Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd v Pain

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

RETAIL EMPLOYEES SUPERANNUATION PTY LTD v PAIN

[2016] SASC 121

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

8 August 2016

SUPERANNUATION - INDUSTRY SUPERVISION

SUPERANNUATION - PRIVATE SECTOR FUNDS - AMENDMENT OF TRUST DEED

SUPERANNUATION - PRIVATE SECTOR FUNDS - TRUSTEES - POWERS AND DUTIES

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION

Application under section 59C of the Trustee Act 1936 to vary terms of a trust.

The plaintiff is the trustee of the Retail Employees Superannuation Trust, which was established in 1987. The defendant is a beneficiary of the Trust appointed to represent the interests of actual and potential beneficiaries. The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority was joined as an intervener at the request of the Court.

Clause 19 of the Trust Deed empowers the trustee to amend the Trust Deed, but the power of amendment is subject to limitations. Since 1988, the trustee has amended the Trust Deed on 40 occasions. Its terms are now very different to the terms of the original Trust Deed. As originally constituted, membership of the Trust was open only to employees of participating employers, the trust fund was solely an accumulation fund, the investments attributed to all members were pooled, and there was a single product and single division.

In 1997, the Trust Deed was amended to constitute the Trust as a public offer entity. The Trust was divided into Division I (employer-sponsored members) and Division II (members of the public).

In 1998, the Trust Deed was amended to empower the trustee to establish and maintain separate investment options. The principal investment option continued to be the Core Strategy, but the trustee also created 12 additional investment options.

In 2002, the Trust Deed was amended to create Division III (REST Pension) for members who applied for or elected to receive a pension benefit and Division IV (Acumen) for members whose employers negotiated special terms. The trustee subsequently created sub-plans in Division IV, of which 5 subplans remain, including sub-plans that provided defined benefits.

In 2013, the Trust Deed was amended to create a MySuper class of beneficial interest. It was also amended to allow the trustee to admit members of the public to Division I and to transfer member’s products between products and divisions without the consent of members in certain circumstances. The trustee created two separate products, REST Super and REST Corporate, within Division I.

The plaintiff is concerned that some of the amendments made over the years may arguably not have complied with clause 19. The plaintiff seeks an order varying the Trust Deed to validate all previous amendments with prospective effect. The plaintiff also seeks variation of the Trust Deed to substitute a new clause 19 and to amend some of the substantive provisions of the Trust Deed.

Held (granting the application to vary the Trust Deed):

1.       The Court has jurisdiction to vary the Trust notwithstanding that the proper law of the Trust Deed is that of New South Wales. The Court should exercise…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd v Pain and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd v Pain, the plaintiff, Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd, sought variations to the Trust Deed governing the superannuation fund, which was established to provide benefits to retail industry employees. The plaintiff aimed to amend the power of amendment of the Trust Deed, clarify the validity of past amendments, and introduce new substantive changes to the Trust Deed. The legal issues primarily revolved around the authority of the trustee to amend the Trust Deed, the validity of past amendments, and whether the proposed changes were in the best interest of the beneficiaries. Additionally, the court had to interpret relevant statutory provisions and consider the regulatory framework governing superannuation funds.

The court found that while there was a contractual relationship between the trustee and the members, the trustee's power to amend the Trust Deed was subject to restrictions and could not be used to remove those restrictions. The court also concluded that due to ambiguities in the existing clause 19, it was impractical to determine the validity of past amendments. Therefore, it was appropriate to vary the Trust Deed to ensure the validity of past amendments and improve the provisions in the interest of the members. The court exercised its discretion to make the order sought by the Trustee, subject to certain amendments.

