Paula Chung v Territory Insurance Office

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

CITATION:Paula Chung v Territory Insurance Office [2018] NTLC033

PARTIES:PAULA CHUNG

v

TERRITORY INSURANCE OFFICE

TITLE OF COURT:  WORK HEALTH COURT

JURISDICTION:  WORK HEALTH

FILE NO(s):21539747

DELIVERED ON:  13 March 2018

DELIVERED AT:  DARWIN

HEARING DATE(s):  29 January 2018

JUDGMENT OF:  Chief Judge Lowndes

CATCHWORDS:

WORK HEALTH – DEFAULT / SUMMARY JUDGEMENT – PROPER

CONSTRUCTION OF THE PHRASE “AS SOON AS PRACTICABLE” IN RULE

5.03(2) OF THE WORK HEALTH COURT RULES – WAS THE APPLICATION

TO THE COURT SERVED “AS SOON AS PRACTICABLE” – CONSEQUENCES

OF THE WORKER’S FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH RULE 5.03(2)

Work Health Court Rules r 5.03(2)

McMillan v Territory Insurance Office (1998) 57 NTR 24 considered

Maddalozzo v Maddick (1992) 84 NTR 27 followed

Horne v Retirement Guide Management Pty Ltd [2017] VSCA 47 applied

Nicholl v Hunter 20 MVR 384 applied

State of Western Australia & Anor v Rothmans of Pall Mall (Australia) Ltd [2001]

WASC 25 applied

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Worker:Mr M Littlejohn

Employer:Ms K Frost

Solicitors:

Worker:Ward Keller

Employer:Hunt & Hunt

Judgment category classification:       A

Judgment ID number:  [2018] NTLC 033

Number of paragraphs:  135

IN THE WORK HEALTH COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21539747

BETWEEN:

Paula Chung

Worker

AND:

Territory Insurance Office

Employer

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 13 March 2018)

CHIEF JUDGE LOWNDES

THE EMPLOYER’S APPLICATION

  1. The employer has filed an interlocutory application pursuant to rules 5.03(2), 21.01(1)(a) and (b), 21.02(d) and 1.12 of the Work Health Court Rules and rule 28.01(1) of the Local Court ( Civil Jurisdiction) Rules.

  2. The employer seeks the following orders:

    (1)Default judgment for the employer;

    (2)In the alternative, summary judgment for the employer;

    (3)In the further alternative, the worker’s proceedings commenced by Application to the Work Health Court, filed on 25 August 2015, be permanently stayed;

    (4)The worker pay the employer’s costs of and incidental to the interlocutory application and proceedings at 100% of the Supreme Court scale, to be taxed in default of agreement.

  3. The interlocutory application is supported by the affidavit of Chris Osborne affirmed on 2 January 2018 and the affidavit of Kate Elizabeth Frost affirmed on 22 January 2018.

  4. The worker opposes the application and the orders sought, relying on the affidavit of Markus Andreas Spazzapan affirmed on 29 January 2018.

  5. The Court received written decisions and heard oral decisions on 29 January 2018 and reserved its decision. This is the Court’s ruling on the application and reasons for decision.

    THE EMPLOYER’S ARGUMENT

  6. The employer’s application is based on the failure of the worker to serve the Application to the Court as “soon as practicable” in accordance with rule 5.03 of the Work Health Court Rules which provides as follows:

  7. A party must file sufficient copies of an application made under this Division to enable the party to serve a sealed copy on each other party.

  8. The party must serve a sealed copy of the application and, if applicable, the documents referred to in rule 5.02(2() personally on the other parties as soon as practicable.

  9. The appropriate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paula Chung v Territory Insurance Office and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NTLC 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Paula Chung v Territory Insurance Office involved a dispute concerning work health and safety. The worker, Paula Chung, filed a claim against the employer, Territory Insurance Office, and its insurer, GIO. The dispute primarily revolved around the employer's application for default judgment due to the worker's failure to serve the application to the Work Health Court as soon as practicable. The legal issues before the court were whether the worker's delay in serving the application justified the entry of default judgment and what remedies, if any, the employer should be afforded.

The court considered the employer's application for default judgment under the Work Health Court Rules. It noted that the employer had applied for default judgment based on the worker's failure to comply with rule 5.03(2) and the associated prejudice. The employer argued that the delay had caused difficulties in recalling events and locating witnesses, among other issues. The court examined the employer's affidavit, which detailed the challenges faced due to the delay and the potential prejudice to the employer's ability to defend the claim. The court weighed these factors and the principles of fairness and efficiency in the legal process.

