Reschke v Trevor Reschke Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

RESCHKE v TREVOR RESCHKE NOMINEES PTY LTD; RESCHKE v AUSTRALIAN EXECUTOR TRUSTEES LTD

[2020] SASC 60

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

23 April 2020

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS - FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION - STIFLING OF LITIGATION

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS - FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION - JUSTICE OF CASE

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS - FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION

The plaintiff in separate actions sues the beneficiaries of the estates of, or gifts by, his father and grandmother claiming an entitlement to the beneficial ownership of, or alternatively a lien over, land in the Coonawarra region. He relies on causes of action of constructive trust, estoppel and equitable lien.

The defendants in each action apply for security for costs. They seek security for costs totalling $300,000 and rely on evidence that the value of the plaintiff’s assets is $400,000 and on a contention that the plaintiff’s assets are likely to be exhausted by paying his own legal costs by the end of the actions, such that they will not recover their costs if they are successful in the actions. They contend that an order for security is necessary in the interests of justice within the meaning of rule 194(1)(e) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA).

Held:

1. The defendants have discharged the onus of proving on the balance of probabilities that, if security is not ordered, the plaintiff’s financial position is such that they will not recover their costs if they are successful in the actions (at [54]).

2. The plaintiff did not adduce any evidence that an order for security will stultify the actions (at [55]).

3. Orders for security should be made. The parties are to be heard on the terms of the order (at [64]-[66]).

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 194(1); Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1335(1), referred to.
Idoport Pty Limited v National Australia Bank Limited (No 35) [2001] NSWSC 744; John Irving as Liquidator of Mawson KLM Holdings Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Starmaker (No 51) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] SASC 310; Li v State of New South Wales [2013] NSWCA 165; Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72; Roctor Tanks Pty Ltd v Adam [2001] SASC 196; Adelaide (SA Pools & Spa) Manufacturing and Installation Pty Ltd v Westcourt General Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd [2016] SASC 60; Dictating Machine Centre Pty Ltd v Combe (1981) 26 SASR 316; Strazdins v ANZ Banking Group Ltd [2017] SASC 3; Pearson v Naydler [1977] 3 All ER 531; Bell Wholesale Co Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2 FCR 1; Duke Holdings Ltd (in liquidation) v Duke Group Ltd (in liquidation) [2009] SASC 245, considered.

RESCHKE v TREVOR RESCHKE NOMINEES…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reschke v Trevor Reschke Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Reschke v Trevor Reschke Nominees Pty Ltd involved security for costs applications filed by the defendants in two separate actions against Burke, the plaintiff. These applications were heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central issue before the court was whether Burke should be required to provide security for the defendants' costs in both actions, up until the end of the trial.

The court was required to determine whether the defendants had demonstrated that Burke had sufficient financial resources to cover the costs of the litigation, and whether there were any circumstances that would justify the defendants being granted security for costs. The court considered several factors in making its decision, including the nature and complexity of the claims, the prospects of success for both parties, and the potential for the litigation to be stifled if Burke were not required to provide security for costs.

The court found that Burke had limited personal financial resources and that the defendants had demonstrated that they had a strong likelihood of success in the litigation. The court also noted that the actions involved complex and contentious issues, and that the potential costs of the litigation were significant. Based on these factors, the court concluded that it was necessary in the interests of justice to order Burke to provide security for the defendants' costs.

