R v Thrupp; R v Taiao; R v Walker; R v Daniels

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

R v Thrupp; R v Taiao; R v Walker; R v Daniels [2024] QCA 134

PARTIES:

In CA No 48 of 2021:

R
v
THRUPP, Trent Michael
(appellant)

In CA No 49 of 2021:

R
v
TAIAO, Davy Malu Junior
(appellant)

In CA No 54 of 2021:

R
v
WALKER, Waylon Ngaketo Cowan
(appellant)

In CA No 70 of 2021:

R
v
DANIELS, Stou
(appellant)

FILE NO/S:

CA No 48 of 2021
CA No 49 of 2021
CA No 54 of 2021
CA No 70 of 2021
SC No 1701 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against Conviction

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane – Date of Conviction: 11 March 2021 (Boddice J)

DELIVERED ON:

In CA No 48 of 2021; CA No 49 of 2021 and CA No 70 of 2021: 30 July 2024

In CA No 54 of 2021:
Date of Orders: 16 July 2024
Date of Publication of Reasons: 30 July 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

8 June 2023

JUDGES:

Mullins P and Bond JA and Livesey AJA

ORDERS:

In CA No 48 of 2021

1.   In relation to the convictions on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment for the murders of Breton and Triscaru:

(a)   Appeal allowed.

(b)  Convictions set aside.

(c)   New trial ordered.

2.   In relation to the convictions on counts 3 and 4 of the indictment for the torture of Breton and Triscaru, appeal dismissed.

In CA No 49 of 2021

1.   In relation to the convictions on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment for the murders of Breton and Triscaru:

(a)   Appeal allowed.

(b)  Convictions set aside.

(c)   New trial ordered.

2.   In relation to the convictions on counts 3 and 4 of the indictment for the torture of Breton and Triscaru, appeal dismissed.

Date of Orders in CA No 54 of 2021: 16 July 2024

1.   Appeal allowed.

2.   Convictions for manslaughter on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment set aside.

3.   Direct judgment and verdicts of acquittal of manslaughter on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment be entered.

In CA No 70 of 2021

1.   In relation to the convictions on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment for the murders of Breton and Triscaru:

(a)   Appeal allowed.

(b)  Convictions set aside.

(c)   New trial ordered.

2.   In relation to the convictions on counts 3 and 4 of the indictment for the torture of Breton and Triscaru, appeal dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – VERDICT UNREASONABLE OR INSUPPORTABLE HAVING REGARD TO THE EVIDENCE – OTHER MATTERS – where two people were lured to a home unit, tortured by being detained at the unit, assaulted, bound, and placed in a toolbox and locked inside it, and then subsequently driven to a wetlands area and disposed of by being placed in the waters and weighed down by concrete and tyres, which resulted in their death by drowning or asphyxiation – where the Crown alleged that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Thrupp; R v Taiao; R v Walker; R v Daniels and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCA 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of R v Thrupp; R v Taiao; R v Walker; R v Daniels, the appellants were convicted of the murders of two individuals who were tortured, assaulted, and ultimately drowned in a wetlands area. Each appellant argued that their convictions were unreasonable and could not be supported by the evidence due to the Crown's failure to prove the necessary state of knowledge, intention, or belief required for criminal responsibility under the relevant sections of the Criminal Code (Qld). The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the verdicts were unreasonable and not supported by the evidence, and whether there were deficiencies in the particulars given to the jury that amounted to a miscarriage of justice.

The Court of Appeal considered the arguments of the appellants and the Crown's submissions, reviewing the evidence and the jury directions provided by the trial judge. The Court noted that to be criminally responsible under s 7(1)(b) or s 7(1)(c), a person must know of the offence which is being or about to be committed by the person they are aiding or intending to aid. The Court found that the trial judge's directions to the jury were insufficient to ensure they understood the specific knowledge required to convict the appellants of murder. The Court concluded that the verdicts were unreasonable and not supported by the evidence, and that there were deficiencies in the particulars that amounted to a miscarriage of justice.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeals, set aside the convictions, and ordered new trials for the appellants in relation to the murder charges. The Court dismissed the appeals in relation to the torture charges. The Court also allowed the appeal of one appellant in relation to the manslaughter convictions, setting aside those convictions and entering direct judgments and verdicts of acquittal on those counts.

