Ramadan v ACN 098 408 176 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

RAMADAN v ACN 098 408 176 PTY LTD

[2018] SASCFC 16

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Parker)

9 March 2018

CRIMINAL LAW - GENERAL MATTERS - ANCILLARY LIABILITY - COMPLICITY - AID, ABET, COUNSEL OR PROCURE

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT - CHARACTER AND ATTRIBUTES OF CONDUCT - KNOWLEDGE OR INTENTION

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT - PARTICULAR CLASSES OF CONDUCT - CONCERNING BANKS AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS

Appeal against dismissal of claim for damages for being knowingly concerned in unconscionable conduct.

The appellant Mrs Ramadan sued the first respondent (originally called Unique Finance Pty Ltd) for unconscionable conduct in respect of the entry by Mr and Mrs Ramadan into a loan agreement with and grant of a mortgage over their home in favour of Unique Finance.  Mrs Ramadan sued the second respondent, Mr Ventrice, for damages for being knowingly concerned in the unconscionable conduct.  While the trial Judge found that Unique Finance had engaged in unconscionable conduct, the Judge dismissed the claim against Mr Ventrice because he was not satisfied that Mr Ventrice was intentionally involved in the contravention.

The species of unconscionable conduct engaged in by Unique Finance was based on the plaintiff acting as a surety in the transaction and obtaining no gain from it; the lender being taken to have understood that the plaintiff’s husband may not have fully explained the effect of the transaction; and the lender not itself taking steps to ensure that the effect was explained to the plaintiff in circumstances in which in reality the plaintiff did not fully understand the effect: Garcia vs National Australia Bank Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 395.

The appellant contends on appeal that the Judge erred in not finding that Mr Ventrice was accessorially liable under s. 12GF of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) in respect of the contravention by Unique Finance of s. 12CB the Act.

Held by Blue J (Kourakis CJ and Parker J agreeing):

1. There are two components of a cause of action under section 12GF of the Act: a physical component of being involved or participating in the contravention and a mental component of intentional participation with the necessary intent being based upon knowledge of the essential elements of the contravention (at [53]).

2.  The Judge erred in finding that Ventrice was not involved in the contravention in circumstances in which he was the sole guiding mind and will of Unique Finance and involved in every aspect of the dealings with Mr and Mrs Ramadan (at [68]).

3.  On the uncontested evidence at trial and the factual findings made by the Judge, Mr Ventrice knew the essential elements of the contravention, namely that Mrs Ramadan acted as a surety in the transaction…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ramadan v ACN 098 408 176 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASCFC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from a decision of a single Judge of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appellant, Mrs Ramadan, had sought to set aside a mortgage over her home, which she had provided as security for a loan made by the first respondent, ACN 098 408 176 Pty Ltd (Unique Finance), to Ballsam Pty Ltd. The trial Judge had found that Unique Finance had engaged in unconscionable conduct and deferred the question of relief. However, the claim against the second respondent, Mr Ventrice, was dismissed on the basis that he was not found to be intentionally involved in the contravention.

The legal issues before the Full Court were whether the trial Judge erred in dismissing the claim against Mr Ventrice, and whether the trial Judge was correct in finding that Unique Finance had engaged in unconscionable conduct. Specifically, the Court had to consider the nature of "involvement" for the purposes of ancillary liability under the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act), and whether Mr Ventrice's presence and role at the meeting where Mrs Ramadan signed the mortgage documents constituted such involvement. The Court also had to determine if the circumstances surrounding Mrs Ramadan's execution of the mortgage documents amounted to unconscionable conduct, particularly given her limited English proficiency and lack of understanding of the transaction.

