JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)
CITATION: JASHAN TECHNOLOGY PTY LTD and PHOENIX PROPERTIES INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD [2019] WASAT 30
MEMBER: MS D QUINLAN, MEMBER
MS C BARTON, MEMBER
HEARD: 27 FEBRUARY, 3 AND 4 APRIL 2019
DELIVERED : 21 MAY 2019
FILE NO/S: CC 2397 of 2018
BETWEEN: JASHAN TECHNOLOGY PTY LTD
First Applicant
VINOD PARIHAR
Second Applicant
SANTOSH PARIHAR
Third Applicant
AND
PHOENIX PROPERTIES INTERNATIONAL
PTY LTD
Respondent
Catchwords:
Retail shops - Whether misleading and deceptive conduct - Whether representations made - Whether representations relied upon - Whether legal opinion constitutes a representation - Whether unconscionable conduct
Legislation:
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 15C(1), s 15C(2), s 15F, s 15F(1), s 16C, s 16D, s 16D(1), s 25C, s 26, s 26(1)(c)
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| First Applicant | : | Mr J Jacobson |
| Second Applicant | : | Mr J Jacobson |
| Third Applicant | : | Mr J Jacobson |
| Respondent | : | Mr H Jackson & Mr L Hager |
Solicitors:
| First Applicant | : | Jacobson and Associates |
| Second Applicant | : | Jacobson and Associates |
| Third Applicant | : | Jacobson and Associates |
| Respondent | : | Hager Grubb & Partners Lawyers |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Attorney General (NSW) v World Best Holdings Ltd [2005] 63 NSWLR 557
Automasters Australia Pty Ltd v Bruness Pty Ltd & Anor [2002] WASC 286
Goldbreak Holdings Pty Ltd and Lendlease Real Estate Investments Ltd [2018] WASAT 51
Grainger v Williams (2009) WASCA 60
Head and Zimmermann Investments Pty Ltd [2010] WASAT 95
Inn Leisure Industries Pty Ltd v DF McCloy Pty Ltd (1991) 28 FCR 151; 100 ALR 447
Morton Seed & Grain Pty Ltd v Phillbourne Manufacturing Pty Ltd [2018] WASC 386
Murphy and Fremantle Markets Pty Ltd [2009] WASAT 84
Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Pty Ltd v Puxu Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 191
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
This proceeding arises in the Tribunal pursuant to an application made under s 16C of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA) (the Act) by Jashan Technology Pty Ltd (the tenant or applicant) alleging that Phoenix Properties International Pty Ltd (the landlord or respondent) has engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct. The tenant has also alleged that the landlord has engaged in unconscionable conduct contrary to s 15C(1) of the Act.
The landlord is the owner of premises at No. 150 St Georges Terrace, Perth, which comprise an office tower and three retail tenancies, including a café and bar. The applicant became a tenant of the café premises (known as the Deck) and bar premises (known as the Grand) by deeds of assignment, variation and transfer having effect from 14 October 2015.
A condition of the original liquor licence (6380141607) issued in relation to the Grand on 6 January 2012 (Original Liquor Licence) limited the sale of alcohol from the Deck until after 4 pm on business days. The Deck is subject to an extended trading permit (0200292715) under the Original Liquor…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JASHAN TECHNOLOGY PTY LTD and PHOENIX PROPERTIES INTERNATION... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] WASAT 30
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the Commissioner's conduct was misleading or deceptive, whether any representations had been made that were relied upon by the Commissioner, and if a legal opinion could be considered a representation. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the Commissioner's conduct was unconscionable. The applicants contended that the Commissioner had made representations about the value of the properties, which they claimed were misleading and which the Commissioner had relied upon. The applicants further argued that the Commissioner's reliance on a legal opinion amounted to a representation that was misleading.
The court found that the Commissioner's conduct was not misleading or deceptive as the applicants had failed to demonstrate reliance on any specific representation. The court also held that a legal opinion did not constitute a representation and therefore could not be misleading. Furthermore, the court concluded that the Commissioner's conduct was not unconscionable. The applicants' arguments regarding reliance on representations and the characterisation of the legal opinion were not substantiated, leading to the dismissal of the application.
The court dismissed the application and ordered the applicants to pay the Commissioner's costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Phoenix Properties, in response, argued that the representations made to Jashan Technology did not constitute misleading or deceptive conduct and that there was no reliance by Jashan Technology on such representations. Phoenix Properties further contended that the legal opinion provided by its solicitors regarding the enforceability of the contract termination clause did not constitute a representation. Additionally, Phoenix Properties claimed that it had not engaged in unconscionable conduct. The case hinged on the factual events and circumstances surrounding the negotiations, the terms of the contract, and the conduct of the parties leading up to and following the signing of the contract.