In summary, the court granted the plaintiff's application to vary the Trust Deed, subject to certain conditions. The court found that the Trustee had the authority to amend the Trust Deed, the past amendments were of questionable validity, and the proposed changes were in the best interest of the beneficiaries. The court's decision ensured the validity of past amendments and improved the provisions of the Trust Deed, thereby protecting the rights and benefits of the members.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff seeks variation of the Trust Deed in three ways. First, variation of the power of amendment of the Trust Deed. Secondly, variation of substantive provisions of the Trust Deed to reflect past amendments whose validity has recently been doubted. Thirdly, new proposed variations of substantive provisions of the Trust Deed.PART A: BACKGROUNDSuperannuation regulatory regime It is necessary to understand the regulation of the Trust under the general law and statute because it provides a context for, explains and constrains many provisions of the Trust Deed. General law Superannuation funds are governed by the general law. Although universally structured as trusts, a contributing member has a direct financial and commercial interest in the fund which would be contractual but for the trust structure. Such a member has a beneficial interest in the trust and in any separate fund within the trust, albeit not in any individual asset of the trust. In Mettoy Pension Trustees Limited v Evans,[2] Warner J said:… the beneficiaries under a pension scheme such as this are not volunteers. Their rights have contractual and commercial origins. They are derived from the contracts of employment of the members. The benefits provided under the scheme have been earned by the service of the members under those contracts and, where the scheme is contributory, pro tanto by their contributions.[3][2] [1990] 1 WLR 1587. [3] At 1610. In Lock v Westpac Banking Corporation,[4] Waddell CJ in Eq said:… pension plans are different in nature from traditional trusts. They are based upon a contract between the employer, the trustee, and employees pursuant to which both the employer and the employees contribute to the fund for the purpose of providing defined benefits in defined circumstances to employees. The usual form of trusts involve the creation of a benefit by the settlor for which the beneficiary gives no consideration. Pension schemes are created in the context of the employer/employee relationship and are part of the terms of engagement.[5][4] (1991) 25 NSWLR 593. [5] At 601-602. In Finch v Telstra Super Pty Ltd,[6] French CJ, Gummow, Heydon, Crennan and Bell JJ said:The Trustee was trustee of a trust. It had a duty to distribute to those who fell within the definition of "Total and Permanent Invalidity" and a duty not to distribute to those who did not. … That duty was owed to the Members, including the applicant. The applicant was not the object of a discretionary power of appointment. He was the beneficiary of a trust, and although the precise form and quantum of his beneficial interest was contingent on particular events, he did have a beneficial interest…Different criteria might be thought to apply to the operation of a superannuation fund from those which apply to discretionary decisions made by a trustee holding a power of appointment under a non-superannuation trust. Employer superannuation is part of the remuneration of employees. … Superannuation is not a matter of mere bounty, or potential enjoyment of another's benefaction. It is something for which, in large measure, employees have exchanged value – their work and their contributions.[7][6] [2010] HCA 36, (2010) 242 CLR 254. [7] At [30], [33]. (Citations omitted. Emphasis added).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The exceptions include payment to an individual if the trustee has not, after making reasonable enquiries, found a legal personal representative or a dependant.[22][22] Regulation 6.22(3). See [591] below for more detail concerning the exceptions.The evidence John Edstein is a director, Paul Howard is general counsel, Allan Bowles is a senior product manager and Jamie Hwang is acting general manager investments of the Trustee. Three affidavits by Mr Edstein, four affidavits by Mr Howard and one affidavit by each of Mr Bowles and Mr Hwang were tendered by the plaintiff. They included numerous exhibits. Mr Edstein also gave oral evidence. These witnesses gave evidence about the current and historical structure and operation of the Trust, amendments to the Trust Deed and terms of trust deeds of other large superannuation funds. Louise Campbell is an independent actuary. Her expert report was tendered by the plaintiff. Noel Davis is an independent barrister specialising in superannuation law. An affidavit by Mr Davis was tendered by the plaintiff. Benjamin Carruthers is a senior manager in APRA’s legal team. An affidavit by Mr Carruthers was tendered by APRA. He deposed to and exhibited a legal review undertaken by APRA of the terms of the proposed Trust Deed as if a fresh application had been made by the plaintiff under section 29L of the SIS Act for registration of the Trust. The review concluded that it complied with the relevant parts of Part 6 of the SIS Act (provisions relating to the governing rules of superannuation entities). The review related to the proposed Trust Deed as it was at the outset of the application. That version was revised in the course of the hearings.The TrustCreation In 1986, the Conciliation and Arbitration Commission announced that it would approve industrial agreements providing for employer contributions to approved superannuation funds of up to three per cent of wages and salaries. In 1987, the Retail Traders’ Associations of New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia and Tasmania, the Retailers Association of Queensland Limited and the Pharmacy Guild of Australia as Sponsors agreed to create a superannuation fund in the form of a trust to provide superannuation benefits to employees of retail industry employers admitted to participate in the Trust. The plaintiff was incorporated to act as trustee of the proposed trust. The directors and shareholders were nominees of the Sponsors. On 2 December 1987, the Trust was created by execution by the plaintiff of the Trust Deed. The Trust Deed provided that the plaintiff was the trustee (the Trustee) of the trust created by the Trust Deed. On 1 January 1988, the Trust commenced. Original trust deed The Trust Deed empowered the Trustee to permit an employer engaged in an appropriate business on application to become an “Employer” (participating employer) by executing a deed of adoption whereupon it became bound by the Trust Deed. It empowered the Trustee to admit an employee of a participating employer on application as a member (member), whereupon the employee became bound by the Trust Deed. It provided for a fund (the Fund) comprising all monies received by the Trustee, investments, policies of insurance and other assets in which the monies were invested.