Return to Work Corporation of South Australia v Mitchell

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

RETURN TO WORK CORPORATION OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA v MITCHELL

[2019] SASCFC 34

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Stanley and The Honourable Justice Hinton)

11 April 2019

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - ENTITLEMENT TO COMPENSATION - EMPLOYMENT RELATED INJURY, DISABILITY OR DISEASE

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT AND AMOUNT OF COMPENSATION

Appeal from a decision of the Full Bench of the South Australian Employment Tribunal (SAET).

The worker suffered a compensable lower back injury in the course of employment. He successfully claimed lump sum compensation for non-economic loss pursuant to s 43 of the repealed Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) (the repealed Act).

The worker underwent a lumbar spinal fusion surgery. He made a claim for lump sum compensation pursuant to s 43 for several subsequent impairments caused by his ingestion of one or more medications prescribed to him for pain control following the surgery. The Judge accepted the worker’s claim, holding that for the purpose of determining the level of Whole Person Impairment (WPI), the WPI assessments for these impairments were all to be combined as well as combining them with the WPI assessment previously made in respect of the worker’s back injury and scarring. That was because each of the impairments and the lower back injury itself were all “compensable injuries arising from the same trauma” within the meaning of s 43(6) of the repealed Act.

On appeal, the Full Bench of the SAET upheld the Judge’s decision.

On appeal to this Court, at issue is whether the respondent suffered a single compensable injury or two or more compensable injuries within the meaning of s 43(6). If the answer is the former, then s 43(6) does not apply. If the answer is the latter, there is the further question of whether the respondent’s compensable injuries arose from the same trauma.

Held per Stanley J (Kourakis CJ and Hinton J agreeing), allowing the appeal:

1.  The impairments to the respondent’s upper and lower digestive systems, his urinary and reproductive system and mastication and deglutition are separate physiological changes from the impairment of his lumbar spine, constituting a distinct, subsequent compensable injury.

2. The impairments that arose as a complication of the respondent’s ingestion of opioid medication to relieve the symptoms of his lumbar spine following surgery arose not from the injury to his lumbar spine, but from his ingestion of opioid medication. As that event occurred subsequent to the events which resulted in the injury to his lumbar spine, it was not the case that those injuries arose from the same trauma as the lumbar spine injury. Accordingly, the condition for combination prescribed by s 43(6) is not made out.

3. Appeal allowed, the order awarding compensation to the respondent pursuant to s 43 of the repealed Act in the sum of $359,190 is set aside and the matter is remitted to the SAET for appropriate factual findings to be made and for an assessment of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Return to Work Corporation of South Australia v Mitchell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASCFC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia considered an appeal by the Return to Work Corporation of South Australia against a decision of the Employment Tribunal. The dispute concerned the respondent worker's entitlement to lump sum compensation for multiple impairments, including xerostomia, loss of mastication and deglutition, digestive system impairment, genito-urinary system impairment, erectile dysfunction, and bladder dysfunction. These impairments arose from the worker's ingestion of powerful medications, primarily opioids, prescribed for pain management following surgery for a compensable lower back injury sustained in late 2008 and early 2009.

The central legal issue before the Full Court was whether the worker's subsequent impairments, resulting from prescribed medication, constituted separate compensable injuries or were to be treated as part of the original lower back injury for the purposes of calculating permanent impairment under the repealed Workers' Compensation Act 1971 (SA). Specifically, the court had to determine if these impairments arose from the "same trauma" as the initial back injury, as contemplated by section 43(6) of the repealed Act, which would allow for the combination of various percentage whole person impairment (WPI) assessments.

The Full Court reasoned that adverse consequences of medical treatment necessitated by an original compensable injury should be regarded as part of that original injury, provided there is no gross negligence breaking the chain of causation. Relying on established authorities such as *Lindeman*, *Mahony*, and the dissenting judgment in *Migge*, the court held that surgery and medical treatment, and their complications, are not to be treated as separate traumas. Therefore, the impairments suffered by the worker due to the prescribed medications were considered to have arisen from the same trauma as his initial lower back injury. This approach distinguished the present case from situations where a new and independent trauma causes a subsequent injury, as seen in *Marrone*.

