Repipe Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Repipe Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents [2019] FCA 1956

File number: WAD 323 of 2018
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 22 November 2019
Catchwords: PATENTS – validity – manner of manufacture under s 18(1A)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) – Encompass Corporation Pty Ltd v InfoTrack Pty Ltd (2019) 145 IPR 1 applied – whether the patents, methods and systems for providing and receiving information for risk management in the field, are patentable subject matter – nature of the technical contributions of the patents considered
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 18(1A)(a)

Cases cited:

CCOM Pty Ltd v Jiejing Pty Ltd (1994) 51 FCR 260

Commissioner of Patents v Microcell Ltd (1959) 102 CLR 232

Commissioner of Patents v RPL Central Pty Limited (2015) 238 FCR 27

D’Arcy v Myriad Genetics Inc (2015) 258 CLR 334

Data Access Corporation v Powerflex Services Pty Ltd (1999) 202 CLR 1

Encompass Corporation Pty Ltd v InfoTrack Pty Ltd (2018) 130 IPR 387

Encompass Corporation Pty Ltd v InfoTrack Pty Ltd (2019) 145 IPR 1

Grant v Commissioner of Patents (2006) 154 FCR 62

International Business Machines Corporation v Commissioner of Patents (1991) 33 FCR 218

National Research Development Corporation v Commissioner of Patents (1959) 102 CLR 252

Repipe Pty Ltd [2018] APO 42

Research Affiliates LLC v Commissioner of Patents (2014) 227 FCR 378

Rokt Pte Ltd v Commissioner of Patents [2018] FCA 1988

Welcome Real-Time SA v Catuity Inc (2001) 113 FCR 110

Winner v Ammar Holdings Pty Ltd (1993) 41 FCR 205

Date of hearing: 25-27 June 2019
Date of last submissions: 25 October 2019
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and Associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 101
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr N Murray SC with Ms F St John
Solicitor for the Appellant: Mallon & Co Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C Dimitriadis SC with Mr C Burgess
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

WAD 323 of 2018
BETWEEN:

REPIPE PTY LTD

Appellant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 NOVEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties confer to bring in a minute reflecting these reasons within 14 days.

2.Any dispute on the content of the minute be addressed by written submissions not exceeding five pages to be dealt with by the Court on the papers unless otherwise ordered.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MCKERRACHER J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. Repipe Pty Ltd was the registered proprietor of two Australian Innovation Patents.  They are described as number 2017100560, entitled ‘Methods and Systems for Providing and Receiving Information For Risk Management in the Field’ (the 560 Patent) and number 2017100943, entitled ‘Methods and Systems for Providing and Receiving Information For Risk Management in the Field’ (the 943 Patent) (together, the Patents).  A delegate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Repipe Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1956
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Repipe Pty Ltd brought an appeal against the Commissioner of Patents over the revocation of their patents concerning methods and systems for providing and receiving information for risk management in the field. The central legal issue was whether the patents in question constitute a 'manner of manufacture' as defined by s 18(1A)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The court examined whether the inventions claimed in the patents were patentable subject matter, considering the technical contributions of the patents. Repipe argued that the patents disclose technological inventions where computer technology is integral and significant, whereas the Commissioner contended that the patents merely describe a business method or scheme implemented using computers.

The court found that the patents, despite their reliance on specific software applications, do not disclose a technical means by which ordinary computing functions are performed. The claimed inventions were characterised as a business method rather than a technical advance, as they primarily use computers to share and complete documents in a more convenient manner. The specifications of the patents admit that the claimed inventions can be implemented using any software application, indicating that the inventions lack a specific technical contribution. The court concluded that the patents do not meet the criteria for patentability as they do not constitute a manner of manufacture.

