R v SEL

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

R v SEL [2024] QCA 166

PARTIES:

R
v
SEL
(appellant)

FILE NO/S:

CA No 24 of 2023
DC No 798 of 2021

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against Conviction

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Cairns – Date of Conviction: 14 February 2023 (Morzone KC DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

10 September 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 November 2023

JUDGES:

Mullins P and Bond and Flanagan JJA

ORDER:

The appeal is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – VERDICT UNREASONABLE OR INSUPPORTABLE HAVING REGARD TO EVIDENCE – OTHER MATTERS – where the appellant was convicted of three counts of wilful and unlawful exposure to an indecent act (counts 1, 3 and 4), and one count of unlawful and indecent dealing (count 2) – where the offending conduct involved 2 complainants – whether the verdict on count 4 was unreasonable and cannot be supported by the evidence

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE – PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCES AMOUNTING TO MISCARRIAGE – IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE – where evidence of the complainants being given alcohol or drugs was admitted – where evidence of the appellant leaving the unit or hiding was admitted – where the appellant contended a direction given by the trial judge was not sufficiently strong and failed to indicate that the jury could have no regard to that evidence – whether there was a miscarriage of justice by the admission of the alcohol or drug evidence, and, or the admission of evidence of the appellant leaving or hiding

R v Thrupp; R v Taiao; R v Walker; R v Daniels[2024] QCA 134, applied

COUNSEL:

J Lodziak for the appellant
S L Dennis for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the appellant
Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the respondent

  1. MULLINS P:  I agree with Bond JA.

  2. BOND JA:  As at January 2019, the appellant, a man aged 33, had been in an off and on relationship with Suzanne[1], a woman in her late 20s for about 7 years.  They had a child (aged 2) (the appellant’s child).  Suzanne had two younger half-sisters: Linda (aged 12) and Mary (aged 10).  Mary had a friend named Jane also aged 10.

    [1]Note that in these reasons pseudonyms are being used in place of the names of involved parties.

  3. On 20 January 2019, Linda, Mary and Jane, were at Suzanne’s two-bedroom unit for a two-night sleepover.  On the first night, after having a verbal altercation with Suzanne, Linda called her mother and left without staying the night.  It was alleged that at some time after Linda had left, the appellant committed the following offences of indecent treatment against Mary and Jane:

    Count 1:That the appellant wilfully and unlawfully exposed Jane to an indecent act by he and Suzanne in that he penetrated Suzanne’s vulva or vagina with his finger in their bedroom and exposed Jane to this act.

    Count 2:That the appellant unlawfully and indecently…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v SEL and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCA 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant was convicted of three counts of wilful and unlawful exposure to an indecent act and one count of unlawful and indecent dealing. The appellant appealed the conviction, arguing that the verdict on count 4 was unreasonable and not supported by the evidence. The appellant also contended that the trial was a miscarriage of justice due to the admission of evidence about the complainants being given alcohol or drugs, and evidence of the appellant leaving the unit or hiding. The court was required to decide whether the verdict on count 4 was unreasonable and not supported by the evidence, and whether the admission of the alcohol or drug evidence, and the admission of evidence of the appellant leaving or hiding, amounted to a miscarriage of justice.

The court found that the difficulties and discrepancies in the evidence were matters for the jury, and it was not open to the court to reach a view contrary to that reached by the jury. The court found that it was not unreasonable for the jury to accept the complainant's evidence beyond a reasonable doubt, and that the circumstances of the emergence of the complainant's complaint were corroborative of her evidence and supported a conclusion as to its reliability. The court also found that the evidence of the girls being given alcohol or drugs was relevant to properly explain the sequence of events and why none of the parents saw the appellant at the unit at the material times. The court found that the evidence of the appellant leaving the unit or hiding was relevant to the jury's assessment of the competing evidence of the adult witnesses, particularly as between Suzanne on the one hand and the girls' mothers on the other.