The Full Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the decision of the Employment Tribunal that the worker's various impairments were to be combined with his initial back injury assessment for the purpose of calculating his total WPI. This meant that the worker's total WPI was assessed at 70 per cent, entitling him to lump sum compensation based on this combined assessment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In order to understand the question of statutory construction which arises, it is necessary to set out the factual background to the matter and its litigation history.The facts In late 2008 and early 2009 the respondent worker suffered a compensable lower back injury. In January 2011 the worker underwent surgery by way of lumbar spinal fusion for his compensable lower back injury. The back injury was assessed in July 2013 for the purposes of the repealed Act as a WPI of 26 per cent. This consisted of a 25 per cent loss of function attributable to the back injury plus one per cent loss of function for scarring. There is no complaint on appeal in relation to that assessment. The worker made claims for lump sum compensation pursuant to s 43 in respect of several subsequent impairments, namely, xerostomia (dry mouth), loss of mastication and deglutition, impairment of the upper and lower digestive system, impairment of the genito-urinary system, erectile dysfunction and bladder dysfunction. These impairments were the result of the worker’s ingestion of one or more of the “extraordinary array of powerful medications, mainly of opioids” prescribed to him for pain control following the surgery in January 2011. Decisions of the Employment Tribunal At first instance, Judge Calligeros found that each of these impairments was caused by the consumption by the worker of medication that was prescribed following the lumbar spinal fusion surgery and “from the over-use of medication”. The judge assessed the entitlements arising as follows:Upper digestive: 10 per cent;Lower digestive: 14 per cent;Urinary and reproductive system (erectile dysfunction): 20 per cent;Urinary and reproductive system (bladder disease): 28 per cent; Mastication and deglutition: 10 per cent; The judge held that, for the purpose of determining the level of WPI, the WPI assessments for these impairments were all to be combined as well as combining them with the WPI assessment of 26 per cent previously made in respect of the worker’s back injury and scarring. That was because each of the impairments and the lower back injury itself were all “compensable injuries arising from the same trauma” within the meaning of s 43(6) of the repealed Act. The judge considered that the he was constrained by the decision of the Full Bench of the Employment Tribunal in Martin v Return to Work SA[1] to hold that the impairments were “injuries arising from the same trauma” which must be combined for the purposes of WPI assessment. The judge said that, had he not been bound by the decision in Martin, he would have regarded the approach of the Full Court in Marrone v Employers Mutual Ltd[2] as dictating a different conclusion. [1] [2016] SAET 95. [2] [2013] SASCFC 67, (2013) 116 SASR 501. The result of combining the various WPI assessments into a single WPI for the purposes of calculating compensation pursuant to s 43 was that the worker’s total WPI was 70 per cent. On the basis of the judge’s reliance upon the reasoning in Martin, it was unnecessary to make any findings as to which particular medication or combination of medications, or which instance of taking medication, gave rise to a trauma which resulted in each impairment, or when these events occurred. The judge expressly declined to proceed in that way.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The worker made claims for lump sum compensation pursuant to s 43 in respect of several subsequent impairments, namely, xerostomia (dry mouth), loss of mastication and deglutition, impairment of the upper and lower digestive system, impairment of the genito-urinary system, erectile dysfunction and bladder dysfunction. These impairments were the result of the worker’s ingestion of one or more of the “extraordinary array of powerful medications, mainly of opioids” prescribed to him for pain control following the surgery in January 2011. Decisions of the Employment Tribunal At first instance, Judge Calligeros found that each of these impairments was caused by the consumption by the worker of medication that was prescribed following the lumbar spinal fusion surgery and “from the over-use of medication”. The judge assessed the entitlements arising as follows:Upper digestive: 10 per cent;Lower digestive: 14 per cent;Urinary and reproductive system (erectile dysfunction): 20 per cent;Urinary and reproductive system (bladder disease): 28 per cent; Mastication and deglutition: 10 per cent; The judge held that, for the purpose of determining the level of WPI, the WPI assessments for these impairments were all to be combined as well as combining them with the WPI assessment of 26 per cent previously made in respect of the worker’s back injury and scarring. That was because each of the impairments and the lower back injury itself were all “compensable injuries arising from the same trauma” within the meaning of s 43(6) of the repealed Act. The judge considered that the he was constrained by the decision of the Full Bench of the Employment Tribunal in Martin v Return to Work SA[1] to hold that the impairments were “injuries arising from the same trauma” which must be combined for the purposes of WPI assessment. The judge said that, had he not been bound by the decision in Martin, he would have regarded the approach of the Full Court in Marrone v Employers Mutual Ltd[2] as dictating a different conclusion. [1] [2016] SAET 95. [2] [2013] SASCFC 67, (2013) 116 SASR 501. The result of combining the various WPI assessments into a single WPI for the purposes of calculating compensation pursuant to s 43 was that the worker’s total WPI was 70 per cent. On the basis of the judge’s reliance upon the reasoning in Martin, it was