The court's decision was grounded in the principle that a claimed method implemented by a computer does not become patentable merely because it is executed by a computer. The inventions, while potentially useful, do not offer a technical advance or contribution to computing. The court found that the claims and specifications do not define or disclose any specific technical means by which the ordinary computing functions are performed. As a result, the patents were held to be invalid, and the appeal was dismissed. The parties were directed to confer and prepare a minute reflecting these reasons within 14 days, with any disputes to be resolved by written submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer to bring in a minute reflecting these reasons within 14 days.

2. Any dispute on the content of the minute be addressed by written submissions not exceeding five pages to be dealt with by the Court on the papers unless otherwise ordered.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Patents contemplate that alerts can be provided to GPS-tracked field personnel when particular on-site events occur.CHRONOLOGY AND AGREED FACTS AND ISSUES Both the Patents claim divisional status from international patent application PCT/AU2016/050179 (published as WO 2016/141442). As noted, the earliest priority date of both Patents is 12 March 2015. As to the subsequent chronology, a Request for Examination of the 560 Patent was filed on 17 May 2017. The 560 Patent was granted on 1 June 2017. Adverse examination reports were issued on 3 August 2017, 22 November 2017 and 29 January 2018. Repipe proposed amendments to the claims in the 560 Patent on 17 January 2018. Repipe requested to be heard on 2 February 2018. A Request for Examination of the 943 Patent was filed on 10 July 2017. The 943 Patent was granted on 20 July 2017. Adverse examination reports were issued on 7 September 2017, 22 November 2017 and 5 March 2018. Repipe proposed amendments to the claims in the 943 Patent on 27 February 2018. Repipe requested to be heard on 7 March 2018. The hearing in relation to the Patents took place in Melbourne on 10 April 2018. By way of examination, the Commissioner, by a delegate, delivered the Decision on 28 June 2018, which determined that the Patents should be revoked: Repipe Pty Ltd [2018] APO 42. The delegate revoked the Patents because the inventions, so far as claimed, were not a manner of manufacture within the meaning of s 18(1A)(a) of the Patents Act. The delegate further held that there was no patentable subject matter in the applications: the Decision (at [69]). Repipe lodged the appeal to this Court on 17 July 2018. Repipe appeals, under s 101F(4) of the Patents Act, from the whole of the Decision. It is common ground between the parties that:(1)There is often a disconnect between policy and procedure on the one hand, and what happens in the workplace on the other. (2)Risk management often entails the implementation of complex and overlapping procedures, particularly in high risk environments.(3)The tasks performed by a computer or smartphone may involve routine computer functions. A computer or smartphone does not perform ingenious functions simply because it has been loaded with specific software.(4)The technology that existed for database management is generally as described by Assoc Prof Hussain in his affidavit dated 20 March 2019 (at [18]-[26]) to the following effect:(a)In March 2015, databases and associated database programming were commonly used to store, combine, compare, provide access to, and display information. These databases and the associated database programming could provide information to users of portable electronic devices over a communications network, such as the internet. Applications of this database technology included programs installed on mobile phones to allow users to access data held by banks and insurance companies. These programs relied on a single database or multiple databases managed by the bank or insurance company, and a server which communicated with the user’s device. These programs were capable of displaying a customised document to the user, which the user could then interact with. For example, a user could input data into a form. Such programs were commonly used in March 2015.(b)In March 2015, there were two broad approaches to storing the information that would be required for a tool such as the one described in Patent 560. The two broad approaches were ‘SQL databases’ and ‘NoSQL databases’. (c)SQL databases can be regarded as a storage mechanism wherein information is stored in ‘tables’ and relations between the tables. A table is a structure in which information is stored in ‘records’. Each record has a number of ‘fields’. For example, a table might be created to store information about vehicles owned by a company. The table would include a record for each vehicle. Each vehicle record would include a series of fields, which might include the numberplate, brand, model and colour of each vehicle in the table. Information can be stored in one or more of the fields that are associated with each record. Tables can be related to each other. SQL databases are not flexible when it comes to changing the fields of a table or the relations between tables. (d)NoSQL databases on the other hand do not impose a pre-defined scheme or structure. Instead, they lend themselves to storing information (such as documents) in a way that allows the database to develop to suit unexpected types of information. NoSQL databases increased in popularity between about 1998 and about 2010. Generally speaking, NoSQL databases lend themselves easily to customisations. By March 2015, a number of commercially-available NoSQL database implementations or solutions were available.