PATTERSON and CRAFT DECOR PTY LTD (ACN 008 759 206)

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)

CITATION:   PATTERSON and CRAFT DECOR PTY LTD (ACN 008 759 206) [2021] WASAT 89

MEMBER:   DR S WILLEY, SENIOR MEMBER

HEARD:   30 JANUARY 2020, 8, 9 AND 10 SEPTEMBER 2020 AND 21 DECEMBER 2020

DELIVERED          :   25 JUNE 2021

FILE NO/S:   CC 1208 of 2019

BETWEEN:   MATTHEW DAVID PATTERSON

First Applicant

JACQUELINE ANNE ARGUS

Second Applicant

AND

CRAFT DECOR PTY LTD (ACN 008 759 206)

Respondent

FILE NO/S:   CC 1670 of 2019

BETWEEN:   CRAFT DECOR PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

MATTHEW DAVID PATTERSON

First Respondent

JACQUELINE ANNE ARGUS

Second Respondent


Catchwords:

Retail shop lease - Questions arising under a lease - Requirement to remove floor tiles - Landlord's fixtures - Requirement to make good - Unconscionable conduct - Failure to properly account for rent and outgoings

Legislation:

Building Act 2011 (WA)
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 9, s 11(5), s 12(1)(a), s 12(1a)(b), s 12(1a)(e), s 12(1b), s 12(1)(d), s 15C, s 15C(1), s 15D, s 15D(1), s 15D(2), s 16, s 16(1), s 16(1)(a), s 16(1)(b), s 16(2), s 26, s 26(1)(a)
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 56
Property Law Act 1969 (WA), s 9(1), s 47(1), s 77, s 78

Result:

CC 1208 of 2019:  Application partially successful
CC 1670 of 2019:  Application successful

Category:    B

Representation:

CC 1208 of 2019

Counsel:

First Applicant : Mr R Moss
Second Applicant : Mr R Moss
Respondent : Mr T Brickhill

Solicitors:

First Applicant : Origen Legal
Second Applicant : Origen Legal
Respondent : N/A

CC 1670 of 2019

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr T Brickhill
First Respondent : Mr R Moss
Second Respondent : Mr R Moss

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
First Respondent : Origen Legal
Second Respondent : Origen Legal

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Arise Joondalup Pty Ltd and Loveday Corp Pty Ltd [2015] WASAT 92

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C G Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2000] FCA 2; (2000) 96 FCR 491

Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) v Kobelt [2019] HCA 18; (2019) 368 ALR 1

Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) v National Exchange Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 226; (2005) 148 FCR 132

CA & Associates Pty Ltd v Fini Group Pty Ltd [2020] WASCA 31

Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio [1983] HCA 14; (1983) 151 CLR 447

Damaro Pty Ltd and Hydrox Nominees Pty Ltd [2020] WASAT 7; (2020) 99 SR (WA) 1

Douglass v Lawton Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 89

Duong and Coventry Village Pty Ltd [2016] WASAT 32

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640

Head and Zimmerman Investments Pty Ltd [2010] WASAT 75

Holland v Hodgson (1872) LR 7 CP 328

Jetpoint Nominees Pty Ltd and Lee [2021] WASAT 10

Litigation Capital Partners LLP PTE Ltd (Registration No 200922518M) v ACN 117 641 004 Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (formerly known as Vale Cash Management Fund…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PATTERSON and CRAFT DECOR PTY LTD (ACN 008 759 206) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASAT 89
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Patterson, the Lessor, initiated proceedings against Craft Décor Pty Ltd, the Lessee, in the Retail Tenancies Tribunal (WA). Patterson alleges that Craft Décor has failed to meet certain obligations under their lease agreement, leading to disputes over the condition and maintenance of the leased premises. Craft Décor, in turn, contests these allegations and has raised several defences, including claims that Patterson has not upheld its own obligations under the lease and that the renovations and fit-out works were carried out independently of Craft Décor's responsibilities.

The central legal issues before the Tribunal involved determining whether Craft Décor had breached the lease by failing to maintain the premises and whether Patterson had fulfilled its own obligations regarding the property's condition. Additionally, the Tribunal had to assess whether Craft Décor's conduct, as described in the statutory declaration, constituted unconscionable behaviour under the Retail Shops Act. The Tribunal also needed to ascertain whether Patterson's renovation and fit-out activities were adequately documented and whether these works could be separated from any alleged breaches by Craft Décor.

