Court

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — consideration of factors relevant to “interests of justice” under s 128(4)(b) — proper and just determination of the proceeding — seriousness of the offence in respect of which privilege against self-incrimination claimed — interest of witness in the proceeding — forensic disadvantage to witness in being required to give evidence — possible incomplete protection of a certificate — risk of action being taken by International Criminal Court — relevance of effect on reputation of witness — effect on health of witness

Legislation:

Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) s 268.70

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 128, 129, 174

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37AF, 37AG

International Criminal Court Act 2002 (Cth) ss 7, 53, 69A

Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) ss 25, 26

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd (No 9) [2013] FCA 323; (2013) 212 FCR 406

Australian Workers’ Union v Registered Organisations Commissioner (No 7) [2019] FCA 195

Cureton v Blackshaw Services Pty Ltd [2002] NSWCA 187

Damberg v Damberg [2001] NSWCA 87; (2001) 52 NSWLR 492

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Shi [2021] HCA 22; (2021) 273 CLR 235

Lifetime Investments Pty Ltd v Commercial (Worldwide) Financial Services Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 696

Gedeon v The Queen [2013] NSWCCA 257; (2013) 280 FLR 275

Hamilton v Oades [1989] HCA 21; (1989) 166 CLR 486

In Marriage of Atkinson (1997) 136 FLR 347

Lee v The Queen [2014] HCA 20; (2014) 253 CLR 455

Mokbel v The Queen [2013] VSCA 118; (2013) 40 VR 625

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 4... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1614
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 40), the dispute involved a claim for damages in three defamation proceedings where the applicant, Ben Roberts-Smith, alleged defamatory imputations made by the respondents, newspaper companies and journalists, that he murdered or was involved in the murders of Afghan males during the war in Afghanistan. The respondents sought to rely on the defences of justification and contextual truth under the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW), necessitating the subpoena of soldiers who were alleged to be involved in the murders. These soldiers claimed privilege against self-incrimination under section 128 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), asserting that they would be unwilling to give evidence even with the benefit of a certificate.

The court was required to decide whether there were reasonable grounds for the soldiers' objection to giving evidence, particularly whether the evidence they could provide would tend to prove that they had committed an offence against or arising under a law of a foreign country, as per section 128(4)(a) of the Evidence Act. Additionally, the court needed to consider whether the interests of justice required the soldiers to give evidence under section 128(4)(b), taking into account factors such as the seriousness of the offence, the interest of the witnesses in the proceeding, any forensic disadvantage to the witnesses, and the potential impact on their reputation and health.

