Walters v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Walters v Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 1270

TAXATION AND REVENUE – consideration of whether a taxpayer engaging in a sequence of transactions by reason of which the taxpayer did not realise a capital gain upon disposal of a CGT asset nevertheless engaged in a sequence of transactions constituting a scheme to which Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), applies – consideration of the notions of ‘scheme’, ‘obtaining a tax benefit’, ‘purpose’, the application of an exclusion by reason of s 177C(2)(a) of the Act – consideration of principles governing the determination of an amount of additional tax by way of penalty – consideration of ss 226 and 222C of the Act as those provisions applied prior to the repeal of Part VII of the Act

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), s 177A(1), s 177A(5), s 177C(1), s 177C(2), s 177D, s 177F(1), s 177F(2)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth), the provisions of Subdivision 122‑A
Tax Laws Amendment (Repeal of Inoperative Provisions) Act 2006 (Cth)
Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth)

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404 - cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Peabody (1994) 181 CLR 359 - cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Hart (2004) 217 CLR 216 - cited
Walstern v Commissioner of Taxation (2003) 138 FCR 1 - quoted

DAVID JAMES WALTERS AND RHONDDA ISOBEL WALTERS v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
QUD8 OF 2006

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION v DAVID JAMES WALTERS AND RHONDDA ISOBEL WALTERS
QUD10 OF 2006

GREENWOOD J
20 AUGUST 2007
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD8 OF 2006

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY SENIOR MEMBER BJ MCCABE

BETWEEN:

DAVID JAMES WALTERS
First Applicant

RHONDDA ISOBEL WALTERS
Second Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Respondent

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD10 OF 2006

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY SENIOR MEMBER BJ MCCABE

BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Applicant

AND:

DAVID JAMES WALTERS AND RHONDDA ISOBEL WALTERS
Respondents

JUDGE:

GREENWOOD J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 AUGUST 2007

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application by David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel Walters is dismissed. 

2.The application by the Commissioner of Taxation is upheld.

3.The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 16 December 2005 by which the Tribunal set aside the decision of the Commissioner of Taxation ‘to impose penalty tax in the amount of 50% on each taxpayer pursuant to s 226 of the ITAA36 (Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)) and substitute a decision to pay penalty tax of 25%’ is set aside and in lieu the objection decisions of the Commissioner of Taxation in relation to David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel Walters in respect of the payment of additional tax by way of penalty is affirmed.

4.The costs of and incidental to each application are reserved.

5.David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walters v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1270
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Walters v Commissioner of Taxation was brought by the Commissioner of Taxation against the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which had set aside the Commissioner's decision to impose penalty tax on David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel Walters. The Commissioner argued that the Tribunal had erred in finding that the taxpayers had a reasonably arguable case and in failing to consider whether it was reasonably arguable that Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (ITAA36) did not apply. The court had to determine whether the Tribunal's findings were correct and whether the penalty tax should be imposed.

The legal issues in this case centred on the interpretation of Part IVA of the ITAA36 and the concept of a "reasonably arguable case." The court had to assess whether the Tribunal correctly applied the law in determining whether the taxpayers' scheme was for the purpose of obtaining a tax benefit. The court also had to consider whether the Tribunal properly assessed whether it was reasonably arguable that Part IVA did not apply to the taxpayers' scheme. The court examined the evidence and the Tribunal's findings to determine if there was a legal error justifying the appeal.

The court found that the Tribunal had erred in its interpretation of the law. It held that the Tribunal should have considered whether it was reasonably arguable that Part IVA did not apply to the taxpayers' scheme. The court determined that the Tribunal had not properly assessed whether the taxpayers' scheme was for the purpose of obtaining a tax benefit. The court found that the Tribunal's conclusion that the taxpayers did not incur a capital gain was based on an incorrect application of the law. The court held that the penalty tax should be imposed as the taxpayers' scheme was indeed for the purpose of obtaining a tax benefit.

The court set aside the Tribunal's decision and affirmed the Commissioner's decision to impose penalty tax on David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel Walters. The court ordered that the penalty tax in the amount of 50% on each taxpayer be imposed, as originally decided by the Commissioner. The court reserved the costs of and incidental to each application, requiring the parties to file and serve submissions within a specified period.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application by David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel Walters is dismissed.

