Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd v Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

BLONG UME NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS v SEMWEB NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS

[2017] SASC 137

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

25 September 2017

EQUITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - FIDUCIARY OBLIGATIONS - PARTICULAR CASES - JOINT VENTURER

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - IMPLIED TERMS - DURATION OF CONTRACT

CORPORATIONS - MEMBERSHIP, RIGHTS AND REMEDIES - MEMBERS' REMEDIES AND INTERNAL DISPUTES - OPPRESSIVE OR UNFAIR CONDUCT - WHAT CONSTITUTES - GENERALLY

This matter arose out of a disagreement between the parties about the operation of a joint venture. The joint venture in question was established in 2002 to provide office accommodation for the professional practices of Nicholas Orfanos, Michael Michaels and Willem Ouwens (collectively, the ‘Three Principals’). Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd, Melrob Investments Pty Ltd and Ouwens Corporate Services Pty Ltd (‘OCS’) are the respective corporate vehicles of the Three Principals. Blong Ume Pty Ltd is the alleged successor to Orfanos Nominees.

Orfanos Nominees, Melrob, OCS and Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd (‘Semweb’) are the parties to the relevant joint venture deed (‘JVD’). The JVD records their agreement to purchase, hold and manage the subject property. Semweb holds the subject property pursuant to a Trust Deed. The Three Principals are the directors of Semweb and each hold a one third interest in Semweb and the Trust.

After a series of disagreements between the parties, Orfanos Nominees purported to terminate the joint venture in 2012. This was rejected by Melrob and OCS. The plaintiffs now seek to realise their interest in the subject property and have sought a variety of remedies from this Court.

In doing so, the plaintiffs contend that:

1. the joint venture gave rise to a partnership pursuant to the Partnership Act 1891 (SA);

2.  the JVD contains an implied right to terminate upon the giving of reasonable notice;

3.  the JVD contains an implied right to terminate upon breach by any of the joint venturers;

4. the Property should be realised pursuant to s 69(2) of the Law of Property Act 1936 (SA);

5.  Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens breached the Trust Deed, JVD and the fiduciary duties they owed to both Semweb (as its directors) and the other joint venturers;

6. The Trust should be revoked and its assets distributed pursuant to s 36 and s 59C of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) because Semweb breached its fiduciary duty to the beneficiaries of the Trust and the terms of the Trust Deed;

7. the conduct of Mr Ouwens and Mr Michaels was oppressive and unfairly prejudicial pursuant to s 232(e) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and constituted a breach of their statutory duties to Semweb pursuant to s 181 and s 182 of that Act; and

8. Semweb should be wound up pursuant to the just and equitable ground in s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act.

Held (Parker J):

1. The joint venture does not give rise to a partnership. There is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd v Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 137
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd and Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd, through their director Nicholas Orfanos, sought various remedies against the defendants, including Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd, Melrob Investments Pty Ltd, Ouwens Corporate Services Pty Ltd, Michael Michaels, and Willem Ouwens. The central dispute revolves around the interpretation and enforcement of a joint venture deed (JVD) and a trust deed, as well as the conduct of the defendants in relation to the property and the joint venture. The plaintiffs sought a range of remedies, including declarations, winding-up orders, termination of trusts, sale of property, equitable compensation, and various other orders.

The court was required to address several legal issues, including the implications of the joint venture deed and trust deed, the existence and scope of fiduciary duties among the parties, the interpretation of contractual terms, and whether the defendants' conduct amounted to oppressive or unfair conduct under the Corporations Act. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the plaintiffs had standing to bring the action and whether certain breaches of duty had occurred.

The court found that the joint venture did not create a partnership, and therefore, remedies under the Partnership Act were not available. The court held that a right to terminate the joint venture upon reasonable notice could not be implied into the JV. However, a right to terminate for repudiation could be implied, though Mr Orfanos did not rely on a breach or repudiation when he terminated the joint venture. The claim for partition and sale of the property was dismissed as the joint venture remained active, and Mr Orfanos still had the option to sell his interest. The court also found that the defendants had not breached any fiduciary duties or trust obligations as the plaintiffs failed to establish that the defendants were paying less than the market rent. Consequently, the plaintiffs' claims under the Corporations Act were dismissed as the alleged breaches of fiduciary duty did not occur.

