Princi v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Princi v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] FCA 441

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – notice of appeal – whether question identified in notice was a question of law - application for leave to amend – amendment would require significant departure from agreed basis of dispute in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal

INCOME TAX – deductions – dominant purpose of scheme to obtain tax benefit

Held:  The applications be dismissed.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 43(1), 44(1)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 169A(3), 170, 175, 177, 177A, 177D, 177D(b), 177D(b)(v), 177F, 177F(1), 177F(3), 177G, 177G(1)

Federal Court Rules O 53

Allan v Transurban City Link Ltd (2001) 208 CLR 167
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Donald (2003) 136 FCR 7
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Saxby Bridge Financial Planning Pty Ltd (2003) 133 FCR 290
Australian Telecommunications Corp v Lambroglou (1990) 12 AAR 515
Commissioner of Taxation v Dixon (2006) 155 FCR 101
Commissioner of Taxation v Glennan (1999) 90 FCR 538
Commissioner of Taxation v Perkins (1993) 93 ATC 4524
Commissioner of Taxation v Sleight (2004) 136 FCR 211
Craig v South Australia (1995) 131 ALR 595
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia v Richard Walter Pty Limited (1994) 183 CLR 168
Fabry v Commissioner of Taxation (2003) ATC 4885
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Peabody (1994) 181 CLR 359
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404
Fletcher v Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 19 FCR 442
Price Street Professional Centre Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 97 ALD 593
Re Princi and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 66 ATR 133
Sleight v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2003) 53 ATR 667
Star City Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 1701
Stevenson v Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 29 FCR 282
Telstra Corporation Ltd v Warren, Graham [1997] FCA 102
TNT Skypak International (Aust) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (1988) 19 ATR 1067
Walters and Another v Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 162 FCR 421
Waterford v Commonwealth of Australia (1987) 71 ALR 673
WR Carpenter Holdings Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2006) 63 ATR 577
WR Carpenter Holdings Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 161 FCR 1

VINCENZO PRINCI, DOMENIC PRINCI, MATE TOLICH AND KEVIN DORN v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
WAD 66 OF 2007

PHILLIP SHIELDS AND MARK KHO v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
WAD 69 of 2007

KEVIN DORN v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
WAD 236 of 2007

MCKERRACHER J
4 APRIL 2008
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 66 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY BRUCE PASCOE (SENIOR MEMBER)

BETWEEN:

VINCENZO PRINCI
DOMENIC PRINCI
MATE TOLICH
KEVIN DORN
Applicants

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 APRIL 2008

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed. 

2.The applicants are to pay the costs of the respondent to be taxed if…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Princi v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 441
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Princi v Commissioner of Taxation involved multiple applicants contesting the Commissioner's assessment of their tax liabilities under Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. The applicants argued that the Tribunal erred in its application of the law, particularly in relation to the interpretation of certain statutory provisions and the consideration of expert evidence. The applicants sought to amend their grounds of appeal during the proceedings, which the Commissioner contested on the basis that the amendment was not timely. The central issues for the court were whether the Tribunal had correctly applied the law in determining the nature of the scheme and whether there were any errors in the consideration of the expert evidence.

The court found that the Tribunal's conclusions were consistent with established legal principles and did not constitute legal errors. The Tribunal's assessment of the factual distinctions and the expert evidence was within its jurisdiction and did not contravene any legal principles. The court held that the Tribunal was entitled to make factual findings and draw conclusions based on those findings, and that such determinations were not subject to review on appeal. The amendment to the grounds of appeal was deemed untimely and did not alter the legal issues at hand. Therefore, the court dismissed the application and ordered the applicants to pay the costs of the Commissioner.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicants are to pay the costs of the respondent to be taxed if not agreed.

