Quenchy Crusta Sales Pty Ltd v Logi-Tech Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

QUENCHY CRUSTA SALES PTY LTD  v  LOGI-TECH PTY LTD & ANOR

[2002] SASC 374

Appeal from a Master

  1. DOYLE CJ:            Quenchy Crusta Sales Pty Ltd (“the plaintiff”) is the plaintiff in an action in this Court.  Sharp Corporation of Australia Pty Ltd (“Sharp”) is the second defendant.

  2. The plaintiff applied for an order that Sharp make further and better discovery of certain documents identified in an affidavit filed in support of the application.  A Master dismissed the application.  The plaintiff appeals against that order.

  3. The appeal challenges only one of the bases upon which the Master dismissed the application.

  4. Very briefly, there had been a previous application for an order for further and better discovery relating to the same documents.  The Master dismissed that application.  Later, an expert retained by Sharp, in a report provided by Sharp to the plaintiff, made use of a document summarising the effect of, or drawing from, the same documents of which the plaintiff had sought further and better discovery.  The plaintiff then made a further application for further and better discovery, relying on the use made by the expert of the summary.  The Master said that the expert had not used the primary documents, but only the summary.  Presumably, the Master adhered to his earlier view that discovery of the documents was not required under r 58A.03 of the Supreme Court Rules.  The Master dismissed the further application for further and better discovery.

  5. The plaintiff appeals against that order.

    Rule 58A

  6. The Supreme Court Rules have been amended to limit the scope of the obligation to make discovery of documents in civil proceedings and to exercise greater control over the process of discovery.

  7. Rule 58A.03 provides:

    “The parties must discover in their list of documents, but discover only, the documents which are or have been in their possession, custody or power which are directly relevant to any issue arising on the pleadings.”

  8. The meaning and proper application of this Rule can only be understood in its historical context.  It replaces a Rule the effect of which was to require discovery of documents if they related to any matter in question in the action.  That requirement had been interpreted broadly.  It extended to any document if it was reasonable to suppose that it contained information which might directly or indirectly enable the parties seeking discovery to advance that party’s own case or to damage the case of the opponent, or which might fairly lead the party to a train of inquiry which might have either of those consequences: see Mulley v Manifold (1959) 103 CLR 341 at 345 Menzies J. The new Rule takes a different and much more restrictive approach.

  9. Now discovery is to be made only of documents which are “directly relevant to any issue arising on the pleadings.”  The meaning of the expression “directly relevant” will have to be worked out over time.

  10. I agree with the observations made by Bleby J in Southern Equities Corporation Ltd (In Liquidation) v Arthur…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Quenchy Crusta Sales Pty Ltd v Logi-Tech Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 374
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an appeal brought by Sharp against a discovery order made by the trial judge in the case of Quenchy Crusta Sales Pty Ltd v Logi-Tech Pty Ltd. The primary issue was whether the trial judge was correct in ordering Sharp to provide further and better discovery of documents, specifically those referenced in a "Service Record," which Sharp claimed were not relevant to the case.

The legal issues that the court needed to decide were whether the documents in question were relevant to the pleadings and whether ordering their discovery would be oppressive or in the interests of justice. The court considered arguments from both parties, including the cost and effort required to locate and produce these documents, and the importance of the documents to Sharp's defence.

The court determined that the documents in question were relevant to the pleadings and that ordering their discovery was not oppressive, given the scale of the claim. The court emphasised that the interests of justice and the efficient conduct of the trial were paramount, and that Sharp had raised the issue of reliance on the conclusions drawn from the "Service Record." The court offered Sharp an opportunity to dismiss the appeal by providing a written assurance that it would not rely on the "Service Record" or comparisons of warranty claim rates by other users of Notebook Computers based on service records if Mr Garde were called to give evidence.

Ultimately, the court allowed the appeal but required Sharp to give the specified assurance to avoid the need for further and better discovery. The court noted that while the cost of producing the documents was significant, it was not oppressive when considered in the context of the overall claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Nicholson, counsel for Sharp, submits that all of these matters are for the trial judge, that Sharp will decide in due course whether to call Mr Garde and whether to persist with his evidence and the use that he makes of the “Service Record.” Accordingly, he submits that it is not in the interests of justice to order further and better discovery. He also makes the point, which has some force, that the Notebook Computers are in possession of the plaintiff, that it is in a position to establish, through its own experts, any defects that may be found in the Notebook Computers, and that to some extent it is the generality of the plaintiff’s pleadings that is the source of the problem. I agree with most of what he puts on that point, but while I agree that the plaintiff’s pleadings are unhelpfully general, much the same issue would arise even if they were specific as to the faults of design or manufacture that were said to be the cause of the breakdowns complained of.Conclusions My view is that while Sharp reserves the right to call Mr Garde, if permitted to do so, to give evidence in terms of his report, and on the basis stated in the report, the interests of justice require an order for discovery of the documents referred to in the “Service Record.” While I doubt whether Mr Garde will be permitted to give that evidence on that basis, it is not for me to decide. It is Sharp that has raised the issue of reliance on the conclusions to be drawn from the “Service Record”, and that being so that factor, combined with the Court’s interest in the efficient conduct of the trial (a factor relevant to the interests of justice), all lead me to that conclusion. That being so, I propose to publish these reasons and to give Sharp an opportunity to consider its position. I gave it that opportunity during the course of the argument, but it declined to take it up then. If Sharp is prepared to give a written assurance to the solicitors for the plaintiff to the effect that if it calls Mr Garde, it will not place any reliance on the “Service Record”, or on any comparison of warranty claim rates by other users of Notebook Computers based on service records, I will dismiss the appeal. I would do so because, in those circumstances, the documents from which the “Service Record” is drawn would not be directly relevant to the issues arising on the pleadings. And, that assurance having been given, the interests of justice would not make it appropriate to order further and better discovery of the documents in question. Subject to that I would allow the appeal despite the claim that an order for further and better discovery is oppressive. The solicitor for Sharp has exhibited to an affidavit a facsimile from one of Sharp’s employees, which states that locating and printing out the documents referred to in the “Service Record” would occupy four people for at least between two and three weeks. During the course of submissions I put to counsel that that suggested a cost of about $12,000 (twelve person weeks at about $1,000 each week), recognising that this was said to be a minimum, but assuming that the estimate given was a reasonable estimate. This may seem a little rough and ready, but this was the only information provided by Sharp. Bearing in mind that the claim is for an amount in excess of $600,000, my view is that it is not oppressive to order further and better discovery.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.