The Full Court upheld the trial Judge's finding that Unique Finance had engaged in unconscionable conduct. The Court reasoned that Mrs Ramadan suffered from a special disability due to her limited English, illiteracy, and lack of understanding of the transaction, and that Unique Finance, through its solicitor, had taken unfair advantage of this disability. The Court noted that the terms of the transaction were uncommercial and that it should have been obvious that Mrs Ramadan required a full explanation, which was not provided. Regarding Mr Ventrice, the Court found that while he was present at the meeting and was the sole director and beneficiary of Unique Finance, there was insufficient evidence to establish that he was intentionally involved in the unconscionable conduct. The trial Judge's finding that Mr Ventrice was not intentionally involved was therefore upheld.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. The Full Court affirmed the trial Judge's finding of unconscionable conduct by Unique Finance and the dismissal of the claim against Mr Ventrice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The trial Judge found that Unique Finance had engaged in unconscionable conduct and deferred the question of relief to a subsequent hearing.[6] The Judge dismissed the claim against Mr Ventrice because he was not satisfied that Mr Ventrice was intentionally involved in the contravention.[6] Ramadan v ACN 098 408 176 Pty Ltd [2017] SASC 63.Background Mrs Ramadan was born in Palestine in 1940. She attended primary school in Jordan to grade 2, leaving at the age of 8. Her native tongue is Arabic. She was not taught and did not speak English. She married Mr Ramadan at the age of 14. They had four children before migrating to Australia in 1969. A fifth child was born after they migrated to Australia when they were living in Melbourne. After moving to South Australia in 1975, the Ramadans purchased a house at Woodville. In 1977 the Ramadans commenced operating the Jerusalem Sheshkebab House (the Jerusalem restaurant) in Hindley Street Adelaide. The business was principally conducted by Mr Ramadan but Mrs Ramadan also worked part-time as a cook and a kitchen hand. In 1979 Mr Ramadan incorporated Merhi Pty Ltd (later called Ballsam Pty Ltd) (Ballsam) to act as trustee of the Steve Merhi Family Trust. Ballsam acquired ownership of the property in Hindley Street at which the Jerusalem restaurant business was conducted. Mr Ramadan incorporated Haifa Pty Ltd to carry on the restaurant business. Ballsam rented the Hindley Street property to Haifa. Over the years, Ballsam acquired other property. Mr and Mrs Ramadan were the directors of Ballsam from its incorporation in 1979 until 2002. Mr Ramadan generally made the business decisions. In 2002 Mrs Ramadan asked her husband if she could cease to be a director of Ballsam because she had no involvement in it and he agreed. Both Mr and Mrs Ramadan resigned as directors and their son Mohamad was appointed its sole director. Mr and Mrs Ramadan were the shareholders of Ballsam until 2006. In August 2006 Mr Ramadan caused their shares to be transferred to Mohamad. In 2001 Mr Ventrice and Jason Di Lulio incorporated Unique Finance. In 2002 Mr Di Lulio resigned as a director and Mr Ventrice continued as sole director. Mr Ventrice was as at 2007 the person who stood to benefit from any profit made by Unique Finance.[7][7] This is the wording of the plaintiff’s pleading which was admitted by the defendants. In 2007 Mr Ramadan and Yousef Jelil agreed to engage in a Middle East business venture involving the government of Iraq or Iran (the evidence was ambiguous as to which of these two countries it was). Shortly before 24 July 2007 Mr Jelil told Mr Ventrice of the business venture. Mr Jelil introduced Mr Ventrice and Mr Ramadan at the Ramadan home at Woodville. Mr Ramadan and Mr Jelil asked Mr Ventrice for a loan of about $70,000 for the business venture. Mr Ramadan told Mr Ventrice that he could provide security over properties in his company’s name. Mr Ventrice said that it would be a lot cheaper to obtain finance from a bank. Mr Ramadan said that he needed the money quickly or he would miss out on the business opportunity.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Ventrice did not give evidence. The Judge was informed that he was ill and offered to adjourn the trial for two weeks to permit him to give evidence but he declined this offer. The defendants did not call any witnesses to give evidence.The reasons for judgment The Judge said that overall he accepted the evidence of Mrs Ramadan. In particular he accepted her evidence in respect of the critical meeting at the officeof Mr Burtt. The Judge found that Unique Finance engaged in unconscionable conduct under the Act and in equity. The Judge said:In the circumstances of this matter, I am satisfied the plaintiff is a volunteer. She is, in effect, a constructive guarantor of the transaction. Her signature was necessary to allow the family home to be used as security for the subject loan. Her husband and Jelil used the money for an unknown business proposition. I accept that the plaintiff does not know what the money was borrowed for and what became of the funds, other than the fact that she is aware the monies were paid to Ballsam. She has received no benefit from the transaction.…In summary then, the plaintiff was a volunteer. She was a person under a special disability, in that she is barely able to speak English, and is not able to read or write English. I accept that, at the signing meeting, her husband spoke to the plaintiff in Arabic. It should have been obvious, at least to the solicitor, that it was necessary to fully explain the transaction to the plaintiff. More so because the terms of the transaction were uncommercial. It should also have been obvious that the plaintiff was a person suffering from a special disability.I accept the plaintiff’s evidence that no-one explained anything about the nature and effect of the transaction to her, other than her husband telling her they were borrowing $300,000 for one month, after which the money would be repaid. I also accept the plaintiff’s evidence that she was unaware that she was giving a mortgage over her property. There can be no other result than a finding that, in all the circumstances, the first defendant unconscientiously took advantage of the plaintiff’s special disability in procuring her signature. The result is the same, whether applying principles of equity or the provisions of s 12CB of the ASIC Act. The Judge found that it was not proved that Mr Ventrice was intentionally involved in the contravention by Unique Finance. The Judge said:The provisions of s 12GF and s 12GM of the ASIC Act permit the Court to make orders awarding compensation for a person who suffers loss or damage by reason of a contravention of, inter alia, section 12CB of that Act. The Court’s power extends to a person who is involved in a relevant contravention. The question then becomes whether the second defendant was involved in the contravention in the relevant sense. In most cases that might be relatively straightforward. The difficulty here is that the evidence of the plaintiff about what occurred at the meeting is not clear. In particular, she gave no direct evidence about what, if anything, the second defendant did or said at the meeting.…It needs to be remembered that it is not the terms of the contract of loan and mortgage that make the transaction unconscionable. If the details of the proposal had been fully and properly explained to the plaintiff and she nonetheless agreed to enter into it, she would have no cause for complaint. Thus, it is the circumstances by which she came to execute the documents which is the critical aspect of this claim. The meeting was conducted by the first defendant’s solicitor in his office. All we know about the second defendant is that he was a director of the first defendant and was present at the time the loan documents were signed. In the absence of any direct evidence in respect of the conduct of the second defendant at the meeting, I am not prepared to make a finding that he was intentionally involved in the contravention.The statutory regime

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.