SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
BLONG UME NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS v SEMWEB NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS (No 2)
[2021] SASC 22
Judgment of the Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis
EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - APPOINTMENT, REMOVAL AND ESTATE OF TRUSTEES - RETIREMENT AND REMOVAL - REMOVAL BY THE COURT - JURISDICTION AND POWERS
CORPORATIONS - MEMBERSHIP, RIGHTS AND REMEDIES - MEMBERS' REMEDIES AND INTERNAL DISPUTES - OPPRESSIVE OR UNFAIR CONDUCT
STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION
Messrs Orfanos, Michaels and Ouwens, referred to as ’the three principals’, formed a joint venture comprising of their respective corporate vehicles, of which they were the principals, Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd (Orfanos Nominees), Melrob Investments Pty Ltd (Melrob) and Ouwens Corporate Services Pty Ltd (OCS). Under the joint venture, the joint venture company, Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd (Semweb), of which each of the three principals was a director, was to purchase and hold an office building as trustee from which the three principals could operate their respective practices.
Semweb leased, on a five-year term expiring in December 2007, part of the building to Sims Richmond Pty Ltd (Mr Michaels) and part of it to OCS (Mr Ouwens) and Orfanos Corporate (Mr Orfanos) through a joint venture between OCS and Orfanos Corporate. In December 2007, Mr Orfanos vacated the property after falling into dispute with Mr Ouwens. In the years which followed, Mr Orfanos raised, on two occasions, complaints that Semweb did not lease the property on market terms and conditions.
At trial, the Judge found that Messrs Ouwens, Michaels and Orfanos owed fiduciary duties to themselves and their associated joint venturers and that the joint venturers owed duties to each other. However, the Judge dismissed the action, in all respects, on the grounds that the plaintiff had not proved that the rent collected by Semweb was less than the market rent.
On appeal, the Full Court overturned the trial Judge's decision, finding that Semweb breached its fiduciary and equitable duties it owed to the joint venturers as beneficiaries and that a landlord exercising reasonable skill and diligence would have taken steps to obtain a market rental income from the property and made orders for an account and inquiry as to the shortfall in rental income to be paid to the plaintiffs.
The Full Court ordered two residuary issues be remitted for rehearing in relation to the plaintiffs’ claims for the removal of the first defendant as trustee or the winding up of the trust under ss 36 and 59C of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) (the Trustee Act), and the plaintiffs’ claim for relief on the basis of oppressive conduct under ss 232, 233 and 461 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act).
Held (Kourakis CJ):
1. The spirit of the trust extends to, and includes, the commercial purposes of the joint venture to accommodate the beneficiaries’ interests in the property as an investment and as office accommodation for their related professional practices.
2. The objectives and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd v Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] SASC 22
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the spirit of the trust, which included the commercial purposes of the joint venture, had been compromised by the actions of the trustees, Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens, who attempted to take advantage of Mr Orfanos's personal circumstances. This was deemed a breach of the underlying spirit of the trust arrangement, inconsistent with the duties of good faith and fairness inherent in such arrangements. The Court ruled that the objectives and purposes of the joint venture and the trust had largely been achieved, and the balance of considerations strongly favoured the termination of the trust. The Court did not find it necessary to determine the scope of the power under s 233 of the Corporations Act but noted that the power would have been exercised if no alternative remedy was available. The Court held that a wide interpretation should be taken when considering the availability of remedies under s 59C of the Trustee Act and s 233 of the Corporations Act, given the public interest in ensuring that a remedy is available when the legal structures adopted for business ventures involving multiple parties are used oppressively or become unworkable.
The Court ordered the revocation of the trust and the distribution of the trust property accordingly, highlighting the importance of the underlying spirit and purposes of the trust arrangement.
Orders
Orders of the court
Held (Kourakis CJ):
1. The spirit of the trust extends to, and includes, the commercial purposes of the joint venture to accommodate the beneficiaries’ interests in the property as an investment and as office accommodation for their related professional practices.
2. The objectives and purposes underlying the joint venture and the trust have largely been achieved and the balance of considerations weighs strongly in favour of the termination of the trust.
3. Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens have attempted to take advantage of Mr Orfanos's personal circumstances by insisting on a ‘minority discount’. The approach is unreasonable and a breach of the underlying spirit of the trust arrangement. It is inconsistent with the duties of good faith and fairness inherent in the arrangement.
4. It is unnecessary to determine the scope of the power under s 233 of the Corporations Act, nonetheless, that power to wind up Semweb would have been exercised if an alternative remedy were not available.
5. A wide interpretation should be taken when considering the availability of remedies under s 59C of the Trustee Act and s 233 of the Corporations Act. There is a public interest in ensuring that a remedy is available when the legal structures adopted for business ventures involving multiple parties are used oppressively or become unworkable.