In conclusion, the court dismissed all claims brought by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs remained entitled to sell their interest in the joint venture according to the terms of the JV, and the court found no basis for the various other remedies sought.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

While in essence the plaintiffs seek to realise their interest in the subject property, the remedies they have sought are wide-ranging.[1] They include a declaration, an order for winding up under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), orders for the termination of a trust, the sale of land and the distribution of proceeds, orders regulating the affairs of a company in the future including the sale of its land and the distribution of the proceeds, an order for the dissolution of a partnership, equitable compensation for breach of fiduciary duty, orders for an account or an enquiry as to profits and payment of monies, an indemnity, costs and interest. Background[1] Strictly speaking, the interest is held by the second plaintiff, Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd.The parties The third plaintiff, Nicholas Orfanos, is a chartered accountant by profession and has practised for many years as a liquidator. He conducts his practice through Orfanos Corporate Services Pty Ltd. He ceased to conduct his practice from the subject premises in December 2007. Mr Orfanos is also a director of the second plaintiff, Orfanos Nominees Pty Ltd, and the sole director of the first plaintiff, Blong Ume Nominees Pty Ltd (“Blong Ume”).[2] The standing of Blong Ume to institute these proceedings is disputed by the defendants (other than the first defendant).[2] Pronounced “Belong You Me”. The fourth defendant, Michael Michaels, is also a chartered accountant. He conducts his practice under the aegis of Sims Richmond Pty Ltd at the subject premises. Mr Michaels is a shareholder in and the sole director of Melrob Investments Pty Ltd (“Melrob”), the second defendant. The fifth defendant, Willem (Bill) Ouwens, has practised for over forty years as a solicitor. His firm is Ouwens Lawyers. He is a director of and a shareholder in the third defendant, Ouwens Corporate Services Pty Ltd (“OCS”). The directors of that company comprise Mr Ouwens, his wife Sue, his daughter Karina (a solicitor) and his son Alex (a real estate agent). Mr Ouwens is the Honorary Consul for the Netherlands in South Australia and the Northern Territory. He conducts his legal practice and also the work of the consulate from the subject premises. OCS is paid by the Government of the Netherlands for the processing of passport and visa applications and other consular work. The first defendant, Semweb Nominees Pty Ltd (“Semweb”), is the trustee of a trust that was settled under a trust deed dated 25 November 2002 (“the Trust”) entered into by Semweb, Orfanos Nominees, Melrob and OCS. Semweb is the registered proprietor of the relevant land and holds it subject to the Trust. Only three shares have been issued in Semweb. One share is held by each of Mr Orfanos, Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens (for brevity I will collectively refer to them where relevant as “the Three Principals”). The Three Principals are the only directors of Semweb. In many instances the correspondence exchanged by the Three Principals referred to a natural person when the legal rights under discussion were actually vested in a body corporate, e.g. an email message might refer to “Nick” when the holder of the legal interest was actually Orfanos Corporate Services. In other cases reference was made to an incorrect body corporate, e.g. Orfanos Corporate Services when the relevant legal entity was actually Orfanos Nominees. Loose identification of this type is commonplace between persons who know each other well and where the body corporate is controlled by the named person. It appears the parties sometimes only took care to identify the person or entity correctly when they engaged in formal transactions. The references I make to entities or natural persons when referring to the contents of correspondence will replicate the description of the entity or person used in the relevant document. In no case was there any uncertainty about the identity of the person or entity being referred to in the documents. Purchase of the land