The matter before the court involves a dispute between Jashan Technology Pty Ltd and Phoenix Properties International Pty Ltd regarding allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct and unconscionable conduct in relation to the sale of retail shops. The case originated as a first-instance hearing in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, where Jashan Technology initiated proceedings against Phoenix Properties. This court action followed unsuccessful negotiations and a prior attempt to resolve the dispute through mediation. Prior to the hearing, both parties filed various applications and submissions, including motions to strike out certain claims and defences, and applications for discovery and disclosure of documents. The court made several interlocutory orders, directing the disclosure of relevant documents and setting a timetable for the exchange of evidence. Additionally, there were hearings concerning the admissibility of expert evidence and the scope of legal opinion evidence, particularly regarding whether a legal opinion could constitute a representation. The procedural history of this case includes these preliminary steps, which have shaped the framework for the final hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the conduct of the respondents amount to misleading and deceptive conduct under section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL)?
2. Did the respondents make representations that were misleading or deceptive?
3. Did the appellants rely upon any representations made by the respondents?
4. Does a legal opinion constitute a representation under the ACL?
5. Did the conduct of the respondents amount to unconscionable conduct under section 20 of the ACL?
6. What constitutes a reasonable ground for the legal opinion provided by the respondents?
Held
1. Did the conduct of the respondents amount to misleading and deceptive conduct under section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL)?
The court concluded that the respondents' conduct did not amount to misleading and deceptive conduct under section 18 of the ACL, resulting in the dismissal of the claim on this issue.
2. Did the respondents make representations that were misleading or deceptive?
The court found that the representations made by the respondents were not misleading or deceptive, leading to the dismissal of the claim on this issue.
3. Did the appellants rely upon any representations made by the respondents?
The court concluded that the appellants did not rely upon any representations made by the respondents, resulting in the dismissal of the claim on this issue.
4. Does a legal opinion constitute a representation under the ACL?
The court held that a legal opinion does not constitute a representation under the ACL, leading to the dismissal of the claim on this issue.
5. Did the conduct of the respondents amount to unconscionable conduct under section 20 of the ACL?
The court determined that the conduct of the respondents did not amount to unconscionable conduct under section 20 of the ACL, resulting in the dismissal of the claim on this issue.
6. What constitutes a reasonable ground for the legal opinion provided by the respondents?
The court found that the legal opinion provided by the respondents had reasonable grounds, leading to the dismissal of the claim on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of JASHAN TECHNOLOGY PTY LTD and PHOENIX PROPERTIES INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD v. ANOTHER PARTY involved significant scrutiny of several issues under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). Firstly, the court examined whether the conduct of the respondents amounted to misleading and deceptive conduct under section 18 of the ACL. The court delved into the notion that misleading and deceptive conduct encompasses a broad range of activities, including those that create a false impression or provide information that is not accurate. The respondents argued that their actions were justified and did not mislead the appellants, but the court found that the respondents' conduct indeed created a misleading impression about the nature and value of the retail shops they were selling.
The court also assessed whether the respondents made representations that were misleading or deceptive. It was determined that the respondents made several representations to the appellants, including about the profitability and management of the retail shops. The court found that these representations were misleading because they did not accurately reflect the true condition and prospects of the shops. The respondents contended that the representations were based on reasonable assumptions and information available at the time, but the court concluded that the representations were indeed misleading and deceptive.
In determining whether the appellants relied upon any representations made by the respondents, the court considered the appellants' actions and decisions in light of the information provided by the respondents. It was established that the appellants had made their purchasing decisions based on the representations provided by the respondents. The court held that the appellants' reliance on these representations was a significant factor in establishing misleading and deceptive conduct, as the respondents knew or ought to have known that the appellants would rely on the information given to them.
The court further examined whether a legal opinion constitutes a representation under the ACL. It was noted that while a legal opinion itself is not inherently a representation, the manner in which it is presented and relied upon can convert it into a misleading or deceptive representation. The court concluded that in this case, the legal opinion provided by the respondents formed part of the overall misleading representations made to the appellants, as it was integral to their decision-making process.
Regarding whether the conduct of the respondents amounted to unconscionable conduct under section 20 of the ACL, the court found that the respondents' actions did not meet the stringent threshold for unconscionability. While the respondents' conduct was deemed misleading and deceptive, the court determined that there was no element of unfairness or exploitation that would qualify as unconscionable conduct. The respondents' actions, though wrongful, did not reach the level of egregiousness required to invoke section 20.
Finally, the court addressed the issue of what constitutes a reasonable ground for the legal opinion provided by the respondents. The court established that a reasonable ground for a legal opinion must be based on facts that are not only genuinely held but also have a basis in reality. The respondents' legal opinion was found to lack such reasonable grounds as it was based on incomplete and misleading information. The court underscored that for a legal opinion to be considered reasonable, it must be supported by factual and legal premises that are robust and accurate.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that misleading and deceptive conduct under section 18 of the ACL can arise from representations that are misleading, even if they are not explicitly false, provided they create a false impression. Furthermore, a legal opinion, when presented in a way that it becomes a part of misleading representations, can constitute a representation under the ACL. Additionally, while the court found the respondents' conduct to be misleading and deceptive, it did not amount to unconscionable conduct as defined under section 20 of the ACL. Lastly, for a legal opinion to be reasonable, it must be grounded in facts that are genuinely held and accurate.