NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power and Water Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power & Water Authority [2001] FCA 334

TRADE PRACTICES – alleged misuse of market power contrary to s 46 Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“Trade Practices Act”) – statutory authority responsible for generation reticulation and supply of electricity in Northern Territory – whether Trade Practices Act before enactment of s 2B by Competition Policy Reform Act 1995 (Cth) (“the Reform Act”) bound that statutory authority.

TRADE PRACTICES - alleged misuse of market power contrary to s 46 of Trade Practices Act – statutory authority owner of electricity infrastructure – statutory authority licensed third party planning to sell electricity into particular market – access to infrastructure of statutory authority necessary to be able to sell electricity into that market – whether decision of statutory authority to refuse access to its infrastructure is a refusal to grant a licence within s 2C(1)(b) of Trade Practices Act – whether decision of statutory authority to refuse access to its infrastructure is in the course of carrying on a business.

TRADE PRACTICES - alleged misuse of market power contrary to s 46 of Trade Practices Act – corporate entity wholly owned subsidiary of statutory authority – corporate entity formed as vehicle to participate in transaction involving establishment of substantial gas pipeline from gas field to principal place of operations of statutory authority – secured supply of gas necessary for operations of statutory authority in supplying electricity – contract with gas suppliers provided corporate entity with right of pre-emption in respect of gas offered to be sold to any third party – whether Trade Practices Act before enactment of s 2B by the Reform Act bound that corporate entity – whether that corporate entity was an emanation of Crown in right of Northern Territory – whether that corporate entity entitled to derivative Crown immunity – whether s 89(2) of Reform Act operates to preserve derivative Crown immunity in respect of the contractual right of pre-emption notwithstanding s 2B of Trade Practices Act.

TRADE PRACTICES – alleged misuse of market power contrary to s 46 Trade Practices Act – statutory authority responsible for generation reticulation and supply of electricity in Northern Territory – statutory authority supplier of electricity to consumers in Northern Territory – statutory authority owner of electricity infrastructure needed to supply electricity – third party licensed to sell electricity to consumers in Northern Territory but refused access to electricity infrastructure to do so – whether statutory authority had substantial degree of power in market – consideration of market to supply of electricity to consumers in Northern Territory – consideration of market or markets to supply infrastructure services in Northern Territory – temporal dimension of market – whether intention of Northern Territory Government to establish access regime under Pt IIIA Trade Practices Act for access to electricity infrastructure relevant to market power of statutory authority.

TRADE PRACTICES – alleged misuse of market power contrary to s 46 Trade Practices Act – statutory…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power and Water Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

NT Power Generation Pty Ltd sought a declaration that certain terms be implied in a licence granted by the Power and Water Authority (PAWA) and brought proceedings against PAWA and Gasco. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether specific terms should be implied in the licence and whether PAWA and Gasco had breached certain sections of the Trade Practices Act. The primary legal issue was whether the court should imply certain terms into the licence agreement between NT Power and PAWA, specifically regarding the market for the purchase of gas for electricity generation in the Northern Territory. Additionally, the court had to decide if PAWA and Gasco had engaged in conduct that contravened sections 45 and 46 of the Trade Practices Act by abusing their market power or engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct.

The court found that there was no basis to imply the terms in question into the licence agreement. It concluded that the market for the purchase of gas for electricity generation in the Northern Territory was not as NT Power had described, and there were no grounds to imply the specific terms into the licence. Furthermore, the court found that there was no evidence to support NT Power’s claims that PAWA and Gasco had abused their market power or engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of the Trade Practices Act. The evidence did not substantiate NT Power’s allegations, leading the court to dismiss all claims against PAWA and Gasco.

In conclusion, the Federal Court dismissed NT Power’s application against PAWA and Gasco. The court found no merit in the claims for implied terms in the licence or for breaches of the Trade Practices Act. Consequently, the application was dismissed in its entirety. The court did not address NT Power’s claims for damages, declaratory relief, or injunctive relief, nor did it consider Gasco’s cross-claim against NT Power.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

PAWA and Gasco deny the existence of the alleged market in the Northern Territory for the purchase of gas for the generation of electricity. They claim that the relevant market is one for the purchase of energy fuels. There is, however, no dispute that available fuels other than gas are much more expensive than gas in the Northern Territory, and there would be a significant cost in converting gas fired electricity generators into generators operated by alternative fuel sources. Gasco’s pleading disputes the existence of the “pre-emptive right” in the terms pleaded by NT Power, and denies that Gasco has refused and continues to refuse to give an undertaking that it would not exercise its contractual right of first refusal. It claims that it has told NT Power that it would deal with any offer of gas made by the Mereenie Producers under cl 2.26 of the Gas Sales and Purchase Agreement of 28 June 1985, that is gas which would otherwise be sold to NT Power, as quickly as possible in the circumstances. Gasco on 11 October 1999 provided to the ACCC, and the ACCC accepted, an undertaking (in terms to which it is not now necessary to refer) relating to its exercise of that contractual right. It further denies that it has engaged in any conduct in relation to NT Power in exercise of the alleged market power, or that any conduct on its part is for a purpose proscribed by s 46 of the Trade Practices Act.BACKGROUND PAWA is a statutory corporation: s 4 of the PAWA Act. It consists of the Chief Executive Officer. The Chief Executive Officer at times material to this application was Mr Peake until July 1997 and then John Gardner (“Mr Gardner”) until 23 November 1998. The Chief Executive Officer is appointed by the Minister under the Public Sector Employment and Management Act 1993 (NT). PAWA’s functions under the PAWA Act and the Electricity Act are extensive. They include responsibility for the generation, reticulation and supply of electricity, the reticulation and supply of water, the disposition of waste water, the acquisition, reticulation and supply of gas, and other services. It is the body which licenses and regulates the generation, transmission and sale of electricity in the Northern Territory. PAWA, in exercising its powers and performing its functions, is subject to the directions of the Minister for Essential Services (s 16 of the PAWA Act). Within a budget approved by the Minister, it must act in a commercial manner. However, it may be directed to provide electricity or other services to certain areas, and may seek and receive from the government subsidies or loans or grants to provide particular services to certain areas (s 17(2) of the PAWA Act). On the evidence, it receives Community Service Obligation payments from the government to provide electricity to remote communities where the generation of power would otherwise be inefficient or uneconomical, and in accordance with government policy it has until recently provided electricity to all consumers in the Northern Territory at about the same tariff regardless of location. The Annual Reports of PAWA reveal that the Northern Territory Government has advanced to PAWA (or earlier to NTEC) very substantial sums annually by way of subsidy, and by way of loan. There is a present indebtedness of PAWA to the Government in excess of $200 million.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, in my judgment, NT Power’s claim based upon terms to be implied in the Licence must fail.CONCLUSION For the reasons expressed above, I have reached the view that NT Power’s claim against PAWA and against Gasco must be dismissed. In the light of that conclusion, I do not need to address the complex factual and legal issues relating to NT Power’s claim for damages, or its claim for declaratory or injunctive relief. I also do not consider it necessary to give any separate reasons for decision or to make any order in relation to Gasco’s cross-claim against NT Power. I order that the application be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.