Ascf Managed Investments Pty Ltd v De Pasquale

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

ASCF MANAGED INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v DE PASQUALE & ORS

[2023] SASC 157

Judgment of the Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis  

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS - FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS - FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION - STIFLING OF LITIGATION

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS - FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION - PLAINTIFF'S OR APPLICANT'S IMPECUNIOSITY

This is an application by ASCF Managed Investments Pty Ltd (ASCF) and several cross-respondents for security for costs.

These proceedings commenced with an application by ASCF to enforce a mortgage over the Simcock Street residence of the respondents to that application, Antonio and Sally De Pasquale (the De Pasquales), and their companies. The De Pasquales have cross-claimed against ASCF and other financiers, brokers and solicitors, alleging unconscionable conduct, fraud, conspiracy, misrepresentation and negligence.

ASCF submits that the De Pasquales and their companies are impecunious. ASCF further submits that an order for security for costs should be made because the cross-claim extends beyond a defensible action; the trial will likely exceed seven weeks; there are likely to be ongoing disputes about particulars; and discovery will be a substantial exercise.

Held:

1.      The applications for security for costs are dismissed.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1335; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 115.1, referred to.
Adelaide (SA Pools & Spa) Manufacturing and Installation Pty Ltd v Westcourt General Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd [2016] SASC 60; Dae Boong International Co Pty Ltd v Gray [2009] NSWCA 11; Dictating Machine Centre Pty Ltd v Combe (1981) 26 SASR 316; Madgwick v Kelly [2013] FCAFC 61; Mannix Electrical Pty Ltd v Belport Pty Ltd (2019) 134 SASR 438; Merribee Pastoral Industries Pty Ltd & Ors v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1998) 193 CLR 502; Pearson v Naydler [1977] 3 All ER 531; Reschke v Trevor Reschke Nominees Pty Ltd; Reschke v Australian Executor Trustees Ltd [2020] SASC 60; Strazdins v ANZ Banking Group Ltd [2017] SASC 3, considered.

ASCF MANAGED INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v DE PASQUALE & ORS
[2023] SASC 157

Civil - Application

  1. KOURAKIS CJ:  These proceedings commenced with an application by ASCF Managed Investments Pty Ltd (ASCF) to enforce a mortgage over the Simcock Street residence (Simcock Street) of the respondents to that application, Antonio and Sally De Pasquale.  Sally and Antonio (jointly the De Pasquales) have cross‑claimed against ASCF and other financiers, brokers and solicitors, alleging unconscionable conduct, fraud, conspiracy, misrepresentation and negligence.  On I June 2023, I dismissed applications brought by a number of the cross-respondents for separate trials of the claims made against them.  This is an application by ASCF and several of the cross-respondents for security for costs.  The narrative which follows is derived largely from the allegations made in the cross-claim…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ascf Managed Investments Pty Ltd v De Pasquale and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 157
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Ascf Managed Investments Pty Ltd v De Pasquale, the primary dispute revolves around the De Pasquales' application for security for costs. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central issue for the court was to determine whether the De Pasquales were entitled to an order for security for costs in the context of a cross-claim against multiple respondents, including ASCF Managed Investments Pty Ltd, FMCL, Borg, and DePasquale Enterprises. The De Pasquales argued that they were impecunious and that their cross-claim against the respondents was complex and likely to be lengthy, with substantial discovery issues, justifying the need for security for costs.

The court considered various factors relevant to the exercise of discretion in granting security for costs, as identified by Mitchell J in Dictating Machine Centre Pty Ltd v Combe. These factors included the impecuniosity of the applicant, the prospect of the applicant's claim succeeding, and the potential for the application to stifle litigation. ASCF argued that the De Pasquales' claims lacked foundation and were oppressive. The court found that while the De Pasquales were indeed impecunious due to earlier transactions with other parties, their delay in bringing the cross-claim was not unreasonable given their priority to secure their home. The court concluded that the application for security for costs should be dismissed as the De Pasquales had acted reasonably promptly in bringing their cross-action after securing their home, and the potential for the application to stifle litigation was not sufficiently demonstrated.

The court further reasoned that the claims made by the De Pasquales had an evidential foundation and were not without merit. The court found that the De Pasquales' delay in bringing the cross-claim did not significantly prejudice the respondents, and the need for security for costs was not substantiated. The court balanced the competing interests of the parties and determined that the De Pasquales' impecuniosity did not warrant an order for security for costs. Consequently, the applications for security for costs were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FMCL complains that there is no foundation for the unconscionability claim. It also contends that there is no foundation for the alleged duty to make further enquiries, nor to require that the De Pasquales receive separate legal advice. It submits that it could not have known what, if any, arrangements had been made within Conatur Legal in respect of such matters. The allegations made against FMCL have an evidential foundation capable of proving the elements of unconscionability referred to in [45] above. FMCL also complains that it is not pleaded how the absence of information about income and serviceability gave rise to knowledge or a realisation that recovery would depend on realisation of the security. Those submissions are unrealistic given that the repayment of the loan depended entirely on the Leffler interests quickly on-selling the Payneham units. If they were not sold, the security offered by the De Pasquales and Depent would almost certainly be lost. Conclusion I dismiss the applications for security for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Dictating Machine Centre Pty Ltd v Combe,[13] Mitchell J identified seven potential factors that are often considered, namely: 1.the true role of the applicant; 2.the existence of any special relationship between the applicant and the respondent; 3.the time at which the application for security for costs is made; 4.whether the applicant’s claim is bona fide; 5.the prospect of the applicant’s claim succeeding; 6.the oppressive use of the application for security; and 7.the applicant’s want of means induced by the respondent. [13] (1981) 26 SASR 316.Consideration ASCF submits that it is plain that the De Pasquales, Depent and DePasquale Enterprises are impecunious. So much can be accepted. ASCF submits that on a proper balancing of their respective competing interests an order for security for costs should be made because:·the cross-claim extends beyond a defensive action;·the claims made against multiple cross respondents are complex and the trial is likely to exceed seven weeks;·there are likely to be ongoing disputes about particulars before the pleadings have closed;·discovery will be a substantial exercise (that submission is made as to the company). ASCF submits that it has not been shown that they are the cause of the De Pasquales’ impecuniosity. That, too, can be accepted. It was the earlier transactions with FMCL and Borg which have left them impecunious. ASCF complains that the De Pasquales could have brought the cross-claim against the broker’s solicitors, FMCL and Borg earlier. However, ASCF issued a Notice of Default against the De Pasquales in 2019, and then brought proceedings for an order for possession. That order was granted by a Master of this Court on 19 December 2019. The De Pasquales appealed to a single Judge of this Court who, on 2 March 2021, made orders allowing the appeal and transferring the application to the ordinary civil list to continue on the pleadings. A defence was filed by the De Pasquales on 16 August 2022, and a counterclaim and third-party claim was filed on 17 August 2022. A revision of the statement of cross-claim was filed on 22 August 2022, bringing the claims against the other respondents. The cross-respondents entered appearances between 22 August 2022 and 9 September 2022. I accept that if the litigation had been conducted as expeditiously as it could be, a sight which is rarely seen, the De Pasquales ought to have brought proceedings against the other respondents earlier. However, naturally enough, their first priority was to save their Simcock Street home. After they had secured their home, pending litigation in the ordinary civil list, they acted reasonably promptly in bringing their cross action. In any event, it is most unlikely that the actions against the other cross‑respondents would have progressed very far even if initiated earlier. Given the commonality of the factual context of all of their cross-claims, the actions against the cross-respondents are likely to have been consolidated with the actions against ASCF for reasons similar to those I gave for dismissing of the application for separate trials.