1. The application is dismissed.

3. The applicant is to pay the costs of the respondent to be taxed if not agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 177D of the Act stipulates when Pt IVA of the Act will apply to a ‘scheme’. The eight categories set out in s 177D(b) ‘are posited as objective facts’ (emphasis added): see also Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Peabody (1994) 181 CLR 359 at 382. The conclusion reached having regard to all those matters set out in par (b) must be the conclusion of a reasonable person having regard, as objective facts, to the matters answering the description in subs (b): Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404 at 422. The grounds considered in light of these principles Applying these principles, ground 4.1.1 relates to a suggested failure on the part of the Tribunal to take into account the factual distinction in relation to the advance of the funds of $200,000 and to draw a conclusion that that factual distinction precluded the applicants from having the requisite dominant purpose. The Tribunal examined this issue and reached a different conclusion on the facts from that argued by the applicants. Similarly with ground 4.1.2, considering the payback period, the ground of complaint is the failure on the part of the Tribunal to prefer the evidence for the applicants as distinct from the evidence of Mr Banks. This is not referable to any question of law. In relation to ground 4.2, it is clear that the Tribunal needed to reach a conclusion as to what constituted the scheme. To do so is an essential ingredient of s 177D of the Act. The Tribunal summarised the scheme as it perceived it to be and did so, in accordance with the agreement by the parties, in a way which was entirely consistent with the summary given by the Full Court in Sleight 136 FCR 211. No legal error arises. Ground 4.3 relates to Mr Dorn. As the Full Court did in Sleight 136 FCR 211, the Tribunal was entitled to find that Mr Dorn’s other tax losses were attributable to similar investments in three other ‘tax driven’ projects. But again, this is a question of fact and is not referable to any question of law. Ground 4.4, in dealing with the payback period, complained about the Tribunal’s conclusion in relation to the expert evidence. Mr Banks concluded that the payback period allowing for risk was unlikely to be less than 20 years. It is clear that the Tribunal did not accept Mr Simpson’s evidence of recovery within seven to eight years. It is also clear that was a view it was entitled to take. It is a decision on a question of fact or opinion, not on a question of law. AMENDMENT In recognition of the difficulty posed by the formulation of the initial questions of law and grounds of appeal, the applicants sought to amend their notice of appeal. The minute of this amendment was not produced until well into the applicants’ argument but senior counsel for the applicants proceeded with argument on the first day of the hearing on the assumption that the matter could be approached in terms of the legal argument to which the proposed minute of amended notice of appeal was directed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MCKERRACHER J
The issue before the Tribunal was defined by an agreement constituted in an exchange of correspondence. 1.On 1 February 2007 the Australian Government Solicitor for the Commissioner wrote to the solicitors for the applicants saying (in part):5.Firstly we understand from our recent discussions (and earlier correspondence) that the position is that for the purpose of the proceedings the Applicants and Respondent agree that the decision of the Full Federal Court in Commissioner of Taxation v Sleight (2004) 136 FCR 211 applies in relation to the Applicants unless the following matter make any difference:(a)in relation to all of the Applicants: so much of the evidence adduced from the expert witnesses (namely Messrs Simpson and Banks) that is admitted into evidence by the Tribunal; and(b)in relation to Messrs Domenic Princi, Vincent Princi, Mate Tolich and Kevin Dorn:so much of the evidence adduced from those applicants, that is admitted into evidence by the Tribunal, as to the amount of money lent by each of them to the Northern Rivers project and the consequent “cash negative” position of each of them in relation to the project as a whole. …7.Secondly, in respect of the contention that the Part IVA determination is not valid, we understand the following to be the situation:(a)the only Applicants that will be making this contention are Messrs Domenic Princi, Vincent Princi, Mate Tolich, Kevin Dorn, Phillip Shields, Graham Saggers, Gary Hopkins, Robert Ong and Elmer Galloway; and(b)the only ground for the contention will be that the Respondent did not make a Part IVA determination in either the 1995 and/or the 1996 years prior to issuing an amended assessment for those income years. 2.The solicitors for the applicants by letter dated 8 February 2007 responded to the Australian Government solicitor in the following terms (in part):5For the purpose of the various proceedings we agree that the findings of the fact in the decision of Sleight v Commissioner of Taxation (2003) ATC 4801 and Commissioner of Taxation v Sleight [2004] 136 FCR 211 (the decisions) apply to all of the Applicants’ cases unless:(i)in relation to all of the Applicants: to the extent that the evidence adduced by the experts Simpson and Banks alters the application of the decisions; and(ii)in relation to Messrs Domenic Princi, Vincent Princi, Mate Tolich and Kevin Dorn: to the extent that the evidence adduced by them alters the application of the decisions … …7With respect to some of the Applicants’ contentions that the Part IVA determination is not valid, the Applicants Messrs Domenic Princi, Vincent Princi, Mate Tolich, Kevin Dorn, Phillip Shield, Graham Saggers, Gary Hopkins, Robert Ong and Elmer Galloway will be contending that the Respondent did not give effect to the Part IVA determination by issuing an amended assessment in accordance with Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Jackson (1990) 21 ATR 1012, and consequently the Respondent cannot rely on Part IVA to support the relevant amended assessments. THE DECISION IN SLEIGHT 136 FCR 211

