FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 14) [2021] FCA 552
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 1... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] FCA 552
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was the balancing of the public interest in maintaining confidentiality and the public interest in ensuring the proper administration of justice. The court had to assess the evidence provided by the IGADF and the AFP regarding the potential harm caused by disclosure and the impact on their respective roles and investigations. The court also had to consider the previous orders made by Justice Colvin in other related proceedings.
In its reasoning, the court found that the IGADF had properly acknowledged the existence of public interest considerations on both sides of the equation. The court accepted the evidence given by the IGADF in support of the claim for non-disclosure, particularly regarding the need for confidentiality in the conduct of the Afghanistan Inquiry. The court also noted the consequences of the previous orders made by Justice Colvin, which affected the weight to be given to the various considerations in the balancing exercise. Ultimately, the court held that if the AFP documents existed, the balance weighed in favour of non-disclosure.
The court made several orders, including excusing the AFP from the obligation to state whether they had possession of the documents and to produce them. The court also ordered that there should be no disclosure of the reasons for judgment and confidential reasons for judgment until further order. The IGADF was required to provide any further confidential evidence and/or submissions in relation to their public interest immunity claims by a specified date. The costs of the public interest immunity claims made by the IGADF and the AFP were reserved, and liberty to apply was granted.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Proper Officer of the Australian Federal Police is excused from the obligation to state whether the Australian Federal Police has possession of documents answering the description set out in the subpoena dated 23 December 2020 issued by the Applicant as amended on 6 May 2021 and from the obligation to produce any such documents.
2. Pursuant to s 37AF of the of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act) and on the grounds referred to in s 37AG(1)(b) and (c) of the Act, there is to be no disclosure, by publication or otherwise, of:
(a) The reasons for judgment of Abraham J in Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publication Pty Limited (No 14) [2021] FCA 552 until further order, or by 5:00pm on 27 May 2021 (whichever is the later).
(b) The confidential reasons for judgment of Abraham J in Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publication Pty Limited (No 14) [2021] FCA 552 in relation to the IGADF’s public interest immunity claims until further order.
(c) The confidential reasons for judgment of Abraham J in Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publication Pty Limited (No 14) [2021] FCA 552 in relation to the Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police’s public interest immunity claims until further order.
3. Order 2(a) does not prevent disclosures to and between Authorised Persons within the meaning of Order 1 of the orders made by his Honour Justice Besanko on 15 July 2020 (as amended on 17 December 2020, 5 March 2021 and 6 May 2021) under ss 19(3A) and s 38B of the National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004 (Cth) (s 38B orders).
4. Order 2(b) does not prevent disclosures to and between Authorised Persons within the meaning of Order 97 of the s 38B orders.
5. Order 2(c) does not prevent disclosures to and between the Commonwealth and/or a Commonwealth Representative within the meaning of the s 38B orders.
6. Upon an undertaking given by Evan Evagorou, Senior Executive Lawyer, Australian Government Solicitor, that the documents referred to in this Order will be made available to any Court on appeal, the two confidential affidavits of Assistant Commissioner Lee Sworn on 3 May 2021 and 13 May 2021, together with their annexures, exhibits and materials accompanying those affidavits, be returned to the Australian Government Solicitor.
7. On a date to be fixed, a representative of the Australian Government Solicitor is to attend on the chambers of Abraham J to collect the documents referred to in Order 6.
8. The IGADF is to provide any further confidential evidence and/or confidential submissions in relation to his public interest immunity claims to her Honour Justice Abraham’s chambers by 4:00pm on 7 June 2021.
9. Costs of the public interest immunity claims made by the IGADF be reserved.
10. Costs of the public interest immunity claims made by the AFP be reserved.
11. Liberty to apply.
THE COURT NOTES THAT:
12. Within three months of the conclusion of the hearing of the substantive proceedings before his Honour Justice Besanko, the parties, the IGADF, and the AFP have leave to have this matter relisted before Justice Abraham to address the issue of the period of time for which order 2(b) and order 2(c) should operate.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The respondents did not take a position on the application.Consideration As noted above, the IGADF accepted, and properly so, that there was a relevant public interest consideration on each side of the equation (that harm would be done by disclosure of the documents sought and the proper administration of justice would be frustrated or impaired if the documents were withheld), and that the balancing exercise described in Alister v The Queen is to be performed. The documents sought are documents which, if they exist, arose as a result of the Inquiry. The circumstances in which the Inquiry arose and the role of the IGADF are described above and are unnecessary to repeat. Suffice to say for present purposes, that significant steps were taken in its conduct and the reporting of its findings, to ensure confidentiality. Given the basis of the Inquiry was to ascertain whether there was any substance to rumours and allegations of breaches of the Laws of Armed Conflict by elements of the ADF's Special Forces in Afghanistan, the seriousness of the subject matter and the consequent need for confidentiality to enable Major-General Brereton to conduct his investigation, is self-evident. I accept the evidence given by the IGADF in the open and confidential affidavits. The deponent plainly has extensive experience both in the military and in his role as Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force. It is also evident that care has been taken in the preparation of the affidavits. The issues addressed concern matters not wholly within the Court’s experience. The experience of Mr Gaynor, most particularly over the course of the Afghanistan Inquiry places him in a special position to assess the damage to the public interest that would arise if the information in question was released. The basis on which the issue of safety is put is readily understandable. In respect to the second basis of the claim Mr Gaynor in his open affidavit at [47] states that:The types of inquiries that the Office of the IGADF conducts pursuant to its statutory mandate are very often of a most serious nature, as was the case with the inquiry. Investigations of this kind require a very high degree of trust and confidence in the integrity of the Office of the IGADF and I and members of the inquiry team have taken great care to build and foster sufficient trust and confidence within the ADF and with others who may be considering engaging with my office. Significant weight can be attached to the opinions he expresses about the impact of disclosure of the information sought, particularly on his ability to fulfil his statutory role. That said, this case has an added feature, not ordinarily present in cases where such a claim is made, in that there has already been orders made by Colvin J which have had consequences in the production of material to the parties generated from the Inquiry: Roberts-Smith (No 6); Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 8) [2020] FCA 1630 (Roberts-Smith (No 8)). For the reasons explained below, that may affect the weight to be attached to the various considerations in the balancing exercise, including relatively to each other, which must necessarily include the weight to be attached to the evidence of the IGADF. Given the information sought, the consequences of the previous orders are part of the factual matrix against which these claims are made and must be considered.