unnecessary to make any findings as to which particular medication or combination of medications, or which instance of taking medication, gave rise to a trauma which resulted in each impairment, or when these events occurred. The judge expressly declined to proceed in that way. The Full Bench, in dismissing the appeal from Judge Calligeros, followed its earlier decision in Martin. The Full Bench held that all of the impairments arose from “the same trauma” as the initial lower back injury. In their joint judgment, McCusker J and Deputy President Lieschke held that the authorities of Lindeman Ltd v Colvin,[3] Mahony v J Kruschich (Demolitions) Pty Ltd[4] and the dissenting judgment of Mason JA (as he then was) in Migge v Wormald Bros. Industries Ltd[5] established the proposition that surgery and medical treatment are not to be treated as produced by separate traumas. They held that compensable injury includes the instigating event and the complication. As a result, treatment of the complication completes the concept of injury.[6] Their Honours said:[7]By s 43 a worker who suffers a compensable injury resulting in permanent impairment is entitled to compensation for non‑economic loss by way of a lump sum. A compensable injury may result in more than one impairment and that is assumed by the Act. But so too separate compensable injuries may arise from the same trauma. That is the correct description of what has happened in this worker’s case. And for the reasons explained, surgery and medical treatment are not to be treated as produced by separate traumas. In this case and particularly in regard to the opiates, the compensable injuries arose from the one trauma.In Martin the Full Tribunal held:“In our view, relevant authorities and common sense lead to the conclusion that provided the medical treatment is made necessary because of the original injury, short of gross negligence that might break the chain of causation, any adverse consequences of that treatment should be regarded as forming part of the original compensable injury.” [Authorities omitted.]Once this stage of analysis is reached, namely that the concept of compensable injuries arising from the same trauma includes any medical treatment or surgery attendant upon the injury then Marrone allows the injuries to be treated as one injury. Only in the case of fresh instigation, as was the case in Marrone, with the development of injury and impairment in the opposite arm due to overuse after return to work would the injuries be treated as arising from separate traumas. These aspects of the law have already been closely considered on a number of occasions. This result is entirely consistent with the result in Preedy.[Citations omitted].[3] (1946) 74 CLR 313. [4] (1985) 156 CLR 522.[5] (1972) 2 NSWLR 29. On appeal the High Court in Migge v Wormald Bros. Industries Ltd (1973) 47 ALJR 236 approved Mason JA’s dissent in the New South Wales Court of Appeal. [6] [2017] SAET 81 at [17].[7] [2017] SAET 81 at [19]-[21].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Bench considered the judge’s conclusion to be incorrect. The Full Bench found that the judge’s conclusion proceeded from the premise that the original injury and the consequences of treatment are to be treated as separate compensable injuries. The Full Bench rejected that premise. It did so in reliance upon the same line of authority relied upon by the Full Bench in this case, namely, Lindeman, Mahony and Migge. The Full Bench concluded:[21]In our view, relevant authorities and common sense lead to the conclusion that provided the medical treatment is made necessary because of the original injury, short of gross negligence that might break the chain of causation, any adverse consequences of that treatment should be regarded as forming part of the original compensable injury.It follows that the so called Marrone principles do not apply to this issue and the learned Deputy President’s ruling in respect of it must be set aside.[22][Footnotes omitted.][21] [2016] SAET 95 at [66]-[67].[22] Although it is not necessary to decide for the purposes of this appeal, the correctness of the qualification said to be established in Mahony that negligent medical treatment might break the causal chain in relation to the compensability of the consequences of surgical or medical treatment of the work injury must be doubted, particularly in light of the different statutory context under the repealed Act, especially s 30(3)(e). Consideration At issue is whether the respondent suffered a single compensable injury or two or more compensable injuries within the meaning of s 43(6). If the answer is the former, then s 43(6) does not apply. If the answer is the latter, there is the further question of whether the respondent’s compensable injuries arose from the same trauma. It is convenient first to address the question of whether the respondent suffered a single compensable injury or two or more compensable injuries within the meaning of s 43(6). The starting point is the concept of “injury”. In Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May,[23] Gageler J considered the ordinary sense in which the term “injury” is used in the context of workers compensation legislation. He said:[24]An injury, it has long been repeatedly explained, is some definite or distinct “physiological change” or “physiological disturbance” for the worse which, if not “sudden” is at least “identifiable”. The universality of that explanation has been questioned, and the comment has fairly been made that “a distinct physiological change is not itself an expression of clear and definite meaning”. The expression has nevertheless been shown by repeated usage to have utility as an exposition of the particular sense in which injury has been used, and continues to be used, in the particular legislative context.[Citations omitted.][23] [2016] HCA 19, (2016) 257 CLR 468.[24] [2016] HCA 19 at [75], (2016) 257 CLR 468 at 486. An injury was compensable under the repealed Act pursuant to s 30, if it arose from employment. I have set out the terms of that provision earlier in these reasons.