In its reasoning, the court found that the worker's failure to serve the application as soon as practicable was significant. However, the court also considered the broader implications of entering a default judgment, including the potential for injustice and the need to balance the rights of both parties. The court ultimately determined that while the delay was problematic, it did not warrant the entry of default judgment. Instead, the court opted to address the delay by imposing specific conditions on the worker to ensure timely service of future documents and to mitigate any prejudice caused to the employer. The court's decision thus focused on providing a remedy that balanced the need to enforce procedural requirements with the overarching goal of achieving a just outcome.

The court ordered that the worker must comply with certain conditions to ensure timely service of future documents, including serving the employer within two days of filing the application. The court also noted that failure to comply with these conditions could result in further consequences, including the potential entry of default judgment. The final orders aimed to address the delay while preventing similar issues in the future and ensuring the proceedings could proceed fairly and efficiently.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having found that the worker failed to serve the Application to the Work Health Court as soon as practicable, it remains to consider whether the employer should be afforded any of the remedies sought in its interlocutory application.·The Application for Default Judgment The employer has applied for default judgment on the basis of the failure of the worker to comply with the requirements of rule 5.03(2) of the Rules. Rule 21.01(1) of the Work Health Court Rules provides that a party may apply for default judgment:(a)on the ground that the other party has failed to comply with these Rules or with an order of the Court; or(b)as provided by these Rules. Rule 21.03 (1) provides that an application for default judgment is to be made in accordance with Part 6 of the Rules. Such an application is in the nature of an interlocutory application which must be in accordance with Form 6A unless the Court orders otherwise: rule 6.03(a). The application may be supported by an affidavit: rule 6.03(c). In support of its application for default judgment the employer relies upon the affidavit of Kate Elizabeth Frost affirmed on 22 January 2018. After outlining the usual claim and dispute process (at paragraphs 16 – 18), Ms Frost deals with the prejudice that the employer would suffer if the proceedings were to continue as a ground that favours default judgment being entered. She deposes as follows:19. At this stage, I expect that the employer would want to adduce evidence from, among other people in response to and in defence to the worker’s substantive application:a. Ms Kym McMaster, physiotherapist, who provided Konekt’s Worksite Assessment Report and Return to Work plan dated 20 and 19 May 2015 respectively;b. Ms Erin Coote, occupational therapist, who provided Konekt’s Workplace & Ergonomic Assessment Report dated 15 July 2015; andc. the worker’s colleagues. as to causation, liability and incapacity.20. On or about 22 January 2918, I telephoned Konekt’s Darwin Office and queried whether McMaster and Ms Coote were still employed. I was informed and verily believe to be true that they are no longer employees of Konekt.21. I am further advised by Mr Sean Marson, Underwriting Manager of GIO, and verily believe to be true that he had to refer to his records to answer queries directed by GIO’s solicitor, Hunt & Hunt, to TIO in relation to the worker’s claim, proceedings and TIO’s conduct of same over the preceding 3 years.22. In the circumstances, GIO and the employer believes that they have been prejudiced by the delay in the worker’s serving her substantive application and seeking to progress same through the Court, given the protracted period of time that has elapsed since the issue of the Certificate of Mediation in relation to her disputed claim. In particular, GIO and the employer are concerned that the employer’s position is prejudiced and it may not be able to properly respond and defend the worker’s application/proceeding due to:(a) the time that has elapsed since the worker’s injury and her claim to date;(b) the difficulty with relevant witnesses’ memories and recall of events in relation to the worker’s alleged injury and claim;(c) the location and availability of witnesses that the employer may wish to obtain information on in relation to this matter and call as witnesses at any hearing of the worker’s application/proceeding;(d) the added difficulty of obtaining contemporaneous medical records and factual information which the employer may have required in support of its dispute of liability for the worker’s claim on issues of pre-existing conditions, credit, evidence from other lay witnesses and other lines of inquiries which may no longer be relevant or available to the employer as a result of the worker’s delay;(e) the additional costs to the employer and its insurer, GIO, in having to deal with and respond to the worker’s substantive application/proceeding after GIO had closed its file in relation to same;(f) the employer and its insurer, GIO, has now lost the opportunity to properly deal manage and/or deal with the employer as a result of the worker’s delay.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.