Nojin v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nojin v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] FCAFC 192

Citation: Nojin v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] FCAFC 192
Appeal from: Nojin v Commonwealth of Australia [2011] FCA 1066
Parties:

ELIZABETH NOJIN ON BEHALF OF MICHAEL NOJIN v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA and COFFS HARBOUR CHALLENGE INC (IN LIQUIDATION)

GORDON PRIOR v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA and STAWELL INTERTWINE SERVICES INC

File numbers: VID 1110 of 2011
VID 1111 of 2011
Judges: BUCHANAN, FLICK AND KATZMANN JJ
Date of judgment: 21 December 2012
Catchwords: HUMAN RIGHTS – discrimination on the ground of disability – intellectually disabled workers employed at Australian Disability Enterprises – use of Business Services Wage Assessment Tool to assess wages –assessment of productivity and “competencies” – whether there was a requirement or condition that to secure a higher wage intellectually disabled workers undergo assessment using the Business Services Wage Assessment Tool – whether appellants were able to comply with requirement or condition – whether a substantially higher proportion of people without intellectual disabilities were able to comply – whether requirement or condition was not reasonable – where wages linked to lowest pay grade in award – where competencies assessed in part by question and answer – where all or nothing assessment of competencies
Legislation:

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) ss 3, 6, 15, 24, 45, 122
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act1986 (Cth)
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) s 5
Anti-Discrimination Act1977 (NSW) s 24
Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (Vic) s 17

Australian Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Workers Union Supported Employment (Business Enterprises) Award 2001

Cases cited: Australian Iron and Steel Pty Limited v Banovic (1989) 168 CLR 165
Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No. 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424
Catholic Education Office v Clarke (2004) 138 FCR 121
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (1997) 80 FCR 78
Hurst v Queensland (2006) 151 FCR 562
Nojin (on behalf of Nojin) v Commonwealth [2011] FCA 1066, 283 ALR 800
Richardson v ACT Health and Community Care Services (2000) 100 FCR 1
Rogers v Whittaker (1992) 175 CLR 479
Secretary, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade v Styles (1989) 23 FCR 251
Sievwright v State of Victoria [2012] FCA 118
State of New South Wales v Amery (2006) 230 CLR 174
State of Victoria v Turner [2009] VSC 66, 23 VR 110
Waters v Public Transport Corporation (1991) 173 CLR 349
Date of hearing: 24-25 May 2012
Date of last submissions: 29 June 2012
Place: Sydney (via video link to Melbourne)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 269
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr H Borenstein SC with Dr K P Hanscombe SC and Mr L W L Armstrong
Solicitor for the Appellants: Holding Redlich
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms D Mortimer SC with Mr M Felman
Solicitor for the Respondents: Australian Government Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 1110 of 2011

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nojin v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCAFC 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nojin v Commonwealth of Australia involved the appellants, intellectually disabled workers employed at Australian Disability Enterprises, who sought relief in the Federal Court of Australia against the Commonwealth of Australia. The dispute centred on the use of the Business Services Wage Assessment Tool (BSWAT) in assessing the wages of intellectually disabled workers. The appellants argued that the use of BSWAT to assess their wages constituted discrimination on the ground of disability, as they were unable to comply with the requirement to undergo the assessment due to their disabilities, while a substantially higher proportion of people without intellectual disabilities were able to comply.

The court was required to decide whether the use of BSWAT constituted a requirement or condition that discriminated against intellectually disabled workers, whether the appellants were able to comply with the requirement or condition, and whether the requirement or condition was not reasonable. The court also had to consider whether the wages were linked to the lowest pay grade in the award and the assessment of competencies in part by question and answer, which led to an all or nothing assessment of competencies.

The court found that the use of BSWAT constituted a requirement or condition that discriminated against intellectually disabled workers, as the appellants were unable to comply with the requirement to undergo the assessment due to their disabilities, while a substantially higher proportion of people without intellectual disabilities were able to comply. The court also found that the requirement or condition was not reasonable, as the wages were linked to the lowest pay grade in the award, and the assessment of competencies in part by question and answer led to an all or nothing assessment of competencies. The court found that the use of BSWAT was not reasonably necessary to achieve a legitimate aim and was not proportionate to the aim pursued.

The court ordered that the first respondent pay the applicant’s costs, as taxed if not agreed, and that the amended application filed on 27 February 2009 be otherwise dismissed. The court also ordered that the first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, such costs to be taxed if not agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. The first respondent pay the applicant’s costs, as taxed if not agreed.

3. The amended application filed on 27 February 2009 be otherwise dismissed.”

3. The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, such costs to be taxed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The result here is striking. Mr Prior scored 0 because he did not carry out checks. This seems fairly clearly to be the result of his physical handicap, as the respondents submitted. It also appears to be the same deficiency that told against him in relation to the first core competency. I accept that this may represent an example of BSWAT operating against the interests of a worker with a physical disability, but the issue in the present case does not turn on whether such workers are, in some circumstances, also disadvantaged by BSWAT. In both his initial BSWAT assessment and reassessment Mr Prior did not achieve a score on any competency, core or industry. Those failures are not all attributable to his physical disability. It is an aspect of BSWAT, in its application to Mr Prior, that his assessed productivity score of over 50% was halved due to Mr Prior scoring 0 on the competency side of his BSWAT assessment. As I conclude later, the very use of BSWAT, with those outcomes and consequences, must be assessed by reference to its impact on the capacity of intellectually disabled workers to respond effectively to it.The expert evidence The trial judge received expert evidence from four people. One expert witness was Ms Louise Boin, a neuropsychologist whose evidence was, in all relevant respects, accepted by the trial judge as unchallenged. I refer to it later. The other three experts gave evidence concurrently. They each provided a written report, they contributed to a joint document disclosing the extent of their agreement and disagreement, and they gave oral evidence concurrently. Mr Richard Giles is a principal of Evolution Research and was engaged by HOI as a consultant at the outset of the project to develop a wage assessment tool for Business Services. He was one of the persons who developed, tested and refined BSWAT. He is a staunch supporter of BSWAT and of the notion embedded in it that it is legitimate, practical and relevant to assess competencies as well as productivity when fixing wages for disabled workers. The competencies included in BSWAT were developed by reference to “industry based competencies” drawn from a range of industry training packages. Mr Giles’ written report said: Competency based wage assessments focus on the abilities of the person being assessed without necessarily focusing on their productivity or the speed with which they undertake tasks. Competency based assessment is the foundation of industry led training programs and as such is seen as a critical component of wage assessment for the Business Services sector. As I indicated earlier, during the development of BSWAT an initial trial of the draft wage tool in 19 Business Services sites produced results which were regarded as yielding wage outcomes that were too high. The tool was revised. A number of changes were made. One change was to more closely align the competency-based component with a Certificate II level of competency rather than a Certificate I level, thus raising the standard to be satisfied. Mr Giles justified the changes in his written report in this way:An initial trial of the draft wage tool in 19 Business Service sites in four different states showed that whilst the productivity element was appropriate, the competency element did require refinement. In effect, the competency based component was seen to be too rudimentary for operation in a number of the industry settings. This was effectively a change in the ‘pitch’ of the competency based components and led to them being more closely aligned with a Certificate II level of competency rather than a Certificate I level. It was agreed by the project team and by the steering group that this was a more accurate reflection of a full wage earner in an open employment setting, and where their skills were expected to be.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.