(e)Cloud-based services were used to deliver many applications involving databases in March 2015. Applications that use cloud-based services, such as cloud-based databases, can be more convenient for small organisations as they reduce the complexity of the task of procuring, hosting, managing and backing up the databases. (f)In March 2015, information in databases was commonly compared, combined, analysed and displayed to users using algorithms. Information about geographic location or time could be combined with information in the database to produce alerts or warnings that were sent or displayed to a user based on their location, the location of another user or an object, the time of day and the passage of a period of time. (g)In March 2015, it was possible for databases to be designed and implemented in a way that assigned different roles to different users. A user’s role could be used to control their access to information in the database, to control their ability to change information in the database, and to define whether they were alerted to changes to the information in the database.(5)Implementing the invention claimed in the Patents requires the combination of known hardware components, which would need to be programmed to perform the invention.(6)The PCT application from which the Patents were divided had an International Search Report with four documents cited. One of the cited documents was US2004/0078098, titled ‘Computer System for Assessing Hazards’ (Jeffries Patent).(7)There is a difference between the user roles described in the 560 Patent and the authorised persons mentioned in the Jeffries Patent.(8)The Jeffries Patent does not involve updating information and providing it to other people in the field.(9)There are differences between the nature of the report in the Jeffries Patent and the dynamic document claimed in the 943 Patent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Full Court in Encompass explained (at [91]):In each case, the Full Court was seeking to describe the conceptual distinction between a manner of manufacture and an unpatentable abstraction. In each case, the Full Court was explaining that a claimed method that is unpatentable does not change its legal character merely because the method is implemented by the instrumentality of a computer.EVIDENCE Repipe relied on two affidavits made by Dr Aitken: first, an affidavit deposed to on 10 December 2018 (Aitken 1); and, secondly, an affidavit deposed to on 22 May 2019 (Aitken 2). He is an expert in computer systems. He gave evidence as to his understanding of the operation and programming of computers and the difference between general-purpose and specific purpose computers and computer implementation as at the priority date. He also gave evidence about the person to whom the Patents are directed, the nature of the inventions in the Patents, what is needed to implement the inventions in the Patents and whether programming a computer to implement the inventions is technical in nature. The Commissioner’s expert was Assoc Prof Hussain. He is a tenured academic with expertise in developing and implementing databases. Evidence was also foreshadowed by the Commissioner’s Workplace Health and Safety/Risk Management (WHS) expert, Ms Shaw. Repipe also foreshadowed reliance on two affidavits of Mr McDonald, who is a risk management consultant. Ultimately, that evidence was not adduced.DO THE PATENTS DISCLOSE A ‘MANNER OF MANUFACTURE’? Repipe argues that both Patents are not merely business methods or schemes implemented using a computer. The computer is not merely an intermediary or a tool. Rather, the Patents claim technological inventions where the computer technology is integral to, and is the most significant feature of, the claims. For the Commissioner it is contended that the substance of the invention claimed in each of the Patents is an unpatentable business, method or scheme. On the Commissioner’s reading, what Repipe claims is a scheme for sharing and completing workplace health and safety documents. It is implemented by using computers to perform their ordinary functions, there being no invention in the way that the computers carry out the scheme or method. The Commissioner particularly emphasises that the claimed inventions use ordinary computing functions to share and enable completion of the necessary forms, as is apparent from the words used in the claims themselves: for example, ‘selecting a document’, ‘downloading information’, ‘displaying the downloaded information’, ‘receiving input’ and ‘uploading the input’. In short, it is argued that the claims do not define, and the specifications do not disclose, any technical means by which these ordinary computing functions are performed. No such means is described, because the inventions are not a technical advance or contribution to computing. The inventions are a mere scheme that utilise the well-understood ability of computers to enable documents to be shared and completed in a faster and more convenient way.