The appeal was dismissed, and the conviction and sentence of the appellant were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The defence case accepted that the appellant and Suzanne drank alcohol during the sleepover. I have mentioned that Suzanne denied giving either of the girls alcohol or drugs. The appellant told police in the interview played to the jury that Jane cannot have alcohol and Mary, although she had previously had a sip of Suzanne’s can “here and there” in the past, did not have any alcohol during the sleepover, that he recalled.The evidence of the appellant leaving the unit or hiding Jane told police: “…when [Mary]’s parents arrived to check up on us and visit um [the appellant] was like just disappearing…”. She added: “[Mary]’s mum and dad … like drove up to a pathway and then Suzanne was like, my mum and dad are here, you need to go. And um [the appellant] just ran outside as fast as he can”. Mary told police that her parents did not know the appellant was at Suzanne’s unit. She thought that the appellant “ran out the back and went to the shop” when she and Jane arrived at the unit and knocked on the door. Once her mother left, the appellant “ran in the back door”. She said Suzanne always told the appellant to leave or hide. Linda said the appellant was hiding when she was dropped off at Suzanne’s unit. He hid until her mother left. The defence answer to that evidence was the appellant’s poor relationship with Suzanne’s parents. That was supported by the evidence given by Suzanne and her mother.Consideration The respondent submitted and I agree that the evidence of hiding was relevant to properly explain the sequence of events and who it was thought would be at the unit at the material times. It was also relevant to explain why none of the parents saw the appellant at the unit at the material times. Jane and Mary gave evidence that the appellant was there at the unit and explained why he would not have been seen. It was relevant to the jury’s assessment of the competing evidence of the adult witnesses, particularly as between Suzanne on the one hand and the girls’ mothers on the other. It was also relevant from the perspective of the appellant’s account to police in his interview as to the nature of his relationship with Suzanne (who he described as controlling most aspects of his life), that he relied on in his own case, in particular as an example of why it was said the jury would accept his account as honest. Indeed in his counsel’s closing address the issue was turned to his advantage in this way:“And he was honest about this strange – what you might see as strange, you know, hiding from his parents – from Suzanne’s parents, and him complying with Suzanne’s wishes in relation to that, because otherwise there was yelling and screaming, he said, but also he knew of the difficult relationship he had with [Suzanne’s stepfather]. He doesn’t remember hiding that night, but he said that was often, he said, when her parents turned up, he was told to hide, and he would just comply.” Before this Court, the appellant accepted that unless his argument in relation to intoxicants found favour the submissions concerning the evidence regarding hiding would not by themselves justify a finding of miscarriage.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ground 2 fails.Conclusion Neither ground of appeal is established. The appeal should be dismissed. FLANAGAN JA: I agree with Bond JA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Jane’s version of events was put to him and he too made relevant denials.Consideration I am not persuaded of the appellant’s argument in favour of ground 1. The evidence is to be assessed by reference to the High Court authorities referred to in R v Thrupp; R v Taiao; R v Walker; R v Daniels [2024] QCA 134 at [123]. Such difficulties and discrepancies as there were as between Jane’s evidence and Mary’s evidence on the one hand and that of Suzanne and the appellant in his record of interview on the other were matters explicitly dealt with by each side in closing submissions before the jury. They were quintessentially jury questions and there is no particular reason why this Court should reach a view contrary to that reached by the jury or conclude that it was not open to the jury to reach the view that it did. The appellant’s counsel suggested that the quality of Jane’s evidence in relation to count 4 was not as good as her evidence in relation to count 3. There is some merit in that suggestion, but not sufficient to justify a conclusion that it was not open to the jury to accept it. I accept the respondent’s submission that it was not unreasonable for the jury to accept Jane’s evidence beyond a reasonable doubt not only that she was exposed to the conduct subject of count 3 but that Mary was similarly exposed to that conduct. The circumstances of the emergence of Jane’s complaint were corroborative of her evidence and supported a conclusion as to its reliability. Moreover, Mary’s evidence did corroborate the general proposition that the appellant had exposed Jane and Mary to some form of sexual activity between he and Suzanne. While it is true that Mary’s evidence did not corroborate the details of Jane’s evidence in relation to count 4, given Mary’s obviously immature grasp of what “sex” was, it could hardly be said to be inconsistent with Jane’s evidence. Ground 1 fails.Ground 2The evidence of the girls being given alcohol or drugs I have already mentioned Mary’s evidence concerning alcohol and drugs. Jane too gave evidence on the use of alcohol. She told police that Suzanne gave Linda and Mary alcohol. She thought it was vodka or something that looked like water but was not water. Mary had one glass and Linda had “like four”. Linda did not give evidence of having been given any alcohol or of having consumed any alcohol. Jane did not say that she consumed or was given any alcohol. The defence case accepted that the appellant and Suzanne drank alcohol during the sleepover. I have mentioned that Suzanne denied giving either of the girls alcohol or drugs. The appellant told police in the interview played to the jury that Jane cannot have alcohol and Mary, although she had previously had a sip of Suzanne’s can “here and there” in the past, did not have any alcohol during the sleepover, that he recalled.The evidence of the appellant leaving the unit or hiding Jane told police: “…when [Mary]’s parents arrived to check up on us and visit um [the appellant] was like just disappearing…”. She added: “[Mary]’s mum and dad … like drove up to a pathway and then Suzanne was like, my mum and dad are here, you need to go. And um [the appellant] just ran outside as fast as he can”.