Re F: Litigants in person guidelines

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

[2001] FamCA 348

FAMILY LAW ACT 1975

IN THE FULL COURT OF THE
FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE  Appeal No. SA 1 of 2000
  File No.  ML 10368 of 1994

IN THE MATTER OF:

Re F : Litigants in Person Guidelines

_____________________________________________________________

EDITED
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF THE FULL COURT

_____________________________________________________________

Coram:  NICHOLSON CJ, COLEMAN AND O'RYAN JJ
Date of Hearing:                4 SEPTEMBER 2000
Date of Judgment:            4 JUNE 2001

Appearances:

The husband appeared in person.

Mr Skerlj of Counsel instructed by
Peter Falconer and Associates
5B Lt. Ryrie Street, Geelong, VIC, 3220
appeared for the respondent wife.

Catchwords:  Family Law - Children - Parenting Orders - Residence - Contact.

Family Law - Practice and Procedure - Hearing - Whether trial Judge afforded procedural fairness - Compliance with the guidelines set out in Johnson and Johnson (1997) FLC ¶92-764 - Consideration and revision of the guidelines set out in Johnson and Johnson (1997) FLC ¶92-764.

Family Law - Court and Judges - Whether bias or apprehension of bias by trial Judge - whether trial Judge should have disqualified himself.

This was an appeal from Guest J in proceedings between husband and wife concerning residence of and contact with the child of their marriage, [T] aged 6 years. The parties had been continuously engaged in litigation, both with regards to [T] and also in the context of financial matters, since May 1996.  The wife had retained solicitors throughout. Having availed himself of legal representation in the past, the husband had more latterly conducted the litigation in person and represented himself before the trial Judge. On the fourth day of the trial the husband made an application to his Honour that he should disqualify himself. His Honour rejected this application.

In the result, his Honour concluded that that [T] should reside with the wife and she should have sole responsibility for her long term and day to day care, welfare and development.  This was also the recommendation of the child representative. He noted that, notwithstanding the husband’s stated devotion to [T], his antipathy to the wife obfuscated his proper attention to the child’s best interests. His Honour ordered that a counsellor supervise contact to assist the parties in relation to compliance.

Nine grounds were relied upon by the husband in his amended Notice of Appeal filed 21 August 2000:

  1. In displaying clear prejudice against the husband during proceedings thereby causing a miscarriage and / or denial of justice.

  2. In displaying clear bias towards the wife during proceedings thereby causing a miscarriage and / or a denial of justice.

  3. In conducting proceedings so as to raise the reasonable apprehension of bias and the reasonable belief that he may not have brought an impartial mind to the issues before him.

  4. In predetermining the applications before him without having heard the evidence in its totality, as evidenced by the comments made by his Honour early in proceedings.

  5. By failing to afford the husband procedural fairness.

  6. In making findings of fact, which were not open…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re F: Litigants in person guidelines and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FamCA 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Family Court of Australia considered the application of guidelines for judges dealing with litigants in person, particularly in the context of parenting orders. The case involved a dispute concerning residence and contact arrangements for children, where at least one party was representing themselves.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether the trial judge had afforded procedural fairness to the litigants, specifically in relation to compliance with the guidelines established in *Johnson and Johnson* (1997) FLC ¶92-764. The Court also examined whether the trial judge had demonstrated bias or given rise to an apprehension of bias, and consequently, whether the judge should have disqualified himself from hearing the matter.

The Court engaged in a detailed consideration and revision of the *Johnson and Johnson* guidelines. It was observed that guideline 6 merely restated the statutory requirement of s132 of the *Evidence Act 1995* (Cth). Guideline 7, concerning the obligation to ensure a fair trial, was deemed problematic in its existing form, as it could create unrealistic expectations and potentially give a false impression of partiality. The Court acknowledged the inherent disadvantage faced by litigants in person due to the professional skills and objectivity of legal representation, noting that a truly level playing field is not achievable. The Court proposed a reformulation of the guidelines to better reflect the judicial duty to conduct proceedings fairly and impartially, while also recognising the challenges posed by self-represented litigants, whether by choice or financial necessity. The Court also noted that similar considerations might arise when a party is represented by an incompetent lawyer.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As far as guideline 6 is concerned, it does no more than remind judges of the statutory requirement of s132 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). We think that guideline 7 should be also be reformulated. All that was intended to be conveyed by the guideline was that there was an obligation on a trial judge to ensure a fair trial. We regard it in its present form as possibly leading to the creation of expectations that cannot be achieved. It is always the duty of a judge to ensure that proceedings are conducted fairly and impartially - that the parties are entitled to a fair trial. It should be recognised that persons who represent themselves are almost always at a disadvantage in legal proceedings. Advocacy is a professional skill that has almost always been performed by highly trained lawyers in our legal system. They not only bring those skills to bear but also professional objectivity that a litigant in person lacks, particularly in family law proceedings. It is simply not possible to create a level playing field where one party is represented by a professional and the other is not. Thus, to provide a guideline to judges of this type, if applied literally, not only sets the judge an impossible task but is likely to create unreal expectations on the part of the litigant in person and at the same time give a false impression of lack of impartiality by the judge to the party who is represented. Litigants may be self-represented by choice or increasingly, as a result of being unable to afford representation while at the same time failing to qualify for legal aid. The Court is moving to deal with this situation in a number of ways but it cannot by the use of guidelines affect its obligation to conduct trials according to law. In the High Court decision of Ebner v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 176 ALR 644, Gaudron J said at para 80: For the reasons already stated we think that this guideline in its present form may upon a literal interpretation, give rise to arguments that operate detrimentally to such a principle. We would re-formulate the Johnsonguidelines as follows. We would retain what are currently guidelines 1,2,3,6 and 8 in their present form, save for minor grammatical additions that do not affect their substance. We would reformulate what is currently guideline 4 to read: We would reformulate what is currently guideline 5 to read: What currently appears as guideline 7 should be replaced by the following, and should be the first guideline of the set: We would add a further guideline in the following terms:- Before leaving this matter, we would note that in our consideration of the how a judge may assist a litigant in person, we see that comparable considerations may also arise in circumstances where a judge is concerned that a party is being represented by an incompetent lawyer: see Ipp J (1995) “Judicial Intervention in the Trial Process” Vol. 69 The Australian Law Journal 365. We are also conscious that the role that a judge may play in assisting litigants is part of a broader expectation of managerial judging for the attainment of a fair trial and the interests of justice. To those ends, we appreciate that situations arise which require varying degrees of judicial intervention to control the conduct of proceedings, for example, by curtailing proceedings: see Rogers J (1993) “The Managerial or Interventionist Judge” Vol. 3 Journal of Judicial Administration, 96. We leave these issues for consideration by the Full Court on an appropriate occasion.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.