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It may well be that specific software needs to be designed to achieve the ‘invention’, but even so, that is not the substance of the claimed inventions. As to the ‘specific application software’:(a)No software application or program code for carrying out the identified steps in the computer is defined by the claims or made the subject of the claims. (b)No software application or program code for carrying out the identified steps in the computer is disclosed anywhere in the complete specifications. (c)The specifications admit that the claimed inventions may be implemented using any software application, that uses any technical means, that causes a generic server and smartphone to perform the claimed steps. (d)The ‘specific application software’ referred to by Dr Aitken is something that must be developed and written by a programmer in order to implement the claimed inventions.CONCLUSION The claimed inventions are as to a business method. Even if construction of the specifications alone were to produce a different characterisation, that would be to elevate form over substance. The Patents may well contain a good idea, but they are not a manner of manufacture and are not patentable subject matters.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Repipe contends claim 5 is an independent claim comprising the same three components previously identified. The Commissioner argues claim 5 of the 943 Patent is a ‘system’ claim, adopting the same general form as claim 5 in RPL. In other words, claim 5 is a system claim that merely specifies the ordinary computing components that may be used to implement the scheme of claim 1 of the 943 Patent, namely, a server, a plurality of portable personal computing devices, a communications channel and a ‘rules engine’. The ‘rules engine’ is simply the programming logic that will determine what the user is permitted to do according to the role and authority the user has. The program logic itself is not disclosed in the specification of the 943 Patent and the specification proceeds on the basis that the existing portable computing devices, servers and communication channels can be programmed in the manner described in claim 5. Compared with claim 1, claim 5 also contains the additional feature of transmitting a response to the information that was uploaded by the worker. This is mere detail about the scheme. CONSIDERATION It is accepted by Repipe that the need to complete routine WHS documents, such as Equipment Pre-Starts, Job Safety Assessments, ‘Take 5’ Assessments and Job Permits identified in the Patents, ‘formed part of the common general knowledge and the regulatory milieu for workplace health and safety before the priority date’. The Patents do not say otherwise. That is, the Patents do not say that the inventiveness or ingenuity of the inventions is in the field of WHS. This, Repipe says, reinforces the centrality of the computer aspects to the claimed inventions. This must be so. Repipe submits, and I accept, that the fact that the Patents do not claim to have invented new hardware does not mean they are not patentable. Nor does the fact that they do not claim to rely on artificial intelligence. Artificial intelligence is not a pre-requisite for patentability of a computer-implemented business method. The solution disclosed in the Patents is put into effect by executing specific software applications on the server and the smartphones. The inventions could not be carried out using a generic or unconfigured server or smartphone, because the tasks those devices must perform are so specific. A generic server or smartphone would not be capable of performing the steps of the method without the addition to each of a specific program to configure and control these devices to do so. Without the appropriate programming, the devices are, as Dr Aitken put it, ‘like a malleable lump of clay without being formed into a bowl shape and fired to form the rigid bowl’. Once configured as required to perform the steps of the claims, the server and smartphones are not generic. The things they must be configured to do are not things they are normally configured to do. It is common ground that the claims assume that software will be written to configure the hardware to carry out the steps of the claim. However, Repipe notes that software is not at large – it must conform to the technical architecture and functional requirements mandated by the claims. By the specifications, the programmer is given the ‘architecture’ of the system and the steps of the method to be performed, including the sequence of operation and functionality of the server and the smartphone. Then the programmer would write code to carry out that logic and sequence of operation and to provide that functionality. The programming will configure the device to perform the necessary functions and will also control the configured capabilities as the devices are operated so that they can move from step to step as required.