SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
R v KU & Ors; ex parte A–G (Qld) [2008] QCA 154
PARTIES:
R
v
KU
(respondent)
AAC
(respondent)
WY
(respondent)
PAG
(respondent)
KY
(respondent)
KZ
(respondent)
BBL
(respondent)
WZ
(respondent)
YC
(respondent)
EX PARTE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF QUEENSLAND
(appellant)FILE NO/S:
CA No 343 of 2007
CA No 344 of 2007
CA No 345 of 2007
CA No 346 of 2007
CA No 347 of 2007
CA No 348 of 2007
CA No 349 of 2007
CA No 350 of 2007
CA No 351 of 2007
DC No 146 of 2007DIVISION:
Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:
Appeals against Sentence by A-G (Qld)
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court at Aurukun and Cairns
DELIVERED ON:
13 June 2008
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATES:
13 May 2008; 14 May 2008
JUDGES:
de Jersey CJ, McMurdo P and Keane JA
Judgment of the CourtORDERS:
In CA No. 350 of 2007, R v WZ:
Appeal allowed;1.
Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;2.
Order that the respondent be imprisoned for six years and fix a parole eligibility date of 13 June 2010;3.
There will be a declaration that 55 days pre-sentence custody (from 19 September to 5 November 2006 and 16 November to 22 November 2006) be treated as time served under this sentence;4.
Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days.5.
In CA No. 343 of 2007, R v KU:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentences imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. On each count order that the respondent be imprisoned for concurrent terms of six years and fix a parole eligibility date in each case of 13 June 2010;
4. Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days.
In CA No. 345 of 2007, R v WY:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentences imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. On each count order that the respondent be imprisoned for concurrent terms of six years and fix a parole eligibility date in each case of 13 June 2010;
4. Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days.
In CA No. 351 of 2007, R v YC:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. Order that a conviction be recorded;
4. Order that the respondent be sentenced to three years probation on the usual conditions, with a further condition that the respondent attend the Griffith Youth Forensic Service or any other program as directed by the Department of Communities, comply with all reasonable requirements of the program and maintain a rate of progress which is satisfactory to the treatment program;
5. Direct that the respondent's legal representative explain to the respondent the purpose and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v KU; ex parte Attorney-General (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] QCA 154
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the sentencing judge did not adequately explain the reasons for the sentences imposed. The judge had referred to the offence as "having sex with young girls" rather than "rape" and had stated that all respondents would be treated the same "in terms of the behaviour." The court held that this was insufficient under the statutory requirements for sentencing reasons. Additionally, the court found that the sentences were manifestly inadequate. The adult respondents were sentenced to fully suspended terms of six months imprisonment, while the juvenile respondents were sentenced to 12 months probation with no conviction recorded. The court noted that sexual offences by adults on children usually warrant custodial sentences, and sexual offences by juveniles on children usually warrant a term of detention.
The court also considered whether the Attorney-General could appeal against the sentences despite the prosecution's earlier submissions that non-custodial sentences were appropriate. The court held that the Attorney-General was not precluded from appealing due to the prosecution's submissions, and that the appeal should proceed if the court found the sentencing process had miscarried. The court concluded that the sentences were manifestly inadequate and ordered new sentences for each respondent. For the adults, the court ordered imprisonment terms of six years, while for the juveniles, the court ordered detention or probation with additional conditions. The court also ordered that convictions be recorded for the juvenile respondents.
Orders
Orders of the court
In CA No. 350 of 2007, R v WZ:
Appeal allowed;1.
Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;2.
Order that the respondent be imprisoned for six years and fix a parole eligibility date of 13 June 2010;3.
There will be a declaration that 55 days pre-sentence custody (from 19 September to 5 November 2006 and 16 November to 22 November 2006) be treated as time served under this sentence;4.
Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days.5.
