JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)
CITATION: NHUNG HUY DUONG and COVENTRY VILLAGE PTY LTD [2016] WASAT 32
MEMBER: DR B DE VILLIERS (MEMBER)
HEARD: 2 FEBRUARY 2016
DELIVERED : 8 APRIL 2016
FILE NO/S: CC 353 of 2015
BETWEEN: NHUNG HUY DUONG
Applicant
AND
COVENTRY VILLAGE PTY LTD
Respondent
FILE NO/S :CC 744 of 2015
BETWEEN :COVENTRY VILLAGE PTY LTD
Applicant
AND
NHUNG HUY DUONG
Respondent
Catchwords:
Commercial tenancy Right to exclusively sell certain products Termination of lease for late payment of rent Estoppel Unconscionable conduct causing tenant to enter into new lease Unconscionable conduct leading to termination of lease Variation of lease if lease had been terminated Coercion to execute lease Is disclosure statement and tenant guide required if existing tenant takes up new lease within the same retail shopping centre? Rule of Jones and Dunkel Inferences drawn of noncalling of potential witnesses
Legislation:
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA), s 6(1), s 6(4), s 15(C), s 15C(1), s 15C(2)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 87
Result:
1. Matter CC 353 of 2015 is dismissed in its entirety.
2. Matter CC 744 of 2015 is successful in part in that Coventry Village Pty Ltd is entitled to be compensated for rent loss as a result of the termination of the first lease dated 11 November 2011. Matter CC 744 of 2015 is dismissed in all other respects.
3. The parties may, by no later than 15 April 2016, file with the Tribunal a minute of consent orders in which the quantum to be paid by Mr Duong to Coventry Pty Ltd, pursuant to orders, as well as the time for payment are agreed. If the parties fail to file a minute of consent orders, the Tribunal will determine the quantum and date of payment.
4. The parties may, by no later than 15 April 2016, file with the Tribunal an application, if any, for legal costs arising from these proceedings. If no application is filed, the Tribunal will make the following order: 'There be no order as to costs'.
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
This dispute concerned six principal questions (as summarised by the Tribunal from the 19 issues identified by the parties) pursuant to the Commercial Tenancy (Retails Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA). The dispute concerns two leases between the same parties in the Coventry Market Gardens. For the sake of convenience, reference is made to the Tenant and the Owner to identify the parties. The first lease was terminated by the Owner. The parties then entered into a second lease. The Tenant voided the second lease.
The six principal questions were: Firstly, whether the Owner in regard to the first lease induced the Tenant into the belief that the Tenant would be the sole tenancy that could operate as an Asian grocery store. Secondly, whether the Owner terminated the first lease unlawfully for late…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Nhung Huy Duong and Coventry Village Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] WASAT 32
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the landlord's conduct was unconscionable or amounted to coercion that led the tenant to sign the second lease, and if the landlord had abused their power in the landlord-tenant relationship. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the disclosure statement and tenant guide were required when the tenant signed the new lease within the same retail shopping centre. The court also had to consider the rule of Jones v Dunkel and draw inferences from the non-calling of potential witnesses.
The Tribunal found that while the tenant was under significant stress upon receiving the notice of termination, the landlord's conduct on the day of the termination and the offer of a second lease did not amount to unconscionability or coercion. The Tribunal noted that the landlord offered the tenant the opportunity to move to alternative premises within the same shopping centre to minimise potential losses, and provided assistance in the relocation process. Despite the stressful situation, the Tribunal concluded that the landlord did not abuse its position or exert illegitimate pressure on the tenant to sign the second lease. The Tribunal also found that the landlord's explanation for terminating the first lease and offering a second lease was plausible, as the alternative premises may have provided better exposure and potentially improved the tenant's turnover.
The Tribunal rejected the tenant's claim that they were coerced into signing the second lease. While the process was rapid and stressful, the Tribunal found that there was insufficient evidence to support the claim of coercion. The Tribunal emphasised that the landlord was entitled to possession of the premises after the termination of the first lease and had the right to offer a second lease. The Tribunal also noted that the tenant's legal representative had been involved in negotiating the terms of the second lease, and variations were made based on the tenant's inputs. Ultimately, the Tribunal found that the landlord did not coerce the tenant into signing the second lease, did not abuse their power, and that the second lease could not be voided due to the landlord's purported coercion.
