Commissioner of Taxation v Dixon

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ilba v Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations
[2006] FCA 1520

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44(1)
Social Security Act 1947 (Cth) s 156
Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) s 1184K
Federal Court Rules O 20, r 2  

Re Krzywak v Secretary to the Department of Social Security (AAT 4614, 9 September 1988) referred to
Groth v Secretary, Department of Social Security (1995) 40 ALD 541 referred to

EDWARD ILBA v SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF EMPLOYMENT AND WORKPLACE RELATIONS
SAD 154 OF 2006

BESANKO J
15 NOVEMBER 2006
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 154 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

EDWARD ILBA
Applicant

AND:

SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF EMPLOYMENT AND WORKPLACE RELATIONS
Respondent

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 NOVEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 154 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

EDWARD ILBA
Applicant

AND:

SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF EMPLOYMENT AND WORKPLACE RELATIONS
Respondent

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE:

15 NOVEMBER 2006

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application by notice of motion by the respondent seeking an order dismissing an appeal by Mr Edward Ilba from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. On Mr Ilba’s application for review, the Tribunal decided to affirm the decision under review. Mr Ilba’s appeal to this Court is limited to an appeal on a question of law: s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). I will refer to Mr Ilba as the appellant and the Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations as the respondent.

    The facts

  2. The appellant sustained a work-related injury on or about 10 May 1985.  He made a claim in relation to the injury. Between 10 May 1985 and 17 May 1989 the appellant and his partner received the sum of $13,349.10 by way of sickness benefits and unemployment benefits. On 17 May 1989 the appellant settled his claim for compensation for an amount of $70,000. Of this amount, $13,349.10 was paid directly to the then Department of Social Security, and the balance was forwarded to the appellant’s solicitors.

  3. On 22 March 2005 the appellant wrote to the respondent referring to the amount paid to the then Department of Social Security, and asking for that money to be repaid to him. The appellant asserted that since 1991 he had been ‘harassed’ by Social Security and Centrelink. The respondent considered that the appellant’s letter was a request for a review of the original decision to recover the amount of $13,349.10, and notified the appellant of this by letter dated 6 June 2005. On 6 September 2005 an officer of the respondent wrote to the appellant advising him that the moneys would not be refunded. The appellant replied to this letter and asserted that the respondent was ‘liable to pay the money back immediately…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Dixon and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1520
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the Commissioner of Taxation, represented by the respondent, filed an application to dismiss an appeal brought forth by Mr. Edward Ilba against a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT had affirmed a decision made by the respondent, the Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations, to recover $13,349.10 from Mr. Ilba, who had previously received this sum in sickness and unemployment benefits related to a work-related injury. Mr. Ilba appealed the AAT’s decision, asserting that the tribunal failed to consider the special circumstances of his case and did not adequately weigh these circumstances. Additionally, he sought either the repayment of double the sum recovered in 1989 or compensation for the manner in which his matter was handled by Centrelink.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether the AAT's decision correctly interpreted the law concerning the recovery of compensation-affected payments and whether the appeal presented a valid question of law warranting review by the Court. The Court examined whether the AAT's decision was made lawfully and whether the appeal met the criteria for dismissal under the Federal Court Rules. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the appeal disclosed no reasonable cause of action, was frivolous or vexatious, or an abuse of court process.

In its reasoning, the Court noted that Centrelink’s actions in recovering the sum in question were lawful, and the appellant had not provided sufficient evidence to substantiate his claims of harassment by Centrelink. The Court found that the AAT had correctly exercised its discretion under the relevant social security legislation, which permitted the recovery of compensation-affected payments. The Court also concluded that the appeal did not present a valid question of law and did not disclose a reasonable cause of action. Therefore, the appeal was deemed frivolous and vexatious, leading to the conclusion that it should be dismissed under O 20 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules.

