Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 12)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 12) [2021] FCA 465

[Redacted pursuant to the orders made in these proceedings on 12 July 2021 under s 19(3A) of the National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004 (Cth)]

File numbers: NSD 1485 of 2018
NSD 1486 of 2018
NSD 1487 of 2018
Judgment of: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 23 April 2021
Date of publication of reasons: 6 May 2021
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — defamation proceedings — interlocutory application for leave to issue subpoenas to give evidence to twelve persons — where time for compliance with orders made for filing and serving outlines of evidence has expired — where respondents do not propose to file outlines of evidence with respect to nine of twelve persons — where respondents became aware that certain persons could give relevant evidence after receiving PAP Notice — where applicant has been aware of relevant evidence for some time — where respondents do not possess sufficient information to serve outline of evidence with respect to Person 56 — leave granted to issue subpoenas to five persons whose evidence relates to incident pleaded in existing defence — application refused with respect to Person 56 whose evidence relates to new incident, XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX and is not set out in an outline of evidence

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — defamation proceedings — interlocutory application for leave to amend defence to include additional truth particulars — where respondents did not know of information particularised in additional truth particulars prior to receipt of sensitive documents — where additional truth particulars allege two additional incidents — where the applicant contends that leave being granted would require applicant to reinterview certain persons and undertake a number of other pre-trial steps — where the respondents contend that a number of persons with relevant knowledge unlikely to cooperate; there is only a small number of witnesses to each new incident; the applicant’s response is simply that incidents did not occur; and there is public interest in matter being ventilated — consideration of the prospect of real and substantial prejudice to applicant in terms of his preparation for trial — leave to amend defence to include additional truth particulars refused

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — defamation proceedings — interlocutory application for leave to file and serve amended outline of evidence for Person 18 — where leave to amend would require applicant to reinterview certain persons — application refused insofar as it refers to incident raised in proposed additional truth particulars — application allowed insofar as it refers to incident raised in existing particulars of truth

Legislation:

Defence Act 1903 (Cth) ss 21, 22, 29, 124

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 135, 136

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37AI

National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004 (Cth) s 38B

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 24.01

Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Regulation 2016 (Cth) s 32

Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) ss 25, 26

Cases cited:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 1... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 465
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 12) involved an interlocutory application by Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (the respondents) in a defamation proceeding against Ben Roberts-Smith (the applicant). The respondents sought leave to issue subpoenas to twelve individuals, amend their defence to include additional truth particulars, and file an amended outline of evidence for one person. The dispute centred on the respondents' attempt to introduce new evidence and allegations after the original deadline for filing outlines of evidence had passed.

The legal issues before the court included whether the respondents were entitled to subpoena certain individuals to testify, whether the respondents could amend their defence to include new incidents and truth particulars, and whether the respondents could file an amended outline of evidence for one individual. The court had to balance the respondents' need to present their case with the applicant's rights and the potential prejudice caused by late amendments.

The court granted leave for the respondents to issue subpoenas to five individuals whose evidence related to incidents pleaded in the existing defence, but denied leave for Person 56 whose evidence pertained to a new incident not included in the existing defence. The court also refused leave to amend the defence to include additional truth particulars, finding that granting such leave would cause significant prejudice to the applicant's preparation for trial. Finally, the court allowed the respondents to file an amended outline of evidence for Person 18 but disallowed certain paragraphs due to their confidential nature.

The final orders of the court were that leave be granted to issue subpoenas to Persons 24, 40, 41, 42, and 43, but denied for Person 56; leave to amend the defence with additional truth particulars be refused; leave to file an amended outline of evidence for Person 18 be granted except for paragraphs 24–36; and the question of costs on the interlocutory application be reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondents be granted leave to issue a Subpoena to Give Evidence at the trial to each of the following Persons:

(a) Person 24;

(b) Person 40;

(c) Person 41;

(d) Person 42; and

(e) Person 43.

2. Leave to issue a Subpoena to Give Evidence to Person 56 be refused.

3. The respondents’ application to amend their Defence to include particulars in the document entitled “SECRET — confidential — Additional truth particulars” to be served in accordance with the s 38B Orders made on 5 March 2021 be refused.

4. The respondents be granted leave to serve the amended outline of evidence of Person 18 being Annexure “DLB-2” to the affidavit of Peter Llewellyn Bartlett sworn on 15 March 2021 save and except for paragraphs 24–36 inclusive.