The court found that there were no reasonable grounds for Person 66 to object to giving evidence as he was not subject to the law of Afghanistan with respect to his deployment in 2012, and therefore, the evidence could not tend to prove he had committed an offence under a foreign law. However, concerning Person 4, the court decided that it was not in the interests of justice to require him to give evidence about the mission to W108. This decision was based on the serious nature of the offence, the availability of other evidence supporting the respondents' defences, and the potential risk of action by the International Criminal Court. Consequently, the court provided Person 4 with information under section 128(3) and he gave evidence willingly with the benefit of a certificate, except for questions about the mission to W108, to which he objected under section 128(1) of the Evidence Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I was satisfied that Person 66 was and is not subject to the law of Afghanistan with respect to his deployment in 2012, such that there is no relevant “law of a foreign country” for the purposes of s 128(4)(a) of the Evidence Act. As such, the evidence could not tend to prove that Person 66 has committed an offence against or arising under a law of a foreign country.Section 128(4)(b): the Court must be satisfied that the interests of justice require that the witness give the evidence I begin by identifying a number of general principles which are established by the authorities and which were not in dispute on the hearing of the application. It is a significant inroad on a fundamental common law right for a Court to require a witness who is unwilling to give incriminating evidence to give that evidence. The Court is not to do so unless it is satisfied that the interests of justice require that the witness give the evidence. It is well established by authority that the interests of justice is a broad concept (see, for example, Cureton v Blackshaw Services Pty Ltd [2002] NSWCA 187 at [37] per Sheller JA with whom Meagher and Beazley JJA agreed). The onus is on the party seeking to adduce the evidence to establish that the interests of justice require that the witness give the evidence (Gedeon at [285] per Bathurst CJ, with whom Beazley P, Hoeben CJ at CL, Blanch and Price JJ agreed, but see Shi at [89] per Edelman J). It is important to note that the text of s 128(4)(b) is not to the effect that the interests of justice is a relevant consideration in terms of the decision to be made or that the interests of justice must favour a particular course. The test is whether the interests of justice require that the witness give the evidence (emphasis added). This is a demanding test in a context where an affirmative answer will result in the abrogation of a fundamental common law right of a party or a witness. It is not sufficient that the evidence be relevant to the issues in the proceeding; the evidence must be relevant to a substantial degree or extent (Gedeon at [286] per Bathurst CJ). In assessing that matter, a related and relevant consideration is the availability of other evidence from other sources (Lifetime Investments Pty Ltd v Commercial (Worldwide) Financial Services Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 696 (Worldwide Investments) at [33] per Spender J; Australian Workers’ Union v Registered Organisations Commissioner (No 7) [2019] FCA 195 (Australian Workers’ Union v Registered Organisations Commissioner) at [26] per Bromberg J). In Kang-Kem v Paine [2003] NSWSC 916 (at [7]), Barrett J made the point that in the first instance at least, the interests of justice is to be approached by reference to the proper and just determination of the proceeding. That matter is no doubt an important consideration, but it is also necessary to keep in mind the importance of the interests of the witness and that it is his or her privilege which is abrogated if the Court decides to require the witness to give the evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A submission made by the applicant relevant to the interests of justice or the residual discretion is set out in [24] of the closed Court reasons. As I explain, I did not need to rule on the relevance of that matter.Conclusion It would appear that Person 66 is able to give relevant and probative evidence. Considered only through the lens of these proceedings and the parties to it, the interests of justice would strongly favour requiring Person 66 to give the evidence. Serious allegations are made and the Court is best served by having all available evidence before it. The respondents are likely to be the party disadvantaged if Person 66 is not required to give the evidence. However, the interests of justice is not only concerned with these proceedings and the parties to it. It includes the interests of the witness and the deviation from the accusatorial judicial process. This is occurring in a case where the offence is the most serious in the criminal calendar and where there is other evidence in support of the respondents’ defences of substantial truth and contextual truth. In the circumstances, I decided that it was not in the interests of justice to require Person 66 to give the evidence.Person 4 Person 4 raised an objection to giving evidence on certain matters relating to the mission to Darwan on the ground specified in s 128(1) of the Evidence Act. I decided that there were reasonable grounds for a number of these objections and provided the information in s 128(3) to Person 4. Person 4 gave the evidence willingly with the benefit of a certificate. When it came to questions about the mission to W108, Person 4 raised an objection to giving evidence on that particular matter under s 128(1) of the Evidence Act. The particular question to which he objected was as follows:… can you please tell me what you recall happened on a mission to a compound called Whisky 108 on or about Easter Sunday in 2009? The respondents had filed an outline of evidence of Person 4 in May 2019 and it included the following:6.On or about 12 April 2009, the Applicant, Person 4 and the troop of which they were a part conducted a mission around the village of Kakarak.7.The troop was instructed to assault a compound code-named Whiskey 108. Gothic 5, which was the patrol that both Person 4 and the Applicant were members of, was responsible for conducting the assault on Whiskey 108.8.Upon entering a compound, Person 4, Person 5 and the Applicant encountered two Afghan males in the compound. They observed that the compound had a significant cache and tunnel system, where rockets and small arms were being stored.9.Person 4 observed that the two Afghan males were not engaging in conduct and posed no risk.10.Person 4 observed the two Afghan males and discussed with Person 5 and the Applicant how to deal with the Afghan males.11.Person 5 directed Person 4 to execute one of the Afghan men. The Applicant was present when this directive was given.12.Person 4 removed the Afghan male to a nearby location, placed him on his knees and executed him.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established