Duval-Comrie v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Duval-Comrie v Commonwealth of Australia [2016] FCA 1523

File number(s): VID 1367 of 2013
Judge(s): NORTH J
Date of judgment: 16 December 2016
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceedings – approval of settlement by court – whether proposed settlement is fair and in the interests of the group as a whole – whether differential outcomes for group members is unfair
Legislation:

Business Services Wage Assessment Tool Payment Scheme Act 2015 ss 6(2), 6(4), 8(3)(b), 9, 10, 35(3), 36, 37, 98

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) ss 6, 15, 122

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 33V, 33ZB, 33J, 33ZF

Federal Court Rules 2011 r 9.70

Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s 46PH(1)(i)

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chats House Investments (1996) 71 FCR 250

Commonwealth of Australia and Anor v Prior; Commonwealth of Australia and Anor v Nojin and Anor [2013] HCA Trans 101

Nojin v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] FCAFC 192

Date of hearing: 12 December 2016
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 75
Counsel for the Applicant: Dr K Hanscombe QC with Ms K Bowshell
Solicitor for the Applicant: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr P Hanks QC with Mr D Star SC and Mr T Goodwin
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

VID 1367 of 2013
BETWEEN:

TYSON DUVAL-COMRIE (BY HIS LITIGATION REPRESENTATIVE CLAUDINE DUVAL)

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

JUDGE:

NORTH J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 DECEMBER 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Confidentiality

1.Pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), and on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the opinion of Counsel for the applicant which is Confidential Annexure KMT-4 to the Affidavit of Kelly Maree Thomas made 25 November 2016 remain confidential, and be placed on the Court file in a sealed envelope marked "Not to be opened except by Direction of a Judge of the Court".

Settlement approval

2.Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act and r 9.70 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, the Court approves the settlement of this proceeding upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement exhibited as Annexure PCB-3 to the affidavit of Paul Christopher Barker made 11 April 2016 (the Deed).

3.Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act or otherwise, the Court authorises the applicant nunc pro tunc on behalf of the group members as defined in paragraphs 2 and 2A of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim filed 21 December 2015 (Defined Group Members) to enter into and to give effect to the Deed and the transactions thereby contemplated for and on behalf of the Defined Group Members.

4.Pursuant to s 33ZB of the Act, the Court declares that the persons affected and bound by the settlement of the proceedings are:

(a)the applicant;

(b)the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Duval-Comrie v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1523
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Duval-Comrie v Commonwealth of Australia involves the approval of a settlement in representative proceedings concerning the BSWAT scheme. The dispute centres on whether the proposed settlement is fair and in the interests of the group as a whole, particularly in relation to differential outcomes for certain group members. The court was required to determine if the settlement terms, including the handling of special arrangements for two group members, were equitable and advantageous for all involved parties. Additionally, the court assessed whether the settlement adequately considered the interests of group members and whether the Commonwealth would bear the costs of the proceeding, thereby ensuring no group member would incur costs as a result of the settlement.

The court's reasoning focused on the fairness and equity of the settlement terms. It concluded that the special arrangements made for two group members, Andrew Smith and Alysia Maloney, were fair as they received the same amount they would have under the scheme, including adjustments for income tax liabilities. The court found that the settlement was fair and in the interests of the applicant and the group members as a whole, given the benefits of avoiding lengthy and complex litigation, the administrative support provided by the Commonwealth, and the degree of acceptance among group members. The court also noted that the settlement included provisions for interest and indexation, and the Commonwealth would bear all costs, ensuring no financial burden on the group members.

The court approved the settlement as it was fair and in the interests of the group members. The Commonwealth was ordered to bear the costs of the proceeding, ensuring no shortfall would be recovered from the applicant or group members. The court also approved the administration of payments by the Commonwealth, relieving the applicant and group members from administrative costs. The settlement was declared binding on the applicant, the respondent, and the defined group members, except those who opted out. The court extended the opt-out period and dismissed the proceedings with no order as to costs.

The final orders included maintaining the confidentiality of certain documents, approving the settlement terms, authorising the applicant to act on behalf of the group members, declaring the persons bound by the settlement, extending the opt-out dates, vacating previous costs orders, and dismissing the proceedings without costs. These orders ensured that the settlement process was fair, transparent, and equitable for all parties involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Confidentiality

1. Pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), and on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the opinion of Counsel for the applicant which is Confidential Annexure KMT-4 to the Affidavit of Kelly Maree Thomas made 25 November 2016 remain confidential, and be placed on the Court file in a sealed envelope marked "Not to be opened except by Direction of a Judge of the Court".

Settlement approval

2. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act and r 9.70 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, the Court approves the settlement of this proceeding upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement exhibited as Annexure PCB-3 to the affidavit of Paul Christopher Barker made 11 April 2016 (the Deed).

3. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act or otherwise, the Court authorises the applicant nunc pro tunc on behalf of the group members as defined in paragraphs 2 and 2A of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim filed 21 December 2015 (Defined Group Members) to enter into and to give effect to the Deed and the transactions thereby contemplated for and on behalf of the Defined Group Members.

4. Pursuant to s 33ZB of the Act, the Court declares that the persons affected and bound by the settlement of the proceedings are:

(a) the applicant;

(b) the respondent; and

(c) the Defined Group Members, other than those who have opted out of the proceeding pursuant to s 33J of the Act.

Settlement and opt out process

5. The date in Order 3 of the Orders made on 28 October 2016 be extended nunc pro tunc to 4 November 2016.

6. The date in Order 9 of the Orders made on 28 October 2016 be extended nunc pro tunc to 10 November 2016.

Costs

7. The respondent will pay the applicant's costs of the proceeding in accordance with cl 2.4 of the Deed.

8. All costs orders made to date in the proceedings (including orders reserving costs) are vacated.

Dismissal of proceedings

9. These proceedings be dismissed with no order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Special arrangements have been made for two group members, Andrew Smith and Alysia Maloney, who have settled claims related to the use of BSWAT, thereby becoming ineligible for the scheme (s 4 and s 6(4) of the BSWAT Scheme Act). The effect of the special arrangements is that Smith and Maloney are to receive the same amount by settlement as they would have received under the scheme. That is achieved through separate Deeds of Settlement regarding each of Smith and Maloney, which provide for the payment of an extra sum of money to account for the expected income tax liability incurred by the receipt of the settlement payment, and a determination by the Secretary of the Department of Social Services that the settlement payments will be an exempt lump sum for the purposes of income tests under the SSA. CONCLUSION It follows that from these reasons for judgment that the terms of settlement set out in the Deed of Settlement are fair and in the interests of the applicant and the group members as a whole. Consequently, the settlement is approved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Commonwealth will bear the costs of the proceeding so that claims under the scheme will not be reduced by any sum for the legal costs incurred to date. The applicant’s legal representatives’ costs agreements expressly provide that no shortfall will be recovered from the applicant, nor is there any proposal to recover any shortfall from the group members. The result is that no group member will pay costs as a result of the settlement.ADMINISTRATION OF PAYMENTS Further, the applicant and the group members will not be responsible for the administration of the calculation and payment of the claims. The Commonwealth will administer the system of payment. That relieves the applicant and the group members from bearing the costs of administering the payment scheme. As the group comprises over 9,700 members the costs of administering the system of distribution would be considerable. The operation of the scheme is subject to accountability to Parliament being a result of legislative enactment. Further, the integrity of its operation is subject to oversight by the Australian National Audit Office. These are each valuable protections for the claimants under the scheme. INTEREST AND INDEXATION It is likely that the Court would order interest to be paid on any compensation awards made in contested litigation to account for the delay between when the sums were due and when they are paid. The BSWAT Act, however, provides for annual indexation of the claim amounts (s 8A). Whilst the rate of indexation is probably lower than the rate of interest which would be awarded, there is some provision to take account of the passage of time from when the payment was due.CONSEQUENCES OF THE CONTINUANCE OF THE PROCEEDING It is necessary to consider the consequences if the proceeding is to continue. The interlocutory steps are at an early stage. Only limited discovery has been made and no directions have been given about the preparation for or conduct of the trial including, for instance, the exchange of expert reports. The trial is likely to be highly complex because the defences of the Commonwealth will require the examination of the circumstances of some individual group members or some sub-groups of the group members. Apart from the cost of preparing and conducting complex litigation of this nature, it is likely that the outcomes would be delayed long past the date when payments under the scheme would otherwise be available. The applicant and the group members would likely experience the attendant stress and uncertainty of the outstanding litigation over a long period. DEGREE OF ACCEPTANCE AMONG GROUP MEMBERS The Department of Social Services has verified the identity of 14,590 persons who have been assessed under BSWAT. Those persons include all of the 9,735 identified group members. On 16 June 2016, 11,918 BSWAT-assessed persons were sent notices advising them of the proposed settlement of the proceeding. In view of the disabilities of the BSWAT-assessed persons, the settlement notice was prepared in Easy English style, which combines text and images to convey information simply and directly. They were invited to return a notice to the Court if they objected to the settlement. 913 BSWAT-assessed persons were excluded from that mailout because they had previously opted out of the proceeding. The Department subsequently discovered an error in the initial mailout which meant that 1,759 BSWAT-assessed persons had not been sent notice of the settlement. On 4 November 2016, 7,143 BSWAT-assessed persons were sent the settlement and objection notices. That further mailout included all of the 1,759 persons affected by the identified error. Thus, allowing for the inherent difficulties in verifying the details of workers employed at over 100 ADEs, it appears that all of the 14,590 BSWAT-assessed persons have been sent a notice of the settlement.