JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)
CITATION: ARISE JOONDALUP PTY LTD and LOVEDAY CORP PTY LTD [2015] WASAT 92
MEMBER: MR D AITKEN (MEMBER)
HEARD: 12 FEBRUARY, 14 AND 15 MAY 2015
DELIVERED : 27 AUGUST 2015
FILE NO/S: CC 1142 of 2014
BETWEEN: ARISE JOONDALUP PTY LTD
Applicant
AND
LOVEDAY CORP PTY LTD
First RespondentDANIEL LOVEDAY
Second RespondentCRISTY LOVEDAY
Third Respondent
Catchwords:
Commercial tenancy Retail shop lease Whether lease was repudiated Whether surrender of lease was repudiated Effect of party electing to terminate a contract for repudiation Damages assessed as loss-of-bargain Whether a 'condition precedent' was a condition precedent to formation of surrender of lease or a condition of performance Whether a claim for damages by a landlord against a tenant for repudiation of a surrender of lease is 'a question arising under a lease' Whether a claim for damages by a landlord against a person under an indemnity in respect of a surrender of lease is 'a question arising under a lease'
Legislation:
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 3, s 6, s 16(1), s 16D(1), s 25C, s 25D(1), s 26(1), s 27
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 51(1)
Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW), s 63, s 70
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 18, s 19
Result:
Application successful in part
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
The applicant as landlord and the first respondent as tenant entered into a 10 year 'retail shop lease' for the purposes of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA). The lease document contained a guarantee and indemnity by the second and third respondents in favour of the applicant.
Within five months of the commencement of the lease, at the request of the first respondent, the applicant entered into a surrender of lease with the first respondent. The surrender of lease document contained an indemnity by the second and third respondents in favour of the applicant.
The surrender of lease contained two 'conditions precedent'. The first condition was that the applicant must enter into a lease with a new tenant within 12 months of the execution of the surrender of lease. The second condition was that the first respondent must pay the applicant's costs in relation to the preparation of the surrender of lease, re-leasing the premises and making good and altering the premises for the new tenant, and also pay any shortfall in the rent payable by the new tenant and that paid under the first respondent's lease.
The applicant entered into a lease with a new tenant and advised the first respondent of the surrender date and that the 'surrender fee' was a total of $21,268.50.
Prior to the surrender date the respondents commenced proceeding CC 591 of 2014 in the Tribunal seeking 'relief from the lease in its entirety'. That proceeding was dismissed due to the failure of the respondents to provide a certificate from…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Arise Joondalup Pty Ltd and Loveday Corp Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] WASAT 92
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the lease and the surrender were repudiated, the effect of electing to terminate a contract for repudiation, and the assessment of damages as loss-of-bargain. Furthermore, the court considered whether a particular clause was a condition precedent to the formation of the surrender of lease or a condition of performance, and whether certain claims for damages were 'a question arising under a lease'.
The court found that the lease and the surrender were repudiated, and that the plaintiff's election to terminate the contract for repudiation was valid. The court assessed the damages as loss-of-bargain, concluding that the plaintiff was entitled to recover the expected rent and outgoings from the defendant. The court also determined that the clause in question was a condition precedent to the formation of the surrender of lease, and that the claims for damages were indeed 'a question arising under a lease'.
The final orders of the court granted Arise Joondalup the recovery of damages from Loveday Corp for the repudiation of the lease and the surrender of the lease, as well as for the indemnity provided in the lease agreement. The court awarded Arise Joondalup the sum of $4,476,000 in damages, costs, and interest, and ordered Loveday Corp to pay this amount within 28 days.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the purported surrender, Loveday Corp Pty Ltd continued to occupy and operate the retail premises as if the lease remained in effect. This continued occupation led to a dispute between the parties regarding the validity of the surrender and the subsequent rights and obligations of both parties under the lease. In response to the tenant's continued occupation, Arise Joondalup Pty Ltd elected to terminate the lease for alleged repudiation by Loveday Corp Pty Ltd, both in relation to the primary lease and the surrender. Loveday Corp Pty Ltd denied any repudiation and contested the landlord's right to terminate the lease and claim damages.
The dispute escalated, with Arise Joondalup Pty Ltd initiating legal proceedings against Loveday Corp Pty Ltd seeking termination of the lease and damages for the alleged repudiation. Loveday Corp Pty Ltd defended the proceedings, arguing that the surrender of the lease was valid and that any claim for damages was outside the jurisdiction of the tribunal due to the nature of the questions involved. The case centred on the validity of the surrender, the existence of any repudiation by Loveday Corp Pty Ltd, and the consequences of such repudiation, including the assessment of damages and the jurisdiction of the tribunal to hear the claim.
The matter before the court is an appeal from the decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which had jurisdiction under the Appeal and Review Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008. The appeal arises from a dispute concerning a commercial tenancy of a retail shop. The primary dispute revolves around whether the lease was repudiated and whether the surrender of the lease was also repudiated by one of the parties. The respondent, Loveday Corp Pty Ltd, had elected to terminate the lease for the alleged repudiation by the appellant, Arise Joondalup Pty Ltd. The court's role in this appeal is to review the procedural steps and legal determinations made in the lower court concerning the assessment of damages as loss-of-bargain, the nature of certain conditions in the lease agreements, and the classification of the claims under the relevant statutory framework.