The Tribunal made no orders to set aside the second lease agreement, and the tenant's claim was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The reasons for this finding are as follows:a)The Tribunal accepts that the Tenant was under severe pressure and stress on 14 April 2014 after he had received the Notice of Termination. He saw his entire business come to a standstill. Whether he showed emotions or not is not material. Human nature would tell that he must have been shocked, stressed and anxious. These emotions would not be dissimilar to what is experienced by many tenants that are in default and then locked out of a tenancy. The Tribunal is, however, not satisfied that the conduct of the Owner was unconscionable or untoward later on the day of 14 April 2014 when he offered to the Tenant the second lease to take up an alternative premises within the Market. This would have enabled the Tenant to move his equipment, shelves and produce from one tenancy to another so as to minimise potential losses and costs. The Tenant inspected the proposed premises and the Owner offered to assist with the relocation and to make available staff to help the Tenant to transfer equipment. Although the situation was stressful, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the conduct of the Owner was improper or that the Owner abused its relationship with the Tenant by coercing the Tenant into signing the second lease. The Tribunal is also not satisfied that the conduct of the Owner or words that were said by Mr Thorpe or Mr Holtham comprised a threat or illegitimate pressure as referred to in Electricity Generation Corporation t/as Verve Energy v Woodside Energy Ltd [2013] WASCA 36 at [31] and [32]. The onus is on the Tenant to prove on the balance of probabilities: (i) what words were said and (ii) that those words or conduct were unconscionable. The Tenant fails in both respects.b)The Tribunal accepts the explanation given by Mr Thorpe for the Owner as to why the Owner would, on the one hand, terminate the first lease, but, on the other hand, offer a second lease to the Tenant who had had trouble paying rent as per the first lease. The explanation of Mr Thorpe was that the proposed premises offered pursuant to the second lease may have provided better exposure to the Tenant and thereby may have improved the turnover of the Tenant. The Tribunal accepts that the Tenant may not have shared this assessment of the Owner, but the rationale of the Owner is plausible. The rationale of the Owner is supported by the expert evidence of Mr Geers, (a valuer called by the Owner) who says that, from a rental perspective, the proposed premises the subject of the second lease was of similar value as the tenancy the subject of the first lease. This is not to say that the Tenant saw the two tenancies of similar value. The Tenant may have had a different view, but the conduct of the Owner did not amount to an abuse of power or coercion. It was for the Tenant to accept or refuse the offer of proposed premises after the first lease had already been terminated.c)Although the Tenant had only received the draft of the second lease on 14 April 2014 and executed it late on 15 April 2014, it is noted that it was the phone call from the legal representative of the Tenant, Mr Raymond Tan, to Mr Thorpe on 14 April 2014 that initiated the negotiations for the second lease; it appears as if the Tenant and Ms Pham did receive legal advice from Mr Tan in regard to the draft second lease; and Mr Tan exchanged emails with Mr Thorpe about the proposed terms of the second lease and some variations were made to the draft second lease as a result of the inputs made by Mr Tan to Mr Thorpe. The Tribunal accepts that the entire process leading to the signing of the second lease was speedy and stressful, but that does not mean the Owner coerced the Tenant into signing the second lease. The proposition by the Owner that the Owner offered a lifeline to the Tenant is credible and there is insufficient evidence before the Tribunal to find that the Tenant was coerced or forced into signing the second lease.d)It is not clear what exactly was said on 14 and 15 April 2014 when representatives of the Owner met with the Tenant on site. On the one hand, the Tenant says he was put under unbearable pressure and told that if he did not sign the second lease within 15 minutes he would be locked out. Mr Thorpe, who attended the site on 15 April 2014, denies that such words were spoken or that an ultimatum of such nature was given. The members of the family of the Tenant who purportedly overheard the discussions, were not called to give evidence to collaborate the version of the Tenant. Account must be taken that since the first lease had been terminated on 14 April 2014, the Owner was entitled to possession of Shop 192a: see clause 5.2(i) of the first lease. The image of the events sought to be portrayed by the Tenant is not credible. The facts are that the first lease was terminated lawfully on 14 April 2014; the Owner had the right to take possession of the premises; the Owner offered to the Tenant a second lease at the request of Mr Tan and gave the Tenant a licence to remain on the premises subject to the second lease being executed so as to enable the Tenant to move to the proposed premises; and the Owner made it clear to the Tenant that if the Tenant did not sign the second lease, then lockout would proceed. The Tribunal accepts that the Tenant may have executed the second lease in a hurry and fuelled by the panic of his business being closed down, but at the same time there was no obligation on the Owner to offer a second lease or to grant a licence to the Tenant to remain on site after 14 April 2014. The conduct of the Owner was not improper and did not constitute coercion. The Tribunal rejects the proposition that the Tenant signed the second lease as a result of the 'extraordinary and patent pressure exerted' by the Owner: see paragraph 67 of Closing Submissions of the Applicant dated 26 February 2016.The Tribunal therefore finds that the Owner did not coerce the Tenant into signing the second lease; that the Owner did not abuse its power; and that the second lease could not be voided as a result of the purported coercion by the Owner.