Background
Background to the litigation
The court also found that Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens had attempted to take advantage of Mr Orfanos by insisting on a 'minority discount', which was unreasonable and a breach of the underlying spirit of the trust arrangement. It was inconsistent with the duties of good faith and fairness inherent in the arrangement. While it was unnecessary to determine the scope of the power under s 233 of the Corporations Act, the court noted that it would have exercised that power to wind up Semweb if an alternative remedy were not available. The court took a wide interpretation of the availability of remedies under s 59C of the Trustee Act and s 233 of the Corporations Act, noting the public interest in ensuring that a remedy is available when the legal structures adopted for business ventures involving multiple parties are used oppressively or become unworkable.
The case of Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd v Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) involves a complex dispute concerning the termination of a joint venture trust and the removal of a trustee. The matter came before the court as an application by Blong Ume, a beneficiary, seeking an order to remove Semweb as trustee of the joint venture trust or, in the alternative, to revoke the trust entirely. The application followed a protracted dispute between the joint venturers, which had reached an impasse. Prior to this application, there had been attempts to resolve the dispute through negotiations and mediation, but these efforts had failed to achieve a resolution. The case involved significant procedural steps, including the filing of various applications and interlocutory orders. The court had to consider the appropriate legal framework for addressing the dispute, weighing the powers available under both the Trustee Act and the Corporations Act. The court also needed to assess the merits of removing the trustee versus revoking the trust, considering the potential implications for the beneficiaries and the broader public interest in the availability of effective remedies in such complex business arrangements.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Michaels is 52. He testified that Mr Ouwens had informed him earlier this year that he intended to pass his practice on to his daughter. Mr Ouwens had mentioned the proposal in general terms and had not put anything specific as to the form of the assignment or transaction. He had indicated that he wished to continue rent office accommodation in the property, but that his daughter would take over the legal practice. Consideration Blong Ume seeks an order pursuant to s 36 of the Trustee Act removing Semweb as trustee, and, in the alternative, an order pursuant to s 59C of the Trustee Act revoking the trust. The pre-conditions of the exercise of the power to remove a trustee pursuant to s 36 of the Trustee Act are that the removal is in the interests of the beneficiaries, or necessary or desirable, in order to advance the purposes of the trust. In this case, the appointment of an independent trustee, either a natural person or a corporate trustee, would serve very little purpose. Far from bringing an end to disputation it would simply change its character. If the underlying tension between the joint venturers remains unresolved, an independent trustee is likely to find itself regularly seeking directions from the Court on how to resolve their competing demands. Moreover, the appointment of an independent trustee must come at a cost. I would not make an order removing Semweb as trustee. Section 59C of the Trustee Act was enacted in response to the recommendation of Justice Zelling in his capacity as Chairman of the Law Reform Committee. The concern of the Committee was that there was no express power to vary or revoke a trust when it was without legal capacity to consent to that course. Plainly, cases like this do not fall within that concern. The provision is broadly expressed, a feature which provoked some Parliamentary debate.[6] However, it is trite to observe that once enacted the scope and meaning of a provision is for the Courts to determine.[6] Hansard 27 February 1980 and 5 June 1980 Legislative Council, pp 1252 – 1253, 2302-2303. Bollen J considered the scope of s 59C of the Trustee Act in Benzija v Adriatic Fisheries Pty Ltd,[7] in the context of a joint venture to operate a prawn fishing vessel, the Barameda C. The joint venturers were the Benzija, Cubelic and Matulic families. Adriatic Fisheries Pty Ltd undertook the prawn fishing operations as trustee on their behalf. When the families fell into dispute the Benzija family sought orders pursuant to s 59C of the Trustee Act revoking the Trust.[7] Benzija v Adriatic Fisheries Pty Ltd (1984) 37 SASR 545. Bollen J considered when the power might be exercised in the following passages:[8]There is no present authority dealing with this section. The section is difficult to interpret. It is difficult to know when to use it. There are no positive criteria stating the possible circumstances in which orders may be made. There are stated circumstances in which the Court should not exercise powers given by the section. One is that the exercise of the powers must not “disturb the trusts beyond what is necessary to give effect to the reasons justifying the exercise of the power”. Yet there is no hint in the section of what reasons Parliament might think adequate for the exercise of the jurisdiction.…I think that there is no need for me to attempt any general statement about the width of s. 59c. I think that there is no doubt that I have power on the application of these applicants to vary or revoke the trusts before me. Equally I think, as I have said, that there must be some weighty reasons proved before I contemplate varying or revoking. Even if weighty reasons exist I must still consider the matters mentioned in s. 59c(3). The power to vary or revoke is discretionary. I must exercise that discretion judicially. …[8] Benzija v Adriatic Fisheries Pty Ltd (1984) 37 SASR 545 at 559.