Head and Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   COMMERCIAL & CIVIL

ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)

CITATION:   HEAD and ZIMMERMANN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [2010] WASAT 95

MEMBER:   MR T CAREY (MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   1 JULY 2010

FILE NO/S:   CC 1868 of 2009

BETWEEN:   BRIAN HEAD

Applicant

AND

ZIMMERMANN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
Respondent

Catchwords:

Retail shop lease ­ Claim that landlord engaged in unconscionable conduct ­ Principles governing unconscionable conduct claim under Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA) ­ Application of principles to conduct relied upon

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA), Pt IIA, s 15C, s 15C(1), s 15F, s 15F(1), s 16
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 55

Result:

Application unsuccessful
Question of whether respondent's conduct constituted unconscionable conduct answered in the negative

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr J Eastoe

Respondent:     Mr M Levitan

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Jonathan Eastoe, Solicitor

Respondent:     Melvin Levitan

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Attorney General of New South Wales v World Best Holdings Ltd & Ors [2005] NSWCA 261

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Simply No­Knead (Franchising) Pty Ltd (2000) 178 ALR 304

Automasters Australia Pty Ltd v Bruness Pty Ltd [2002] WASC 286

Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447

Head and Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd [2009] WASAT 61

Head and Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd [2009] WASAT 61 (S)

Head and Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd [2010] WASAT 75

JA McBeath Nominees Pty Ltd v Jenkins Corporation Pty Ltd [1992] 2 Qd R 121

Murphy and Fremantle Markets Pty Ltd [2009] WASAT 84

World Best Holdings Ltd v Sarker [2010] NSWCA 24

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. The applicant claimed that the respondent had engaged in unconscionable conduct within the meaning of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA) in its dealings as the applicant's landlord and sought a number of orders consequent upon the Tribunal making such a finding. Various matters were relied upon, such as the levying of charges in order to recoup rent increases foregone when the Tribunal struck down a rent review clause, insisting on being informed of flammable materials present at the leased premises and giving notice of termination when the information was not provided, and accepting a hearsay version of an altercation with another tenant which formed the basis of another termination threat. The applicant also invited the Tribunal to have regard to the respondent's conduct giving rise to earlier proceedings in the Tribunal.

  2. The Tribunal considered the scope of unconscionable conduct in the relevant sense, having regard to other decisions of the Tribunal, the Supreme Court of Western Australia and courts in other jurisdictions where similar legislative provisions operate.  In recognising that the statutory variant is broader than the equitable concept of unconscionable conduct, the Tribunal noted a number of descriptions appearing in the reported cases which it found useful in assessing the respondent's conduct the subject of complaint.

  3. Although…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Head and Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASAT 95
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Head and Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the tenant, Head, and the landlord, Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd, concerning alleged unconscionable conduct by the landlord under a retail shop lease. The dispute centred on Zimmermann Investments' imposition of fees for car parking and advertising signs, which Head claimed were unjustifiable and amounted to unconscionable conduct under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA). The primary legal issues were whether the landlord's actions constituted unconscionable conduct and if the lease allowed for the imposition of such fees. The court examined the principles governing unconscionable conduct claims under the Act and whether the landlord's conduct, particularly the imposition of the fees, fell under these principles.

The court found that while the landlord had no right to impose the fees, their conduct did not amount to unconscionable behaviour. The court relied on the decision in World Best Holdings Pty Ltd v Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd, which outlined factors relevant to determining unconscionable conduct. The court noted that the fees, if enforced, would have had a significant impact on Head's profitability and might have required Head to take legal action to challenge them. However, the court concluded that the landlord's actions did not directly pressure Head to abandon the premises, nor did they place Head in a position where they would be forced to choose between significant financial loss and legal action. The court also considered whether the landlord acted in bad faith or in a way designed to wear down the tenant, but found that the landlord's actions, while unjustifiable, did not reach the threshold of unconscionable conduct.

In summary, the court held that although the landlord's imposition of the fees was unjustifiable, it did not constitute unconscionable conduct under the Act. The court found that the landlord's actions, while improper, did not meet the criteria for unconscionability as established in World Best Holdings Pty Ltd v Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd. Consequently, the court dismissed the claim for unconscionable conduct. The court did not need to make any final orders as the claim was dismissed on the basis of the landlord's conduct not amounting to unconscionable behaviour.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The position in relation to the advertising sign is a little less clear. Clause 6.07 of the lease provides that a sign is not to be affixed or exhibited without the lessor's consent, which consent is not to be unreasonably withheld. It would appear that no consent for his advertising sign was ever obtained by Mr Head. However, as Mr Head submits, the consequence of this is that Zimmermann Investments would be entitled to issue a notice of default requiring that the sign be removed. Mr Head would then be able to seek the landlord's consent pursuant to cl 6.07 for the sign, which Zimmermann Investments would not be able to unreasonably withhold. A Queensland authority was cited for the proposition that Zimmermann Investments is not entitled to request a payment in order to obtain his consent (JA McBeath Nominees Pty Ltd v Jenkins Corporation Pty Ltd [1992] 2 Qd R 121 at 123). I am again, for the purposes of this application, prepared to find that the landlord has established no right to charge a fee for an advertising sign. I also note that reliance is placed upon apparently discriminatory treatment of Mr Head regarding a decision to purportedly levy such a fee, as was the case with the car parking fee. I find myself in agreement with a number of observations made on Mr Head's behalf concerning these fees. In particular, it seems clear that an object of imposing the fees was to ameliorate the consequences of the invalid rent review decision. That is, Zimmermann Investments saw the imposition of the fees as a way in which to claw back the anticipated rent increases which would no longer occur by reason of the invalid rent review decision (paragraph 20 of the respondent's submissions dated 29 January 2010 concedes as much). Further, the car parking and advertising fees, representing a 31% increase in rent and outgoings for the premises, is clearly outside what would be contemplated as a likely rent review outcome. But more significantly, as I find for the purposes of this matter, the lease simply gave rise to no right to raise them. The way in which I characterise Zimmermann Investments' conduct in purporting to levy the car parking fee and advertising sign fee, for the first time, only against Mr Head, is that it has indulged in unjustifiable behaviour. The question I must determine, though, is whether it is sufficient for unconscionable conduct. Again, I look to the matters found to be significant in World Best Holdings 2010. The first point to be made concerns the consequences for the tenant of the conduct. They are either that Mr Head pays the fees levied, and suffer the impact upon profitability that would have, or take action to invalidate them. I have already mentioned the form that action might have taken. The tactic (if that is what it was) was not one which, directly at least, placed pressure on the tenant to abandon his premises. Rather, it was an impost based on a dubious justification. The other aspects of the World Best Holdings 2010 findings which may have resonance on the facts of this case include lack of good faith and acting in a way calculated to wear down the tenant and exhaust his resources, in the context of an alleged accumulation of incidents, or (to adopt another phrase of the applicant's) a 'campaign of harassment'. However, as has and will be seen in my assessment of the other matters relied upon, they do not, either individually or cumulatively, amount to conduct falling under the unconscionability provisions.