Accordingly, the Court made the following order: the appeal brought by Mr. Edward Ilba against the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by notice of motion by the respondent seeking an order dismissing an appeal by Mr Edward Ilba from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. On Mr Ilba’s application for review, the Tribunal decided to affirm the decision under review. Mr Ilba’s appeal to this Court is limited to an appeal on a question of law: s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). I will refer to Mr Ilba as the appellant and the Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations as the respondent.The facts The appellant sustained a work-related injury on or about 10 May 1985. He made a claim in relation to the injury. Between 10 May 1985 and 17 May 1989 the appellant and his partner received the sum of $13,349.10 by way of sickness benefits and unemployment benefits. On 17 May 1989 the appellant settled his claim for compensation for an amount of $70,000. Of this amount, $13,349.10 was paid directly to the then Department of Social Security, and the balance was forwarded to the appellant’s solicitors. On 22 March 2005 the appellant wrote to the respondent referring to the amount paid to the then Department of Social Security, and asking for that money to be repaid to him. The appellant asserted that since 1991 he had been ‘harassed’ by Social Security and Centrelink. The respondent considered that the appellant’s letter was a request for a review of the original decision to recover the amount of $13,349.10, and notified the appellant of this by letter dated 6 June 2005. On 6 September 2005 an officer of the respondent wrote to the appellant advising him that the moneys would not be refunded. The appellant replied to this letter and asserted that the respondent was ‘liable to pay the money back immediately plus the interest from the day the money has been deducted’. The respondent treated this reply as a request for review by the respondent’s authorised review officer. On 4 October 2005 an authorised review officer decided that the decision being reviewed was the decision in 1989 to recover the sum of $13,349.10. The decision of that officer was that no part of that amount would be refunded to the appellant. On 4 October 2005 the respondent sent a notice to the appellant informing him of the review officer’s decision and the reasons for that decision. The appellant appealed to the Social Security Appeals Tribunal. That Tribunal conducted a hearing on 17 March 2006 and it decided that the decision under review should be affirmed. On 3 March 2006 the appellant filed an application with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal seeking a review of the decision. On 16 August 2006 the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made an order affirming the decision under review. On 21 August 2006 the appellant filed a notice of appeal to this Court. He stated that the questions of law raised on the appeal are as follows:‘1. Failed to take note of the special circumstances of the case.2. Failed to give enough weight to the special circumstances of the case.’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO J
The appellant identified the orders sought as follows:‘3. Payment of twice the sum recovered in 1989.4.The manner of handling this matter by Centrelink has been unacceptable.’The decision of the Tribunal The Tribunal member identified the facts as set out above. He said that it had been agreed between the parties, and, further, having regard to the evidence put before him he found, that Centrelink acted lawfully and otherwise correctly in recovering an amount of $13,349.10 paid to the appellant and/or his partner in the form of ‘compensation affected payments’ between 9 November 1987 and 6 January 1989. He identified the issue before him as whether Centrelink was required to pay to the appellant double the sum recovered in 1989 or any other sum. He noted that the appellant did not detail in evidence before him the nature and extent of the harassment he suggested that he experienced from Centrelink since about 2003. The Tribunal member said that once moneys have been determined to be recoverable by Centrelink after having been paid in the form of compensation effected payments, then the only way in which he could see that those moneys could be returned to the appellant would be through the favourable exercise of a discretion which, at the time the moneys were paid, was contained in s 156 of the Social Security Act 1947 (Cth) and were now to be contained in s 1184K of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth). The Tribunal member noted that these sections gave the Secretary the power to treat the whole or part of a payment by way of compensation that has been, or that will be, made as not having been made or is not likely to become liable to be made if the Secretary considered it appropriate to do so in the special circumstances of the case. The Tribunal member referred to two authorities which had considered the nature of this discretion. He referred to Re Krzywak v Secretary to the Department of Social Security (AAT 4614, 9 September 1988) and Groth v Secretary, Department of Social Security (1995) 40 ALD 541. The Tribunal member said that, in the appellant’s circumstances, the consequence of the compensation legislation was as intended, that is to say, that neither the appellant nor Mrs Ilba should retain compensation and compensation effected Centrelink payments. He noted that the appellant argued that in some way Centrelink had foregone its right to retain the recovered moneys through what he considered to be Centrelink’s harassment of himself. The Tribunal member said that on the evidence before him he was unable to conclude that the appellant had been harassed by Centrelink, but he said that in any event, he considered that any such harassment was unrelated to Centrelink’s decisions in 1989, that is at least 14 years prior to the date the appellant suggested his harassment by Centrelink commenced. For these reasons, the Tribunal decided that the decision under review should be affirmed.The application The respondent seeks an order that the appeal from the Administrative Appeals Tribunal be dismissed under O 20 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules. This rule gives the Court the power to dismiss proceedings if no reasonable cause of action is disclosed or the proceeding is frivolous or vexatious or the proceeding is an abuse of the process of the Court. In my opinion, it is clear that it is not arguable that the appeal raises a question of law, the case falls within O 20 r 2 and the appeal should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J