2. The application by the Commissioner of Taxation is upheld.

3. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 16 December 2005 by which the Tribunal set aside the decision of the Commissioner of Taxation ‘to impose penalty tax in the amount of 50% on each taxpayer pursuant to s 226 of the ITAA36 (Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)) and substitute a decision to pay penalty tax of 25%’ is set aside and in lieu the objection decisions of the Commissioner of Taxation in relation to David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel Walters in respect of the payment of additional tax by way of penalty is affirmed.

4. The costs of and incidental to each application are reserved.

5. David James Walters and Rhondda Isobel Walters are to file and serve submissions (if any) in relation to the costs of the proceedings within seven days and the Commissioner of Taxation is to file and serve submissions (if any) in relation to the costs of the proceedings within a further seven days.

Background

Background to the litigation

As to the amount of additional tax imposed by way of penalty, the Commissioner of Taxation appeals by an Amended Notice of Appeal filed 7 February 2006 against the Tribunal’s decision on the following grounds:(a)The Tribunal erred in holding, at paragraph 67 of its reasons, that the respondents did have a reasonably arguable case.(b)The Tribunal erred in failing to consider, properly or at all, whether it was reasonably arguable, as that expression is defined in s 222C of the ITAA36 that Part IVA of the ITAA36 did not apply.(c)On a proper construction of s 226(2) of the ITAA36 and the expression reasonably arguable, the Tribunal should have held that it was not reasonably arguable that Part IVA of the ITAA36 did not apply.Background Facts The facts found by the Tribunal and its conclusions arising out of those facts are these ([12] – [49] of these reasons). On 19 November 1991, Dart Trading was incorporated. David and Rhondda Walters, Terrence Walters and his wife Annette Walters became directors and each individual was issued with one ordinary share of $1.00 in the company. There were no other shareholders. The company conducted the business of a supermarket in Gordonvale in North Queensland. In 1998, the shareholders of Dart Trading conducted discussions with Franklins about the possibility of selling the business (presumably either the business or shares in Dart Trading) to Franklins. Nothing came of those discussions. The applicants, however, became interested in selling their interest in the business in any event. David Walters contended that he was having marriage difficulties; sought a restructuring of his affairs to protect his assets; and contended he was motivated by estate planning purposes. David Walters met legal advisers about steps that might be implemented. The Tribunal notes that the applicants gave evidence that they were advised to enter into a transaction in several parts. David Walters As to David Walters, the steps were these. On 13 April 1999, David Walters entered into an agreement in writing to sell his share in Dart Trading to Sailpeal at a price constituting the market value of the share on 13 April 1999 as determined by a firm of chartered accountants in Cairns. By cl 2.2 of the agreement, the purchase price would be satisfied by the issue of 2,000 $1.00 shares in Sailpeal to David Walters. David and Rhondda Walters were appointed directors of Sailpeal and David Walters agreed to provide a duly executed transfer instrument for the share to Sailpeal. Having agreed to a transfer of the share in Dart Trading to Sailpeal and Sailpeal having issued 2,000 ordinary non‑redeemable shares to him in satisfaction of the consideration, David Walters executed on 13 April 1999 a document for the purposes of Subdivision 122‑A of Division 122 of Part 3‑3 of the 1997 Act by which he chose to obtain a roll‑over pursuant to s 122‑15 in respect of the CGT ‘trigger event’ being the disposal of his share in Dart Trading to Sailpeal, a company in which he owned all of the issued shares immediately after the trigger event (s 122‑25, the 1997 Act).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GREENWOOD J
Adelong Hills as trustee of the Adelong Trust sold the share originally held by David Walters, to Port Bracknell as trustee of the Dart Trust for $35,000.00. Adelong Hills as trustee of the Adelong Trust No. 2 sold the share originally held by Rhondda Walters to Sailpeal as trustee of the Dart Trust No. 2 for $35,000.00. Each agreement recognised that the sale price of $35,000.00 was substantially below the market value of $350,000.00. Since the sale agreement was not the expression of an agreement between arms‑length parties in connection with the CGT event, the capital proceeds of $35,000.00 are replaced with the market value of the asset (Division 116, Capital Proceeds, Part 3‑1, the 1997 Act, s 116‑30(2)) and the cost base of the asset in the hands of the purchaser is the market value ($350,000.00). Accordingly, when the shares were sold on 10 September 1999 by David and Rhondda Walters in their respective capacity as trustee of the relevant trust, the vendor of the share, it was said, did not realise a capital gain upon disposal of a CGT asset. The Conclusions of the Tribunal In relation to the transactions, the Tribunal made these observations. 26.[The applicants] say the shares were disposed of to [Sailpeal] and [Port Bracknell] on 13 April 1999 in return for shares in those companies. Those transactions were CGT events … but the taxpayers elected in each case that [Subdivision 122-A] of the ITAA97 should apply. The taxpayers say the fact they subsequently resumed legal ownership of the shares when they were appointed as trustees is irrelevant since they did not hold any beneficial interest in the assets. They also say the Tribunal should ignore the fact they ultimately received the proceeds of sale.29.Taken at face value, the sale of the shares in [Dart Trading] at first instance to [Sailpeal] and [Port Bracknell] in return for shares in those companies had the effect of divesting the applicants of any legal and beneficial interest in the [Dart Trading] shares. While the machinations of 13-15 April 1999 appear to have had the effect of restoring legal ownership of the [Dart Trading] shares to the applicants (albeit as trustees), those transactions did not restore beneficial ownership of the shares to the applicants.36.In this case, it appears the applicants intended the documents to have their full effect – indeed, the taxpayer depended on the documents taking effect according to their tenor in order that they might be placed in a position to exploit the taxation (and perhaps other) advantages that would become available when a sale of the shares in the business to a third party was completed.37.… In this case, the applicants became aware of a result they wanted to achieve and gave instructions to their professional advisers to prepare the necessary steps.38.… I am satisfied after hearing all the evidence that the applicants regarded themselves as committed to the transactions and reaping whatever benefits might flow. I accept their failure to comply with the detailed notice requirements [that is, presentation of share transfers so that changes in ownership might be recorded in the share register] reflects nothing more than a lack of attention to corporate secretarial functions. 39.Subject to the operation of Part IVA [the 1936 Act] I accept each of the taxpayer did not incur a capital gain in the amount of $349,999.00 following the sale of the [Dart Trading] shares as a result of the transactions they entered into.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GREENWOOD J