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I accept the submission of the plaintiffs that when the Court assesses under the Corporations Act whether the conduct of Mr Ouwens and Mr Michaels was oppressive and unfairly prejudicial to Mr Orfanos it may take into account the allegations that they had breached the fiduciary and statutory duties owed to Semweb, even though the plaintiffs have not sought leave to bring a derivative action. Documentary evidence A great deal of the evidence in this matter comprises documentary evidence of communications that passed between the parties, particularly by way of email message. While the volume of that evidence is very large, it is necessary to set out that material at length. On 5 May 2006, Mr Ouwens sent an email message to Mr Orfanos about the OCS² joint venture. He confirmed that Mr Orfanos had advised him orally on 29 April 2006 that from 1 July 2006 Mr Orfanos did not intend to continue the arrangement whereby Orfanos Corporate Services and OCS leased the first floor of the Property from Semweb. Mr Ouwens noted that Mr Orfanos had stated that it was a matter for Mr Ouwens to decide whether Orfanos Corporate Services paid the rent for its office space to Semweb or to OCS. Mr Ouwens asserted that the unilateral action taken by Mr Orfanos had repudiated and breached their agreement. His daughter, Karina Ouwens, and Mr Michaels agreed there had been a repudiation. Nevertheless, both Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens intended to abide by the agreement. Mr Ouwens noted that Mr Orfanos had requested Ms McLean to calculate the expected income and expenses for OCS² up to 30 June 2006 so as to assist Mr Orfanos wind down affairs. Mr Ouwens stated that OCS did not wish to assist Mr Orfanos in his repudiation of their agreement. Therefore, Ms McLean had been instructed not to provide assistance in the manner sought by Mr Orfanos. Mr Ouwens also noted the statement by Mr Orfanos that he was not willing to provide funds to OCS² to meet the expenses currently due to OCS for Ms McLean’s services until she provided the calculations that he had requested. Mr Ouwens said that there was no relationship between that calculation and with Mr Orfanos’ refusal to provide money to OCS². Mr Ouwens asked Mr Orfanos to advise him within several days when he would make funds available to OCS² to allow it to pay OCS in respect of the debt that had accrued over the previous 16 months without the knowledge of Mr Ouwens. On 30 June 2006, Mr Orfanos responded to Mr Ouwens’ message dated 5 May 2006. Mr Orfanos asserted that there was no enforceable agreement covering the first floor tenancy, nor was there any enforceable partnership or joint venture agreement between him and Mr Ouwens in relation to the first floor. He also asserted that the OCS² joint venture had never had an agreed timeframe. The OCS² joint venture had been set up to collect rent and out of pocket expenses from each tenant for payment to Semweb or service providers. Mr Orfanos reiterated that because the joint venture was not working he had advised Mr Ouwens on 29 April 2006 that it was to cease on 30 June 2006. He had suggested two options when he met with Mr Ouwens on 29 April 2006. First, he would pay the rent to Mr Ouwens who would then pay Semweb or, alternatively, he would pay Semweb directly. Secondly, the value of the assets of the OCS² joint venture should be split between them and Mr Orfanos would finalise OSC² matters with the ATO and the bank.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The plaintiffs have also sought orders under s 36 and s 59C of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) that the Trust be revoked and its assets distributed. Clearly, those remedies are dependent upon a finding that Semweb breached its duties as trustee due to the alleged failure to ensure that the market rent was paid by OCS and Sims Richmond. As that allegation has not been made out, there is no basis to grant relief under the Trustee Act.Conclusion My findings may be summarised as follows:(a)The joint venture did not give rise to a partnership. Thus, the remedies under the Partnership Act are not available;(b)A right to terminate the joint venture upon the giving of reasonable notice cannot be implied into the JVD;(c)A right to terminate the joint venture for breach cannot be implied into the JVD. However, a right to terminate for repudiation can be implied. However, Mr Orfanos did not rely upon a breach or repudiation when he gave notice on 10 September 2012 of the termination of the joint venture;(d)The claim for partition and sale of the Property under the Law of Property Act must also be dismissed because the joint venture remains on foot and Mr Orfanos still has the option to exercise his right to sell the Property in accordance with cl 9 of the JVD;(e)The claim that OCS and Sims Richmond paid less than the market rent for their office accommodation in the Property after December 2007 has not been established on the balance of probabilities;(f)While the participants in the joint venture owed each other fiduciary duties, the breaches of duty alleged by the plaintiffs are entirely dependent upon the contention that Mr Ouwens and Mr Michaels had exercised their power over Semweb so as to permit Sims Richmond and OCS to pay less than the market rent. As the allegation that Sims Richmond and OCS were paying less than the market rent has not been established to the satisfaction of the Court, there has been no breach of fiduciary duty;(g)For the same reason, the breaches of trust alleged against Semweb and also the breaches of the JVD and the Trust Deed alleged against Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens have not been established;(h)The conduct of Mr Orfanos in relation to the termination of the OCS2 joint venture would not have provided a basis to refuse relief on discretionary grounds if the plaintiffs had otherwise made out their claim for relief connected with or arising from the alleged underpayment of rent;(i)The plaintiffs were entitled to proceed in respect of the duties said to be owed to Mr Orfanos and Orfanos Nominees by Mr Michaels and Mr Ouwens, even though they had not sought leave from the Court to bring a derivative action against Semweb in respect of the cognate duties said to be owed to Semweb by Mr Ouwens and Mr Michaels; and(j)the claims for relief on various grounds under the Corporations Act have not been made out. The result of my findings is that Mr Orfanos remains entitled to sell his interest in the joint venture in accordance with cl 9 of the JVD. Thus, the contractual rights he obtained in 2002 when he entered the joint venture remain available to him. The fact that the sale price for a partial interest in the Property may be less than the value of a proportionate interest in the Property is a consequence of the JVA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.