5. The question of costs on the interlocutory application filed on 16 March 2021 be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For his part, the applicant relied on two affidavits of his solicitor, Mr Mark O’Brien, affirmed on 24 March 2021 and 1 April 2021 respectively. The evidence given by Mr O’Brien is summarised in the next section of these reasons.The Facts It is convenient to organise my statement of the facts by reference to the three orders sought by the respondents.Leave to issue Subpoenas to Give Evidence at the trial to Persons 24, 40, 41, 42, 43 and 56 On 13 February 2019, the Court made orders in relation to the filing and serving of outlines of evidence and those orders included an order that the respondents file and serve their outlines of evidence by 8 May 2019. On 22 May 2019, the parties agreed to a variation to the timetable to the effect that the respondents’ outlines of evidence were to be filed and served by 31 May 2019. On 17 December 2020, this Court made orders that the Inspector-General produce to the parties copies of the Sensitive IGADF Documents. On 18 December 2020, Mr Jeremy Forbes, a solicitor assisting Mr Bartlett, attended the offices of the Australian Government Solicitor in Sydney and collected copies of the Sensitive IGADF Documents. The Sensitive IGADF Documents comprise the PAP Notice given to the applicant and his response to that notice. The respondents’ case is that prior to the receipt of the Sensitive IGADF Documents, the respondents, including their legal representatives, were not aware of any evidence that each of Persons 24, 40, 41, 42, 43 and 56 may be able to give which is relevant to matters in issue in the proceedings. The respondents, including their legal representatives, did not have contact details for each of those persons and have not been able to contact them. The respondents seek to adduce evidence from each of these persons at trial XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX X With respect to Person 56, the respondents’ understanding is that XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX X XXXXX XXXXX XX particularised in paragraphs 93–117 (Darwan), paragraphs 122A–122H (Syahchow) and paragraphs 123–129 (last mission) of the existing Particulars of Truth as well as one of the additional incidents in the Additional truth particulars and may have evidence relevant to the matters particularised. Mr Bartlett states that he is informed by Mr Dean Levitan, a solicitor assisting him, that the respondents, including their legal representatives, have made multiple attempts to speak to Person 56, including by contacting his legal representative, in excess of eight times since February 2020. Person 56 has not agreed to speak to the respondents or their legal representatives. Mr Bartlett states that the respondents, including their legal representatives, are not in possession of sufficient information to enable them to serve an outline of the evidence they anticipate Person 56 will give.Leave to amend the Defence to add the Additional truth particulars Mr Bartlett states that the respondents did not know of the information particularised in the Additional truth particulars and, accordingly, they were not in a position to particularise the incidents in their Defence prior to the receipt by them of the Sensitive IGADF Documents. The basis upon which the particulars are provided by the respondents is the information in the Sensitive IGADF Documents and the information in the amended outline of evidence for Person 18.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The fourth order sought by the respondents is that they be granted leave to file and serve an outline of evidence of Mr McLeod. As I have said, due to its late introduction into the interlocutory application, that part of the application has been stood over to a date to be fixed.The Evidence The respondents rely on an affidavit of their solicitor, Mr Bartlett, sworn on 15 March 2021. Mr Bartlett was briefly cross-examined by counsel for the applicant. I permitted cross‑examination of Mr Bartlett because the respondents’ application raises important matters for both parties and because, on any view, the application is made late. The trial is listed for six to eight weeks commencing on 7 June 2021. The evidence given by Mr Bartlett is summarised in the next section of these reasons. It was convenient for identification purposes to receive into evidence on this application the Additional truth particulars referred to in the second order sought by the respondents and that document was marked Exhibit R3. The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force (the Inspector-General) has conducted an inquiry under the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Regulation 2016 (Cth) (IGADF Regulation) (the Inquiry) into a number of incidents XXXXX XXXXX X XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXX. The Inspector-General produced a report which was released to the public and the following appears in the report: Consistently with the terms of reference and legal principles which define the Inquiry’s jurisdiction, in respect of potential criminal conduct, the highest the Inquiry’s findings rise in respect of potential criminal conduct of an individual is that there is credible information that a person has committed a certain identified war crime or disciplinary offence. This is not a finding of guilt, nor a finding (to any standard) that the crime has in fact been committed. The respondents also sought to tender a “PAP” Notice given to the applicant and the applicant’s response to that notice. In Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 6) [2020] FCA 1285 (Roberts-Smith (No 6)) at [4], Colvin J described the nature of a PAP Notice as follows:When established, the Inquiry was required to be conducted in private. In the manner described below, the Inquiry has continued to be conducted in private. It has now reached a point where notices are being issued to persons who might be adversely affected by the Inquiry’s findings and recommendations (described by the Inquiry as Potentially Affected Persons). A number of notices have been issued to Potentially Affected Persons that contain the details of potential findings or recommendations that the Inquiry is considering whether to make that may affect the individual person to whom the notice is addressed. In addition, each notice sets out relevant factual background and a summary of relevant evidence (PAP Notices). The applicant objected to the tender of the PAP Notice given to the applicant and the applicant’s response to the notice. His objection was based on three grounds and they may be summarised as follows:(1)the tender of the PAP Notice and the applicant’s response would infringe the prohibition in s 32(2) of the IGADF Regulation;(2)the tender of the PAP Notice and the applicant’s response should be refused on the basis that the probative value of those documents is substantially outweighed by the danger that the evidence might be unfairly prejudicial to the applicant (see s 135 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)); and(3)both the PAP Notice and the applicant’s response are substantially redacted and, therefore, are not complete. It is unfairly prejudicial to the applicant to receive and possibly act on documents which are substantially incomplete. Expressed in this way, this ground would seem to be an aspect of the second ground.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I made an interim suppression order pursuant to s 37AI of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) in relation to Person 18’s amended outline of evidence. Subject to giving the Commonwealth of Australia an opportunity to make a submission, I would replace that order with a final order, but only as to that part of the outline which has been disallowed (i.e., paragraphs 24–36 inclusive). The content of those paragraphs will not be part of the trial and, in my view, it would prejudice the proper administration of justice for the information to become public by reason of an unsuccessful attempt to seek leave to adduce the evidence at the trial.Conclusions For the reasons set out above, I made the following orders on 23 April 2021:1.The respondents be granted leave to issue a Subpoena to Give Evidence at the trial to each of the following Persons:(a)Person 24;(b)Person 40;(c)Person 41;(d)Person 42; and(e)Person 43.2. Leave to issue a Subpoena to Give Evidence to Person 56 be refused.3.The respondents’ application to amend their Defence to include particulars in the document entitled “SECRET — confidential — Additional truth particulars” to be served in accordance with the s 38B Orders made on 5 March 2021 be refused.4.The respondents be granted leave to serve the amended outline of evidence of Person 18 being Annexure “DLB-2” to the affidavit of Peter Llewellyn Bartlett sworn on 15 March 2021 save and except for paragraphs 24–36 inclusive.5.The question of costs on the interlocutory application filed on 16 March 2021 be reserved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established