In CA No. 343 of 2007, R v KU:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentences imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. On each count order that the respondent be imprisoned for concurrent terms of six years and fix a parole eligibility date in each case of 13 June 2010;
4. Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days.
In CA No. 345 of 2007, R v WY:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentences imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. On each count order that the respondent be imprisoned for concurrent terms of six years and fix a parole eligibility date in each case of 13 June 2010;
4. Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days.
In CA No. 351 of 2007, R v YC:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. Order that a conviction be recorded;
4. Order that the respondent be sentenced to three years probation on the usual conditions, with a further condition that the respondent attend the Griffith Youth Forensic Service or any other program as directed by the Department of Communities, comply with all reasonable requirements of the program and maintain a rate of progress which is satisfactory to the treatment program;
5. Direct that the respondent's legal representative explain to the respondent the purpose and effect of this order in accordance with s 158 of the Juvenile Justice Act 1992 (Qld) and the consequences of non-compliance.
In CA No. 347 of 2007, R v KY:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentences imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. Order on each count that convictions be recorded;
4. Order on each count that the respondent be sentenced to three years probation on the usual conditions, with a further condition that the respondent attend the Griffith Youth Forensic Service or any other program as directed by the Department of Communities, comply with all reasonable requirements of the program and maintain a rate of progress which is satisfactory to the treatment program;
5. Direct that the respondent's legal representative explain to the respondent the purpose and effect of this order in accordance with s 158 of the Juvenile Justice Act 1992 (Qld) and the consequences of non-compliance.
In CA No. 348 of 2007, R v KZ:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 6 November 2007;
3. Order that a conviction be recorded;
4. Order that the respondent be sentenced to detention for three years to be released after serving 50 per cent of that term;
5. There will be a declaration that 41 days pre-sentence detention (from 1 to 3 July 2006, 19 to 20 September 2006, 5 October to 10 November 2006, 7 to 8 December 2006 and 19 to 20 March 2007) be treated as time served under this sentence;
6. Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days;
7. Direct that the respondent's legal representative explain to the respondent the purpose and effect of this order in accordance with s 158 of the Juvenile Justice Act 1992 (Qld).
In CA No. 346 of 2007, R v PAG:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;
3. Order that a conviction be recorded;
4. Order that the respondent be sentenced to three years probation on the usual conditions, together with a condition that the respondent attend the Griffith Youth Forensic Service or any other program as directed by the Department of Communities, comply with all reasonable requirements of the program and maintain a rate of progress which is satisfactory to the treatment program;
5. Direct that the respondent's legal representative explain to the respondent the purpose and effect of this order in accordance with s 158 of the Juvenile Justice Act 1992 (Qld) and the consequences of non-compliance.
In CA No. 349 of 2007, R v BBL:
1. Appeal allowed;
2. Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 6 November 2007;
3. Order that a conviction be recorded;
4. Order that the respondent be sentenced to probation for three years, on the usual conditions, together with a condition that the respondent attend the Griffith Youth Forensic Service or any other program as directed by the Department of Communities, comply with all reasonable requirements of the program and maintain a rate of progress which is satisfactory to the treatment program;
5. Direct that the respondent's legal representative explain to the respondent the purpose and effect of this order in accordance with s 158 of the Juvenile Justice Act 1992 (Qld) and the consequences of non-compliance.
In CA No. 344 of 2007, R v AAC:
Appeal allowed;1.
Set aside the sentence imposed in the District Court on 24 October 2007;2.
Order that a conviction be recorded;3.
Order that the respondent be sentenced to two years detention to be released after serving 50 per cent of that term;4.
There will be a declaration that one day pre-sentence detention (from 8 to 9 October 2007) be treated as time served under this sentence;5.
Order that a warrant issue for the arrest of the respondent to lie in the registry for seven days;6.
Direct that the respondent's legal representative explain to the respondent the purpose and effect of this order in accordance with s 158 of the Juvenile Justice Act 1992 (Qld).7.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.