The Tribunal examined the evidence provided, including the statutory declaration by Robin Pyle and the limited documentation regarding the renovations. It was noted that the extensive fit-out works carried out by Patterson lacked detailed documentation and permits, which complicated the determination of which works were attributable to Craft Décor's responsibilities. The Tribunal found that Patterson had not adequately demonstrated that Craft Décor failed to meet its maintenance obligations. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that Patterson's extensive renovations and fit-out activities were not sufficiently documented to separate them from any potential breaches by Craft Décor. Consequently, the Tribunal ruled in favour of Craft Décor, dismissing Patterson's claims.

The Tribunal ordered that Patterson pay Craft Décor's costs of the proceeding, as stipulated under the Retail Shops Act. The decision underscored the necessity for clear documentation and compliance with legal requirements, particularly concerning the separation of independent fit-out works from lease obligations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Included in that reply from Craft Décor was a statutory declaration sworn by Robin Pyle which outlined the agreement with Craft Décor regarding the porcelain tiles (Statutory Declaration). The Statutory Declaration was dated 6 February 2019. One of the complicating factors in this matter is the fact that the Lessors did not simply move into the Premises. They, almost immediately, undertook significant renovation and fit-out works in the 'warehouse' establishing a new trades area (termed as the 'S&T area'), a new kitchen and shower as well as a mezzanine level above. In the main showroom area, a new office has been created. The works involved in this refurbishment are not insignificant. They involve demolition of five rooms, constructing four new rooms as well as a new mezzanine level. However, there is no evidence of any permits being granted under the Building Act 2011 (WA). There are not even any plans. There is only one invoice available for the entirety of the fit-out works. That invoice is from EBCO Pty Ltd (EBCO) for $5,164.50 (GST inclusive). This is despite the fact that it is an agreed fact that Mr Esposito (from Espo) did some tiling work as part of the new fit-out. While, of course, the Lessors are entitled to use and fit-out the Premises as they see fit, in circumstances where they are claiming that Craft Décor has not met its covenants under the Lease, it is important that the Lessors are able to verify (and indeed demonstrate) what works were done as a result of Craft Décor's alleged failings under the Lease, as opposed to the works undertaken for the separate fit-out works for the Premises (for which Craft Décor are not responsible). Section 16 of the Retail Shops Act provides (subject to s 11(5) in relation to the rent payable) that a party to a retail shop lease may refer to the Tribunal any question between the parties which they believe to be a question arising under the lease. Section 16(1)(a) of the Retail Shops Act then provides that the Tribunal shall determine whether or not the question referred to the Tribunal is a question arising under the lease, and if it is such a question, hear and determine it. Section 16(2) of the Retail Shops Act provides that the matter for determination referred to in s 16(1)(a) may be determined by the Tribunal in such manner as it thinks fit, subject to each party being given an opportunity to make a written submission. Section 15D(1) of the Retail Shops Act provides that a tenant is not to engage in conduct which is unconscionable conduct in connection with the lease. Section 15D(2) of the Retail Shops Act states:Without in any way limiting the matters to which the Tribunal may have regard for the purpose of determining whether a tenant has contravened subsection (1), the Tribunal may have regard to -(a)the relative strengths of the bargaining positions of the landlord and tenant; and(b)whether, as a result of conduct engaged in by the tenant, the landlord was required to comply with conditions that were not reasonably necessary for the protection of the legitimate interests of the tenant; and(c)whether the landlord was able to understand any documents relating to the lease; and(d)whether any undue influence or pressure was exerted on, or any unfair tactics were used against, the landlord (or a person acting on behalf of the landlord) by the tenant or a person acting on behalf of the tenant in relation to the lease; and(e)the amount for which, and the circumstances under which, the landlord could have granted an identical or equivalent lease to a person other than the tenant; and(f)the extent to which the tenant's conduct towards the landlord was consistent with the tenant's conduct in similar transactions between the tenant and other similar landlords; and(g)the requirements of any applicable industry code; and(h)the requirements of any other industry code, if the landlord acted on the reasonable belief that the tenant would comply with that code; and(i)the extent to which the tenant unreasonably failed to disclose to the landlord -(i)any intended conduct of the tenant that might affect the interests of the landlord; and(ii)any risks to the landlord arising from the tenant's intended conduct that are risks that the tenant should have foreseen would not be apparent to the landlord;and(j)the extent to which the tenant was willing to negotiate the terms and conditions of any lease with the landlord; and(k)the extent to which the tenant acted in good faith; and(l)the extent to which the tenant was not reasonably willing to negotiate the rent under the lease; and(m)the extent to which the tenant unreasonably used information about the turnover of the tenant's or a previous tenant's business to negotiate the rent; and(n)the extent to which the tenant was willing to incur reasonable refurbishment or fit out costs.