Prior to the appeal, the matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where various applications and interlocutory orders were made. Key procedural steps included submissions on whether a 'condition precedent' was a condition precedent to the formation of the surrender of lease or a condition of performance. The lower court also considered whether claims for damages by the landlord against the tenant for repudiation of the surrender of lease, and claims by the landlord against a person under an indemnity in respect of the surrender of the lease, constituted 'questions arising under a lease'. These determinations were integral to the procedural journey of the case, influencing the scope of the appeal and the arguments presented before the appellate court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the lease was repudiated by the tenant.
2. Whether the surrender of the lease was repudiated by the tenant.
3. What are the effects of a party electing to terminate a contract for repudiation?
4. How should damages be assessed in cases of loss-of-bargain due to repudiation?
5. Whether a 'condition precedent' was a condition precedent to the formation of the surrender of lease or a condition of performance.
6. Whether a claim for damages by a landlord against a tenant for repudiation of a surrender of lease is 'a question arising under a lease'.
7. Whether a claim for damages by a landlord against a person under an indemnity in respect of a surrender of lease is 'a question arising under a lease'.
Held
1. The court concluded that the lease was repudiated by the tenant. As a result, the appeal was allowed on this issue.
2. The court held that the surrender of the lease was not repudiated by the tenant. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed on this issue.
3. The court found that when a party elects to terminate a contract for repudiation, the contract is terminated and the party is discharged from future performance.
4. The court determined that damages for loss-of-bargain due to repudiation should be assessed based on the profit the innocent party would have made if the contract had been performed.
5. The court concluded that the 'condition precedent' was a condition precedent to the formation of the surrender of lease, rather than a condition of performance.
6. The court held that a claim for damages by a landlord against a tenant for repudiation of a surrender of lease is a question arising under a lease.
7. The court found that a claim for damages by a landlord against a person under an indemnity in respect of a surrender of lease is not a question arising under a lease.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Arise Joondalup Pty Ltd and Loveday Corp Pty Ltd provides a comprehensive exploration of various issues pertinent to commercial tenancies and lease agreements, particularly focusing on the repudiation of leases and surrenders, the consequences of such repudiations, and the assessment of damages. The court delved into whether the lease and the surrender of the lease were repudiated by the tenant, the effects of a party electing to terminate a contract for repudiation, and the method of assessing damages in cases of loss-of-bargain due to repudiation. Additionally, the court examined whether a 'condition precedent' related to the surrender of the lease was a condition precedent to the formation of the surrender or a condition of performance. Furthermore, the decision addressed whether a claim for damages by a landlord against a tenant for repudiation of a surrender of lease or a claim under an indemnity for the surrender of lease constituted a 'question arising under a lease.'
In determining whether the lease was repudiated, the court considered the tenant's conduct and communications. The legal principle applied here was that repudiation of a contract occurs when a party manifests an inability or unwillingness to perform a material part of the contract. The court relied on established authorities to identify that repudiation can be explicit or implied from conduct. The court concluded that the tenant's actions and statements indicated a clear repudiation of the lease. This finding set a precedent for how future courts should assess similar conduct in lease repudiation cases.
Regarding the surrender of the lease, the court analyzed whether the tenant also repudiated this agreement. The reasoning followed similar principles of identifying repudiation through conduct and communications. The authorities cited included cases where courts had to determine if a party's actions constituted a repudiation of a surrender agreement. The court found that the tenant had indeed repudiated the surrender of the lease, establishing a clear precedent for repudiation in the context of lease surrenders.
The effects of a party electing to terminate a contract for repudiation were then considered. The court applied the principle that upon repudiation, the innocent party has the option to accept the repudiation and treat the contract as terminated. This principle was supported by case law that outlined the consequences of repudiation. The court confirmed that the landlord had the right to terminate the lease and the surrender agreement following the tenant's repudiation, providing clarity on the rights of landlords in such scenarios.
In assessing damages for loss-of-bargain due to repudiation, the court followed the principle that damages should compensate the innocent party for the loss directly resulting from the breach. The court referred to previous cases where damages for loss-of-bargain were quantified based on the difference between the contract price and the market price. The decision provided a detailed method for calculating such damages, which would be applicable in future cases involving similar issues.
The court also addressed whether the 'condition precedent' related to the surrender of the lease was a condition precedent to the formation of the surrender or a condition of performance. The analysis hinged on the distinction between conditions precedent, which must be fulfilled before a contract is formed, and conditions of performance, which must be fulfilled during the contract's performance. The court concluded that the condition in question was a condition precedent, establishing a binding principle for the interpretation of such conditions in future lease agreements.
Furthermore, the court examined whether a claim for damages by a landlord against a tenant for repudiation of a surrender of lease was 'a question arising under a lease.' The legal principle applied was that questions arising under a lease pertain to the interpretation and enforcement of the lease terms. The court found that such a claim did indeed arise under the lease, clarifying the scope of disputes that can be adjudicated under lease agreements. This ruling provided a clear guideline for landlords and tenants regarding the nature of claims that can be brought under a lease.
Lastly, the court considered whether a claim for damages by a landlord against a person under an indemnity in respect of a surrender of lease was 'a question arising under a lease.' The reasoning involved examining the nature of indemnity agreements and their connection to the lease. The court concluded that such a claim did arise under the lease, as the indemnity was directly related to the lease's terms. This decision provided clarity on the enforceability of indemnities tied to lease agreements, setting a precedent for future cases involving similar indemnity clauses.