Orders

Orders of the court

In CA No 48 of 2021

1. In relation to the convictions on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment for the murders of Breton and Triscaru:

(a) Appeal allowed.

(b) Convictions set aside.

(c) New trial ordered.

2. In relation to the convictions on counts 3 and 4 of the indictment for the torture of Breton and Triscaru, appeal dismissed.

In CA No 49 of 2021

1. In relation to the convictions on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment for the murders of Breton and Triscaru:

(a) Appeal allowed.

(b) Convictions set aside.

(c) New trial ordered.

2. In relation to the convictions on counts 3 and 4 of the indictment for the torture of Breton and Triscaru, appeal dismissed.

Date of Orders in CA No 54 of 2021: 16 July 2024

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Convictions for manslaughter on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment set aside.

3. Direct judgment and verdicts of acquittal of manslaughter on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment be entered.

In CA No 70 of 2021

1. In relation to the convictions on counts 1 and 2 of the indictment for the murders of Breton and Triscaru:

(a) Appeal allowed.

(b) Convictions set aside.

(c) New trial ordered.

2. In relation to the convictions on counts 3 and 4 of the indictment for the torture of Breton and Triscaru, appeal dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This was explained in R v Licciardello[12], in a lengthy discussion by McMurdo JA (with whom Sofronoff P and Douglas J agreed) of which it suffices to quote the following:[12]R v Licciardello [2018] 3 Qd R 206 at [15] to [30].“[29] … The appellant in [R v Brown[13]] was found not guilty of murder, but guilty of manslaughter of a man who had been killed by several blows to his head, which could have been caused by fists, feet, boots or a blunt object. The appellant and others went to the deceased’s home in order to collect a drug debt. The appellant was armed with a hammer and there was evidence that he used it to strike the deceased. But there was some evidence that further violence was inflicted on the deceased by others. The prosecution case was that the appellant was guilty of murder either under s 7 or s 8. The appellant’s first ground of appeal was that the trial judge erred in directing the jury about s 7(1)(c), by telling the jury that they could convict him of manslaughter under that provision if they found that he had aided the principal offender with knowledge that that offender had an intention to assault the deceased. It was argued that for the jury to convict the appellant of manslaughter under s 7(1)(c), it was necessary for them to be satisfied both that a reasonable person in his position would have foreseen death as a possible outcome of the assault that he was aiding and that he actually foresaw this. That argument was rejected. McMurdo P said:[13]R v Brown (2007) 171 A Crim R 345.‘The case against the appellant at trial under s 7(1)(c) was that he was present and knowingly aided the perpetrator in a lethal assault upon the deceased. To convict the appellant of manslaughter on the basis of s 7(1)(c) in this case, the jury had to be satisfied that the appellant knowingly aided the perpetrator to assault the deceased; the assault was a substantial or significant cause of the death; the killing was unlawful; but not satisfied that the appellant intended to kill or do grievous bodily harm to the deceased.’In the same case, Holmes JA (as she then was) said:‘The state of knowledge which the Crown had to prove in order to convict the appellant as an aider under s 7(1)(c) of the Criminal Code was of the ‘essential facts constituting or making up the offence that [was] being or about to be committed by the person he [was] aiding or assisting’; that is to say, the assault which caused the deceased’s death. The direction given met that requirement.’Conclusion[30]To be criminally responsible under s 7(1)(b) or s 7(1)(c), a person must know of the offence which is being, or which is about to be, committed by the person he is aiding or intending to aid. That offence is constituted by the conduct (an act or omission) of the other person which attracts criminal liability. If the principal offender's crime requires a specific intent, then s 7(1)(b) or s 7(1)(c) requires the aider to know that he is aiding the other to act (or omit to act) with that intent. But if "the offence" has no ingredient of an intent (or other state of mind) on the part of the person who does the act or makes the omission, all that the aider need know is that the conduct constituting the offence is occurring or will occur.”[14][14]R v Licciardello [2018] 3 Qd R 206 at [29] and [30], footnotes omitted, italicized emphasis in original.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established