Rehn v Australian Football League

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

REHN v AUSTRALIAN FOOTBALL LEAGUE & ORS
[2003] SASC 159

Civil

Doyle CJ

  1. A defendant in an action in this court has appealed against a Master’s Order that the defendant discover and produce for inspection certain documents in the defendant’s possession.

  2. Two main issues arise on the appeal.  Are the documents “directly relevant to any issue arising on the pleadings”, and so documents which the defendant should have discovered, without the necessity for an Order, by virtue of r58A.03?  Alternatively, is the Order supportable under r58A.04(1) on the basis that the documents are “indirectly relevant to any issue arising on the pleadings” and that it is “in the interests of justice” that the documents be discovered and produced?

  3. There is a subsidiary issue of whether one of the plaintiff’s solicitors should be permitted to inspect the documents.

    Facts

  4. The following facts are drawn from the pleadings.  As yet there has not been a trial.

  5. Mr Rehn was employed as a football player for the Adelaide Football Club (“AFC”).  He was employed to play in the national competition conducted by the Australian Football League (“AFL”).  Both AFC and AFL are parties to his contract of employment.

  6. Mr Rehn claims that in 1999 he was “the premier ruckman” playing for AFC and one of the best ruckmen in the AFL competition.

  7. In February 1999 he injured his knee during the course of a game when he slipped on the plate on which the ball was bounced at centre bounces.  He suffered a serious knee injury.

  8. Mr Rehn claims that AFC and AFL and the South Australian National Football League Inc. are liable to pay damages to him for the injury that he sustained.

  9. Mr Rehn claims that he has suffered and will suffer a loss of earning capacity as a result of his injury.  The particulars of loss in the Statement of Claim refer to loss of income earned under his contract as a player: Statement of Claim, para 22.2.13.  The particulars of loss provided under r46.15 refer to loss of income from endorsements.

  10. It is clear enough that Mr Rehn claims damages for impairment of his capacity to earn income as a player and for loss of opportunities to use his standing as a player to gain income from endorsing products and like activities.

    The Master’s order

  11. Mr Rehn sought discovery and production by AFL of contracts held by AFL.  He sought discovery of player contracts (contracts between AFL clubs and players) and marketing contracts (apparently contracts between players and persons willing to pay players for the right to exploit commercially the player’s reputation).   AFL opposed the application.

  12. The Master ordered discovery and production of the following documents:

    “1.1  The playing contracts of every player in the AFL competition who earned the sum of $245,000.00 and above per football season for the 2000, 2001 and 2002 football seasons, limited to the income of each player, the tenure and name of each player

    1.2    The marketing contracts of every player in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rehn v Australian Football League and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rehn v Australian Football League, the plaintiff, Mr Rehn, seeks damages for injuries sustained during his employment as a football player. He claims that he suffered a serious knee injury while playing for the Adelaide Football Club (AFC) under a contract that involved the Australian Football League (AFL). Mr Rehn contends that AFC, AFL, and the South Australian National Football League Inc. are liable for the damages he sustained, which he claims have resulted in a loss of earning capacity both as a player and from lost endorsement opportunities. The case revolves around whether Mr Rehn is entitled to discover and inspect specific documents held by AFL, including player and marketing contracts, to support his claims.

The legal issues before the court pertain to the scope and conditions of document discovery in the context of a personal injury claim. Mr Rehn sought an order for AFL to produce contracts of players earning over a certain threshold for specified seasons, including details about player incomes, tenure, and names, and marketing contracts with similarly restrictive details. The court had to determine whether the Master's order, which allowed for such discovery, was appropriate and whether any conditions imposed on the inspection of these documents were fair and reasonable. Furthermore, the court had to consider whether one of Mr Rehn’s solicitors could inspect these documents without compromising his ability to represent other players in future negotiations with AFL clubs.

The court found that the Master's order for discovery and production of the specified documents was justified given the relevance to Mr Rehn's claims. It held that the undertakings signed by those inspecting the documents, although difficult to observe, did not warrant setting aside or varying the order. The court also concluded that it was for Mr Rehn to decide whether his solicitor could inspect the documents, and any potential issues regarding conflict of interest would be addressed if they arose. The court dismissed the appeal, affirming the Master's order for the discovery and production of the documents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

There is a subsidiary issue of whether one of the plaintiff’s solicitors should be permitted to inspect the documents.Facts The following facts are drawn from the pleadings. As yet there has not been a trial. Mr Rehn was employed as a football player for the Adelaide Football Club (“AFC”). He was employed to play in the national competition conducted by the Australian Football League (“AFL”). Both AFC and AFL are parties to his contract of employment. Mr Rehn claims that in 1999 he was “the premier ruckman” playing for AFC and one of the best ruckmen in the AFL competition. In February 1999 he injured his knee during the course of a game when he slipped on the plate on which the ball was bounced at centre bounces. He suffered a serious knee injury. Mr Rehn claims that AFC and AFL and the South Australian National Football League Inc. are liable to pay damages to him for the injury that he sustained. Mr Rehn claims that he has suffered and will suffer a loss of earning capacity as a result of his injury. The particulars of loss in the Statement of Claim refer to loss of income earned under his contract as a player: Statement of Claim, para 22.2.13. The particulars of loss provided under r46.15 refer to loss of income from endorsements. It is clear enough that Mr Rehn claims damages for impairment of his capacity to earn income as a player and for loss of opportunities to use his standing as a player to gain income from endorsing products and like activities.The Master’s order Mr Rehn sought discovery and production by AFL of contracts held by AFL. He sought discovery of player contracts (contracts between AFL clubs and players) and marketing contracts (apparently contracts between players and persons willing to pay players for the right to exploit commercially the player’s reputation). AFL opposed the application. The Master ordered discovery and production of the following documents:“1.1 The playing contracts of every player in the AFL competition who earned the sum of $245,000.00 and above per football season for the 2000, 2001 and 2002 football seasons, limited to the income of each player, the tenure and name of each player1.2 The marketing contracts of every player in the AFL competition who earned the sum of $245,000.00 and above per football season for the 2000, 2001 and 2002 football seasons, with information pertaining to the identity of third parties to be masked”The Master authorised nominated persons to inspect and to copy the contracts, subject to them signing an undertaking relating to disclosure of the contents of the contracts and to the use of the contents of the contracts. There are some problems with the form of the undertaking, but nothing turns on that. No information was put before the Master or before me that identifies the number of contracts that must be produced. However, AFL exhibited to an affidavit before the Master copies of some of the documents discovered by it, relating to payments to players, presumably under player contracts. One of these documents is a schedule of player payments in which those payments are shown by reference to bands or levels of dollar amounts and the number of players in each band or level.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It will be for Mr Griffin to decide whether to inspect the contracts. If he does, the issue of whether that compromises his ability to represent a player in later negotiations with an AFL club will have to be determined when the issue arises. Presumably the issue will arise if the Club takes objection to him acting. As I have said, I consider that it will be difficult to observe the undertaking. However, as between the parties before me, I consider that this is not a reason to set aside or to vary the order made.Conclusion For those reasons I would dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established