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The defendant submits that the word “Plan” should be substituted for the word “Fund” in clause 19.2(e), with which the plaintiff agrees. The same change should be made in clause 19.2(d).Conclusion Having considered all of the proposed amendments to clause 19, subject to the further amendments identified above being made, I am satisfied that:1there is good reason to vary the Trust to make the proposed amendments;2the proposed amendments are in the interest of beneficiaries of the Trust;3the proposed amendments do not result in one class of beneficiaries being unfairly advantaged to the prejudice of another class;4the proposed amendments accord as far as reasonably practicable with the spirit of the Trust and do not disturb the Trust beyond what is necessary to give effect to the reasons justifying the exercise of the power to vary the terms of the Trust Deed.PART E: DISCRETION Subject to the further amendments identified being made, all of the criteria are met empowering the Court to make the order sought by the Trustee. The final question is whether the discretion should be exercised to make that order.Validity of past amendments under clause 19 Insofar as the plaintiff seeks an order varying the substantive provisions of the Trust Deed to reflect past amendments, such an order would be unnecessary and there would be reason not to exercise the discretion to make an order if past amendments were of undoubted validity. Due to the ambiguities and uncertainties as to the construction and effect of existing clause 19, in many instances it cannot be concluded that past amendments are of undoubted validity for the reasons given above. Because the Trust Deed has been amended on 40 occasions and numerous amendments are cumulative upon earlier ones, it would be a Herculean task to disentangle valid from invalid amendments if any amendments have been invalid. It is appropriate to exercise the discretion to make an order varying the Trust effectively to put the validity of past amendments beyond doubt and at the same time improve the provisions of the Trust Deed in several respects in the interests of the members.Power of trustee to amend clause 19 Insofar as the Trustee seeks an order varying clause 19 of the Trust Deed, such an order would be unnecessary and there would be reason not to exercise the discretion to make such an order if the Trustee could itself amend clause 19 to the same effect. It is a general principle of construction of constitutions such as trust deeds that the trustee cannot utilise its power of amendment of the trust deed to remove restrictions on its power of amendment.[131] A trust deed could provide that the trustee is empowered to amend the power of amendment by removing existing restrictions, but this would require express provision as it would contradict the existence of the restrictions on the power of amendment and it would be inconsistent with the existence of the restrictions to imply a power to remove them.[131] Re Reevie and Montréal Trust Co of Canada [1984] 46 OR (2d) 667 at 673 per O’Brien J; In re Courage Group’s Pension Schemes [1987] 1 WLR 495 at 505 per Millett J; Air Jamaica Ltd v Charlton [1999] 1 WLR 1399 at 1411 per the Privy Council.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is likely that there is a contractual relationship between the Trustee and members. Rule 2.2 provides that applicants for enlisted membership[8] are to submit an application to be accepted or rejected by the Trustee. Subclause 13.3 provides that employers are to submit an application to be accepted or rejected by the Trustee and that the terms and conditions contained therein are binding on the employees of the employer.[9] Rule 2.9 provides that each member agrees to be bound by the Trust Deed.[8] I define the term “enlisted member” at [99] below to mean an individual who completes an application to the Trustee for admission as a member after receiving or downloading a product disclosure statement containing the application, who is accepted by the Trustee as a member and from whom the Trustee receives a contribution.[9] Such employees are employer-sponsored members: see [97] below. Whether the employee becomes a party to such a contract will depend on whether the employer is acting within the scope of actual or ostensible agency in purportedly entering into the contract on behalf of its employees.Superannuation Industry and Corporations Acts The Trust is extensively regulated by Commonwealth legislation. The Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) (the SIS Act) and the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the SIS Regulations) apply to the Trust. Parts 7.6 and 7.9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) and corresponding provisions of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Regulations) apply to the issue of beneficial interests in the Trust. The main object of the SIS Act is expressed by section 3 to be to make provision for the prudent management of certain superannuation funds in respect of which the Commonwealth has constitutional power under the corporations and pensions powers and for their supervision by APRA, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and the Commissioner of Taxation. The evident purpose of most provisions is the protection of members’ rights and benefits. Part 7.9 of the Corporations Act addresses financial product disclosure and issue, sale and purchase of financial products. Part 7.6 addresses licensing of financial services providers. The evident purpose of Parts 7.9 and 7.6 insofar as they apply to superannuation interests is the protection of the interests of members and potential members of superannuation entities. Section 10 of the SIS Act defines a "superannuation fund" to include an indefinitely continuing superannuation fund. Section 19 enables a trustee of a superannuation fund whose governing rules require its trustee to be a corporation, by notice given to APRA, to elect that the Act apply to the fund and thereby for the fund to become a “regulated superannuation fund”. A regulated superannuation fund is a “superannuation entity” and, if not a self-managed superannuation fund, is also a “registrable superannuation entity” within the meaning of section 10 of the SIS Act. The Trust is a superannuation fund, a regulated superannuation fund, a superannuation entity and a registrable superannuation entity.