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MCKERRACHER J

Although there was substantial detail and evidence contained in the material filed in support of the consolidated ‘appeals’, in my view, the proper and appropriate disposition of the ‘appeals’ ultimately does not and cannot turn on examination of that extensive material. SECTIONS OF THE ACT FALLING FOR CONSIDERATION These appeals do not raise detailed questions of statutory construction but the sections of the Act (or parts of them) falling for consideration are set out for convenience. The first, in relation to the determination argument, is s 169A(3):(3)In determining whether an assessment is correct, any determination, opinion or judgment of the Commissioner made, held or formed in connection with the consideration of an objection against the assessment shall be deemed to have been made, held or formed when the assessment was made. Section 170 sets out certain time limits within which the Commissioner may amend assessments which have been made. Under s 177A of the Act it is provided by subs 5 that a reference in Pt IVA to a scheme or part of a scheme being entered into or carried out by a person for a particular purpose shall be read as including a reference to the scheme or part of the scheme being entered into or carried out by the person for two or more purposes of which that particular purpose was the dominant purpose. Relevantly by s 177F(3) it is provided:(3)Where the Commissioner has made a determination under subsection (1) or (2A) in respect of a taxpayer in relation to a scheme to which this Part applies, the Commissioner may, in relation to any taxpayer (in this subsection referred to as the relevant taxpayer):(a)if, in the opinion of the Commissioner:(i)there has been included, or would but for this subsection be included, in the assessable income of the relevant taxpayer of a year of income an amount that would not have been included or would not be included, as the case may be, in the assessable income of the relevant taxpayer of that year of income if the scheme had not been entered into or carried out; and(ii)it is fair and reasonable that that amount or a part of that amount should not be included in the assessable income of the relevant taxpayer of that year of income;determine that that amount or that part of that amount, as the case may be, should not have been included or shall not be included, as the case may be, in the assessable income of the relevant taxpayer of that year of income; or(b)if, in the opinion of the Commissioner:(i)an amount would have been allowed or would be allowable to the relevant taxpayer as a deduction in relation to a year of income if the scheme had not been entered into or carried out, being an amount that was not allowed or would not, but for this subsection, be allowable, as the case may be, as a deduction to the relevant taxpayer in relation to that year of income; and(ii)it is fair and reasonable that that amount or a part of that amount should be allowable as a deduction to the relevant taxpayer in relation to that year of income;determine that that amount or that part, as the case may be, should have been allowed or shall be allowable, as the case may be, as a deduction to the relevant taxpayer in relation to that year of income.…and the Commissioner shall take such action as he considers necessary to give effect to any such determination.