Accordingly, the court made an order that Burke provide security for the defendants' costs in both actions, up until the end of the trial. The court also noted that it would hear the parties concerning the quantum and form of the security for costs to be ordered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons address the security for costs applications. BackgroundLand ownership and transfers In his current statements of claim in the two actions, Burke pleads details of the ownership and transfer of land the subject of the actions. Defences are yet to be filed to those statements of claim.[1] Set out below is a summary of the effect of Burke’s pleadings which may or may not prove to be contentious when relevant defences are filed. Self-evidently, I make no findings of fact but, for ease of expression, set out the matters pleaded as if they were uncontroversial.[1] A defence was filed to the original statement of claim in the first action. No defence has been filed in the second action. Burke’s paternal grandparents were Reginald Reschke (Reg) and Emiline. Reg inherited, was gifted and acquired land in the Hundred of Comaum in the Coonawarra region, which was held in his own name or by a corporate trustee on behalf of a trust effectively controlled by him (collectively Reg’s land). All references in these reasons for judgment to sections or lots are references to sections or lots in the Hundred of Comaum. Reg and Emiline had five children: Trevor, Tricia Schooley (nee Reschke) (Tricia), Vivienne Reschke (Vivienne), Leone Falcone (nee Reschke) (Leone) and Jennifer Tolley (nee Reschke) (Jennifer). Reg died in 1986. He devised some of Reg’s land to Emiline, being allotments 1, 2 and 3 in section 438 (Emiline’s land). Reg devised the balance of Reg’s land held in his own name, and ownership and control of the land-holding trusts and trustee companies, to Trevor. Emiline also acquired section 439 (section 439), either by devise from Reg or in some other manner. In the meantime, Trevor had married Vivian Reschke (Vivian). They had three children: Burke, Dru Reschke (Dru) and Joanne Edwards (nee Reschke) (Joanne). Trevor inherited, was gifted and acquired land in the Hundred of Comaum, which was held in his own name or by a corporate trustee on behalf of a trust effectively controlled by him (collectively Trevor’s land). Burke established or acquired Reschke Vineyards Pty Ltd (and other companies). Dru established or acquired Altruism Holdings Pty Ltd (Altruism) as trustee of the Altruism Trust. Before 2007, Trevor transferred sections 440, 441, 442 and 444 to a trustee of a superannuation fund of which the beneficiaries were Trevor and Vivian (the Reschke Super Fund). Before 2007, Emiline transferred section 439 to Altruism. Trevor died in 2008. At that time, Trevor’s land included:·sections 226, 227 and 228 owned by Trevor (the Reg Reschke vineyard);·allotment 4 in section 438 owned by Trevor (lot 4);·sections 233, 234 and 235 (Glenroy) owned by Trevor Reschke Nominees Pty Ltd (TRN);·sections 239, 377 and 379 (Rocky Castle) owned by Fabriano Pty Ltd (Fabriano); and·an interest in sections 440, 441, 442 and 444 (Portion Home Block) via his interest (shared with Vivian) in the Reschke Super Fund. By his will, Trevor left the Reg Reschke vineyard to Burke; lot 4 to Dru; his shares in TRN (and hence control of Glenroy) to Dru; and his shares in Fabriano (and hence control of Rocky Castle) to Vivian. Trevor left his superannuation interests in the Reschke Super Fund (and thereby in Portion Home Block) to Vivian by their being transferred to VF Reschke Super Pty Ltd (Vivian Reschke Super) as trustee of the Vivian Reschke Super Fund.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Applications were also made at the same time in both actions by the defendants for dismissal of the actions and by Burke for permission to amend his statements of claim. Those applications were ultimately resolved when Burke filed new statements of claim, the latter of which was filed in the Emiline estate action in March 2020.Evidence on security for costs applications The defendants in the Trevor estate action tendered an affidavit by their principal solicitor Mark Gowans and a portion of an affidavit by a more junior solicitor Kelly Fussell. The defendants in the Emiline estate action tendered an affidavit by their principal solicitor Pam McEwen and an affidavit by Jennifer which exhibited Emiline’s will and a statement of assets and liabilities of the estate. The applications were heard on the basis that evidence adduced by either set of defendants was evidence for the purposes of both applications. Burke did not adduce any evidence. Mr Gowans deposed to searches undertaken at the Lands Titles Office in relation to real property owned by Burke and gave evidence that the only real property owned by him is section 443 (section 443). The certificate of title for section 443 shows that the land is approximately 30 acres. Mr Gowans produced two tables that had been exhibited to an affidavit by Burke in the caveat action setting out his assets (Burke’s tables). Burke’s tables show that Burke’s only asset in his own name is section 443 and Burke attributed a value to it of $120,049. The certificate of title for section 443 appears to show that the land is subject to a mortgage in favour of the National Australia Bank. However, Burke’s tables do not show any liability associated with section 443 and counsel for the defendants in the Trevor estate action (without demur by counsel for the defendants in the Emiline estate action) accepts that section 443 is not subject to any mortgage. I therefore proceed on that premise. The affidavits of Mr Gowans and Ms Fussell show that Burke had formerly been a proprietor of his former matrimonial home at North Adelaide but his interest was transferred to his then wife in 2015 and the property has now been sold in any event. Burke’s tables show assets and liabilities of four companies owned or controlled by him, being Reschke Vineyards, Reschke Pty Ltd, Koonara Management Pty Ltd and Rocky Castle Finance Pty Ltd. Conversely the defendants adduced evidence that Koonara Management Pty Ltd and Rocky Castle Finance Pty Ltd have incurred a significant cost liability as a result of their prosecution of an unsuccessful action in the Federal Court. It was agreed by all parties that, for the purpose of my assessment of Burke’s resources for the purpose of the current applications, any assets or liabilities associated with Burke’s corporate entities are to be ignored. The statement of assets and liabilities of Emiline’s estate shows that the Valuer-General’s valuation of the Emiline land as at 2014 (when Emiline died) was $1,620,000 and the value of all assets of the estate was $2,892,296. Expenses of the estate would include commission payable to AET and funeral expenses, which are not shown in the statement of assets and liabilities.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am satisfied that it is necessary in the interests of justice to order that Burke provide security for the costs of the defendants in the actions.Conclusion The defendants are entitled to an order that Burke provide security for costs. The security sought by the defendants is in respect of their party/party costs to the end of trial. Although it is more common to order security for costs after the first day of trial and consider further security at that point, in view of the manner in which the defendants formulated their requests for security for costs to the end of trial, I am disposed to make an order of that basis. However, I will hear the parties concerning the quantum and form of the security for costs to be ordered.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.