In other words, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the non‑inclusion of the relevant amount in the assessable income of the taxpayer was ‘attributable to’ the choice or election made under s 122‑15 of the 1997 Act. Accordingly, the applicants were ‘unable to bring themselves within the exception provided for in s 177C(2)(a)(i)’ [51]. Considerations At [39] the Tribunal concluded that neither taxpayer realised a capital gain consequent upon the disposal of each share as a result of ‘the transactions they entered into’. Accordingly, neither taxpayer was required to include in his or her assessable income in the year ending 30 June 2000, an amount representing a realisation of a capital gain upon disposal of each share by reason of the transactions, by operation of Part 3‑1 of Chapter 3 of the 1997 Act. Rather, certain steps along the way to an ultimate sale of each share to Terrence and Annette Walters are said to constitute a scheme attracting the operation of Part IVA of the 1936 Act. The Tribunal’s error of law is said to lie in the conclusion that neither taxpayer was entitled to the benefit of the ‘choice or election’ exclusion in s 177C(2)(a)(i) and, secondly, the application of that provision to the facts as found. Section 177F(1) provides that where a tax benefit has been obtained or would but for s 177F be obtained by a taxpayer in connection with a scheme to which Part IVA applies, the Commissioner may, where the tax benefit is referable to an amount not being included in the assessable income of the taxpayer of a year of income, determine that the whole (or part) of such an amount shall be included in the assessable income of the taxpayer of that year of income. A tax benefit in connection with a scheme, relevantly for present purposes, is a reference to an amount not included in ‘the assessable income of the taxpayer of a year of income where that amount would have been included, or might reasonably be expected to have been included, in the assessable income of the taxpayer of that year of income if the scheme had not been entered into or carried out’ (s 177C(1)(a)). A scheme means, among other things, any arrangement, plan, course of action, course of conduct or scheme (s 177A(1)). A scheme, so defined, to which Part IVA applies is one where a ‘relevant taxpayer’ has obtained a tax benefit in connection with the scheme and having regard to eight identified factors, it would be concluded that the person, or one of the persons, who entered into or carried out the scheme or any part of the scheme, did so for the purpose of enabling the relevant taxpayer to obtain a tax benefit in connection with the scheme (or enabling the relevant taxpayer, another taxpayer or other taxpayers each to obtain a tax benefit in connection with the scheme) (s 177D(a) and (b)). A reference to ‘a scheme or part of a scheme being entered into or carried out by a person for a particular purpose’ includes a reference to entering into or carrying out the scheme for two or more purposes of which ‘that particular purpose is the dominant purpose’ (s 177A(5)).